Jack McGurn

Victims
Held over 7 Chicago deaths, February 14, 1929; never tried. Sent to the grand jury and entered on the police ledger as indicted for felony murder; the case was nolle prossed December 2, 1929
Years active
February 14, 1929 (the seven deaths)
Location
Chicago, Illinois
Method
Murder (charged; never tried)
Status
Never tried; died in Chicago on February 15, 1936

Seven men died together on the North Side of Chicago on the morning of February 14, 1929, and within two weeks the city police had booked Jack McGurn as one of the men they held responsible. On March 16 the coroner sent him to the grand jury, and a judge ordered him held without bail. The police homicide ledger enters an indictment for felony murder against his name. He never stood trial. On December 2, 1929, the case against him was nolle prossed, and no court ever ruled on whether he had any part in the deaths.

Federal prosecutors later turned to the Mann Act against him, and the police held him on a charge under it. On February 15, 1936, he was killed in Chicago.

He was born Vincenzo Gibaldi in Sicily in 1902 or 1903 and was brought to Brooklyn, New York, as an infant. In Chicago he also went by Vincent Gebardi. By his teens he was in Chicago, boxing as an amateur, and he fought briefly as a professional welterweight under the name Jack McGurn. He won three bouts, lost one and drew two, and then he quit the ring.

He went into the Torrio-Capone organization and was taken on, with Frank Nitti, as a bodyguard to Al Capone. Through the Prohibition years it feuded with the North Side gang in the liquor traffic.

The seven men who died that morning were James Clark, Frank Gusenberg, Peter Gusenberg, Adam Heyer, John May, Reinhardt Schwimmer and Albert Weinshank. Six of them belonged to the North Side gang that was the organization's chief rival in the liquor traffic. The seventh kept company with them and had no criminal record. The leader of the North Side gang was not among them.

The city reacted at once. Police raided and rounded up men across Chicago through the night and into the next day, bringing in close to forty. No one questioned that first day would describe the men responsible. A special coroner's jury was called to open its inquest on February 15.

Over the following weeks the police booked several men in connection with the seven deaths. Two were booked on February 22 and a third on February 27. McGurn was booked the same day, February 27, 1929, together with another man the ledger names beside him. Another member of the organization was indicted for the killings and died before any trial.

McGurn had an answer from the start. A woman who later became his wife swore that he had been with her in Chicago throughout February 14. That account, and the lack of any witness willing to describe the men who carried out the killings, sat at the center of the case against him.

On March 16, 1929, the coroner's decision in the death of one of the seven was "Defendant held to Grand Jury," with McGurn as the defendant. On the same day a judge ordered him held without bail. The ledger record for the deaths of the two brothers lists him among the defendants under the same orders. The ledger record for the death of a fourth of the seven enters his booking on February 27 and closes with the same December entry, "McGurn case Nolle Prossed." The official record ties him to at least four of the seven deaths.

The grand jury entry against his name reads "Indictment for felony murder." The case never reached a jury. On December 2, 1929, the prosecution entered a nolle prosequi and dropped the charge. No one was ever tried for the seven deaths.

Federal prosecutors used the Mann Act against men who had slipped other criminal charges, and McGurn was one of them. Police held him on a Mann Act charge.

After the organization's leader was convicted in federal court in 1931, Nitti took over the organization and pushed McGurn out of it. He was killed in Chicago on February 15, 1936.

His part in the deaths of February 14, 1929, was never tested in court. He was booked, held without bail, sent to the grand jury by the coroner and entered on the ledger as indicted, and the ledger records for four of the seven deaths carry his name, but the charge was dropped and no jury ever heard evidence against him. His alibi was never tried against the prosecution's case. In law he died an unconvicted man, accused of murder and never tried.

Timeline

1902 or 1903: Born Vincenzo Gibaldi in Sicily; brought to Brooklyn as an infant.

1920s: Boxes in Chicago as Jack McGurn, then joins the organization.

February 14, 1929: Seven men die together on the North Side of Chicago.

February 15, 1929: A special coroner's jury is called.

February 27, 1929: Booked by Chicago police with another man.

March 16, 1929: The coroner holds him to the grand jury; a judge orders him held without bail.

December 2, 1929: The murder case against him is nolle prossed.

1931: Pushed out of the organization after its leader's federal conviction.

Before August 1934: Held by police on a Mann Act charge.

February 15, 1936: Dies in Chicago.