On the morning of Monday, June 13, 2016, a woman who had given an eighteen-year-old a home dropped him at the Rockingham shopping centre, south of Perth. He had just taken a phone call from someone she believed was named Trudi. "I said God bless you Aaron," she later told a jury, "and he said God bless you Lady A." It was the last time anyone other than his killers saw Aaron Pajich alive.
On June 21 police found his body at Orelia. The next day two women who lived at the address, one a mother of three who had studied alongside him at a college in Kwinana, the other a tattoo artist and supermarket supervisor from Lincolnshire who had written a novel about a serial killer, were charged with his murder. Each would spend the trial blaming the other. A jury believed neither.
The tattoo artist was Jemma Lilley, and the novel was not her only writing about killers. Before that June she had written for Serial Killer Magazine, which published two of her case histories under her name: one on Martin Bryant and the 1996 Port Arthur massacre in Tasmania, the other on Eric Edgar Cooke, the Perth killer known as the Night Caller.
Aaron Pajich was eighteen and had Asperger’s syndrome; at trial he was described as having been assessed as on the autism spectrum. His mother called him her "precious little boy," her first child, a young man who "loved life."
For about six weeks before his death he had been living at Waikiki with a woman he knew through a local church. She had taken him in at a friend’s request. He went to church with her every Sunday, became close friends with her nine-year-old grandson, and called her "Lady A." He was enrolled at a college in Kwinana, and it was there that he met Trudi Lenon, who was also studying at the college. He was friends with one of her sons and played computer games with him.
When word spread that he had not come home, hundreds of people attended a candlelit vigil, and an online appeal raised more than fifteen thousand Australian dollars toward his funeral.
Jemma Victoria Lilley grew up in England. She was believed to have attended Casterton Business and Enterprise College and New College Stamford, and she lived in the centre of Stamford, Lincolnshire, before emigrating to Western Australia. In Perth she worked as a supervisor at a suburban supermarket and as a tattoo artist. By her own account at trial, she had begun writing a story at sixteen, while studying computer game design in England, which grew into a novel she called Playzone. Its central figure is a serial killer named SOS. She told the court the letters stood for "Style or Smiles," and that she planned a trilogy: a second book about the killers' followers, whom she called the "maggots," and a third giving SOS a backstory and a daughter.
The name did not stay on the page. "SOS" was tattooed on her arm. A video store manager in Girrawheen, where Lilley was a regular customer, testified that her rental account was in the name SOS, for Son of Sam, and that she mostly rented horror and serial killer films. She had other tattoos of fictional killers, including one of Freddy Krueger behind her ear, and the house she rented at Orelia she called "Elm Street," after the street in the Freddy Krueger films. In a letter to the actor Robert Englund, who played the character, she had described Freddy as a "father figure and guardian angel." At trial she said she had seen him as a protector in childhood.
Trudi Clare Lenon, 42 when she was charged, was a mother of three with an interest in BDSM. She had moved into Lilley’s house only about three weeks before Aaron’s death, bringing two of her young sons with her. In the months before, the two women had built an intense relationship carried on largely in Facebook messages, in which Lilley was SOS and Lenon took the name "Corvina," a character she used as a submissive. Lenon wrote that she saw Lilley as her "dominant," and that she would "fear you but respect you." Lilley called her a good servant and wrote that Lenon understood her "SOS role." One message, shown to the jury, said that the "first kill" was going to happen and that Corvina would take charge of the clean-up while SOS returned to reality. According to ABC News, the last such exchange came a few days before Aaron died.
The prosecution’s account of the day rested heavily on cameras. Security footage from the shopping centre showed both women there that morning. Aaron arrived some time later, made a phone call and jogged back toward an exit; prosecutors said he then got into a car owned by Lenon and the two women drove him to Orelia. A security camera at the house recorded him arriving there with them that morning. Prosecutors said that in the days before, both women had made repeated visits to a hardware store in Rockingham.
A forensic pathologist, Dr. Jodi White, told the jury he died of stab wounds. Justice Stephen Hall later said the injuries suggested death came quickly.
The next day Lilley sent Lenon a message thanking her. She was seeing things she had not seen before, she wrote, and feeling things she had not felt before; it was "incredibly empowering." Lenon replied: "You’re welcome SOS."
Aaron’s last confirmed sighting was at a taxi rank at the shopping centre. He was reported missing. Lenon, questioned by police, admitted that she had spoken to him by phone on the day he disappeared but at first denied meeting him. Later she said she had met him and reluctantly agreed to give him a lift, intending to take him to Kwinana, but had instead taken him to the house so he could install video games on the computer for her thirteen-year-old son. She said she lay down, fell asleep, and woke to be told by Lilley that he had left about ten minutes earlier. She had lied at first, she said, because she was worried about getting into trouble.
When police first came to the house, before Aaron was found, Lilley showed them around. On June 21 detectives searching the property at Orelia found his body, and Detective Senior Sergeant Dave Gorton of the Major Crime Squad spoke to reporters about the search. The two women who lived there, aged 25 and 42, were charged with murder. Police said that at least one of them had studied at the same educational facility in Kwinana as Aaron, and that they were still trying to establish a motive.
On June 23, 2016, Jemma Victoria Lilley and Trudi Clare Lenon appeared at Perth Magistrates Court. Neither was required to plead. The court was told that Aaron had been killed on June 13, the day he was last seen. On October 26, 2016, the two women appeared separately at Stirling Gardens Magistrates Court and each pleaded not guilty to murder. They were committed to stand trial in October 2017 and remanded in custody.
Lilley gave police two video-recorded interviews after the body was found. In the first she denied any knowledge of his death and said she had spent the day on a motorbike ride to Mundaring Weir. Told she was under arrest, she said: "I’m baffled. I don’t know what’s going on now. Why am I under arrest for murder?" Asked about the novel, she replied: "I’m the storyteller. I’m not part of the characters."
The trial began in the Supreme Court of Western Australia on Monday, October 2, 2017, before Justice Stephen Hall and a jury, and ran for five weeks. Lilley was 26 by then, Lenon 43. The prosecutor, James Mactaggart, told the jury in his opening address that Lenon had lured Aaron to Lilley’s home so that Lilley, the author of a book about a serial killer, "could feel what it was like to kill someone." The State’s case was that the two women were equally responsible.
Each defendant ran what lawyers call a cut-throat defence. Lenon admitted lying to police and helping to clean up afterwards, which made her an accessory after the fact on her own account, but denied murder and said Lilley alone had killed him. Lilley denied any involvement at all and said Lenon must have done it.
A string of witnesses from Lilley’s working life described what she had said in the years before. The video store manager told the court that around the middle of 2013 Lilley said she "wanted to kill someone and she wanted to do it before she was 25," and that the feeling "was getting stronger." The manager had told no one until she saw the case in the news in 2016 and rang Crime Stoppers. Under cross-examination she rejected the suggestion that Lilley had said she expected to be killed by 25, rather than to kill. A former friend and co-worker testified that Lilley said she hoped to be diagnosed with a terminal illness so that she could "go on a slaughter-fest" without consequences, and that she had said people with intellectual disabilities did not deserve to live.
The most damaging evidence came from a colleague at the supermarket. He told the jury that during a shift, while Aaron was still listed as missing, Lilley approached him in an aisle and said: "I did it, I killed someone." She showed him the missing teenager’s picture on a website and a design for a jester tattoo she wanted, to mark what she had done. He said she warned him that if he told anyone she "would have to make that problem go away," and that he had answered her gently because he was afraid for his wife and children. Days later he learned that she had been charged, and the next day he went to police. Lilley’s barrister, John Prior, suggested he was mistaken. "It’s not really one of those things that you forget," he replied. The prosecution said that what she told him included details only the killer would know.
Police described items seized from the house, among them a large collection of knives and a handwritten list that the prosecution put before the jury. Lenon said Lilley had told her to write it as research for the novel.
On October 17 the jury watched Lenon’s recorded interview with detectives. Having first told a different story, she said she had been present when Lilley attacked Aaron as he talked with her about video games, that she left the room, and that Lilley later came out and told her he was dead. She had not believed Lilley would go through with it. "I thought she was just all talk," she said. She told detectives she thought Lilley "definitely believed she’s SOS," agreed that Lilley saw herself as the leader of a murder cult, and agreed that she herself had been groomed to deliver a victim. The message of thanks, she said, had been for helping to clean up.
Lilley did. Over several days in late October she told the jury that Lenon had said she might bring home a friend who wanted to be "trained up" in BDSM, and that she had never met or heard of Aaron until the day he came to the house. After dropping Lenon’s sons at school, she said, the two women met him at the shopping centre at about 10 a.m. and drove him back. At the house she drank a coffee, felt dizzy and tired, and went to another room to watch The Simpsons. She said she "didn’t even get past an episode" before falling asleep, and was woken by Lenon at about 2 p.m. and told that Aaron had gone home. That night, she said, Lenon cooked steak and the two of them watched Game of Thrones. The "empowering" message, she said, was about the television series; the thanks was for dinner and for cleaning up.
She denied confessing to her colleague. She said she had texted him afterwards calling herself a "good storyteller" because she believed she had hurt him by turning down his romantic interest. She said she had lied to police about the motorbike ride because Lenon had asked her to. She said the torture list was research, explaining that her books contained a great deal of torture and she needed new ideas. Asked by her own counsel whether she had anything to do with Aaron’s death, she answered no.
The jury retired after five weeks of evidence and deliberated for about two and a half hours. On November 1, 2017, it found both women guilty of murder. Neither showed any emotion. The courtroom was full: Aaron’s family, the detectives who had worked the case, and relatives of both of the accused. Justice Hall thanked the jurors and told them counselling was available to any who needed it.
Outside, Aaron’s mother said she believed justice had been done. Hearing what had happened to her son had been heartbreaking, she said, and the loss would last a lifetime. She called the two women "disgusting animals" and said she hoped they would be jailed for life.
Two days later the court released exhibits that had been shown to the jury, among them security footage from inside the house and photographs taken by police. Footage from a hardware store showed the two women making a purchase the day before Aaron disappeared. Prosecutors had told the jury that Lilley adopted the SOS persona as part of a plan to "make her mark."
Before sentencing, Lenon was attacked in custody. After her arrest she had been hurt by hot water but not hospitalised. On January 1, 2018, another inmate at Bandyup Women’s Prison allegedly poured boiling water over her. According to her lawyer, she suffered serious burns and spent about three weeks in hospital, part of it in intensive care. The inmate was charged with two counts of causing bodily harm. When Lenon came to court for sentencing she showed no visible injuries.
On February 28, 2018, Justice Hall sentenced Jemma Victoria Lilley, then 26, and Trudi Clare Lenon, then 44, to life imprisonment, each with a minimum term of 28 years. He said it was not clear which of them had inflicted the fatal injuries, but he held them equally responsible for a crime he called "morally repugnant," and said there was no doubt that both had intended to kill. Neither had shown any regret. He pointed to the message Lilley sent the day after the killing, in which she said she felt "incredibly empowered." Addressing both women, he said: "You both derived malicious pleasure from the suffering of Mr Pajich’s family."
Aaron’s mother, father and stepmother welcomed the sentence and said nothing would bring him back. His stepmother said she hoped the two women would "rot," and that they would live long enough to regret what they had done. The court was told that Lilley maintained her innocence and intended to appeal. In England, Peterborough Today reported that a woman from Stamford had been jailed for life.
Lenon did not appeal. Lilley did, and on April 10, 2019, three judges of the Court of Appeal heard her case, with Justice Michael Buss, the court’s President, presiding. Lilley appeared by video link from Eastern Goldfields Regional Prison. Aaron’s family sat in the public gallery. Her barrister, Simon Watters, argued that the jury should never have heard three kinds of evidence.
The first was Playzone. Watters said the novel bore no resemblance to the way Aaron died and had "no significant probative value," and that it should have been kept from the jury, although the book itself had not been tendered. Justice Buss observed from the bench that the book had not been written and forgotten: there was evidence that Lilley was calling herself SOS at the time of the killing. The second was the knives. Police had found dozens of them at the house, including machetes, scalpels and butcher’s knives, and Watters argued they had been wrongly admitted as propensity evidence. Justice Mazza said the number was extraordinary and that it was fair to describe Lilley as having an "obsession" with knives and their use in violence. The third was a violent image shown to the jury while Lenon’s lawyer cross-examined Lilley; Watters argued that it should have led to the jury being discharged and a separate trial being ordered. For the State, the Director of Public Prosecutions, Amanda Forrester SC, told the court the novel was only one part of the case and had not been used on its own to prove guilt. The judges reserved their decision.
In October 2019 the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, finding that none of the grounds had merit. The novel, it held, showed "an intense interest in the nature of an obsession in serial killers and murder generally," and was relevant evidence of character and tendency. The knife evidence showed that Lilley was more likely "than an ordinary person" to stab someone. Of the image, the court said: "The image reflected the appellant’s interest in killing," and its probative value was "substantially greater than any prejudice to the appellant." Lilley was not in court. Aaron’s mother and father were, and said they hoped the ruling marked the end of the legal process.
Much of the case against Lilley had been written down in advance: in a teenager’s novel, in a rental account, in tattoos, in private messages and in a list. Lilley never accepted the verdict. She told the jury she was a storyteller, and the prosecution’s answer, which the jury and the Court of Appeal accepted, was that she had set out to make one of her stories real. Lenon, who said she had believed it was all talk, received the same sentence and did not challenge it.
Aaron Pajich was eighteen, a college student who went to church on Sundays and played video games with his friends. He got into a car with a woman he knew from college. In April 2019, Lilley was being held at Eastern Goldfields Regional Prison; both women were serving life terms when the Court of Appeal ruled in October of that year.
• June 13, 2016: Aaron Pajich, 18, is dropped at the Rockingham shopping centre in the morning and is last seen alive entering the house at Orelia with Jemma Lilley and Trudi Lenon.
• June 21, 2016: Police searching the property find his body.
• June 22, 2016: Lilley, 25, and Lenon, 42, are charged with murder.
• June 23, 2016: Both appear at Perth Magistrates Court and are remanded.
• October 26, 2016: Both plead not guilty at Stirling Gardens Magistrates Court and are committed for trial.
• October 2, 2017: The trial begins in the Supreme Court of Western Australia before Justice Stephen Hall.
• October 17, 2017: The jury is shown Lenon’s recorded police interview.
• October 23 to 25, 2017: Lilley gives evidence in her own defence.
• November 1, 2017: Both women are found guilty of murder after about two and a half hours of deliberation.
• January 1, 2018: Lenon is seriously burned in an attack by another inmate at Bandyup Women’s Prison.
• February 28, 2018: Both are sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 28 years.
• April 10, 2019: The Court of Appeal hears Lilley’s appeal against conviction.
• October 2019: The Court of Appeal dismisses the appeal. Lenon did not appeal.