On the evening of March 16, 2000, two Fulton County sheriff's deputies went to Atlanta's West End to serve a bench warrant on a Muslim cleric who ran a small grocery store there and led one of the largest Black Muslim organizations in the country. Before the night was over, Deputy Sheriff Ricky Kinchen was dead and his partner was wounded. The man the surviving deputy named as the assailant was Jamil Abdullah Al-Amin, who a generation earlier, under the name H. Rap Brown, had chaired the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee and become one of the most recognizable voices of the Black Power movement.
A Fulton County jury convicted him of malice murder and twelve other counts on March 9, 2002, and four days later chose life without the possibility of parole over a sentence of death. The verdict survived the Supreme Court of Georgia, a state habeas court, a federal district court and the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit. It also left behind a question that never went away. Every one of those courts found that the prosecutor's closing argument had violated Al-Amin's Fifth Amendment right to remain silent, and every one of them decided that the violation did not require a new trial. Al-Amin denied the killing to the end. He died in federal custody in North Carolina on November 23, 2025, with a motion for a new trial still waiting for a hearing.
Hubert Gerold Brown was born in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, on October 4, 1943. The nickname "Rap" came from the word games he played as a boy. At 15 he helped organize a walkout at Southern High School in Baton Rouge in support of student protests at Southern University. In 1960, at 17, he moved to Washington and joined the Nonviolent Action Group, a campus affiliate of the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee at Howard University. By 1964 he was its chairman, although he was not a Howard student. He spent part of that summer in Mississippi during Freedom Summer, and left after four weeks, frustrated by the barriers that kept Black Mississippians from the ballot. In 1966 the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee named him director of its voter registration work in Alabama.
In 1967 he succeeded Stokely Carmichael as national chairman of the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee, which under his leadership dropped "Nonviolent" from its name. That July he spoke at a civil rights rally in Cambridge, Maryland, on the state's Eastern Shore. Unrest followed in the town, and Maryland charged him with inciting to riot and arson. The case never went to trial, and the state prosecutor eventually dismissed the charges for lack of evidence.
The Black Panther Party named him its minister of justice in 1968, the same year Congress passed a federal anti-riot law that came to be called by his name. In 1970, facing the Maryland charges and federal charges, he disappeared and was placed on the FBI's most wanted list. He was arrested in Manhattan in 1971 and later convicted of robbery, and he served five years in a New York state prison.
In that prison he converted to Islam and took the name Jamil Abdullah Al-Amin. He moved to Atlanta in 1976 and settled in the West End, a neighborhood in the southwest of the city, where he opened a grocery and health food store and became an imam. In the decades that followed he led the National Ummah, a Black Muslim community with about 36 mosques, and campaigned against the drug trade in his neighborhood. By the end of the 1990s his old name belonged, for most of his neighbors, to another era.
The warrant that brought the deputies to the West End came from neighboring Cobb County, where Al-Amin had been charged with theft by receiving, impersonating an officer and driving without insurance. When he failed to appear for his arraignment, a Cobb County Superior Court judge issued a bench warrant, and Fulton County deputies were assigned to serve it.
That evening the two deputies confronted a man outside the property, and within moments both had been wounded. Each believed he had wounded the man in return. The man drove away. One deputy died later that day, killed in the line of duty while carrying out a court order; his partner survived. The next day, while under medication, the surviving deputy looked at a photographic lineup and picked out Al-Amin.
Four days after the killing, federal and local officers took Al-Amin into custody in White Hall, Alabama. A medical assessment after his arrest found no sign that he had recently been wounded. Officers recovered physical evidence in White Hall, and at trial expert testimony linked it to the scene in the West End. An FBI agent mistreated Al-Amin while he lay handcuffed after the arrest and was later disciplined for it, and the defense would argue that this agent planted the evidence.
A Fulton County grand jury indicted Al-Amin on 13 counts on March 28, 2000, among them malice murder, felony murder, and aggravated assault and aggravated battery on a peace officer. The state sought the death penalty, and the case took almost two years to reach a jury.
The state's case rested on two pillars: the surviving deputy, who identified Al-Amin as the assailant, and the physical evidence, which experts tied to the West End scene. Al-Amin did not testify, but about twenty witnesses testified for him. One, a neighbor who said he had seen the confrontation, told the jury he was sure Al-Amin was not the man. The defense stressed that both deputies had believed they hit their assailant, while Al-Amin had no injury when he was arrested. It challenged the identification itself: the surviving deputy had been on medication when he picked Al-Amin from the lineup, and he had consistently described an assailant with grey eyes, while Al-Amin's eyes are dark brown. It argued that the evidence from White Hall had been planted, and that Al-Amin had been targeted because of who he had been in the 1960s. The judge barred the defense from questioning the FBI agent about an unrelated earlier incident but allowed evidence of the agent's conduct at the arrest.
In his closing argument the prosecutor put a series of questions to Al-Amin before the jury, displayed on a chart, asking him to explain the evidence against him. The defense moved repeatedly for a mistrial. The judge denied the motions and instructed the jurors that a defendant had no duty to testify and that no inference could be drawn from his silence.
On March 9, 2002, the jury found Al-Amin guilty on all 13 counts. In the penalty phase the state asked for death, and on March 13, 2002, the jury rejected it and fixed the punishment at life in prison without the possibility of parole. A motion for a new trial was denied in 2003.
The Supreme Court of Georgia decided the appeal unanimously on May 24, 2004. It found the evidence sufficient, rejected his challenges to the makeup of the Fulton County grand and trial juries and to the trial court's rulings on evidence, and upheld the limit on questioning the FBI agent. On the closing argument it agreed with Al-Amin: by questioning a defendant who had invoked his right to remain silent, the prosecutor had in effect cross-examined him, in violation of his constitutional and statutory rights. It then held the error harmless beyond a reasonable doubt in light of the eyewitness identification, the physical evidence and the judge's instruction. The conviction was affirmed, and the Supreme Court of the United States denied review on November 15, 2004.
In a state habeas petition Al-Amin argued, among other claims, that his trial lawyers had been ineffective for failing to pursue another man, O. J., who had repeatedly confessed to the crimes and repeatedly recanted. After an evidentiary hearing, the state habeas court found that the decision not to use him had been a matter of trial strategy and denied relief in 2011. The Supreme Court of Georgia declined to hear an appeal in 2012.
Al-Amin, a Georgia prisoner, had been moved into the federal prison system in 2007, and he filed a federal habeas petition in 2012. The federal district court denied it on September 29, 2017. It agreed that the closing argument had violated his rights and found the judge's instruction ineffective, and it described the identification evidence as mixed. Applying the stricter federal test for harm, however, it held that he had not shown the error substantially affected the verdict, and it rejected the claim about O. J. The Eleventh Circuit affirmed on July 31, 2019. It found the improper questioning repeated and central to the closing argument and the instruction inadequate to cure it, but held that the verdict most likely turned on the credibility of the surviving deputy and of the physical evidence. It also found no constitutional violation in the limit on questioning the FBI agent.
Al-Amin took the case to the Supreme Court of the United States a second time. The Court called for a response from Georgia before it acted, and on April 6, 2020, it denied review. That was the last ruling in his federal challenge.
Al-Amin remained a Georgia prisoner held in federal institutions for the rest of his life. Seriously ill in his last years, he was transferred in February 2025 to the Federal Medical Center in Butner, North Carolina, where he died on November 23, 2025, at the age of 82.
In May 2025 his lawyers filed an extraordinary motion for a new trial, citing newly discovered evidence and constitutional violations, and it had not been heard when he died. In February 2026 the Fulton County District Attorney's Office defended the conviction, saying the evidence still pointed to his guilt although newer laboratory testing had excluded him on some items, while finding that the trial prosecutor had committed misconduct and not opposing a hearing on the case as a whole. As of February 2026 no hearing had been set, and the conviction stood.
Al-Amin never admitted the killing, and the conviction has been contested from the day of the verdict. His defense held that he was framed and that the key evidence from White Hall was planted. No court accepted that claim, but the courts did not dismiss the weaknesses on which it drew: the deputies' belief that they had hit their assailant when Al-Amin had no injury, the grey-eyes description, the identification made under medication and the neighbor's testimony that he was not the man.
The confession of O. J. remains unresolved in any court. Al-Amin's lawyers argued that it was credible and closely matched the evidence; the state habeas court and the federal district court treated it as unreliable because he had recanted and repeated it many times.
The violation of Al-Amin's right not to testify is not in dispute; every reviewing court found it. Whether a properly conducted trial would have ended the same way is the question his final motion asked a court to consider, and as of February 2026 it had not been heard.
October 4, 1943: Hubert Gerold Brown is born in Baton Rouge, Louisiana.
1960: Moves to Washington and joins the Nonviolent Action Group.
1964: Becomes chairman of the Nonviolent Action Group; takes part in Freedom Summer in Mississippi.
1966: Named director of voter registration work in Alabama for the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee.
1967: Succeeds Stokely Carmichael as national chairman of the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee.
July 1967: Charged in Maryland with inciting to riot and arson after unrest in Cambridge; the charges are later dismissed without trial.
1968: Congress passes the federal anti-riot law that becomes known by his name.
1970: He disappears and is placed on the FBI's most wanted list.
1971: Arrested in Manhattan; later convicted of robbery and serves five years in a New York state prison, where he converts to Islam and takes the name Jamil Abdullah Al-Amin.
1976: Moves to Atlanta and settles in the West End.
March 16, 2000: A Fulton County deputy sheriff is mortally wounded and his partner is wounded in the West End; the deputy dies later that day.
March 2000: Taken into custody in White Hall, Alabama, four days after the killing.
March 28, 2000: Indicted in Fulton County on 13 counts.
March 9, 2002: Found guilty on all 13 counts.
March 13, 2002: The jury rejects the death penalty and fixes life without parole.
May 24, 2004: The Supreme Court of Georgia affirms, finding the closing-argument error harmless.
November 15, 2004: The Supreme Court of the United States denies review.
2007: Transferred into federal custody.
2011: State habeas relief denied.
September 29, 2017: The federal district court denies habeas relief.
July 31, 2019: The Eleventh Circuit affirms.
April 6, 2020: The Supreme Court of the United States denies review of the federal habeas ruling.
February 2025: Moved to the Federal Medical Center in Butner, North Carolina.
May 2025: Extraordinary motion for new trial filed.
November 23, 2025: Dies in federal custody at 82.
February 2026: The Fulton County District Attorney's Office defends the conviction, finds misconduct by the trial prosecutor and does not oppose a hearing.