Jack Teitel

Victims
2 murders in 1997; also convicted of two attempted murders (2008), arms-law offenses and incitement to violence, January 16, 2013
Years active
1997
Location
Jerusalem, Israel (killing, arrest and trial); near Susya, South Hebron Hills, West Bank (killing); Shvut Rachel, West Bank (residence); Florida, United States (birth)
Method
Shot (both murders, as set out in the indictment and the convictions)
Status
Two life terms plus 30 years, April 9, 2013; Supreme Court rejected his appeal, June 28, 2016. Imprisoned in Israel, serving two life terms, as of January 2018.

In the summer of 1997, two Palestinian men were killed a few months apart, one in Jerusalem and one in the hills south of Hebron. The police had a suspect within weeks: a young American tourist who left the country soon after the second death. The file was closed as the work of an unknown offender. Twelve years passed before the same man, by then living in a West Bank settlement, was arrested in Jerusalem, and it was 2013 before a court convicted him.

He was Yaakov Teitel, known in the United States as Jack. On January 16, 2013, the Jerusalem District Court convicted him of two counts of murder, two counts of attempted murder, offenses under the arms law and incitement to violence. The court rejected his lawyers' case that mental illness had removed his responsibility, and found that he had been in full control of his faculties when he killed. On April 9, 2013, it sentenced him to two life terms and a further 30 years. On June 28, 2016, Israel's Supreme Court rejected his appeal.

Teitel was born in November 1972 in Florida, and his family later moved to Norfolk, Virginia. In the 1990s he began to travel to Israel on tourist visas. He was a tourist on the trips during which the 1997 murders took place, and between those visits he returned to the United States.

He settled in Israel permanently in 2000. For a time he lived in Beit Shemesh, west of Jerusalem. By 2009 he lived in Shvut Rachel, a small settlement in the northern West Bank, where he worked for himself repairing computers and designing websites. He had never become fluent in Hebrew.

The first death came in June 1997 in Jerusalem. Samir Balbisi was a Palestinian from East Jerusalem. Teitel was later convicted of his murder, but for twelve years no one was charged with it.

A few months later the second death took place in the South Hebron Hills, south of Hebron. Issa Jabarin, as the 2013 court reports spell his name (earlier reports give it as Jabrin), was a Palestinian from the area around Susya. Teitel was convicted of this murder too. He then returned to the United States.

This was the killing that first made the police look at Teitel. The Judea District police set up a special investigation team. Within days they had placed him in the area and found that his account of his movements did not hold up, and they established that he had brought forward his flight to the United States. He left Israel on August 11, 1997. On September 1, 1997, the police asked Interpol for help and declared him wanted for questioning.

The trail went no further. About three months after the killing, the head of the special team recommended that the file be closed, on the ground that there were no findings or evidence leading to the suspect. The case was shelved as the work of an unknown criminal.

The file was reopened in 1999, when a new lead reached investigators, and on July 25, 1999, a 24-hour arrest warrant was issued in his name. Teitel landed at Ben-Gurion Airport on May 12, 2000, at the start of his move to Israel, and he was arrested on arrival. The Shin Bet, Israel's internal security service, questioned him. He denied any involvement in the deaths and was released for lack of evidence. Nine years passed before he was arrested again.

The indictment later charged that between 2000 and 2009 Teitel carried out a series of further acts against Palestinians, police and others. Most of them caused no injury, and the acts charged near the settlement of Eli did not end in attempted murder convictions. The two acts of which he was convicted as attempted murder both took place in 2008.

The first, in March 2008, was in Ariel, a city in the central West Bank. It was aimed at the head of a local Messianic Jewish congregation, and it was the congregation leader's teenage son who was hurt. The boy survived with serious, lasting injuries that still needed treatment five years later.

The second, in September 2008, was in Jerusalem. Its target was Zeev Sternhell, a well-known Israeli historian and political scientist, who was lightly injured. Evidence presented in court later showed that the police and the Shin Bet had information pointing to Teitel as the main suspect in a series of attacks, and that he had evaded them.

On October 7, 2009, police and the Shin Bet arrested Teitel in Jerusalem in a joint operation, on suspicion of attempted murder, aggravated assault, arms offenses and racial incitement. A gag order kept the arrest secret until Sunday, November 1, 2009, when the police announced that he had confessed to the two 1997 murders and to the later acts. In court, Teitel said that he did not recognize its authority.

On Thursday, November 12, 2009, the prosecution filed an indictment of 14 counts against him in the Jerusalem District Court. They included two counts of premeditated murder, three counts of attempted murder, offenses under the arms law and incitement to violence, and they covered a span of about twelve years. When he arrived at the court that morning, Teitel said he had no regrets.

The trial opened in December 2009, but within months it stopped over the question of Teitel's mental health. He was placed under psychiatric observation in a hospital, and in the spring of 2010 the hospital's psychiatrist concluded that he was in a psychotic state and was not fit to stand trial. On May 4, 2010, the Jerusalem district psychiatrist submitted an evaluation to the court that reached the same conclusion. It dealt only with his state at that time and his ability to follow a trial, not with his state of mind in 1997 or 2008. In court he said that he did not know whether he was sane.

Teitel was then sent to a second hospital for a fresh assessment. Its evaluation, submitted to the court at the end of August 2010, contradicted the first: it found him fit to stand trial and responsible for his actions when he committed them. In December 2011 the Jerusalem District Court ruled that Teitel was fit to stand trial.

In May 2012, after nearly three years of denials, Teitel admitted the charges in a plea arrangement. Because he refused to recognize the court, his two lawyers signed and filed the admission on his behalf. He admitted two counts of murder together with further counts of attempted murder, incitement, arms offenses and arson, and the court was left to decide whether he had been criminally responsible. At the defense's request, the state also dropped the passage of the indictment that described his motive as opposition to groups and individuals whose way of life differed from his own.

On January 16, 2013, the Jerusalem District Court gave its verdict. It convicted Teitel of two counts of murder and two counts of attempted murder, of offenses under the arms law and of incitement to violence and terror. The incitement conviction concerned leaflets he had distributed offering a reward for the killing of gay men and lesbians. The panel rejected the defense case that he had been legally insane. It found that he had been in full control of his mental faculties at the time of the murders and was responsible for his actions, and it held that no causal link had been shown between his mental state and the acts for which he was convicted.

On Tuesday, April 9, 2013, the court sentenced him to two life terms, one for each murder, and to a further 30 years for the two attempted murders and the other offenses. It refused a lighter sentence on grounds of his mental condition, holding again that his condition had no bearing on what he had done and that he was fully accountable. Before the sentence was announced, Teitel told the court that he did not regret his actions. The court also ordered him to pay 180,000 shekels to the family of each of the two murdered men and 150,000 shekels to each of the two survivors.

Teitel appealed to the Supreme Court against the finding that he was responsible for his acts. He asked the court to consider a claim of temporary insanity, arguing that he had been in the grip of delusional thoughts when he killed, and that before the murders an angel had appeared to him and commanded him to carry them out.

On Tuesday, June 28, 2016, the Supreme Court rejected the appeal. It found that a claim of angelic visions raised at so late a stage cast doubt on the credibility of the appeal as a whole, and it left both the convictions and the sentence of two life terms plus 30 years in place.

Teitel has been held without a break since his arrest in October 2009. As of January 2018 he remained in Israeli custody, serving his two life sentences.

He told investigators that God had instructed him in a dream to carry out his attacks and that he had acted alone. On appeal he added the claim that an angel had commanded the murders. The courts found him responsible for his acts in 2013 and again in 2016.

The number of attempted murders varied with the stage of the case. The indictment of November 2009 contained three counts of attempted murder, and the plea arrangement of 2012 was described as covering more. He was convicted in January 2013 of two.

Teitel did not recognize the authority of the courts that tried him. He appeared at hearings, but his admission of the charges was signed by his lawyers, not by him.

Timeline

November 1972: Born in Florida; the family later moves to Norfolk, Virginia.

1990s: Begins visiting Israel on tourist visas.

June 1997: The first murder, in Jerusalem.

1997: The second murder, near Susya in the South Hebron Hills, a few months later.

August 11, 1997: Leaves Israel for the United States.

September 1, 1997: Police ask Interpol for help and declare him wanted for questioning; the file is later shelved.

July 25, 1999: A 24-hour arrest warrant is issued.

May 12, 2000: Arrested at Ben-Gurion Airport on arrival, questioned by the Shin Bet and released for lack of evidence; settles in Israel.

March 2008: Attempted murder in Ariel; a teenage boy is seriously injured.

September 2008: Attempted murder in Jerusalem; a historian is injured.

October 7, 2009: Arrested in Jerusalem by police and the Shin Bet.

November 1, 2009: The gag order is lifted and the arrest is made public.

November 12, 2009: Indicted on 14 counts in the Jerusalem District Court.

December 2009: The trial opens.

May 4, 2010: The district psychiatrist's evaluation finds him unfit to stand trial.

August 2010: A second evaluation finds him fit and responsible.

December 2011: The court rules him fit to stand trial.

May 2012: Admits the charges in a plea arrangement signed by his lawyers.

January 16, 2013: Convicted of two murders, two attempted murders, arms-law offenses and incitement; found criminally responsible.

April 9, 2013: Sentenced to two life terms plus 30 years.

June 28, 2016: The Supreme Court rejects his appeal.

January 2018: Serving his two life sentences in Israel.