Ivan Demjanjuk spent the last 35 years of his life before courts in three countries, answering the same question in different forms: what had he done in the war? A Ukrainian-born former Soviet soldier who settled in Ohio in 1952 and worked at a Ford engine plant, he was stripped of his American citizenship twice, sentenced to death in Jerusalem, acquitted by Israel's Supreme Court, and finally tried in Munich at the age of 89.
On May 12, 2011, the Munich II Regional Court convicted him as an accessory to the murder of at least 28,060 people at the Sobibor extermination camp in German-occupied Poland, where the judges found he had served as a guard from March 27 to mid-September 1943. They sentenced him to five years and released him while he appealed. He died on March 17, 2012, in Bad Feilnbach, Bavaria, before Germany's Federal Court of Justice could rule. The judgment never became final, and in April 2012 the Regional Court formally closed the case.
Demjanjuk was born on April 3, 1920, in Dubovi Makharyntsi, a village in the Vinnytsia region of central Ukraine, two years before Ukraine became part of the Soviet Union. He worked as a tractor driver on a collective farm before he was drafted into the Red Army. He was wounded, sent back to the front, and taken prisoner by German forces in the fighting on the Kerch Peninsula in May 1942.
What happened next became the subject of every court that ever heard his case. Demjanjuk said he spent most of the war as a prisoner, held in camps for captured Soviet soldiers, and that he joined the Vlasov Army, a force of anti-communist Soviet prisoners that fought alongside the Germans in the last months of the war. The courts that weighed the documents reached a different conclusion. They found that he had trained at Trawniki, an SS camp in occupied Poland where captured Soviet soldiers who volunteered were trained as auxiliary guards, known in German as Wachmänner.
The central document was a Trawniki service identity pass, No. 1393, issued to a man named Iwan Demjanjuk. It surfaced in a Soviet archive. A federal court in Cleveland later found it authentic, noting that it correctly gave his physical features, his father's name, his date of birth and his place of birth. Other records, found in archives in Moscow, Lithuania and elsewhere in Europe, traced the same man's postings: an SS estate at Okzów in September 1942, a Trawniki detachment at Majdanek from November 1942 to early March 1943, a transfer order dated March 26, 1943, moving a group of guards from Trawniki to Sobibor, and an entry placing him at the Flossenbürg concentration camp as of October 1, 1943.
After the war Demjanjuk was held in a displaced persons camp in Germany and worked for a time as a driver for the U.S. Army. When he applied to emigrate, he listed Sobibor as a place where he had lived and said he had farmed there during the war. He later said he had lied to avoid being sent back to Soviet Ukraine. He arrived in the United States on February 9, 1952, settled in Seven Hills, a suburb of Cleveland, and found work as a mechanic at Ford Motor Company's engine plant in Brook Park, Ohio. The U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio admitted him to citizenship on November 14, 1958. In America he went by John.
For more than two decades nothing disturbed that life. The case against him began in 1975, when the Justice Department opened an investigation, and took formal shape in August 1977, when the government filed suit to revoke his citizenship on the ground that he had falsified his immigration and naturalization papers. His name had first been submitted to immigration officials in 1975 in connection with Sobibor, but survivors later identified him as a guard at another camp, Treblinka, a man they knew by a nickname. That identification, not the Trawniki pass, drove the first decade of the case. In 1979 the department's Office of Special Investigations took over the file.
The trial opened in federal court in Cleveland in February 1981. In June 1981 the court revoked Demjanjuk's citizenship and found him deportable, holding that he had concealed his wartime service when he applied to enter the country. Appeals failed, and the U.S. Supreme Court twice declined to hear the case.
Israel asked for his extradition in November 1983. A U.S. immigration judge ordered him expelled in May 1984, and the Board of Immigration Appeals ruled in February 1985 that he must be deported. On October 31, 1985, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati cleared his extradition to Israel. In February 1986 he was extradited to Israel.
Demjanjuk was tried before a three-judge panel of the Jerusalem District Court, presided over by a justice of the Supreme Court on leave from that court. The trial opened on February 16, 1987, and ran for 106 sessions. The prosecution called 21 witnesses and the defense 31. The charges were brought under the Nazis and Nazi Collaborators (Punishment) Law of 1950, and the indictment accused him of being the Treblinka guard the survivors had named.
The defense disputed both his identity and the court's jurisdiction. Demjanjuk maintained that he had been a prisoner of war throughout the period in question and that the Trawniki pass was a Soviet forgery. He produced no witness to support the alibi.
On April 18, 1988, after a day-long reading of a 450-page judgment, the court convicted him of crimes against the Jewish people, crimes against humanity, war crimes and crimes against persecuted people. It found that he was the Treblinka guard named in the indictment, holding that while no single identification would have sufficed on its own, the identifications taken together were overwhelming. It also upheld the Trawniki pass and rejected his alibi. On April 25, 1988, the court unanimously sentenced him to death. It was only the second death sentence an Israeli court had passed; the first had been passed on Adolf Eichmann. The prosecution had argued that the penalty was mandatory, but the court held that it was discretionary under the 1950 law. Under Israeli law the case went automatically to the Supreme Court on appeal.
The appeal took five years, and the evidence changed under the court's feet. As the Soviet Union came apart, evidence from its archives reached the defense. It repeatedly gave a different name, that of another Trawniki-trained guard, for the man the survivors had described at Treblinka. The Supreme Court admitted the new material before deciding the appeal.
Meanwhile the American case reopened. In 1992 the Sixth Circuit, citing the new evidence and claims that Justice Department lawyers had withheld material that might have helped the defense, reopened the extradition case and appointed a federal district judge from Nashville as special master. His report in June 1993 expressed substantial doubt that Demjanjuk was the Treblinka guard, but found the extradition valid, pointing to the evidence that he had trained as an SS guard and had lied to American officials. The Sixth Circuit later ruled that the Office of Special Investigations had committed fraud in its handling of the case.
On July 29, 1993, a five-justice panel of the Israeli Supreme Court unanimously set aside the conviction in Criminal Appeal No. 347/88. The court's president read a two-hour summary of the 405-page ruling. The court held that the prosecution had to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt and found that the new evidence created "a reasonable possibility" that the appellant was not the Treblinka guard named in the indictment. It acquitted him and overturned the death sentence.
The judgment was not a finding of innocence. The court found clear evidence that Demjanjuk had trained voluntarily at Trawniki and had served as a Wachmann, and it found that the same documents placed him at Sobibor and at the Flossenbürg and Regensburg camps. It did not convict him on that evidence because the indictment charged him only with crimes at Treblinka, and because he had never been given a reasonable opportunity to defend himself against other charges.
Survivors then petitioned the Supreme Court to order new proceedings over Sobibor. On August 18, 1993, the court dismissed the petitions. It declined to apply Section 216 of the Criminal Procedure Law, which allows a court to convict of an offense other than the one charged, because giving Demjanjuk a fair chance to answer new allegations would stretch the hearings beyond an acceptable limit. It also noted that Sobibor had already been mentioned in the original indictment and evidence, which raised the risk of trying him twice for the same matter. The attorney general had already decided not to prosecute again, citing the weakness of the evidence and the double jeopardy problem. In September 1993 a Supreme Court justice rejected the last appeals for a new trial, finding none of the "exceptional circumstances" needed to overturn that decision. Demjanjuk had spent seven years in Israeli custody, held in solitary confinement. In September 1993 he flew back to the United States and returned to Ohio.
On February 20, 1998, a judge of the U.S. District Court in Cleveland vacated the 1981 denaturalization judgment. He found that the Office of Special Investigations had possessed evidence in 1981 that could have helped the defense, including an interview with a man who had been at Trawniki, and had failed to disclose it. He made clear that the ruling turned on legal procedure rather than on Demjanjuk's wartime history, and he vacated the judgment without prejudice, leaving the government free to file again.
It did. In May 1999 the Justice Department filed a new complaint, this time built on the documentary trail rather than eyewitness identification. It alleged that Demjanjuk had served as a guard at Sobibor, Majdanek and Flossenbürg.
The case was tried without a jury. On February 21, 2002, the court entered judgment for the United States. It revoked Demjanjuk's citizenship, vacated the November 14, 1958, order admitting him, canceled Certificate of Naturalization No. 7997497, and ordered him to surrender the certificate and any American passport within ten days.
A supplemental opinion explained why the defense had failed. "This is a case of documentary evidence, not eyewitness testimony," the court wrote. Document examiners had shown that the paper, inks and typewriters on the wartime records were in use on the dates the records bore, that defects in the stamps and typewriters recurred from document to document, and that the photograph on the Trawniki pass had been on it from the start. The court held that the pass correctly described him, and that a height discrepancy was not significant against the rest of the evidence. It weighed the statements of former guards and of a Sobibor survivor that the defense relied on and found that none carried the weight claimed for them. It also found that Demjanjuk, who did not testify in person, had given no credible account of where he spent most of the war after leaving the prisoner-of-war camp at Rovno, and that his earlier testimony had changed on dates, work assignments and why he had listed Sobibor as a place of residence. The government, the court held, had met its burden of clear, convincing and unequivocal proof.
His appeals failed. In December 2004 the government began removal proceedings, and on December 28, 2005, the chief U.S. immigration judge ordered Demjanjuk removed to Ukraine, or to Germany or Poland if Ukraine would not take him. The Board of Immigration Appeals dismissed his appeal on December 21, 2006. On May 19, 2008, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to review the case.
German prosecutors had by then built a case of their own. Germany's Central Office for the Investigation of National Socialist Crimes, in Ludwigsburg, gathered records linking him to Trawniki, and experts at the Bavarian State Office of Criminal Investigation examined the identity pass and found it genuine. A Munich court issued an arrest warrant accusing him of being an accessory to the murder of about 29,000 people at Sobibor. Germany claimed jurisdiction because many of the victims had been German Jews and because Demjanjuk had lived in a displaced persons camp near Munich after the war.
His challenges to removal ran into 2009. Four days before he left, the U.S. Supreme Court refused to block the deportation. On May 11, 2009, he was deported, and on May 12 he was formally arrested in Munich and held in custody.
In July 2009 the Munich prosecutors indicted him as an accessory to the murder of 27,900 people at Sobibor between March and September 1943, and he was declared fit to stand trial. They had no witness who could place him at the camp or tie him to any specific act there. The case rested on the Trawniki pass, the transfer order to Sobibor and the other service records, and on a legal argument that had not been tested in a German court: that any guard proven to have served at a camp whose purpose was killing had, by that service, assisted in every killing during his time there.
The trial opened before the Munich II Regional Court on November 30, 2009. Demjanjuk was 89. Because of his health, doctors limited proceedings to two 90-minute sessions a day. His defense argued that a German court had no jurisdiction over a Ukrainian accused of acts in occupied Poland, maintained that he had never been at Sobibor, and contended that the identity pass might be a postwar Soviet forgery. In 2011 a 1985 FBI document questioning the card's authenticity came to light, and the defense relied on it. Demjanjuk made no lengthy statement.
The trial ran for about 16 months. On March 22, 2011, the prosecution asked for a sentence of six years, well below the 15-year maximum, citing his age, the time he had already spent in custody in Germany and the decades since the events. The proceedings closed in mid-March 2011; the trial had taken 91 hearing days in all.
On May 12, 2011, the court found it proven that Demjanjuk had served as a guard at Sobibor from March 27 to mid-September 1943, and that by that service he had assisted in the murder of at least 28,060 people killed at the camp in that period. It convicted him as an accessory to murder and sentenced him to five years in prison. The written judgment ran to 220 pages.
The verdict rested on the argument the prosecution had built. There was no evidence that he had committed a specific act against any individual; the court held that his service at the camp was itself the crime. It was the first time a German court had convicted a former camp guard on that basis.
The court then lifted the arrest warrant on grounds of proportionality, finding that he posed no risk of flight. He left the courtroom free while the case went on appeal.
Both the defense and the prosecution lodged appeals on points of law, a Revision, to the Federal Court of Justice. Until that court ruled, the conviction was not final and Demjanjuk remained, in law, presumed innocent. He died on March 17, 2012, at the age of 91, in Bad Feilnbach, a town in Upper Bavaria, before the Federal Court of Justice had ruled. In April 2012 the Munich II Regional Court discontinued the proceedings because of his death. It ruled at the same time that the state would not pay his necessary expenses, including his defense costs, a departure from the usual rule when proceedings end without a final judgment.
Demjanjuk never admitted serving at Trawniki, Sobibor or any other camp. To the end he said he had been a prisoner of war and was the victim of mistaken identity. His defense argued for decades that the Trawniki pass was a Soviet forgery. Courts in the United States and Germany, and the Israeli Supreme Court, all found the pass genuine.
The Treblinka accusation that brought him to Jerusalem did not survive. The Israeli Supreme Court acquitted him on reasonable doubt that he was the guard the indictment named, and the evidence it relied on named another man. That acquittal did not clear him of service elsewhere: the same court found that he had been a Trawniki-trained guard and that the documents placed him at Sobibor.
His Munich conviction was never tested on appeal. Both sides had appealed when he died, the Federal Court of Justice never ruled, and the proceedings were discontinued. Under German law the conviction never became final. The figure of at least 28,060 victims is the Munich court's; the indictment had charged 27,900.
April 3, 1920: Born in Dubovi Makharyntsi, Vinnytsia region, Ukraine.
May 1942: Taken prisoner by German forces on the Kerch Peninsula.
March 26, 1943: Transfer order moving a group of guards, including a Demjanjuk, from Trawniki to Sobibor.
March 27 to mid-September 1943: Service at Sobibor, as found by the Munich court in 2011.
October 1, 1943: Recorded at Flossenbürg.
February 9, 1952: Arrives in the United States.
November 14, 1958: Naturalized as a U.S. citizen in Cleveland.
August 1977: Government files suit to revoke his citizenship.
June 1981: U.S. District Court in Cleveland revokes his citizenship.
February 1986: Extradited to Israel.
February 16, 1987: Trial opens in the Jerusalem District Court.
April 18, 1988: Convicted of crimes against the Jewish people, crimes against humanity, war crimes and crimes against persecuted people.
April 25, 1988: Sentenced to death.
July 29, 1993: Israeli Supreme Court sets aside the conviction and acquits him.
August 18, 1993: Supreme Court dismisses petitions for new proceedings over Sobibor.
September 1993: Returns to the United States.
February 20, 1998: Citizenship restored; the 1981 judgment vacated without prejudice.
May 1999: Government files a new denaturalization complaint.
February 21, 2002: Citizenship revoked again.
December 28, 2005: Ordered removed from the United States.
December 21, 2006: Board of Immigration Appeals dismisses his appeal.
May 19, 2008: U.S. Supreme Court declines to review the case.
May 11 to 12, 2009: Deported to Germany and arrested in Munich.
July 2009: Indicted in Munich as an accessory to murder.
November 30, 2009: Trial opens before the Munich II Regional Court.
March 22, 2011: Prosecution asks for six years.
May 12, 2011: Convicted as an accessory to the murder of at least 28,060 people; sentenced to five years; released pending appeal.
March 17, 2012: Dies in Bad Feilnbach with his appeal pending.
April 2012: Munich II Regional Court discontinues the proceedings.