Jamie Rouse

Victims
2 people killed in Lynnville, Tennessee, 1995. Tried as an adult for crimes at 17; convicted November 20, 1997, of two counts of first degree murder and two of attempted first degree murder.
Years active
November 15, 1995
Location
Lynnville, Giles County, Tennessee; Columbia, Maury County, Tennessee
Method
First degree murder (two counts); attempted first degree murder (two counts)
Status
Two consecutive life-without-parole terms plus two consecutive 21-year terms (cut from 25 on appeal, 2000); 2016 post-conviction petition held time-barred, affirmed August 14, 2019

James Ellison Rouse, known as Jamie, was 17 and in his final year of high school in Lynnville, Tennessee, when he killed two people there on Wednesday, November 15, 1995, and wounded a third. The dead were Carolyn Foster and a girl named Diane. People nearby restrained him before the morning was out, and he remained in custody from that day on.

He was charged as an adult. A Maury County jury convicted him in November 1997 of two counts of first degree murder and two counts of attempted first degree murder. Tennessee law did not allow a death sentence for anyone under 18 at the time of the crime, so the jury chose between the only two punishments left to it, and it returned life without the possibility of parole on both murder counts. The trial judge ordered every sentence in the case served one after another. In August 2000 the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals cut the additional years for the attempts from fifty to forty-two and left the rest in place. Years later he went back to court in search of a chance at parole, and lost.

The trial was never about who had done it. The one question the jury had to settle was the state of his mind. His lawyers argued that he had paranoid schizophrenia and could not form the intent the law required; the state's psychiatrists told the jury he had no major mental illness at the time. The jury believed the state. A friend was tried separately on a theory of criminal responsibility.

Lynnville is a small community in Giles County, in southern Middle Tennessee. Its regional public school took children from kindergarten through the twelfth grade, which meant that on any weekday the same building held small children, teenagers and adults. That fact would matter a great deal when a jury later weighed what he had put at risk.

The case against him

Rouse was taken into custody the same morning and charged with first degree murder.

Both youths were under 18, and both cases began in the Giles County juvenile court. In early January 1996 the juvenile judge held a transfer hearing and, less than ninety minutes after it ended, ruled that both would be tried as adults. The order moved the cases to circuit court, where life sentences were possible, and sent them to a grand jury. The judge had voiced doubts about binding the friend over as an adult but decided that his guilt or innocence was a question for a jury. The friend's lawyers argued that he had simply been in the wrong place and had become a target of public anger in the county, and they said they would ask for a separate trial.

For the time being the judge sent both boys back to a juvenile detention center in Middle Tennessee. Authorities wanted them held alone and apart from adult inmates, and said the adult facilities did not have enough separate cells to do that. The indictment that followed charged Rouse with two counts of first degree murder and two counts of attempted first degree murder: one attempt for the person he wounded and one for a second intended target who was never hit.

Both cases were later moved out of Giles County to the Maury County Circuit Court in Columbia. Even there, the friend's lawyers argued, the trial was too close to the events to be fair.

The friend's trial

The co-accused was tried first, in the summer of 1996, before a Maury County jury. The prosecution's theory was criminal responsibility for the conduct of another. The defense argued that he could not be convicted merely for failing to stop Rouse.

The jury deliberated about five hours and convicted him on August 2, 1996, of second degree murder, attempted first degree murder and attempted second degree murder. On September 26, 1996, he was sentenced to two consecutive twenty-year terms for the two deaths, plus thirty years for the attempt on the survivor's life to run concurrently, an effective sentence of forty years. He told the court he was sorry, that he had not believed Rouse was serious and that he would have stopped the killings if he could. He began serving the sentence the next day.

The conviction did not stand. On December 9, 1998, the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals reversed it because the trial court had failed to instruct the jury on the lesser offense of facilitation of a felony. The state applied to the Tennessee Supreme Court for permission to appeal, and in August 2000 that application was still pending.

Competency and the long wait

Rouse's own case moved far more slowly. In the summer of 1996, while his friend was on trial, he was placed on suicide watch at the county jail after harming himself; the injuries were not life-threatening, and he was returned to a special cell. His trial was set for early November 1996. At the end of October, experts at a state psychiatric hospital, where he was then being held, found him unfit to stand trial. The circuit judge postponed the case and directed the district attorney's office to bring it to trial once Rouse was able to take part.

The question came back before the court in June 1997, at a hearing where the defense again maintained that he was not competent. Three mental health experts testified, and they could not agree. One psychologist found him sane and another found him insane; the third said he would be ready to stand trial in six to eight weeks. The testimony described a defendant who believed he saw ghosts and heard voices. The judge concluded that the case should go forward despite the conflicting opinions and set the trial for November 10, 1997. Rouse was sent back to the state psychiatric hospital to wait.

Trial in Columbia

The case came to trial in Maury County Circuit Court in November 1997, two years after the events in Lynnville. The state's proof of what had happened was overwhelming, resting on numerous eyewitnesses, medical testimony on the causes of the two deaths and expert evidence tying every one of the injuries to him. The survivor took the stand.

Against that, the defense raised a single contested question. Two members of the team that had evaluated and treated him, a psychiatrist and a mental health clinician, testified that he had paranoid schizophrenia and that at the time of the crimes he was suffering from depression, delusions and auditory hallucinations that kept him from controlling or even understanding what he was doing. The defense asked the jury to find that this diminished capacity meant he could not have acted with premeditation, and argued that he was insane when he acted. The state answered with two psychiatrists of its own, who said that Rouse was not suffering from any major mental illness at the time of the offenses that would have left him unable to control or understand his actions.

The jury deliberated for about four hours over two days and, on Thursday, November 20, 1997, found him guilty as charged on all four counts. He showed no emotion as the verdicts were read. The court moved almost at once to the penalty phase.

The sentencing hearing

Under Tennessee law, when the state does not seek death in a first degree murder case, the jury that convicted the defendant holds a separate hearing and chooses between life imprisonment and life without the possibility of parole. To impose the harsher sentence it must first find unanimously, beyond a reasonable doubt, at least one aggravating circumstance listed in the statute, and must weigh it against any mitigating circumstances.

For the first death the state relied on two aggravating circumstances: that Rouse had knowingly created a great risk of death to two or more people besides the victim, and that he had committed the murder while he had a substantial role in committing or attempting another first degree murder. For the girl's death it relied on the great-risk circumstance alone. Its three witnesses described how many people had been in danger, small children among them, and one estimated that about fifty students had been present.

The defense called eight witnesses and asked the jury to weigh twelve mitigating circumstances, among them his lack of any significant criminal history, his youth, extreme emotional or mental disturbance, substantial impairment from mental disease or defect, his remorse, his amenability to treatment in prison, his character, the lack of sophistication in what he had done, and the closeness in time and place of the offenses, which the defense said showed a single period of aberrant behavior.

The jury deliberated about three hours. It found both aggravating circumstances proved for the first death and the great-risk circumstance for the second, and it sentenced Rouse to life without the possibility of parole on each count.

The trial judge then held his own hearing on the two attempted murder counts. He found four enhancement factors, among them that Rouse had been a leader in an offense involving two or more people and that he had shown no hesitation in committing a crime when the risk to human life was high, and two mitigating factors, his youth and his lack of a real criminal record. He imposed the statutory maximum of twenty-five years on each count. Finding Rouse a dangerous offender, he ordered the two terms served consecutively with each other and with both life sentences, for an effective sentence of two consecutive terms of life without parole plus fifty years.

The appeal

Rouse did not challenge his convictions. With new counsel he attacked only the sentences, raising three claims before the Court of Criminal Appeals at Nashville: that the jury had grossly abused its discretion by choosing life without parole, that the twenty-five-year terms were excessive, and that the trial court had erred in ordering consecutive service. A three-judge panel heard the case at its June 2000 session and filed its opinion on August 10, 2000.

On the life sentences, the court held that once a jury has unanimously found an aggravating circumstance, its choice between life and life without parole rests in its considered discretion and can be overturned only for gross abuse of that discretion. Rouse conceded that the aggravating circumstances fit his case. His argument was that the jury had disregarded the evidence of his mental illness. The court answered that the jury had heard experts on both sides and had plainly credited the state's, and that an appellate court would not second-guess its judgment of the witnesses. Nor did the statute require any further finding before the jury chose life without parole. The panel found no gross abuse of discretion.

On the attempted murder sentences he won in part. The panel found that the trial court had applied one enhancement factor, that the offense involved more than one victim, which does not apply to a single attempted murder, and that the record did not show whether the judge had started from the correct presumptive sentence. It therefore weighed the sentences afresh. It kept three enhancement factors, including his leadership of the offense and the high risk to human life, and gave him the benefit of two mitigating factors, his youth and his lack of a prior record, while declining, as the jury had, to treat his mental condition as mitigation. Starting from the statutory minimum of fifteen years, it set each sentence at twenty-one years.

On consecutive service, the court held that the record supported the trial judge's finding that Rouse was both a dangerous offender and a multiple offender. His lawyers had argued that stacking one sentence of life without parole on another was unnecessary and made no logical sense. The panel said it was guided less by logic than by precedent, since the Tennessee Supreme Court had repeatedly declined to review cases in which further sentences were ordered to follow a term of life without parole.

The judgment was affirmed as modified. His sentence became two consecutive terms of life without the possibility of parole, followed by two consecutive terms of twenty-one years. Rouse asked the Tennessee Supreme Court to hear his case, and on February 26, 2001, it denied his application for permission to appeal. The direct appeal was over.

The petition for a chance at parole

By 2004 Rouse was serving his sentence in a Tennessee state prison. More than fifteen years after the Tennessee Supreme Court's refusal, on December 12, 2016, he sent the Maury County Circuit Court a petition for post-conviction relief of his own. He argued that recent rulings of the United States Supreme Court entitled him to an opportunity for parole, and that stacking his sentences one on another violated the Eighth Amendment's ban on cruel and unusual punishment.

The rulings he had in mind were Miller v. Alabama, decided in June 2012, which held that a mandatory sentence of life without parole for a juvenile offender violates the Eighth Amendment, and Montgomery v. Louisiana, decided in January 2016, which held that Miller had to be applied retroactively. The circuit court found that his petition stated a colorable claim and appointed a lawyer. Counsel amended the petition to argue that his sentences ran afoul of Miller, which had said that sentencing juveniles to life without parole would be uncommon, and later amended it again to seek concurrent sentences under an April 2016 decision of the Court of Criminal Appeals that had ordered the consecutive life-without-parole terms of another juvenile offender, also sentenced by a jury, to run concurrently. The state answered that the petition came too late, that nothing excused the delay, and that Miller did not reach a sentence a jury had chosen.

The circuit court heard the petition on April 13, 2018. His lawyer argued that it was timely because Rouse had filed it within a year of Montgomery. On the merits, counsel conceded that the case did not fall squarely within Miller, which barred mandatory sentences of life without parole for juveniles, while Rouse's sentence had been imposed by a jury; the argument was instead that, read together, Miller, Montgomery and the April 2016 decision made his consecutive sentences excessive.

In a written order, the court denied relief on every ground. Miller did not apply, it found, because Rouse had been sentenced by a jury after a hearing at which he was permitted to present mitigating evidence, including evidence about his youth, his immaturity and his mental health. The April 2016 decision did not help him either, because the Court of Criminal Appeals had already reviewed his consecutive sentences on direct appeal, reduced the terms for the attempts and left consecutive service in place. And the petition was untimely, because Miller had not created a new rule of constitutional law that applied to him.

Rouse appealed. A three-judge panel of the Court of Criminal Appeals heard oral argument at its March 19, 2019, session in Nashville and filed its opinion on August 14, 2019. It noted first that his sentences of life without parole did not directly contravene Miller, since they were not mandatory and had been imposed by a jury after a hearing at which he could present mitigating evidence. But it rested its decision on time. A petition for post-conviction relief in Tennessee must ordinarily be filed within a year of the final action of the highest state appellate court, and his came more than fifteen years after the Tennessee Supreme Court had turned him away. The exception he relied on, for a new constitutional right recognized after trial, required filing within a year of the ruling that established the right.

That ruling, the panel held, was Miller itself. Montgomery had addressed only whether Miller applied retroactively and announced no new rule of its own, and the April 2016 decision had applied Miller and Montgomery without announcing one either. The one-year period therefore began on June 25, 2012, the day Miller was decided, and expired on June 25, 2013. Rouse had filed more than three years after that. He had offered no argument that due process required the deadline to be tolled and no explanation for the wait. The court affirmed the denial of his petition. As of that ruling he remained under an effective sentence of two terms of life without the possibility of parole plus forty-two years.

Context: the sentence available for a juvenile in Tennessee

Two features of Tennessee law shaped the outcome from the day of the transfer hearing. The first was age. Tennessee had the death penalty, but its law did not allow a death sentence for anyone under 18 at the time of the offense, even for first degree murder. Once the juvenile court sent Rouse and his friend to circuit court, the most either could face for murder was life imprisonment.

The second was the sentence that filled that space. Life without the possibility of parole had been created by the Tennessee legislature in 1993, two years before the crimes in Lynnville. It is imposed under a section of the Tennessee Code that governs first degree murder cases in which the state does not seek death. The statute gives the choice to the jury at a separate hearing run under the rules of the capital sentencing statute, without its references to death, and makes the jury's decision reviewable only for gross abuse of discretion. That standard decided Rouse's appeal. Because the jury had found the aggravating circumstances the statute requires, and he conceded they applied, the appellate court asked only whether the jury had acted arbitrarily, and it found that it had not. The same jury choice later defeated his reliance on Miller, which reached only sentences that the law made mandatory.

Disputed and unproven points

His mental state remains the one contested question. Two members of the team that treated him concluded that he had paranoid schizophrenia and was suffering delusions and hearing voices when he acted; two psychiatrists called by the state concluded that he had no major mental illness that would have left him unable to control or understand his conduct. The jury accepted the state's experts, and the Court of Criminal Appeals declined to disturb that judgment. The finding in October 1996 that he was unfit to stand trial, and the divided expert testimony in June 1997, concerned his condition at those times, not at the time of the crimes.

The role of the friend who drove him to school was contested too. He maintained at his sentencing that he had never believed Rouse was serious. His conviction was reversed in December 1998 on an error in the jury instructions, and the state's request to take that ruling to the Tennessee Supreme Court was still pending in August 2000.

Timeline

November 15, 1995: Rouse kills two people and wounds a third in Lynnville, Giles County, Tennessee, and is taken into custody the same morning.

November 1995: a friend of Rouse is arrested and charged.

January 1996: the Giles County juvenile judge transfers both cases to circuit court for trial as adults.

August 2, 1996: a Maury County jury convicts the co-accused on a theory of criminal responsibility.

September 26, 1996: the co-accused is sentenced to an effective forty years.

October 1996: experts at a state psychiatric hospital find Rouse unfit to stand trial, and his November trial date is postponed.

June 1997: after hearing three experts who disagree, the circuit judge sets Rouse's trial for November 10, 1997.

November 20, 1997: a Maury County jury finds Rouse guilty of two counts of first degree murder and two counts of attempted first degree murder.

November 1997: the jury sentences him to life without the possibility of parole on each murder count; the trial judge adds two consecutive 25-year terms and orders all sentences served consecutively.

December 9, 1998: the Court of Criminal Appeals reverses the co-accused's convictions for failure to instruct the jury on facilitation.

August 10, 2000: the Court of Criminal Appeals affirms the terms of life without parole and consecutive service and reduces each 25-year term to 21 years.

February 26, 2001: the Tennessee Supreme Court denies Rouse permission to appeal.

December 12, 2016: Rouse files a petition for post-conviction relief seeking an opportunity for parole.

April 13, 2018: the Maury County Circuit Court hears the petition, then denies it in a written order.

August 14, 2019: the Court of Criminal Appeals affirms the denial, holding the petition time-barred.