Jack Ruby

Victims
1 man killed in Dallas, 1963; died before retrial. Found guilty of murder with malice and sentenced to death, March 14, 1964; verdict reversed October 1966; he died January 3, 1967.
Years active
November 24, 1963
Location
Dallas, Texas
Method
Murder with malice (as indicted and as found by the 1964 jury; verdict later reversed).
Status
Death (jury, March 14, 1964); reversed and remanded by the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, October 1966; died January 3, 1967, before a retrial set for Wichita Falls.

On the morning of Sunday, November 24, 1963, the Dallas police brought Lee Harvey Oswald out of the city jail to move him to the county jail. Two days earlier President John F. Kennedy had been killed in Dallas, and the prisoner, a former Marine, had been charged with his murder and with the murder of a Dallas patrolman. As the transfer began, a man pushed forward and killed him in full view of the police and of a television audience the size of a nation. The man was Jack Ruby, a Dallas nightclub operator, and he was seized where he stood.

Ruby was indicted for murder two days later. In March 1964 a Dallas jury found him "guilty of murder with malice" and assessed the penalty at death. In October 1966 the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals reversed the conviction and sent the case back for a new trial outside Dallas. Ruby died in Dallas on January 3, 1967, before that trial could begin. He killed the one man who might have explained the assassination in a courtroom, and the questions raised by what he did outlived both of them.

He was born Jacob Rubenstein, probably in Chicago, in 1911. The Warren Commission, which reconstructed his life in more detail than any other inquiry, could not settle the date; he most often gave it as March 25, 1911. As a boy he was referred to Chicago's Institute for Juvenile Research for truancy. He went to the Smyth, Clarke and Schley schools, probably finished the eighth grade in 1927, and almost certainly never went to high school. He scalped tickets and sold novelty goods on the streets, and he was known as "Sparky," a name he would fight anyone for using.

In about 1933 he went west, first to Los Angeles and then to San Francisco. He sold racing tip sheets at the Santa Anita and Bay Meadows tracks, and in San Francisco he went door to door selling newspaper subscriptions. He came back to Chicago in about 1937, was out of work for a time, and lived by scalping tickets and buying watches and small goods to sell again at a markup. Then, from late 1937 to early 1940, he worked as an organizer and negotiator for Local 20467 of the Scrap Iron and Junk Handlers Union; the Commission found no evidence that the job tied him to criminal groups. In 1941 he helped found the Spartan Novelty Company, which sold candy-filled cedar chests and punchboards, a small gambling device, across the northeastern states, and he lived out of hotels while he sold. Late that year he moved the business back to Chicago and ran it by mail. After Pearl Harbor he tried selling commemorative plaques and busts of President Roosevelt, a venture that failed when cheaper copies beat his to market, and from late 1942 into 1943 he worked for an auto glass firm and a sales company. He was inducted into the U.S. Army Air Forces on May 21, 1943. He spent five weeks at Farmingdale, New York, and the rest of his service at air bases in the South, where he trained as an aircraft mechanic. His efficiency and character ratings were excellent, and he was honorably discharged on February 21, 1946, as a private first class with the good conduct medal. After the war he ran the sales side of a business called Earl Products, selling the same mix of chests, punchboards and novelties. He worked alone, pushed to add other companies' lines such as costume jewelry, and disliked traveling outside Chicago.

In early 1947 he went to Dallas to help run the Singapore Supper Club, and by the end of that year he had settled there for good, selling his share of Earl Products for more than $14,000 in cash. On December 30, 1947, a Dallas court changed his name to Jack L. Ruby.

For the next sixteen years he ran clubs. The Singapore became the Silver Spur. He tried a dance hall, briefly managed a theater, held a short-lived place called Hernando's Hideaway, and in 1953 took an interest in the Vegas Club, which he still owned in 1963. In late 1959 he opened the Sovereign Club, a private club that became the Carousel Club when a backer insisted on striptease shows in place of memberships. By 1963 it was one of three burlesque clubs in downtown Dallas, with four dancers, a master of ceremonies and a band, and net receipts of about $5,000 a month, most of it paid out in wages. His money was always in disorder. He kept cash in his pockets, the clubs rarely used bank accounts, an accountant quit on him, and his federal tax forms went in weeks or months late. The Texas charter of the corporation behind the Carousel was canceled in 1961 for unpaid franchise taxes. After the courts ruled that dance halls serving incidental food were cabarets, he owed more than six years of excise taxes on the Vegas Club, about $40,000 with interest. Government liens against him passed $20,000 in 1960, the government turned down an $8,000 settlement offer in November 1962, and a $3,000 offer in June 1963 had not been acted on when he was arrested. By then the United States claimed about $44,000 in delinquent taxes.

He was always reaching for the next deal. Over the years he sold costume jewelry and sewing machine attachments at the Texas State Fair, managed a performer, and tried pizza crusts, log cabins, English razor blades and record promotion. In early 1959 he made preliminary inquiries, as a middleman, about selling surplus jeeps to Cuba, a project that never became more than a possibility. In October 1963 he helped with a carnival show at the State Fair and looked for backing for a new club, and in early November he ordered several dozen exercise twistboards and had 2,000 flyers printed to sell them. Through 1963 he was also in a running dispute with the American Guild of Variety Artists, the performers' union, which he believed was letting two rival club owners undercut him with "amateur" strip shows.

In late summer 1959 he traveled to Havana as the guest of a close friend; both men described the visit as purely social. He considered himself a Democrat, and the Commission found no reliable sign that he had ever been tied to any Communist or radical cause. His record with the Dallas police included a $10 fine for disturbing the peace in 1949. He knew a great many Dallas policemen and gave them discounts and free drinks at his clubs, but the Commission found no credible evidence that he sought special favors from them or tried to bribe them.

On Friday, November 22, he was at the offices of a Dallas newspaper, placing advertisements for his clubs' weekend shows, when the news of the attack on the President came. Later that day he closed both clubs for the weekend, and by his own account he could not stop crying. That evening he went to a service at Temple Shearith Israel. Late that night he was at police headquarters, caught up, he later said, in the excitement of history, and he was in the room when the police showed the prisoner to the press. When the district attorney told reporters the prisoner belonged to the "Free Cuba Committee," Ruby called out the correct name of the group. Through the weekend, the Commission found, he was deeply upset by a full-page advertisement critical of the President that had appeared in a Dallas paper on the morning of the visit. On Saturday he went to Dealey Plaza, where the President had been killed, and he spent much of that night telephoning friends.

On Sunday morning he killed the prisoner at police headquarters and was arrested on the spot. Under questioning he denied that the killing had anything to do with a conspiracy to kill the President and said he had acted in a temporary fit of depression and rage over the President's death. He also made other statements to officers that day, and one of them would decide his appeal: that he had first thought of killing the prisoner at the Friday night press appearance.

A Dallas County grand jury indicted him for murder on November 26, 1963. His first lawyer planned to argue that he had acted in sudden passion, which under Texas law would have made the crime murder without malice, with a maximum penalty of five years. The defense changed course when a new lead lawyer took over and sought a full acquittal on grounds of insanity, arguing that Ruby suffered from a rare form of epilepsy, "psychomotor variant," and had acted during a seizure. The defense asked to move the trial out of Dallas. The trial judge refused, and in February 1964 the case went to trial in the city where the President and the prisoner had both been killed.

The prosecution relied on the killing itself and on his post-arrest statements, among them the remark about planning at the Friday press appearance. The rest of the trial became a contest of experts. Witnesses for the defense testified that he had organic brain damage, most likely psychomotor epilepsy, and that he could not tell right from wrong at the time. Neurologists called by the prosecution testified that his brain-wave charts showed no serious abnormality and would not support that diagnosis. Ruby did not testify.

On March 14, 1964, the jury returned its verdict: "We, the jury, find the defendant guilty of murder with malice and assess the penalty at death." The judge denied his motion for a new trial.

The Warren Commission, appointed to investigate the assassination, had to deal with Ruby as well. He asked again and again, from December 1963 on, to be given a lie detector test, and on June 7, 1964, the Chief Justice and members of the Commission took his testimony in the Dallas County jail. He explained the killing as an act of grief. He had read in a newspaper a letter to the President's young daughter, and he had wanted to spare the President's widow the ordeal of coming back to Dallas for a trial. He insisted on the test over the objection of his chief defense lawyer, and an FBI examiner gave it to him on July 18, 1964. Asked whether he had known the prisoner before November 22, or had helped in the assassination, he said no. Asked whether he had first decided to act on Sunday morning, and had done it to spare the widow a trial, he said yes. The examiner reported no sign of deception on the relevant questions, but the Commission declined to rely on the result, calling it nonconclusive, and reached its conclusions without it.

In October 1966 the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals reversed the conviction by a unanimous decision. It held that the trial judge had erred in letting the jury hear testimony that Ruby had admitted planning the killing. That statement had been made at least ten minutes after his arrest, had not been written down, and had been given without a warning of his right to remain silent, and under Texas law it should have been kept from the jury. The court held separately that the judge's refusal to move the trial out of Dallas was, by itself, enough to overturn the verdict. Its order read: "Reversed and remanded with directions." The new trial was to be held outside Dallas County, and Wichita Falls was chosen.

Ruby never reached Wichita Falls. He fell ill in December 1966 and died in Dallas on January 3, 1967, while awaiting the new trial. He was not retried, and with the 1964 verdict set aside he died without a standing conviction for the killing.

Disputed and unproven points

Whether Ruby acted alone was examined by two federal inquiries, and they did not fully agree. The Warren Commission, reporting in September 1964, concluded that he and the prisoner had not known each other and that he had acted independently. It found no evidence that he was part of any conspiracy, domestic or foreign, to assassinate the President, and none that members of the Dallas police had helped him. It accounted for his presence in Dallas on every day after September 26, 1963, except five, and found no evidence that he had gone to Mexico. Law enforcement agencies confirmed his denial that he was part of organized crime. The Commission also ran down a long list of rumors that tied him to the prisoner, to the patrolman killed that Friday and to the Dallas underworld, and found no credible support for any of them.

The House Select Committee on Assassinations, reporting in 1979, took a harder view. It concluded that the killing involved at least some premeditation, that it was less likely than the Commission had believed that he acted without any assistance, and that he had associations with organized crime figures the Commission had not known about. It concluded that he was not a member of organized crime in Dallas or anywhere else, but that he had a significant number of direct and indirect contacts with underworld figures. From tourist cards and immigration, FBI and bank records, it found that he had made at least three trips to Cuba in 1959, judged that vacationing was probably not their purpose, and reached the view that he was most likely serving as a courier for gambling interests. It examined his long-distance calls in the months before November 1963 and found them, by and large, related to his union troubles, though it was not satisfied with the explanations given for several calls to men closely associated with organized crime. It found little evidence of any significant influence by him within the Dallas police, but thought his close relationship with one or more officers may have been a factor in his entry that morning. It found no evidence that he or his family profited from the killing. Theories that he silenced the prisoner on behalf of others have circulated since 1963; no court ever ruled on them.

Ruby's own account was that he had decided on Sunday morning, on impulse, out of grief and to spare the President's widow a trial. The committee rejected that account, relying on a handwritten note he had written to one of his lawyers, made public in 1967, in which he said his first lawyer had told him to give that explanation. The polygraph that supported his account was set aside by the Commission as inconclusive, and a panel of polygraph experts who examined it for the committee found so many procedural errors that it could not interpret the examination at all. The statement that contradicted his account, about planning at the Friday press appearance, was the evidence the appeal court ruled inadmissible. The question of premeditation was never decided by a jury in a lawful trial.

Timeline

1911: Born Jacob Rubenstein, probably in Chicago (he usually gave the date as March 25, 1911).

About 1933: Goes to Los Angeles and San Francisco; returns to Chicago in about 1937.

Late 1937 to early 1940: Organizer for a Chicago scrap iron and junk handlers' union local.

May 21, 1943: Inducted into the U.S. Army Air Forces; honorably discharged February 21, 1946.

1947: Moves to Dallas; on December 30 a court changes his name to Jack L. Ruby.

1953: Takes an interest in the Vegas Club.

Late summer 1959: Travels to Havana; the House committee later finds at least three trips to Cuba that year.

Late 1959: Opens the Sovereign Club, later the Carousel Club.

November 22, 1963: President Kennedy is killed in Dallas; Ruby closes his clubs for the weekend.

November 24, 1963: Kills the man charged with the assassination at Dallas police headquarters; arrested at once.

November 26, 1963: Indicted for murder by a Dallas County grand jury.

February 1964: A motion to move the trial out of Dallas is refused; the trial begins.

March 14, 1964: Found "guilty of murder with malice," penalty assessed at death.

June 7, 1964: Testifies to the Warren Commission in the Dallas County jail.

July 18, 1964: Polygraph examination; the Commission later calls it "nonconclusive."

September 1964: The Warren Commission reports; his case pending on appeal.

October 1966: The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals reverses the conviction, unanimously, and orders a new trial outside Dallas.

January 3, 1967: Dies in Dallas while awaiting retrial in Wichita Falls.

1967: A handwritten note by Ruby, later cited by the House committee against his explanation of the killing, is made public.

1979: The House Select Committee on Assassinations finds "at least some premeditation" in the killing and a significant number of contacts with underworld figures.