On the morning of Thursday, May 7, 2009, three police officers went to a house in the Hospital Hill district of Napier, on New Zealand's Hawke's Bay coast, to carry out a search warrant under the drug laws. They expected a small growing operation, the kind of job the police in a provincial city handle week after week, and nothing they had been told suggested this one would be different. Before the morning was out, Senior Constable Len Snee was dead. His two colleagues had been wounded, and so had a neighbour who tried to intervene. The man the police and the coroner held responsible was Jan Molenaar, the 51-year-old who lived there.
Molenaar never faced a court. A standoff of about 50 hours followed, and he died by suicide before it ended; police confirmed his death on Saturday, May 9. On May 13 the detective superintendent leading the homicide inquiry said the evidence supported the murder of the officer and 21 counts of attempted murder, but no charge was ever laid and none of it was tested before a judge or jury. The only formal findings came from two bodies: the Independent Police Conduct Authority, which declined within a week to investigate the police, and the coroner, whose inquest examined both deaths in 2010.
Molenaar spent his whole life in Napier. He went to Nelson Park Primary, Napier Intermediate and William Colenso College, and he took up weightlifting at 14 and kept at it into middle age. As a young man he worked on the railways. In the 1980s he spent six years in the armoured corps of the Hawke's Bay Wellington Regiment, a Territorial Force unit; he never served overseas, and he left in 1988. When the railway job ended he went to work on the door at Napier pubs, and by 2009 he was living in Hospital Hill with his partner.
An illegal drug was being grown and sold at the property, and that was what brought the police to the door. The coroner later found that a good many people in Napier knew about it, and knew about his potential for violence, and that none of it had reached the police in a form the officers could use.
The senior constable had given the New Zealand Police more than 30 years. That morning he was one of three officers on the warrant, with a community constable and a drug-dog handler. Molenaar's partner let them in, and the search was already under way when Molenaar came back to the house. He killed the senior constable and wounded both of the other officers. A neighbour who had called in that morning tried to stop him and was wounded as well. All three of the wounded survived.
Police sealed off the surrounding streets, and Civil Defense moved hundreds of residents out of their homes while the standoff lasted. It ended with his death, and most residents were allowed home the next day. On May 13 a memorandum from the coroner's office stated that the evidence showed he had died by suicide and had no injuries caused by the police.
That memorandum settled the only question the police watchdog had to decide. The Independent Police Conduct Authority had been notified at the outset and kept informed throughout, and on May 14, 2009, it announced that it would not investigate the actions of the police, concluding that, with Molenaar solely responsible for his own death, no public interest would be served by an investigation.
The coroner's inquest, held in Napier in late March and early April 2010, was the one public, sworn examination of the case. It heard from Molenaar's former partner, from senior police officers and from an inspector of the Department of Labour, which had examined the warrant as a matter of workplace safety. The coroner released his findings on September 3, 2010. In the police summary of those findings, he found that Molenaar "murdered [the senior constable] and then took his own life," and that any actions by the police were not the cause of the officer's death "but were incidental to it." That is a coronial finding of fact, not a criminal verdict. He named the lack of adequate police intelligence about Molenaar as the major failing behind the deaths, found that an extra officer at the property could have saved lives, and recommended that police procedures for executing warrants be upgraded.
No court ever heard a charge against Molenaar. The murder and the 21 attempted murders the police said the evidence supported were never charged, tried or defended, and the coroner's finding that he killed the officer was reached in a proceeding that does not determine criminal guilt. Why he acted as he did was never established in any proceeding.
1980s: Molenaar serves six years in the armoured corps of the Hawke's Bay Wellington Regiment, a Territorial Force unit.
1988: He leaves the Territorial Force.
May 7, 2009: Three officers execute a drug warrant at his home in Hospital Hill, Napier. A senior constable is killed, two officers and a neighbour are wounded, and a standoff begins.
May 9, 2009: Police confirm that Molenaar has died by suicide; the standoff ends after about 50 hours.
May 10, 2009: Most residents return home.
May 13, 2009: A coroner's office memorandum states that he had no injuries caused by the police; police say the evidence supports murder and 21 counts of attempted murder.
May 14, 2009: The Independent Police Conduct Authority declines to investigate the police.
Late March and early April 2010: The inquest is held in Napier.
September 3, 2010: The coroner releases his findings, naming inadequate police intelligence as the major failing.