On the evening of Sunday, May 26, 2013, Jamie Reynolds murdered a 17-year-old girl in Wellington, the Shropshire town where both of them lived. He was 22. He knew her, she trusted him, and she had made it plain that she saw him as nothing more than a friend. The killing was not a sudden act. The judge who sentenced him found that Reynolds had imagined it for years, written about it, chosen her as one of several possible targets and planned it in detail, including the steps he meant to take to avoid being caught. Three days later he was arrested in Glasgow. Six months after that, days before his trial was due to open, he pleaded guilty to murder.
At Stafford Crown Court on December 19, 2013, he was sentenced to life imprisonment with a whole life order. The Court of Appeal refused him leave to challenge the order in October 2014. A year later a multi-agency review in Telford and Wrekin found that the agencies which had dealt with him after an assault on another teenage girl, five years before the murder, had not managed the risk he posed.
Reynolds grew up in Wellington, part of Telford in Shropshire. His earliest years were hard. As a small child he saw domestic violence and the abuse of his mother, and he suffered physical and emotional abuse himself at the hands of his natural father. His mother got herself and her son out of that relationship by her own efforts and built a new life with the man who became his stepfather. The psychiatric evidence before the sentencing court described the stepfather as a loving father to Reynolds and to his sister, and the household as comfortable and supportive, with sensible standards of behavior.
By his early twenties he was still living with his mother and stepfather in Wellington and working part-time at a shop in the town. The Court of Appeal noted that he worked there on the day of the murder.
Behind that ordinary life, the courts later found, lay a preoccupation that had held him since at least 2008. Over those years he built up a large private collection of violent material and wrote some forty stories built around the deaths of young women. Many of the women in the stories were real, young women he knew, named in the text. He also altered photographs of women he knew so that they appeared to be in mortal danger, and kept the results. The sentencing judge treated this material as the key to the case: it showed that the murder was not an aberration but the expression of a long-standing pattern in which Reynolds had repeatedly tried to move from imagining such acts to carrying them out.
The first time he crossed that line, as far as the courts could establish, was in January 2008, when he was 17. He invited a teenage girl to his family's address in Wellington while his parents were away and assaulted her there. She escaped, and the police were called. When he was arrested he played the episode down in interview, claimed to remember little of the day, and said he no longer wanted to look at violent material.
Not long afterward his stepfather found images on his computer, among them altered pictures of women Reynolds knew, and the family handed them to the police. Even so, the West Mercia Police investigation treated the incident as an assault, and Reynolds was dealt with by a final warning, with a requirement that he undergo counseling. In the period that followed he had contact with several agencies, among them the police, the Youth Offending Service, children's services and mental health services.
Years later the Court of Appeal recorded that Reynolds had afterward apologized to the girl and told her he had had counseling and then relapsed, an account the court found untrue.
The pattern resurfaced with a young woman he met through work. From 2010 he pursued her although she wanted no contact with him, and in August 2011, after she rejected him and confronted him, he deliberately reversed his car into hers. She, too, featured in one of his stories, and in an image he had altered.
In February 2013, with his parents away for a week, he persuaded a third young woman to come to the family address in Wellington, and he kept her there for about an hour against her wishes before letting her go. The sentencing judge found that Reynolds had prepared that night for a killing of the same kind he committed three months later. He apologized to her by message afterward. That same February he had been trying to persuade the girl he would later kill to visit him. On that occasion she did not go.
On April 26, 2013, he began writing a new story with the February victim as its subject.
The girl Reynolds murdered was 17 years and nine months old. She lived with her family in Wellington. She had overcome difficulties at her junior school and had gone on to take leadership roles: she had been head girl, and at college she served as a mentor and on its council, concentrating in both roles on helping young people who had been bullied.
She was an all-round sportswoman. She belonged to the RAF Air Cadets and hoped to make her career in the Royal Air Force. She and Reynolds knew each other from Wellington, and she had turned down his romantic advances.
In the weeks before the end of May, knowing that his parents would be in Italy for a week and that his sister would be away, Reynolds sent messages to about sixteen young women he knew, inviting each of them to visit him alone. Two or three showed interest, and the judge found that he had lined them up for later in the week in case his plans for the girl he had chosen came to nothing.
She went to see him in Wellington on the evening of Sunday, May 26, and he murdered her there that evening. The sentencing judge found that Reynolds had won her cooperation by deceit and that she had placed herself in his power because she trusted him. Shortly afterward, the judge found, he contacted the two other young women who had been due to visit the next day and cancelled their arrangements.
He then left Shropshire. On Wednesday, May 29, he was arrested in Glasgow on suspicion of kidnapping her. West Mercia Police, which led the inquiry, announced two days later that new evidence showed she had died at an address in Wellington.
In interview Reynolds told what the sentencing judge found to be a series of lies, using the same lines of deflection he had used in 2008. He first maintained that he had gone north meaning to take his own life. As the police disclosed the evidence against him, he claimed a total loss of memory, and then claimed that flashes of memory were returning.
On Friday, May 31, 2013, West Mercia Police charged him with her murder, and the next day he was remanded in custody and sent for trial at Stafford Crown Court. A trial of about three weeks was fixed to begin on December 9, 2013. For six months Reynolds accepted no responsibility for the death, not even on a basis of diminished responsibility, and her family prepared to sit through a full trial.
Two questions had to be settled first: whether he was fit to plead, and whether his mental state could reduce the offense from murder to manslaughter. A forensic psychiatrist instructed for the defense described recurrent, intense violent fantasies dating from his mid-teens. Reynolds told her he had experienced certain psychotic symptoms, but she found that no diagnosis of psychotic illness could be made. The prosecution's psychiatrist found that he had no recognized mental disorder and no abnormality of mental functioning, and so no foundation for a defense of diminished responsibility.
On Monday, December 2, 2013, Reynolds pleaded guilty to murder at Stafford Crown Court.
On December 19, 2013, the trial judge, a High Court judge sitting at Stafford, passed sentence. The only sentence the law allowed for murder was life imprisonment, and he imposed it. The question was whether the case called for a whole life order or for a minimum term, after which Reynolds could ask the Parole Board to consider him for release.
The judge concluded that the murder fell within the statutory category of the murder of a child in the most serious circumstances, and that its seriousness was exceptionally high. The girl was 17, and the law defines a child as anyone under 18.
He found a series of aggravating features. The murder was long anticipated and carefully planned, both in its commission and in the steps to avoid detection, including evasions and lies he had practiced before. She had been betrayed by someone she trusted. His targets reached beyond one person, since he had arranged for two other young women to visit the following day. And the killing was the expression of a long-standing preoccupation that he had tried to act out against the girl in 2008 and the young woman in February 2013.
Against that he weighed two mitigating factors. The guilty plea had spared her family a trial, but it came at the last moment, in the face of overwhelming evidence and without any genuine remorse, and so carried little weight. His age, 22, mattered more, and the judge read the psychiatric reports to see whether immaturity reduced his culpability. He found nothing in them that did. He imposed life imprisonment with a whole life order.
Reynolds applied for leave to appeal against the whole life order. The Court of Appeal (Criminal Division) heard the application in London on October 16, 2014, and gave its written judgment on October 31, 2014.
His grounds were that the judge had given no credit for the reason the plea came late, since diminished responsibility and fitness to plead had needed to be investigated first; that too little weight had been given to his age and to hers, since at 17 she fell only just within the definition of a child; and that too little weight had been given to the psychiatric evidence.
The court rejected each ground. The plea had rightly been given little weight, given the overwhelming evidence, its lateness and the absence of remorse. On the psychiatric evidence the court preferred the prosecution's analysis and found nothing that reduced culpability. Her age was not in itself a material consideration, because Parliament had provided that she was to be treated as a child, and the court found that she had been vulnerable to his premeditated plans. Setting aside entirely the future danger Reynolds posed, the court held that the only just punishment was a whole life order. Leave to appeal was refused.
On October 14, 2015, the Telford and Wrekin partners in the Multi-Agency Public Protection Arrangements published a Discretionary Serious Case Review into how the agencies had dealt with Reynolds before the murder. It found that the police investigation of the 2008 offense had been narrow and focused on a quick resolution, and that the work which followed had no clear multi-agency plan for managing the risk he posed.
As of October 2015, the latest reporting on the case, Reynolds was serving his whole life order in England.
Because Reynolds pleaded guilty, the evidence was never tested before a jury. The account of his planning, his intentions and his conduct that night rests on the prosecution's opening at the sentencing hearing and on the findings the judge made from it, findings the Court of Appeal later endorsed.
The judge's finding that two other young women had been lined up to visit the following day is a finding about his intentions, made from his messages and his conduct at a sentencing hearing, without a trial.
His own explanations, that he had set out to take his own life and that he could not remember what had happened, were rejected by the sentencing judge as lies. The claim of psychotic symptoms he made to the defense psychiatrist was not accepted as a diagnosis by either psychiatrist, although the defense psychiatrist did not rule out a psychotic illness developing in later years. The Court of Appeal preferred the prosecution psychiatrist's finding of no recognized mental disorder.
January 2008: Reynolds, aged 17, assaults a teenage girl in Wellington, Shropshire; West Mercia Police deal with the case by a final warning with a requirement of counseling.
August 2011: He deliberately reverses his car into the car of a young woman who had rejected him.
February 2013: He keeps a third young woman at the family address in Wellington for about an hour before letting her go.
April 26, 2013: He begins writing a story about the February victim.
May 26, 2013: He murders a 17-year-old girl in Wellington.
May 29, 2013: Police arrest him in Glasgow on suspicion of kidnapping.
May 31, 2013: West Mercia Police charge him with murder.
December 2, 2013: He pleads guilty to murder at Stafford Crown Court.
December 19, 2013: He is sentenced to life imprisonment with a whole life order.
October 31, 2014: The Court of Appeal refuses leave to appeal against the whole life order.
October 14, 2015: A Discretionary Serious Case Review into the agencies' earlier handling of him is published.