James Ford Seale

Victims
2 kidnappings and a kidnapping conspiracy, May 2, 1964; federal jury verdict June 14, 2007; never tried for murder
Years active
May 2, 1964
Location
Warren County, Mississippi (killings); Roxie, Mississippi (residence and 2007 arrest); Jackson, Mississippi (trial); Terre Haute, Indiana (prison and death)
Method
Victims beaten, then drowned (Fifth Circuit's 2010 account of the trial evidence and forensic testimony)
Status
Three life terms, August 24, 2007; reversed 2008; en banc tie June 2009; affirmed March 12, 2010; certiorari denied October 2010. Died in federal custody, Terre Haute, Indiana, August 2011.

On the morning of May 2, 1964, two young Black men from Franklin County, Mississippi, were picked up as they hitchhiked near Meadville and never returned. Henry Hezekiah Dee and Charles Eddie Moore had grown up as friends in that corner of the state. Members of a local Ku Klux Klan unit had marked one of them as a suspected militant on the strength of a rumor, and by the end of the day both were dead. Two Klansmen were arrested that November and released within weeks, and for more than forty years no court heard the case.

James Ford Seale was one of the two men arrested in 1964. In January 2007, after a reopened federal investigation and the cooperation of the other man arrested with him, a federal grand jury in the Southern District of Mississippi indicted him on two counts of kidnapping and one count of conspiracy to commit kidnapping. On June 14, 2007, a jury in Jackson found him guilty on all three counts, and on August 24, 2007, he was sentenced to three life terms. He was never tried for murder. His appeal ran for three more years: a three-judge panel threw out the convictions in 2008 on statute-of-limitations grounds, the full appeals court split evenly in 2009, the Supreme Court declined to answer the question put to it, and in 2010 the convictions were affirmed. Seale died in federal custody in Terre Haute, Indiana, in August 2011.

Two young men from Franklin County

The friend raised in Roxie had been brought up by his grandmother in that small town in rural southwest Mississippi. He grew up poor and finished high school. He had spent time with relatives in Chicago and came back to Mississippi in 1964 known as a sharp dresser, with a new hairstyle he was proud of and often covered with a bandana. The Klansmen who followed him that spring took the bandana as the mark of a militant.

The other friend was born in 1944 in rural Franklin County, near Meadville. He grew up without running water or electricity after his father's death in 1948, and was raised by his mother alongside an older brother. His classmates elected him class president and voted him Most Intelligent. He went on to Alcorn State, was suspended after he joined a student protest, and hoped to become a schoolteacher. The two had been friends since childhood.

Through the spring of 1964 some white residents of Franklin County believed that Black militants were gathering arms for an uprising, and the Klan suspected the Roxie friend of being involved. No arms were ever found.

The Bunkley klavern

According to the trial evidence, Seale belonged in 1964 to the Bunkley klavern, a local chapter of the White Knights of the Ku Klux Klan in Franklin County. The appeals court recorded that the klavern was headed by his father. FBI informants had identified Seale as a member of the White Knights in the same period, and testimony showed that Klan money helped post his bond after his 1964 arrest. He always denied belonging to the Klan.

He was a truck driver in 1964. By the time of his federal trial he was a retired crop duster living in Roxie.

May 2, 1964

At trial the government showed that several members of the klavern gathered in Meadville that morning to identify the Roxie friend. When he left the bank there he met his friend, and the two began hitchhiking. Seale picked them up and drove them into the Homochitto National Forest, with other Klansmen following. There the two were questioned about the supposed arms. They named a Baptist church in Roxie, and three of the Klansmen left to have officers look there. Nothing was found. The pastor's diary for that Saturday recorded that law officers and members of the Klan had come to the church looking for arms.

The two young men were alive when the witness who later testified against Seale last saw them, getting into the back of Seale's car. What happened after that came into court mainly through what Seale was said to have told that witness. The government's case was that Seale and other Klansmen took the two men out of Mississippi through Louisiana and back into Warren County, Mississippi, and that both died there the same day. That crossing of a state line was the basis for federal jurisdiction over the case.

Discovery and the first arrests

The deaths came to light in July 1964, in the course of the federal investigation into the disappearance of three civil rights workers in Neshoba County.

Federal agents worked the case in the months after May 1964, interviewing witnesses and suspects and obtaining warrants. On November 6, 1964, officers of the Mississippi Highway Safety Patrol arrested Seale at his residence in Franklin County, with two FBI agents present, and arrested the man who would later testify against him on the same day. Both were charged with murder under state law.

During the drive to Jackson that day Seale sat silent through questioning by the state officers. When an FBI agent confronted him, he answered that he would not admit it and that they would have to prove it, and said he would say nothing more. Those words would become one of the most contested pieces of evidence in his federal case four decades later.

Seale and his co-defendant were released on bond of $5,000 each on November 11, 1964. On January 11, 1965, at the district attorney's request, the state murder charges were dismissed without prejudice. They were never refiled.

The silent decades

In 1965 the Civil Rights Division of the Justice Department told the FBI in a memorandum that a federal kidnapping charge would require proof that Seale knew the two men had been carried across a state line, and asked agents to establish that knowledge. The suspects stayed silent and no witness would testify.

On January 14, 1966, Seale was among eleven reputed Klansmen, including his father and a brother, questioned by the House Committee on Un-American Activities. He invoked the Fifth Amendment 41 times.

After that the case went quiet. A Mississippi newspaper reported Seale dead in 2001. In fact he was living openly in Roxie, in a trailer on land beside a brother's, close to where the two young men had been picked up.

Reopening

The push to revive the case came first from the older brother of the Meadville friend, a career soldier who had joined the Army weeks before his brother vanished. Beginning in December 1998 he pressed local and federal officials to reopen it. In January 2000 a Mississippi newspaper reported that the killings had likely taken place on federal land, and found a surviving copy of an FBI file the bureau had said was destroyed. The Justice Department reopened the case that year.

The decisive turn came in July 2005. The brother returned to Franklin County with a team of reporters, and on July 9 they confirmed that Seale was alive. Later in 2005 the United States Attorney's office for the Southern District of Mississippi opened a new investigation.

That investigation ran until January 2007. Its centerpiece was the cooperation of the other man arrested in 1964. For more than forty years he had denied knowing anything about the disappearances. In 2006 he gave the FBI a statement that Seale had described the events to him, and he entered into an immunity agreement with the government. He was never charged.

Indictment and trial

On January 24, 2007, a federal grand jury in the Southern District of Mississippi returned a three-count indictment charging Seale with two counts of kidnapping and one count of conspiracy to commit kidnapping, the conspiracy alleged with unnamed members of the White Knights of the Ku Klux Klan. Seale was arrested at Roxie the same day. On January 25 he pleaded not guilty in Jackson, and he was denied bond. Before trial the judge rejected defense motions to dismiss the case as time-barred or for pre-indictment delay, and ruled that the jury could hear Seale's 1964 statement to the FBI.

The trial opened in Jackson at the end of May 2007. The prosecution's case rested on its main witness, Seale's co-defendant of 1964, who testified under the immunity agreement. He told the jury that he and Seale had belonged to the same klavern, and he admitted that he had pointed out the Roxie friend as an enemy of the Klan and had taken part in what happened in the forest himself. He testified that Seale had later told him how the two young men were taken into Louisiana and how they died.

Other evidence was offered to support him. The pastor's diary from the Roxie church and the recollection of the pastor's daughter corroborated the visit of Klansmen and officers looking for arms on May 2. An Army Corps of Engineers engineer and a witness from the 1964 recovery testified about the geography that bore on the interstate question. A retired FBI agent told the jury about Seale's answer in the car in November 1964. A medical expert gave an opinion on the cause of death. The government also brought in evidence of Seale's Klan membership and of racially hostile statements he had made, through a minister of the church he had attended, a former relative by marriage, a friend of his son and an editorial he had written for a county newspaper attacking the Civil Rights Bill. The court admitted that evidence as relevant to motive and intent.

The defense called four witnesses, among them a brother of Seale's, and Seale chose not to testify. The defense attacked the main witness's credibility and argued that the government had not proved that Seale crossed a state line, the element that gave the federal court jurisdiction. On June 14, 2007, after nine days of testimony, the jury found Seale guilty on all three counts.

On August 24, 2007, the trial judge sentenced Seale, then 72, to life imprisonment on each of the three counts, three life terms in all. He was taken into federal custody and held at Terre Haute, Indiana.

The statute-of-limitations appeal

Seale raised seven issues on appeal, but the first panel to hear the case decided only one. On September 9, 2008, a three-judge panel of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit held that the prosecution was barred by the federal five-year limitations period for offenses that are not capital. In 1964 the kidnapping statute allowed a death sentence, and a capital offense could be charged at any time. The panel reasoned that when Congress removed the death penalty from the kidnapping statute in 1972, the offense became non-capital and fell under the five-year rule, retroactively, so that the period had expired at the latest in 1977. It held that the 1994 restoration of the death penalty for kidnapping resulting in death could not revive a prosecution already barred. It vacated the convictions and rendered a judgment of acquittal.

The acquittal never took effect. On November 14, 2008, the Fifth Circuit granted the government's petition for rehearing by the full court, which vacated the panel opinion, and Seale stayed in custody. In June 2009 the eighteen judges of the en banc court divided equally, nine to nine. Under the court's practice the tie affirmed the district court's denial of the motion to dismiss, without any opinion settling the question.

On July 30, 2009, the en banc court certified the limitations question to the Supreme Court. On November 2, 2009, the Supreme Court dismissed the certified question in a one-line order, deciding nothing about the limitations question itself, and the case went back to the original Fifth Circuit panel.

The 2010 ruling

On March 12, 2010, the panel affirmed Seale's convictions by a vote of two to one, in an opinion revised on March 17. It took the remaining issues in turn.

On pre-indictment delay, the court held that the long gap had been investigative, not tactical. It relied on the 1965 Justice Department memorandum about the interstate element and on the silence of the suspects and witnesses, and it accepted the district court's finding that the government moved forward only once it had the cooperation of the 1964 co-defendant. Because Seale could not show bad faith, the court did not need to decide whether the delay had prejudiced him.

The hardest issue was the 1964 statement. Both sides and the trial judge had treated it under the older voluntariness test because it was made before Miranda v. Arizona, but Miranda governs every trial held after 1966. The majority found that admitting the unwarned statement was an error, and an obvious one. Reviewing for plain error because the point had not been raised at trial, it declined to grant relief, holding that the statement was far from an unequivocal admission of guilt and that the evidence was clearly sufficient without it.

The panel also upheld the admission of the medical expert's opinion, the refusal to let the defense call the main witness's lawyer to impeach him, and the evidence of Seale's Klan membership and racial hostility, including the newspaper editorial and the pastor's diary, as proof of motive, intent and corroboration. It rejected the claim that the evidence was insufficient, holding that the main witness's credibility was for the jury.

The third judge, the author of the 2008 panel opinion, concurred in part and dissented in part. He would have held that the statute of limitations had run long before 2007 and that admitting the unwarned statement was reversible error.

On October 4, 2010, the Supreme Court denied Seale's petition for a writ of certiorari. His convictions were final.

Seale served the rest of his life in federal custody at Terre Haute, Indiana. He died there in August 2011, at the age of 76, and the Bureau of Prisons announced his death on August 3, 2011. It gave no cause of death. He was the only person ever convicted in the case.

Disputed and unproven points

Seale was convicted of kidnapping and conspiracy to commit kidnapping, not of murder. The 1964 state murder charges against him were dismissed without prejudice on January 11, 1965, and were never refiled.

He maintained his innocence and denied belonging to the Klan. The main witness had denied any knowledge of the events for more than four decades before his 2006 statement and testified under a grant of immunity; the jury accepted his account, and the appeals court held that his credibility was a matter for the jury.

The appeals court found the admission of the 1964 statement an obvious error, though not one requiring reversal, and one judge would have reversed on that ground. Whether the prosecution was time-barred at all was never decided by a majority of any appellate court.

Seale's birth year is not settled: one report citing FBI records gives 1936, which does not match the ages wire reports gave for him (71 in January 2007, 76 at his death in August 2011). The date the deaths came to light also differs: the court record and wire reports give July 1964, while one broadcaster's case page gives November 1964.

The trial evidence placed other Klansmen at the events of May 2, 1964. None of them was charged, and most had died before the 2007 indictment.

Timeline

May 2, 1964: Two young men from Franklin County are picked up near Meadville, Mississippi, by Klansmen and die the same day.

July 1964: Their deaths come to light during the federal investigation of three disappeared civil rights workers.

November 6, 1964: Seale and another Klansman are arrested on state murder charges.

November 11, 1964: Both are released on $5,000 bond.

January 11, 1965: The state charges are dismissed without prejudice.

June 1965: A Justice Department memorandum asks the FBI to establish the interstate element for a federal kidnapping charge.

January 14, 1966: Seale invokes the Fifth Amendment 41 times before the House Committee on Un-American Activities.

2000: The Justice Department reopens the case.

July 9, 2005: Seale is confirmed to be alive in Roxie, Mississippi.

2005: The United States Attorney's office opens a new investigation.

January 24, 2007: A federal grand jury indicts Seale on two counts of kidnapping and one of conspiracy; he is arrested at Roxie.

January 25, 2007: Seale pleads not guilty in Jackson.

June 14, 2007: A federal jury finds him guilty on all three counts.

August 24, 2007: Seale is sentenced to three life terms.

September 9, 2008: A Fifth Circuit panel vacates the convictions on limitations grounds and renders an acquittal.

November 14, 2008: The Fifth Circuit grants rehearing en banc.

June 2009: The en banc court divides nine to nine, affirming the district court.

July 30, 2009: The en banc court certifies the limitations question to the Supreme Court.

November 2, 2009: The Supreme Court dismisses the certified question.

March 12, 2010: A Fifth Circuit panel affirms the convictions, two to one.

October 4, 2010: The Supreme Court denies certiorari.

August 2011: Seale dies in federal custody at Terre Haute, Indiana, aged 76.