Ira Einhorn

Victims
Holly Maddux murdered in Philadelphia, 1977. Convicted in absentia of first-degree murder in 1993; retried after extradition and found guilty of first-degree murder, October 17, 2002
Years active
1977
Location
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; Champagne-Mouton and Bordeaux, France
Method
First-degree murder
Status
Life in prison (September 30, 1993, in absentia); retried under a 1998 Pennsylvania statute; life without parole (2002); died in custody, April 3, 2020

Ira Einhorn spent the late 1960s and early 1970s as one of the best-known personalities in Philadelphia, a University of Pennsylvania graduate who organized happenings, taught an alternative class, advised corporations about the future and ran for mayor. In 1979 he was charged with murdering the woman he had lived with for five years. He was released on bail, and in January 1981, shortly before his trial was due to begin, he left the country. For sixteen years he lived in Europe under borrowed names while Philadelphia prosecutors, unwilling to let the case lapse, tried him without him. A jury in the Court of Common Pleas convicted him in absentia of first-degree murder in 1993, and he was sentenced to life in prison.

When French police found him in June 1997, that conviction became the obstacle to bringing him back. French law entitles anyone convicted in absentia to a new trial, and the courts in Bordeaux refused to send him to a state that had already judged him. Pennsylvania answered with a statute written for his case, the French courts reversed course, and after four years of appeals that reached the Council of State and the European Court of Human Rights he was flown back to Philadelphia in July 2001. A second jury heard the case in the fall of 2002. On October 17, 2002, it found him guilty of first-degree murder, and he received the sentence the law required: life in prison without parole. He died in Pennsylvania state custody in April 2020, still denying that he had killed anyone.

Einhorn graduated from the University of Pennsylvania in 1961 as an English major. He stayed close to the university after graduation. He taught an alternative education class there and helped found the Free University of Pennsylvania, a movement meant as an alternative to conventional schooling.

Through the second half of the 1960s he became the public face of the counterculture in the city. He organized Philadelphia's first Be-In in 1967 and later a Smoke-In, and in 1971 he ran for mayor of Philadelphia. He kept company with poets and activists and also with corporate executives, spending time with men from General Electric and Bell and offering them predictions about the future. In 1977 he held a fellowship at Harvard's Kennedy School of Government. All the while he kept diaries, filling notebook after notebook, a habit that would matter at his trial a quarter of a century later.

Helen "Holly" Maddux grew up in Tyler, Texas, and came east to Bryn Mawr College, from which she graduated. She met Einhorn in 1972, and for the five years that followed the two lived together in West Philadelphia. She died in Philadelphia in 1977.

The inquiry into her death ran for about eighteen months. Private investigators working on the victim's behalf gathered evidence and brought it to the Philadelphia police, and in 1979 the police arrested Einhorn and charged him with murder.

He did not stay in custody long. At a hearing in 1979 he was released on bail of $40,000. He remained free for almost two years while the case moved toward trial. In January 1981, on the eve of the trial, he left the United States.

He spent the next sixteen years abroad. He lived under assumed names in England, Ireland and Sweden, and finally in France, where he called himself Eugene Mallon, a name borrowed from an Irish friend. By 1997 he was living near Champagne-Mouton, a rural town in southwestern France.

Philadelphia prosecutors took the unusual step of trying him in his absence. The trial was held in 1993 in the Court of Common Pleas, about twelve years after he had left the country, and it was the only murder trial in absentia ever held in Philadelphia. It ran for about a week. The court directed the lawyer who had represented Einhorn before his flight to conduct the defense. On Thursday, September 30, 1993, it found him guilty of first-degree murder, a verdict that carried a life sentence, and he was sentenced to life in prison.

The verdict could not be enforced while he was abroad, but it settled where the case stood. If Einhorn was ever found, he would be returned to serve a life term as a convicted murderer, not to stand trial. That position became the central problem once he was located.

On June 13, 1997, French police arrested him in the Bordeaux region, near Champagne-Mouton, ending sixteen years as a fugitive. The United States asked France to send him back to serve his sentence.

The first round went to Einhorn. In December 1997 an appeals court in Bordeaux rejected the extradition request and ordered him freed on his own recognizance. The refusal rested on the finding that he would not receive another trial in the United States. The United States appealed. On March 3, 1998, France's highest court, the Court of Cassation, upheld the Bordeaux decision. Einhorn was free again. The Bordeaux ruling let him stay in the country while the American appeal ran its course, and a separate French case over his illegal entry into France was still pending.

Pennsylvania's answer came from its legislature. Both chambers passed bills that would allow a retrial if he came back. On January 27, 1998, the governor approved Act 3 of 1998, a Senate bill amending the Judicial Code. Its second section had been written for the Einhorn case: it offered a new trial to a defendant in his position once he was returned, and it took effect the day it was approved. With the statute in place, the United States made a second extradition request. Einhorn was arrested again in September 1998, and on September 29, 1998, a court in Bordeaux ordered him released on bail while the new request was considered.

On February 18, 1999, the French court accepted the request, but only on two conditions: Einhorn could not face the death penalty, and he had to be given a new trial in Pennsylvania. Prosecutors agreed not to seek a death sentence, and assurances went to the French government that the 1993 conviction would be vacated.

He appealed, and he remained free throughout. On July 12, 2001, the Council of State, France's highest administrative court, rejected his challenge and ordered him extradited to the United States. Within hours France agreed to delay the transfer at the request of the European Court of Human Rights, where his counsel had filed a petition, and the extradition was postponed until July 19. The court in Strasbourg then refused to halt it. On July 19, 2001, French police took him into custody in southwestern France and handed him to American officers at Charles de Gaulle Airport outside Paris, and he was flown to Philadelphia on a chartered United States government plane. The extradition fight had lasted about four years.

In Pennsylvania he was held in a state prison while the second trial was prepared. A new trial was now his to claim under the statute and under the terms of his surrender, and in the first weeks after his return he had not yet said whether he would ask for one. His lawyer argued from the first weeks that the 1998 statute was unconstitutional because it violated the separation of powers between the legislature and the courts. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court declined to hear the constitutional question in the winter before the retrial. In August 2002 public defenders filed pretrial motions asking that the trial be halted on the same ground. The case went ahead.

The retrial jury was seated in late September 2002.

The trial lasted about four weeks, and the prosecution's case was circumstantial. The trial judge allowed the jury to hear evidence of his past conduct toward women, and jurors also read passages from his own diaries, which Einhorn told them were metaphorical.

The defense argued reasonable doubt. It suggested that other people had access to the couple's quarters while Einhorn was away early in 1978, and it argued that physical evidence collected in 1979 had since been lost, which made it impossible to test the case properly a quarter of a century later.

Einhorn testified in his own defense and denied murder. He said he had been framed by the Central Intelligence Agency, though he did not say who he believed had killed her.

On October 17, 2002, after about two and a half hours of deliberation, the jury found Einhorn guilty of first-degree murder and rejected the alternative of third-degree murder. The verdict was unanimous.

A conviction for first-degree murder carried an automatic sentence of life in prison without parole, and the death penalty was not available because the United States had promised France that it would not be sought. The judge imposed the mandatory life sentence.

Einhorn spent the rest of his life in Pennsylvania state prisons, serving the life sentence imposed in 2002, and he went on insisting that he had not killed her. He died on April 3, 2020, in state custody in western Pennsylvania.

French law treats a criminal judgment given in the defendant's absence as provisional: a person convicted in absentia is entitled to be tried again, and the French courts would not extradite a fugitive to serve such a sentence without that guarantee. France also opposed the death penalty and would not surrender a person who might face it. Both rules shaped every ruling in the case, and the second became the death-penalty undertaking attached to the 1999 decision.

The Pennsylvania statute was drafted to meet the first rule. It applied to a person who had been tried in absentia and who was living in a country that refused to extradite people so tried. Once returned to Pennsylvania, such a person could ask for a new trial. The earlier conviction stood until the request was made, and a new trial then took its place. The statute became known by Einhorn's name.

In the statute book it is subsection (c), headed "Extradition," of the Judicial Code's section on eligibility for postconviction relief. Its condition was that the refusing country agree "by virtue of this provision" to return the petitioner, and the subsection was to apply "notwithstanding any other law or judgment to the contrary." A separate section of Act 3 made it apply to all existing cases within its provisions, which is what brought a 1993 conviction within its reach.

Einhorn never admitted the killing. From 1979 until his death he denied murder, and at his 2002 trial he blamed an intelligence agency frame for which no evidence was offered. Two juries rejected his account, and the second conviction was in force when he died.

His claim to have been a founder of the first Earth Day in 1970 was contested at the 2002 trial.

The constitutionality of the 1998 statute was challenged by his lawyers before the retrial, on the ground that it let the legislature dictate a remedy that belonged to the courts. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court declined to take up the question before the trial, and the retrial went ahead under the statute.

Timeline

1961: Einhorn graduates from the University of Pennsylvania.

1967: He organizes Philadelphia's first Be-In.

1971: He runs for mayor of Philadelphia.

1972: He meets the victim; they live together in West Philadelphia for five years.

1977: The victim dies in Philadelphia.

1979: Einhorn is arrested and charged with murder; he is released on $40,000 bail.

January 1981: He leaves the United States shortly before his trial.

September 30, 1993: Convicted in absentia of first-degree murder in the Court of Common Pleas, Philadelphia, after a trial of about a week; sentenced to life in prison.

June 13, 1997: Arrested by French police near Champagne-Mouton.

December 1997: The Bordeaux appeals court rejects extradition and frees him.

January 27, 1998: The governor approves Act 3 of 1998, which offers a new trial to defendants convicted in absentia who are returned from countries that refuse to extradite them.

March 3, 1998: The Court of Cassation upholds the Bordeaux decision.

September 29, 1998: A Bordeaux court releases him on bail during the second extradition request.

February 18, 1999: The court accepts extradition on condition of a new trial and no death penalty.

July 12, 2001: The Council of State orders extradition; the transfer is delayed at the request of the European Court of Human Rights.

July 19, 2001: Handed to American officers near Paris and flown to Philadelphia.

Late September 2002: The retrial jury is seated and sequestered.

October 17, 2002: Found guilty of first-degree murder; sentenced to life without parole.

April 3, 2020: Dies in Pennsylvania state custody.