Irmgard Huber

Victims
Accomplice to killings at Hadamar, Germany, 1941-1945; convicted at Wiesbaden, 1945 (over 400 Polish and Russian nationals) and Frankfurt, 1947 (accomplice to murder in at least 120 cases)
Years active
About July 1, 1944, to about April 1, 1945 (Wiesbaden charge); 1941 to 1945 (Frankfurt indictment); Hadamar, Germany
Location
Hadamar; Wiesbaden; Frankfurt am Main (Germany)
Method
Aiding, abetting and participating in the killing of Polish and Russian nationals (Wiesbaden); accessory to murder of patients (Frankfurt)
Status
25 years (Wiesbaden, 1945), confirmed by the 7th Army commander, reduced to 12 years after a 1950-1951 review; eight further years (Frankfurt, 1947); released July 1953

Irmgard Huber ran the female nursing staff of the state institution at Hadamar, a small town in Hesse, through the years in which it was a place of killing. She was the chief female nurse. She took her orders from the institution's only doctor, she oversaw the seven other women nurses, and every morning she sat in the conference at which the doctor signed death certificates and the next deaths were planned.

Two courts convicted her. In October 1945 a United States military commission at Wiesbaden found her guilty of a violation of international law in the killing of Polish and Russian nationals at Hadamar and sentenced her to 25 years' imprisonment. She was the only woman among the seven accused, and hers was the lightest sentence the commission imposed. In 1947 a German court at Frankfurt am Main tried her again, this time for the German patients who had died at Hadamar, convicted her as an accomplice to murder in at least 120 cases, and sentenced her to eight further years, the heaviest prison term that court handed down. A review of the American sentences cut hers to 12 years, and the American military authorities released her in July 1953.

A nurse at Hadamar

Huber was born in 1901. Her service at Hadamar went back to 1932, and by the war years she was the senior woman on its nursing staff.

Hadamar had passed through two phases of killing by the time the forced laborers arrived. The first belonged to the central program the Nazi state ran from Berlin against psychiatric patients, and it ended when that program was halted in 1941. In August 1942, a year later, the staff at Hadamar began killing again. This second phase was not directed from Berlin. Responsibility lay largely with the state and regional administrations, and the medical staff on site chose, day by day, who among the people there would die. The nurses on duty carried the killings out. To the outside the institution kept the look of an ordinary psychiatric hospital, and relatives were lied to about what had happened to the people they had sent there.

The people brought to Hadamar in those years came from across the German Reich and from the occupied countries, above all Poland and the Soviet Union.

The chief female nurse

The commission that later tried Huber set out her place in the institution plainly. She was the chief female nurse, carrying out the orders of the chief physician, Adolf Wahlmann, and overseeing the duties of the seven other female nurses.

Her day began in the doctor's company. Every morning, a member of the staff later stated in a sworn account read into the record of the Nuremberg medical trial, Wahlmann held a conference with the chief male nurse, Heinrich Ruoff, and the chief female nurse, Huber. The commission found it "at least well established" that she took part in those daily meetings. At them Wahlmann signed death certificates, and plans were made for the further disposal of the people held in the institution. When Ruoff was absent, the male nurse Karl Willig sat in his place beside Wahlmann and Huber.

The records that came out of those meetings were false. When people arrived, the staff made out proper papers with their names, sex, nationality and other details. The records of their deaths were always falsified as to the dates and the causes of death. A later German court found that Huber helped to select patients for death and to falsify the death certificates.

The forced laborers

The case that brought Huber before an American court concerned one group among the dead. In the summer of 1944 transports of Polish and Soviet men, women and children began to arrive at Hadamar. They were not patients sent from other asylums. They had been deported to Germany for forced labor and were held under the control of the German Reich, and they came to Hadamar from the labor system. Between June 1944 and March 1945, 476 of them were sent there. Nearly all were killed within days, often within hours, of their arrival.

Huber knew they were coming. The commission found that she knew beforehand of the arrival of the first transport and made preparations for housing the people on it. The decision to kill them had been taken at conferences in the summer of 1944 between an official of the regional administration in Wiesbaden, the institution's chief administrative officer, Alfons Klein, and Wahlmann, and the orders reached the wards through Klein.

The commission found as well that she was present on at least one occasion when patients were put to death, and that there was some evidence that the female nurses themselves took part in the killings. On that last point the evidence it recorded did not name Huber herself.

Liberation and arrest

American troops reached Hadamar on March 26, 1945, and liberated the town and the institution. More than 500 patients were still inside. A US Army investigation began at once. The members of the institution's management still on the premises were taken into custody and questioned, witnesses were interviewed and evidence was seized. Townspeople had told the Americans what had been done there.

Huber was among the staff the Americans arrested. In May 1945 war crimes investigators questioned her about the killings at Hadamar.

Her first answer was that she had never killed a patient. Co-workers and witnesses supported that account, and the Americans let her go. She did not stay free. The investigation went on, she was arrested again, and in the fall she was among the seven members of the staff sent for trial.

The commission at Wiesbaden

The case was United States of America v. Alfons Klein et al. It came before a military commission of American officers sitting at Wiesbaden from October 8 to October 15, 1945. It opened before the international tribunal at Nuremberg had begun its work, and it was the first trial of the "euthanasia" killings in the western zones of occupied Germany. Huber stood in the dock with Klein, Wahlmann, Ruoff, Willig, the bookkeeper Adolf Merkle and the doorman Philipp Blum.

There was one charge, "Violation of International Law," with a single specification. It alleged that the seven, acting jointly and in pursuance of a common intent, and acting for and on behalf of the German Reich, did, between about July 1, 1944, and about April 1, 1945, at Hadamar, "aid, abet, and participate in the killing of human beings of Polish and Russian nationality," in a number unknown but "in excess of 400," held by the Reich as an exercise of belligerent control. All seven pleaded not guilty.

Within that joint charge each accused answered for a part of his or her own. Huber's, as the chief female nurse, was to have been present when some of the killings were carried out and present when the false death certificates were made out. The commission was told to have regard for the rules of procedure and evidence of a general court-martial without being bound by them, and it could admit any evidence that seemed probable to a reasonable man, hearsay included.

The defense attacked the commission's jurisdiction at the outset, denying its right to try the case under international law, and lost. It then raised three pleas for all of the accused. They had acted on orders that came down to them from higher administrative quarters. The killings had been lawful under German law, by force of a decree. And they had acted under coercion and necessity: counsel argued that the staff could neither leave their posts nor protest without risking imprisonment and death in a concentration camp. The commission rejected each plea. It held that people who violate the laws and customs of war are criminally liable even when they act on a superior's order. The defense could not prove that any such decree existed, and even if one had, it could not have made lawful the killing of anyone other than German nationals. Coercion and necessity were established neither in fact nor in law, and the commission accepted the prosecution's answer that the accused could have resigned without fear for their lives.

Verdict and sentence

On October 15, 1945, the commission found all seven defendants guilty. Klein, Ruoff and Willig were sentenced to death and were executed in March 1946. Wahlmann received life imprisonment, Merkle 35 years and Blum 30 years. Huber was sentenced to 25 years' imprisonment.

The commanding general of the 7th Army, Western Military District, confirmed the sentences. Only the death sentences went on to a further confirmation by the commanding general of US Forces in the European Theater. The case had been through review by February 1946. The defendants petitioned for clemency, and the reviewing authority confirmed the commission's findings. Huber went to prison in Germany to serve her term in American custody, and from the time of her sentencing she kept petitioning for release, parole or a reduction of her sentence.

Huber was drawn into the first of the American trials at Nuremberg, the case against the doctors and officials of the Nazi medical system. On January 4, 1947, she signed a one-page affidavit, an Eidesstattliche Erklärung, dealing with the "euthanasia" program as it had been carried out at Hadamar. It went into the record of that trial. She took part in that case only as an affiant.

The Frankfurt trial

The American commission had tried only the deaths of foreign nationals. The German patients of Hadamar lay outside its charge, and the reckoning for them came in a German court. Between 1946 and 1948 the Landgericht Frankfurt am Main held four criminal trials of the staff of three institutions in the region, Hadamar among them. Forty-four people were tried in all: doctors, nurses, attendants and administrative and technical staff.

The Hadamar case opened in February 1947. Twenty-five people stood accused of the murder of patients at Hadamar between 1941 and 1945, and Huber and Wahlmann were in the dock for a second time. With them was a doctor who had worked in the central killing program in 1941. The dead in this case were the German psychiatric patients of the institution, killed there from 1941 to 1945.

The Landgericht gave its judgment on March 21, 1947. The court sentenced the two doctors to death. Neither sentence was carried out. Nine of the accused received prison terms, and the other fourteen were acquitted. The court convicted Huber as an accomplice to murder in at least 120 cases and sentenced her to eight further years. Hers was the longest prison term in the judgment; the other eight ran from two and a half to five years.

The case did not end with the Landgericht. It went up to the Oberlandesgericht Frankfurt am Main, the higher regional court, which gave its decision on October 20, 1948.

Release

Most of those convicted at Frankfurt were released early. Huber's American sentence was reviewed as well. In the early 1950s, under the political pressure of the Cold War, the American authorities granted amnesties and clemency to many of the Nazi perpetrators they held, and Huber's case went before the War Crimes Modification Board.

From 1950 into 1951 the Office of the Judge Advocate at the headquarters of the US European Command reviewed the sentences of the surviving Hadamar defendants. A modification board held a hearing in Huber's case. On its recommendation her term was reduced from 25 years to 12 by a Military Government court order on review. The American military authorities released her in July 1953.

Context: two courts, two groups of the dead

The split between Wiesbaden and Frankfurt followed from the limits of the American commission's authority. The killings of German patients by Germans, inside Germany, were not classed as war crimes, and the American authorities had no basis in international law on which a military commission could try them. The hospital records showed, though, that 476 forced laborers from Poland and the Soviet Union, both Allied nations, had died at Hadamar, and their deaths fell within international jurisdiction. The Wiesbaden specification was drawn for them alone. In framing it the prosecution leaned on the protections for civilians in the annex to the Hague Convention of 1907, which Germany, Russia and later Poland had ratified.

The commission rested its jurisdiction on the universality of jurisdiction over war crimes, on the interest of the United States in crimes against the nationals of its allies, and on the supreme authority the occupying powers assumed in Germany by the Berlin Declaration of June 5, 1945. It also held that civilians, and not only soldiers, could commit war crimes by illegal acts against enemy nationals. Huber was a civilian, and that holding was the basis on which she could be tried at all. The German patients were left to the reconstituted German courts, which could try German nationals for the murder of their own citizens, and the Frankfurt indictment of 1947 took them up.

Disputed and unproven points

Huber's own account from the first weeks after the liberation was that she had never killed a patient. Co-workers and witnesses supported it, and the American investigators released her on the strength of it. The commission's findings against her rested on other ground: her part in the daily conferences, her preparations for the first transport and her presence on at least one occasion when patients were put to death. The evidence it recorded that the women nurses took part in the killings themselves did not name her.

The figures differ between the two courts because they counted different dead. The Wiesbaden charge spoke of more than 400 Polish and Russian nationals, while 476 such laborers had been sent to Hadamar between June 1944 and March 1945. The Frankfurt conviction concerned German patients, in at least 120 cases.

Timeline

1901: Irmgard Huber is born.

1932: Begins her service at the institution at Hadamar.

1941: The central killing program is halted and the first phase of killing at Hadamar ends.

August 1942: The staff at Hadamar begin killing again.

Summer 1944: The first transports of Polish and Soviet forced laborers arrive; Huber prepares housing for the first.

June 1944 to March 1945: 476 Polish and Soviet laborers are sent to Hadamar.

March 26, 1945: American troops reach Hadamar.

May 1945: War crimes investigators question her; she is released and later arrested again.

October 8 to 15, 1945: Tried at Wiesbaden with six other members of the staff.

October 15, 1945: Found guilty and sentenced to 25 years' imprisonment.

January 4, 1947: Signs an affidavit for the Nuremberg medical trial.

February 1947: The Hadamar trial opens before the Landgericht Frankfurt am Main.

March 21, 1947: Convicted as an accomplice to murder in at least 120 cases; sentenced to eight further years.

October 20, 1948: The Oberlandesgericht Frankfurt am Main rules on the case.

1950 to 1951: American review of the Hadamar sentences; a modification board's recommendation cuts her term to 12 years.

July 1953: Released by the American military authorities.