Kwon Jae-chan was convicted of killing three people in Incheon, South Korea, one in 2003 and two in December 2021. In 2003 he killed a 69-year-old pawnshop owner and took a small sum of money, then fled to Japan, where he was caught. He was sentenced to life imprisonment, cut on appeal to 15 years, and he was released in 2018. On December 4, 2021, he strangled a woman in her 50s whom he knew and took her money and jewelry. The next day he killed the man who had helped him withdraw her money and dispose of her body.
The Incheon District Court sentenced him to death in June 2022, the first death sentence from a South Korean trial court in more than four years. A year later the Seoul High Court replaced it with life imprisonment, finding that he had planned the robbery but that it was hard to conclude he had also planned the killings. The Supreme Court made the life sentence final on September 21, 2023.
Little has been made public about Kwon's early years. His record is better known, above all the 2003 case.
In 2003, in Incheon, Kwon beat a 69-year-old pawnshop owner to death, the Sisa Journal and Dailian reported. Aju Business Daily put the place in what is now Michuhol-gu. He took checks and 320,000 won in cash, then smuggled himself out of the country to Japan. He was caught there; the Sisa Journal said the arrest came through cooperation with the Japanese authorities.
Prosecutors charged him with five offenses, robbery-murder among them. The court of first instance sentenced him to life imprisonment, and the appeal court reduced the sentence to 15 years, according to Aju Business Daily and Edaily. He served the full term and was released in 2018. After his release, the Sisa Journal reported, he had no steady job.
Prosecutors later told the court that Kwon owed more than 90 million won, much of it gambling debt, and had been listed as a credit delinquent, Segye Ilbo reported. That, they said, was what led him to the woman he killed in December 2021. She was in her 50s and was someone he knew. She has been identified publicly only by an initial and her age, and nothing more about her life has been made public.
The man he killed the following day is also identified only by an initial. Most reports give his age as in his 40s; Aju Business Daily, in December 2021, said he was in his 50s. Law Times and Aju Business Daily described him as a co-worker. He had not taken part in the woman's killing. According to the courts' findings as reported, he helped Kwon afterward.
On the morning of December 4, 2021, in Michuhol-gu, Incheon, Kwon strangled the woman. He then used her credit card to withdraw 4.5 million won in cash and took belongings, including jewelry, worth about 11 million won. The Korea Times, relaying Yonhap, said he withdrew the cash at an ATM.
Prosecutors told the court that before the killing Kwon had searched online for terms such as "masked robber" and "ATM robber," Segye Ilbo reported. Police said he had learned the PIN for her card before he killed her, and they treated that as evidence that the robbery had been planned.
On December 5 Kwon killed the man who had helped him. He beat him to death in Incheon's Jung-gu district. Edaily placed the killing around midday. Segye Ilbo and the Sisa Journal reported that he had prepared for it in advance.
The date and circumstances of Kwon's arrest have not been made public. Right after it, police said, he claimed falsely that the man he had killed was the one who had killed the woman. Investigators concluded that this had been his plan: to draw the man in as an accomplice and then kill him, leaving him to look like the killer, Aju Business Daily reported.
Under questioning, Kwon said both deaths had happened in quarrels and had not been planned. Police rejected that account. They concluded that he had acted for money and had planned the crimes.
On December 9, 2021, the Incheon Metropolitan Police Agency released Kwon's name, his age, given as 52, and his photograph. The decision was made that afternoon by a disclosure review committee of eight members, five of them outside experts, including legal professionals, and three police officers. The vote was unanimous. The committee cited the cruelty of the crimes, the seriousness of the harm and the strength of the evidence, the Sisa Journal reported. Police also set up a support team for Kwon's own family, to protect them from further harm.
On the morning of December 14, 2021, Kwon was taken from Michuhol Police Station and sent to prosecutors, held on charges of robbery-murder and corpse abandonment. Reporters asked whether the crimes had been planned; he shook his head. Asked whether he had anything to say to the victims, he said briefly that he was sorry. He wore a mask over most of his face and refused requests to remove it.
Kwon was indicted while in custody on charges that included robbery-murder and corpse abandonment. At trial his lawyer admitted the killings but denied that they were robberies, Segye Ilbo reported. The lawyer said Kwon admitted the remaining charges, among them corpse abandonment, special theft and drunk driving.
The difference mattered. As Segye Ilbo explained, under South Korean law robbery-murder carries only death or life imprisonment, while murder carries death, life imprisonment or a prison term of at least five years. Experts quoted by Segye Ilbo said admitting murder while denying robbery was likely an attempt to reduce the sentence.
On May 10, 2022, prosecutors asked the court to sentence Kwon to death. Dailian reported that they cited the request of the victim's family for severe punishment.
On June 23, 2022, the 15th Criminal Division of the Incheon District Court, with 이규훈 presiding, sentenced Kwon to death. It also ordered him to wear an electronic location-tracking device for 30 years.
The court did not convict him of everything as charged. Of the two robbery-murder counts, it found an intent to rob only in the killing of the woman. For the man's death it found no robbery intent and convicted Kwon of murder instead, Dailian reported. The court noted that the sum Kwon had borrowed from the man was not large, and found that his motive was more likely to cover up the whole affair than to escape a debt.
The court said Kwon had approached the woman to get out of financial trouble, then brought in an accomplice and killed him too. It found nothing in his motive or circumstances to mitigate the sentence. He had prepared the means in advance, killed the two victims one after the other, disposed of their bodies, destroyed evidence and tried to flee abroad. The results were very grave, and the court found no sincere remorse.
"Recovery of humanity cannot be expected from the accused," the court said, in the Korea Times translation. The judges acknowledged that death is an exceptional punishment, but said it was imposed to hold him responsible and to prevent such crimes.
Kwon was 53 at sentencing. His was the first death sentence handed down by a South Korean trial court since February 2018, when 이영학 was sentenced to death, a gap Dailian put at four years and four months. That sentence was later reduced to life on appeal and made final.
South Korea still has the death penalty in law, but it has carried out no execution since December 30, 1997, and is regarded internationally as abolitionist in practice, the Korea Times noted. At the end of 2020, 60 people were held under sentence of death.
A week after Kwon's sentencing, the Munhwa Ilbo reported that, according to the Ministry of Justice, 59 people were serving death sentences as of July 1, 2022, four of them from the military. The paper noted that courts had moved away from imposing death sentences on serial killers, and that Kwon's sentence could still be reduced on appeal.
The appeal was heard by Criminal Division 7 of the Seoul High Court, with 이규홍 presiding and 이지영 and 김슬기 sitting with him, as case 2022노1826. Prosecutors again asked for the death penalty.
On June 23, 2023, the court set aside the death sentence and imposed life imprisonment. It did not take a light view of the case. It called the crimes cruel and the case grave, and said Kwon had partly denied the crimes and offered excuses that were hard to accept, Edaily reported. It found no sign that Kwon had made any effort to live as a member of society, and it saw little chance that he would regain his humanity.
The decisive point was planning. "It is accepted that the defendant planned the robbery, but it is difficult to conclude that he went on to plan the killing," the court said, according to Law Times and Edaily. Given the victim's condition, it said, his conduct supported his statement that the killing had been impulsive.
On the death penalty itself, the court said, as Law Times reported, that death is "an extremely exceptional punishment that permanently takes away human life itself," and should be imposed only where it is clear that special circumstances exist.
The prosecution appealed. On September 21, 2023, the First Division of the Supreme Court, with Justice 김선수 presiding, dismissed the appeal in case 2023도9503 and upheld the life sentence, Law Times reported. The 30-year electronic monitoring order stayed in place.
The court found that the High Court had not broken the rules of logic and experience, had not gone beyond the limits of the free evaluation of evidence, and had not misread the law, including the law on robbery-murder, Law Times and Aju Business Daily reported. Kwon was 54, Edaily reported on the morning of the ruling.
The case became part of South Korea's long argument over a death penalty that remains in law but is not carried out. In early September 2023, shortly before the Supreme Court ruling, 승재현, a senior research fellow at the Korean Institute of Criminology and Justice Policy, listed the Kwon case in a Law Times column among cases of the previous ten years in which no death sentence had become final. The column argued over whether South Korea should introduce life imprisonment without the possibility of parole.
Proven by final judgment: the robbery-murder of the woman in her 50s on December 4, 2021, and the murder of the man on December 5, 2021, with corpse abandonment and other offenses. The robbery charge in the man's death was not proven; the courts found that killing was a murder without robbery intent.
Proven by earlier judgment: the 2003 killing of the pawnshop owner, for which he served 15 years. Reports differ on the sentencing path. Aju Business Daily and Edaily say he was first sentenced to life and that the appeal court reduced it to 15 years; the Sisa Journal says only that he was sentenced to 15 years. Exactly which offenses the final 2003 sentence covered has not been made public.
Planning: police and the trial court found that Kwon planned the crimes, including bringing in the man in order to kill him. The appeal court accepted only that he planned the robbery, and found it hard to conclude that he planned the killings. That finding was the main reason it set aside the death sentence.
The man's age: most reports give it as in his 40s; Aju Business Daily, in December 2021, gave it as in his 50s.
2003: in Incheon, Kwon kills a 69-year-old pawnshop owner and flees to Japan, where he is caught. Charged with five offenses including robbery-murder; sentenced to life imprisonment, reduced on appeal to 15 years.
2018: released after serving 15 years.
December 4, 2021, morning: strangles a woman in her 50s whom he knew, in Michuhol-gu, Incheon; withdraws 4.5 million won with her card and takes belongings worth about 11 million won.
December 5, 2021, around midday: kills the man who had helped him, in Eulwang-ri, Jung-gu, on Yeongjong Island.
December 9, 2021: the Incheon Metropolitan Police Agency releases his name, age and photograph after a unanimous committee vote.
December 14, 2021: sent to prosecutors from Michuhol Police Station on charges of robbery-murder and corpse abandonment.
May 10, 2022: prosecutors ask for the death penalty.
June 23, 2022: the Incheon District Court sentences him to death, with 30 years of electronic monitoring; robbery intent is found only for the first killing.
July 1, 2022: the Ministry of Justice counts 59 people serving death sentences.
June 23, 2023: the Seoul High Court sets aside the death sentence and imposes life imprisonment.
September 21, 2023: the Supreme Court dismisses the prosecution's appeal; the life sentence and the monitoring order become final.