James Roszko

Victims
4 officers killed in Alberta, 2005 (attributed); never tried. The RCMP held Roszko responsible; he died by suicide that day. Two men who aided him pleaded guilty to manslaughter, 2009
Years active
March 3, 2005
Location
Mayerthorpe, Alberta, Canada (birth; killings, near the town); Edmonton, Alberta (accessories' sentencing); Stony Plain, Alberta (fatality inquiry)
Method
Shot (RCMP finding, March 4, 2005; no court tested it). Never charged; the accessories pleaded guilty to manslaughter.
Status
Never tried. Accessories' sentences of 15 and 12 years (January 30, 2009) upheld on appeal, 2010. He died untried, by suicide, near Mayerthorpe, Alberta, March 3, 2005.

On March 3, 2005, four officers of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police died near Mayerthorpe, a small town northwest of Edmonton, Alberta. They were Peter Schiemann, Anthony Gordon, Lionide (Leo) Johnston and Brock Myrol. In a news release the next day, the RCMP identified the suspect as James Roszko, a 46-year-old man who had been born in Mayerthorpe. He had died by suicide the same day. It was the greatest loss of life the force had suffered in a single day in more than a hundred years.

Roszko was never charged, and no court ever tried him, so in law the four deaths remain attributed to him rather than proven against him. He had a criminal record reaching back to his teens, with many charges and comparatively few convictions; in 2000 he was sentenced to two and a half years for sexual assault, and he was released on mandatory parole in 2002.

The sequence began with a civil matter. On March 2, 2005, RCMP officers went with bailiffs to his property near Mayerthorpe to carry out a court-ordered seizure, and Roszko left before it could be completed. He returned the next morning, and on March 3 the four officers died.

The criminal case that followed concerned two other men from the district, who had helped him in the hours before the deaths. In July 2007 the Alberta RCMP charged each of them with four counts of first-degree murder. The trial never took place. In January 2009, in the Court of Queen's Bench of Alberta, both men pleaded guilty to four counts of manslaughter, and on January 30, 2009, they were sentenced to 15 and 12 years. Each sentence was reduced by three years in recognition of the guilty plea, with further credit for time already spent in custody. The Court of Appeal of Alberta dismissed their sentence appeals by a majority of two to one in September 2010, and in August 2011 the Supreme Court of Canada declined to review the sentences. The older man was granted full parole on May 12, 2015, and his sentence expired in June 2019.

Alberta's public fatality inquiry, deferred until the criminal case was over, opened at Stony Plain in January 2011 and reported in late March. It found no failings in the training, experience or abilities of the four officers, found that the RCMP had acted appropriately in the circumstances as the officers knew them at the time, and concluded that the deaths could not reasonably have been foreseen or prevented.

No court ever examined the evidence against Roszko. He was never charged, and because he died the same day, there was never an occasion on which a defense could be heard.

The two accessories said they had acted out of fear of Roszko, and they pressed that point on appeal. The majority of the Court of Appeal found no evidence of any overt threat against either man; the dissenting justice would have reconsidered the younger man's sentence. Neither view altered the convictions, which both men had accepted by their pleas.

Timeline

2000: Roszko is sentenced to two and a half years for sexual assault.

2002: He is released on mandatory parole.

March 2, 2005: RCMP officers accompany bailiffs to Roszko's property near Mayerthorpe, Alberta, for a court-ordered seizure; Roszko leaves.

March 3, 2005: Four RCMP officers die near Mayerthorpe; Roszko dies by suicide.

March 4, 2005: The RCMP names the four officers in a news release.

July 2007: The Alberta RCMP charges two men with four counts of first-degree murder each.

January 2009: Both men plead guilty to four counts of manslaughter in the Court of Queen's Bench of Alberta.

January 30, 2009: They are sentenced to 15 and 12 years.

September 2010: The Court of Appeal of Alberta dismisses both sentence appeals, two to one.

January 2011: The public fatality inquiry opens at Stony Plain, Alberta.

March 2011: The inquiry reports that the deaths could not reasonably have been foreseen or prevented.

August 2011: The Supreme Court of Canada declines to review the sentences.

May 12, 2015: The older man is granted full parole.

June 2019: The older man's sentence expires in full.