On October 23, 1998, Barnett Slepian, a doctor who provided abortions in western New York, was killed in Amherst, the suburb on the northeastern edge of Buffalo. A federal jury would later find that he was attacked because of the services he provided. The man convicted of his death was James Charles Kopp, an activist who had spent more than a decade blockading clinics from California to Vermont and who had been arrested dozens of times for it.
Kopp vanished within days. For two and a half years he moved through Mexico, Ireland and France under a string of false names while the FBI placed him on its Ten Most Wanted list. French police arrested him in the Breton town of Dinan in March 2001. After more than a year of extradition proceedings, which turned on a promise that he would not face execution, he was flown back to Buffalo in June 2002. In March 2003 an Erie County Court judge, sitting without a jury, found him guilty of murder in the second degree, and on May 9, 2003, he imposed the maximum term of 25 years to life. On January 25, 2007, a federal jury in Buffalo convicted him of violating the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act, and in June 2007 he was sentenced to life in prison plus ten years. The federal appeals court affirmed his conviction in 2009, and in 2013 the Supreme Court declined to review his case.
Kopp was born in 1954 in Pasadena, California, and grew up in Marin County, north of San Francisco. He went on to the University of California at Santa Cruz, where he took a degree in marine biology in 1976, and later earned a master's degree in biology. He never married, and for most of his adult life he held menial jobs.
From the mid-1980s he became steadily more active in the movement against abortion. Beginning in 1984 he was arrested nine times outside San Francisco clinics, on charges that ran from trespassing to assault. In 1988 he moved east to Binghamton, New York, where Operation Rescue had its base, and he also demonstrated often with a smaller group, the Lambs of Christ. He served ten weeks in jail in Vermont after one blockade. By the late 1990s he was living in St. Albans, Vermont, and his arrest record ran to more than two dozen cases in the United States and Italy.
The killing took place on the evening of Friday, October 23, 1998, and Kopp became a suspect quickly. Several witnesses placed him in the neighborhood in the period before it, and evidence later tied him to the crime. He disappeared eleven days after it.
In May 1999 state and federal complaints charged him in the death: the state with murder in the second degree, and the federal government with a violation of the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act. On June 7, 1999, the FBI added him to its Ten Most Wanted Fugitives list. In January 2000 Canadian authorities issued a Canada-wide warrant charging him with attempted murder in the 1995 wounding of a man in Ancaster, Ontario, near Hamilton, a charge that has never been tried.
By then Kopp was far away. He lived under some two dozen aliases and spent about a year in Ireland, living in hostels and taking clerical work, before moving on to France in March 2001.
The end came on Thursday, March 29, 2001, when French police arrested Kopp in Dinan, a small town in Brittany. He had been a fugitive for two and a half years.
The same day, in New York City, FBI agents arrested a married couple on federal charges of conspiring to harbor a fugitive. In April 2003 both pleaded guilty in federal court in New York to conspiring to harbor Kopp.
Kopp was held in Rennes, the Breton capital, while the United States sought his return. The obstacle was the death penalty. France had abolished capital punishment in 1981 and would not extradite people who faced execution, and the federal charge against Kopp carried a possible death sentence. The U.S. Attorney General gave the French government an assurance that prosecutors would not seek it.
On that basis a French appeal court approved the extradition in June 2001. Kopp was entitled to challenge the decision further, and the case moved slowly. On March 22, 2002, the French prime minister signed the order allowing him to be returned for trial, and on May 27, 2002, Kopp formally gave up his right to appeal it.
On June 5, 2002, U.S. marshals flew him out of Paris. That day, in federal court in Buffalo, he pleaded not guilty to the federal indictment, which charged him with using deadly force to stop the victim from providing reproductive health services, in violation of the clinic access law, and with a related count arising from the same act. The state indictment charged murder in the second degree, reckless endangerment in the first degree and a further possession offense. He was jailed without bail.
The state case came first. Shortly before a jury trial was due to begin in March 2003, Kopp waived his right to a jury and agreed instead to a stipulated trial before a single judge of Erie County Court.
The trial took one day, and no witness testified. The case went to the judge on agreed facts and exhibits, and the first of those facts was that Kopp had caused the death on October 23, 1998. The only real question left was his intent: the defense maintained that he had meant only to wound and asked for acquittal on the murder charge.
The judge gave his verdict the next day. He found Kopp guilty of murder in the second degree. Kopp, who was 48, had not testified. On May 9, 2003, the judge imposed the maximum term of 25 years to life.
The federal charge remained, and the Justice Department brought it to trial. Before the trial, a federal judge ruled that the lawyer who had represented Kopp in the state case could not act for him in the federal one, because he had also represented the couple charged with helping Kopp stay hidden. The federal court also allowed the prosecution to use an admission that Kopp had made during the state proceedings.
Kopp represented himself at the federal trial, which opened in Buffalo in January 2007 and lasted two weeks. He did not dispute that he had caused the death, and he argued once more that he had meant to wound, not kill. On January 25, 2007, the jury found him guilty of violating the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act and guilty on the related count. In June 2007, at 53, he was sentenced to life in prison plus ten years.
Kopp appealed the federal conviction to the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in Manhattan. On April 6, 2009, a three-judge panel upheld both the conviction and the life sentence. According to the Associated Press, the panel rejected his central claim that he had meant only to injure, holding that under the clinic access law it did not matter whether he intended to kill: the statute required only that he intended to injure the victim because he provided reproductive health services, and a life sentence was available where death resulted, so long as he acted with malice and a heightened disregard for human life.
His later challenges joined the state and federal cases together, because both turned on the same lawyer's conflict of interest and on the use in federal court of the admission made while that lawyer represented him. The Second Circuit, the Associated Press reported, held that Kopp had not shown that his rights had been violated. In June 2013 the Supreme Court of the United States denied his petition for review without comment.
As of June 2013 Kopp, then 58, was held in a federal prison in Pennsylvania, serving 25 years to life on the New York murder conviction and life plus ten years on the federal judgment. The Canadian charge of attempted murder had not come to trial as of 2013.
Kopp admitted causing the death, both in the agreed facts at his state trial and in his own statements in court. He never accepted that he meant to kill. Two courts rejected that position, the first on the facts and the second on the law.
He was charged in Canada with attempted murder in the 1995 Ancaster case under a warrant issued in January 2000. As of 2013 that charge had not come to trial, and he had not been convicted of it.
Who helped him during his years as a fugitive was only partly settled in court: the couple arrested in New York pleaded guilty to conspiring to harbor him.
1954: Kopp is born in Pasadena, California.
1976: He takes a degree in marine biology at the University of California at Santa Cruz.
1984: His arrests outside San Francisco clinics begin.
1988: He moves to Binghamton, New York.
October 23, 1998: The killing in Amherst, New York; Kopp disappears eleven days later.
May 1999: State and federal complaints charge him in the death.
June 7, 1999: The FBI adds him to its Ten Most Wanted Fugitives list.
January 2000: Canada issues a warrant charging him with attempted murder in the 1995 Ancaster case.
March 29, 2001: French police arrest him in Dinan, France; a couple is arrested in New York on harboring charges.
June 2001: A French appeal court approves extradition after a U.S. assurance against the death penalty.
March 22, 2002: The French prime minister signs the extradition order.
May 27, 2002: Kopp drops his appeal against extradition.
June 5, 2002: He is flown to the United States and pleads not guilty in federal court in Buffalo.
March 2003: An Erie County Court judge convicts him of murder in the second degree after a stipulated trial.
April 2003: The New York couple pleads guilty to conspiring to harbor him.
May 9, 2003: He is sentenced to 25 years to life.
January 25, 2007: A federal jury convicts him under the clinic access law.
June 2007: He is sentenced to life in prison plus ten years.
April 6, 2009: The Second Circuit affirms the federal conviction and sentence.
June 2013: The Supreme Court denies review; he is held in a federal prison in Pennsylvania.