Jamal Zougam

Victims
191 terrorist murders and 1,856 attempted murders (National Court, October 31, 2007), with terrorist destruction and membership of a terrorist organization
Years active
March 11, 2004
Location
Madrid, Spain (killings); Madrid, Spain (trial); Galicia, Spain (prison, 2019 to 2023)
Method
Explosive devices placed on four commuter trains (court's findings); he denies any part in it
Status
42,922 years (40 to be served under Spanish law); Supreme Court upheld it July 17, 2008. In prison in Spain, closed regime, release date 2044 (as of March 2024).

On March 11, 2004, three days before a general election, attacks on four commuter trains in Madrid killed 191 people and injured about 1,800 more. Two days later, police in Madrid detained Jamal Zougam, a Moroccan who ran a telephone shop in the Lavapiés district of the city. He was the first person arrested in the case, and three and a half years later he stood at the center of its verdict. On October 31, 2007, the National Court convicted him as one of the material perpetrators of the attacks and found him guilty of 191 terrorist murders, 1,856 attempted murders, four offenses of terrorist destruction and membership in a terrorist organization. His sentence came to 42,922 years, of which Spanish law allows 40 to be served.

The Supreme Court upheld his conviction in July 2008. He has never admitted any part in the attacks. He told the trial court that it was impossible for him to have been on the trains, and from prison he has gone on saying, in interviews and to prison staff, that he is innocent and has been jailed unjustly. The case against him rested in large part on witnesses who said they saw him on one of the trains, and those identifications have been under challenge ever since. The courts have not moved. As of March 2024 he was one of three men convicted over the attacks still in prison, with a release date in 2044.

Zougam was born on October 5, 1973, in Tangier, Morocco, and kept his Moroccan citizenship. He has said that he began working at 16. By the time of the attacks he was living in Madrid and running a shop that sold telephone services in Lavapiés, a neighborhood in the center of the city.

The attacks struck four commuter trains in Madrid on the morning of Thursday, March 11, 2004. The people who died were men and women traveling through the city, strangers to the men who attacked them. The court later recognized 191 deaths and 1,856 people who survived attempts on their lives.

The general election went ahead on March 14, as scheduled. In the days before the vote, some suggested a role for ETA, the Basque separatist group. The investigation never found evidence of it, and the trial court later ruled that ETA had played no part.

Police detained Zougam in Madrid on Saturday, March 13, 2004, the day before the election, while he was at work. Investigators had connected his shop to the attacks within the first two days of the inquiry, and two other Moroccan men and two Indian men were detained at the same time. Years later he complained in an interview that his picture was in the newspapers before he had appeared before a judge.

On Friday, March 19, the investigating judge of the National Court charged Zougam and two other Moroccans with 190 killings, 1,400 attempted killings and membership in a terrorist group. The two Indian men were charged with collaborating with a terrorist group and falsifying a commercial document. Zougam was sent to a prison near Madrid. All three Moroccans said they had been asleep in bed when the attacks took place, and all three denied any involvement.

The arrests did not stop with Zougam. By March 26, fifteen people had been arrested, two had been released, and eleven had been charged: five with mass murder and membership in a terrorist group, six with collaboration. Among them was a Spanish man from Asturias, José Emilio Suárez Trashorras, who was later convicted for his part in the attacks.

On April 3, 2004, seven men whom investigators regarded as the leaders of the cell died by suicide in Leganés, a town south of Madrid, as police closed in. A police officer died with them. None of the seven ever stood trial.

On April 11, 2006, the investigating judge indicted 29 people. Zougam was one of three charged with 191 counts of murder and 1,755 counts of attempted murder, accused of a direct part in the attacks. He had told the police that he was asleep when they took place. The indictment described the cell as made up of long-term residents of Spain and found no apparent link to al-Qaida.

The trial opened at the National Court in Madrid on February 15, 2007, with 29 defendants. Zougam was the only detained defendant charged as a direct perpetrator, and he was the first to be questioned. He told the court that it was impossible for him to have been on the trains and that he had been asleep at the time. Four witnesses identified him in court as one of the men they had seen on the trains that morning. He answered that they had recognized him only after seeing his picture on television, and he pointed to what he called obvious errors in one witness's account. Later in the trial he denied any part in preparing the attacks and denied having been at the places where some witnesses put him that morning.

The National Court delivered its judgment on October 31, 2007. It convicted 21 of the 28 remaining defendants and acquitted seven, one other having been cleared during the trial. Zougam and Otman El Gnaoui were convicted as the material perpetrators. Each was found guilty of 191 terrorist murders, 1,856 attempted murders, four offenses of terrorist destruction and membership in a terrorist organization, with a further offense.

Zougam's sentence was the sum of the penalties for each count: 12 years for membership in a terrorist organization, 30 years for each of the 191 murders, 20 years for each of the 1,856 attempted murders and 15 years for each of the four offenses of terrorist destruction, 42,922 years in all. El Gnaoui received 42,924 years, the two extra years for forging official documents for terrorist purposes. Suárez Trashorras was convicted of complicity in the murders and the attempted murders and sentenced to 34,715 years. The other defendants received terms of between three and 18 years, most of them for membership in or collaboration with a terrorist organization.

The acquittals drew as much attention as the convictions. Among the seven cleared was the man the prosecution had accused of being one of the planners; the court found that the evidence did not support his conviction for the Madrid attacks. The judgment found that ETA had played no part, and it did not name al-Qaida. Every defendant had denied the charges.

Zougam took his case to the Criminal Chamber of the Supreme Court. His defense argued that there was no incriminating evidence against him: that the protected witnesses who placed him on the trains had contradicted themselves and had identified him only after his picture had been published widely, that the trial court had ignored his alibi evidence, and that nothing physical tied him to the preparation of the attacks.

The Supreme Court ruled on July 17, 2008, and upheld Zougam's conviction and sentence. It acquitted four of the other men the National Court had convicted, convicted Antonio Toro, whom the trial court had acquitted, and left in place the acquittal of the man accused as a planner. It removed the forgery term from El Gnaoui's sentence while keeping his conviction as a material perpetrator.

His defense carried its challenges as far as the Constitutional Court, without result. His side also brought a criminal complaint for false testimony against two women who had identified him as a man they saw on the trains, a step that could have opened the way to a review of his conviction. The complaint was closed without any charge against the women, and his conviction has never been reviewed.

Zougam has been held in several prisons in different parts of Spain. As of March 2023 he was in Galicia, in the north-west of the country, under the closed regime known as first grade, the strictest classification in the Spanish prison system, and he continued to insist that he was innocent. In an interview from prison in March 2019 he said that he condemned every attack and all violence, that he did not know any of the people involved and that he had no theory of his own about who was responsible.

Most of the others convicted over the attacks have finished their sentences. Several were sent back to Morocco on their release, two in 2017 and another, Rachid Aglif, in May 2022 after serving 18 years. As of March 2024 only three remained in prison: Zougam, El Gnaoui and Suárez Trashorras. All three had release dates in 2044, when they will have served 40 years.

Zougam has denied any part in the attacks from his first hearing in March 2004 to his most recent public statements. He says he was nowhere near the trains that morning. The National Court and the Supreme Court rejected his defense, and his conviction is final.

The identification evidence remains the point of dispute. Witnesses placed him on one of the trains, and his defense has argued since 2008 that they saw his picture before they identified him, that their accounts contained contradictions, and that the identification procedure at trial was flawed. A complaint of false testimony against two of the witnesses was closed without charges, and no court has found that any witness lied.

The suggestions made in March 2004 that ETA was behind the attacks were examined at trial and rejected by the court. The question of who planned the attacks was not fully answered in court: the man the prosecution accused of being one of the planners was acquitted, and several of the people investigators regarded as leaders died in Leganés before they could be tried.

Timeline

October 5, 1973: Jamal Zougam is born in Tangier, Morocco.

March 11, 2004: Attacks on four commuter trains in Madrid kill 191 people and injure about 1,800.

March 13, 2004: Zougam is detained in Madrid, the first arrest in the case.

March 14, 2004: Spain's general election is held.

March 19, 2004: The investigating judge of the National Court charges him with 190 killings, 1,400 attempted killings and membership in a terrorist group.

April 3, 2004: Seven men regarded as the cell's leaders die by suicide in Leganés; a police officer is also killed.

April 11, 2006: The investigating judge indicts 29 people; Zougam is charged with 191 murders and 1,755 attempted murders.

February 15, 2007: The trial opens at the National Court in Madrid.

October 31, 2007: The National Court convicts 21 defendants; Zougam is sentenced to 42,922 years as a material perpetrator.

July 17, 2008: The Supreme Court upholds his conviction.

March 2019: He gives an interview from prison maintaining his innocence.

March 2023: He is held in Galicia under the closed regime.

March 2024: He is one of three men convicted over the attacks still in prison, with a release date in 2044.