Ilse Koch

Victims
Crimes against Buchenwald prisoners, 1937-1943; convicted twice. A US military court at Dachau convicted her in 1947 (common design to run the camp); an Augsburg court convicted her in 1951
Years active
1937 to 1943 (Buchenwald)
Location
Dresden; Sachsenhausen; Buchenwald, near Weimar; Ludwigsburg; Dachau; Augsburg; Aichach
Method
War crimes in the operation of Buchenwald concentration camp (Dachau); crimes against inmates under German criminal law (Augsburg)
Status
Life (1947), reduced to four years, 1948; released October 1949; life (1951); federal appeal rejected April 1952; died by suicide in prison, September 1967

Ilse Koch was tried for the crimes of Buchenwald twice, by two different legal systems, and sentenced to life imprisonment both times. She was the wife of the camp's first commandant, and for six years she lived in the camp's SS settlement on the Ettersberg hill above Weimar while prisoners in their tens of thousands passed through the camp below. In August 1947 an American military court at Dachau convicted her, the only woman among 31 defendants, of taking part in the common design to run the camp, and sentenced her to life. Within a year the American military governor in Germany cut that sentence to four years.

The reduction became one of the most contested decisions of the occupation. It produced protests in Congress, an inquiry by a Senate subcommittee and, once she had served her American term, a second prosecution by the Bavarian authorities for crimes against German and other non-Allied prisoners, a class of victims the American court had no power to judge. The regional court at Augsburg convicted her in January 1951 and imposed life imprisonment. The West German federal court rejected her appeal in April 1952. She spent the rest of her life in a women's prison in Bavaria and died there by suicide in September 1967.

She was born Margarete Ilse Köhler in Dresden on September 22, 1906. She spent eight years in elementary school, from 1912 to 1920, and two more at a commercial school, then began a traineeship in a bookshop in 1922. For the next fifteen years she earned her living in Dresden as a secretary and stenographer.

She joined the National Socialist German Workers' Party in May 1932, months before it came to power, and remained a member until 1945. In 1934 she met Karl Otto Koch, an officer of the SS who was then building a career inside the new concentration camp system. The couple married in May 1937 at Sachsenhausen, the concentration camp north of Berlin.

Shortly after the wedding her husband was given command of a new camp being built on the northern slopes of the Ettersberg, about five miles northwest of Weimar. The SS opened Buchenwald to male prisoners in July 1937. The first prisoners were mostly political opponents of the regime; they were followed by Jews, Jehovah's Witnesses, Sinti and Roma, men the authorities classed as repeat offenders or as "asocial," deserters from the German armed forces, and later prisoners of war, resistance fighters and forced laborers from across occupied Europe. Between July 1937 and April 1945 the SS held some 250,000 people in Buchenwald and its subcamps. Camp authorities left many prisoners unregistered, so the full toll can only be estimated; the SS murdered at least 56,000 male prisoners in the camp system, among them some 11,000 Jews.

Ilse Koch lived beside the camp from August 1937 until August 1943. Her husband commanded Buchenwald from August 1937 until October 1941 and was then sent briefly to command Majdanek, in occupied Poland; she remained in the SS settlement at Buchenwald while he was away. She held no post in the camp and stood outside its chain of command. The family lived well. Its wealth came from property and goods taken from the camp and from the forced labor of prisoners.

The first court to examine the Kochs was not an Allied one. In 1943 an SS and police court opened proceedings against the couple for corruption, and on August 24, 1943, Ilse Koch was arrested on suspicion of embezzling money and goods. She was held in pretrial detention in Weimar for about sixteen months.

The outcome split the couple. On December 19, 1944, the SS court acquitted Ilse Koch of commercial receiving of stolen goods for lack of evidence. Her husband was convicted of embezzlement and of the unauthorized killing of three prisoners, sentenced to death and executed on April 5, 1945. Six days later, on April 11, 1945, prisoners took control of Buchenwald, and American troops entered the camp that afternoon.

Ilse Koch was by then living in Ludwigsburg. In June 1945 a former Buchenwald prisoner recognized her, and United States authorities arrested her.

The case against the Buchenwald staff, United States v. Josias Prince zu Waldeck et al., came before one of the US Army courts sitting at Dachau. It covered the main camp, its subcamps and the evacuation transport of April 1945, and the victims named in it were prisoners of war, civilian inmates and Jews from across Europe.

The trial opened before the General Military Government Court at Dachau on April 11, 1947. Thirty-one people stood accused: SS officers and guards, camp doctors, a Higher SS and Police Leader and a prisoner functionary. Ilse Koch was the only woman.

The prosecution built its case on the doctrine of common design. It did not have to prove that a particular defendant had personally killed a particular prisoner. It had to show that each accused had taken part in, supported or furthered the operation of a camp in which crimes against prisoners were committed, and that each had a connection to the place where those crimes happened. In Ilse Koch's case the prosecution relied on that doctrine rather than on proof that she had personally killed anyone.

The court, a panel of eight American officers presided over by a brigadier general, delivered its findings on August 14, 1947. All 31 defendants were convicted. Twenty-two were sentenced to death. Five, among them Ilse Koch and the Higher SS and Police Leader, received life imprisonment, and four received terms of ten to twenty years.

The Buchenwald sentences were reviewed inside the Army before they became final. The War Crimes Board of Review recommended a reduction of Ilse Koch's sentence. On June 8, 1948, the American military governor in Germany approved it and commuted her life sentence to four years, which set her release for October 1949. The stated reason was that the evidence of her participation did not justify a heavier sentence.

The decision was not announced at the time. When it became public in September 1948, members of Congress sent protests to Army officials, and leading newspapers attacked it on their editorial pages.

A Senate investigations subcommittee took up the case in the fall of 1948 and examined whether the military governor had the authority to reduce the sentence and whether the original sentence could be restored.

The subcommittee's interim report, issued at the end of December 1948, found that the Army had made a serious error, but it advised against reinstating the life sentence on the principle of juridical finality: a sentence once reduced could not lawfully be increased. It urged the Army to help German courts if they chose to try her for crimes against German nationals.

German authorities had already asked for her. Months earlier the state of Thuringia, where Buchenwald lay, inside the Soviet zone of occupation, had requested her extradition on charges of brutality toward German nationals. The day after the Senate report appeared, the American commander in Germany was reported ready to let her be handed over to Thuringia when her four-year term ended. She was instead rearrested and tried in Bavaria.

Ilse Koch served her American sentence in Bavaria. She was released on October 17, 1949, and Bavarian authorities arrested her again the same day. The Bavarian government filed charges against her that October before the Landgericht Augsburg, the regional court, accusing her of the murder and maltreatment of German prisoners at Buchenwald, and she was held in pretrial detention in Augsburg from October 1949 until January 1951.

The new case turned on the point the Senate report had raised. The Dachau court had judged crimes against Allied nationals. The Bavarian prosecution charged crimes against German and other non-Allied prisoners, offenses that had never been before any court, so the earlier trials did not bar it.

The trial opened at Augsburg at the end of November 1950 with the reading of an indictment that ran to 139 pages. It charged her in connection with 45 murders of German and other non-Allied prisoners at Buchenwald and with complicity in 135 further killings; among the counts was the killing of 24 Jewish prisoners at the camp in 1941.

She denied the charges. West Germany had abolished the death penalty, so the most the prosecution could seek was life imprisonment.

The trial lasted about seven weeks. On January 15, 1951, the Landgericht Augsburg convicted Ilse Koch of crimes against inmates of Buchenwald and sentenced her to life imprisonment. She was moved to the women's prison at Aichach, northeast of Augsburg, that month.

The appeal reached the Bundesgerichtshof, the West German federal court of justice in Karlsruhe, in the spring of 1952. In April 1952 the court rejected it, and the life sentence became final.

She asked repeatedly for a pardon, and every request was refused.

Ilse Koch died by suicide in the women's prison at Aichach in early September 1967, still serving the sentence the Augsburg court had passed.

Her name is tied above all to a postwar legend about objects said to have been made from prisoners' remains; the American review found no convincing evidence that she selected prisoners for that purpose or possessed any such article, the Augsburg court did not find it proven, and it is considered unlikely today. The convictions rest on other conduct: at Dachau, her part in the common design to run the camp, and at Augsburg, her crimes against individual prisoners.

Timeline

September 22, 1906: Born Margarete Ilse Köhler in Dresden.

May 1932: Joins the National Socialist German Workers' Party.

May 1937: Marries the SS officer Karl Otto Koch at Sachsenhausen.

July 1937: Buchenwald opens to prisoners; she lives beside the camp from August 1937.

October 1941: Her husband leaves the Buchenwald command.

August 24, 1943: Arrested by the SS on suspicion of embezzlement.

December 19, 1944: Acquitted by an SS and police court.

April 5, 1945: Her husband is executed after conviction by an SS court.

April 11, 1945: Buchenwald is liberated.

June 1945: Arrested by United States authorities in Ludwigsburg.

April 11, 1947: The Buchenwald trial opens before the General Military Government Court at Dachau.

August 14, 1947: Convicted with all 30 co-defendants; sentenced to life imprisonment.

June 8, 1948: The American military governor commutes her sentence to four years.

September 1948: The reduction becomes public; protests in Congress follow.

December 1948: A Senate subcommittee finds the Army erred but opposes reinstating the sentence; Thuringia has requested her extradition.

October 17, 1949: Released from American custody and rearrested by Bavarian authorities the same day.

October 1949: Bavarian charges filed before the Landgericht Augsburg.

November 1950: The Augsburg trial opens.

January 15, 1951: Convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment.

April 1952: The federal court of justice rejects her appeal.

September 1967: Dies by suicide in the women's prison at Aichach.