Ilnaz Galyaviev

Victims
9 killed at his former school in Kazan, May 11, 2021. Convicted April 13, 2023, of murder, attempted murder and three further counts; pleaded guilty; life imprisonment
Years active
May 11, 2021
Location
Kazan, Republic of Tatarstan, Russia
Method
Murder of two or more persons, including minors, in a generally dangerous manner and from hooligan motives; attempted murder; two further offenses and intentional damage to property
Status
Life imprisonment, special-regime colony, fine of 200,000 rubles (April 13, 2023); upheld by the Fourth Court of Appeal of General Jurisdiction, August 7, 2023

On the morning of May 11, 2021, Ilnaz Galyaviev went back to the school in Kazan where he had studied from the first grade. Nine people died there: seven children and two adults. Twenty-four more were injured, eighteen of them children. Galyaviev was 19. He was detained the same day, admitted his guilt within a day and never withdrew that admission.

The case that followed turned less on what had happened than on the state of the man who did it. A team of forensic psychiatrists in Moscow concluded that he had been insane at the time, a finding that would have sent him to compulsory treatment instead of trial. A second team in St. Petersburg concluded the opposite. Investigators, and then the court, accepted the second report. On April 13, 2023, the Supreme Court of the Republic of Tatarstan convicted Galyaviev on five counts, among them the murder of two or more persons and attempted murder, and sentenced him to life imprisonment in a special-regime penal colony, with a fine of 200,000 rubles. An appeal court in Nizhny Novgorod upheld the sentence that August.

Galyaviev was born on September 11, 2001, and grew up in Kazan, the capital of the Republic of Tatarstan. He entered the gymnasium as a first-grader and later finished his schooling there.

After school he enrolled at an institute in Kazan. In court on the day after the killings he described himself as a fourth-year student there. The institute said otherwise. He had stopped attending classes in January 2021, and on April 26, 2021, a little over two weeks before the attack, he was expelled for poor academic performance.

He had no history of psychiatric care. A spokesperson for the Investigative Committee of Russia said on May 12, 2021, that he had never been registered with a psychiatrist or a narcologist. He had, however, repeatedly sought medical help for severe headaches, and in 2020 he had been given a diagnosis indicating a disease of the brain. The condition was not named.

The pupils who died were Alisa, Ilziya, Zulfiya and Damir, and three boys who shared the name Amir. All seven were children. The two adults who died were Elvira Ignatyeva and Venera Aizatova.

The Prosecutor General's Office counted 24 people injured, 18 of them children. That count was carried into the indictment.

The Main Investigative Directorate of the Investigative Committee of Russia took the case. Its investigators opened a criminal case the same day under Article 105, Part 2, of the Russian Criminal Code, the provision for the murder of two or more persons, which carries a possible life sentence. Initial reports of a second attacker were withdrawn the same day, and a deputy prosecutor of Tatarstan said that Galyaviev had acted alone. The case went forward as murder, not as an act of terrorism.

On May 12, 2021, Galyaviev was brought before the Sovetsky District Court of Kazan. Investigators asked for him to be held in custody. The court agreed and ordered two months' detention, to July 11, on the grounds that he might commit further crimes, threaten witnesses or obstruct the investigation. In court he admitted his guilt and did not oppose the request. He was taken to a pretrial detention center in Kazan.

At that hearing the investigators described the evidence in general terms: video recordings, the statements of witnesses, and material Galyaviev had posted online shortly before the attack. They ordered a toxicological review and a forensic psychiatric examination.

The first forensic psychiatric examination was carried out in Moscow by the V. P. Serbsky State Scientific Center for Social and Forensic Psychiatry, where he was sent in May 2021, the month of his arrest. On July 21, 2021, a newspaper published by Moscow's Public Monitoring Commission said that the Serbsky experts had found Galyaviev insane at the time of the killings.

The Serbsky panel's conclusion, as it was later set out at trial, was paranoid schizophrenia and an absence of criminal responsibility. Had it been accepted, it would have meant compulsory medical treatment, not a criminal trial.

Investigators ordered a second, combined psychological and psychiatric examination. Galyaviev was moved to a pretrial detention center in St. Petersburg, where a different panel examined him. It reached the reverse conclusion. The St. Petersburg experts found a schizoid personality disorder, not schizophrenia, and concluded that he had been sane, that he had understood the nature and danger of his actions, and that he could be held criminally liable. Their finding of sanity covered two moments: the morning of the killings and the time of the examination itself.

No official statement announced the result. It became public on November 16, 2021, when Galyaviev's lawyer disclosed that investigators had passed the conclusion to the defense orally. He then dismissed his privately hired lawyers and accepted a court-appointed defender.

On December 10, 2021, the Investigative Committee brought charges in their final form. Its spokesperson announced that the repeat examination had found Galyaviev "sane and subject to criminal liability." The committee said that he had admitted his guilt in full and expressed remorse. More than 600 people had by then been formally recognized as victims.

The indictment ran under Article 105, Part 2, for murder; Article 30, Part 3, read with Article 105, Part 2, for attempted murder; Articles 222.1 and 223.1, each under Part 1; and Article 167, Part 2, which covers the intentional destruction or damage of property. The murder count, as the Prosecutor General's Office framed it, alleged the murder of several people, minors among them, in a generally dangerous manner.

By the spring of 2022 the investigation was finished. Investigators put the damage to the school building, the subject of the Article 167 count, at 1,409,953 rubles.

Ten more months passed before the case reached court. On October 14, 2022, the Prosecutor General's Office of the Russian Federation approved the indictment and sent the case to the Supreme Court of the Republic of Tatarstan for trial on the merits.

The trial opened on November 9, 2022, before the Supreme Court of Tatarstan in Kazan. Six days later, on November 15, the presiding judge asked Galyaviev for his plea. "I plead guilty in full," he answered.

By the end of the trial the number of people recognized as victims had reached 667, of whom 143 were recorded as having suffered serious harm. Their civil claims for compensation totaled more than 48 million rubles.

The two psychiatric reports stood against each other through the whole of the trial. Near the end of the judicial investigation the defense asked the court to order a third examination. The court refused, and the trial went forward on the two reports already in the file.

The question of sanity returned in the closing speeches. The defense asked the court to find Galyaviev insane, on the strength of the Serbsky report, and to send him for compulsory treatment instead of punishment. The prosecution relied on the St. Petersburg report.

On March 29, 2023, the state prosecutor asked for life imprisonment, with the first five years to be served in a prison and the rest in a special-regime colony, and a fine of 240,000 rubles.

Galyaviev was given the last word. He apologized to the families of the dead and to those who had been injured. He promised to pay what he could toward the claims against him.

The Supreme Court of Tatarstan delivered its verdict on April 13, 2023. It found Galyaviev guilty on all five counts. The court rejected the defense's insanity argument, relied on the second examination and treated him as fully responsible for his actions.

The court convicted him under the same lettered subparagraphs that the indictment had cited, for the murders and for the attempted murders alike, and under each of the three remaining articles. It then combined the penalties for the separate offenses by partial addition, under Article 69, Part 3, of the Criminal Code. The sentence that resulted was life imprisonment, the most severe penalty in the Russian Criminal Code, to be served in a special-regime penal colony. The court added a fine of 200,000 rubles, less than the prosecution had asked for.

On the civil side, the court granted the claims for moral damages in part. Ten claimants were awarded a total of about 22 million rubles.

The prosecution did not appeal.

The defense appealed to the Fourth Court of Appeal of General Jurisdiction in Nizhny Novgorod. It raised two grounds. The first was that the trial court had not resolved the question of Galyaviev's mental state, either at the time of the killings or during the proceedings. The second was that the prosecution had not proved that he intended to damage the school building, the basis of the Article 167 count. The defense asked the appeal court to set aside the verdict and order a new trial.

The appeal was heard on August 7, 2023.

The court ruled the same day: "The sentence handed down by the Supreme Court of Tatarstan is upheld, and the appeals are dismissed." With that ruling the verdict came into legal force.

In August 2023 Galyaviev was sent to serve his sentence in a special-regime colony for prisoners serving life terms.

The murder count against Galyaviev combined several of the aggravating circumstances that Article 105, Part 2, lists by lettered subparagraph. The indictment approved in October 2022 cited subparagraphs "a", "e" and "i" for the murders and added subparagraph "v" for the attempted murders, and the verdict described the killings as murder of two or more people, including a minor, in a generally dangerous manner and from hooligan motives. The original case, opened on May 11, 2021, cited subparagraphs "a", "b" and "e".

The central dispute was his mental state. The Serbsky panel found paranoid schizophrenia and insanity at the time of the killings; the St. Petersburg panel found a personality disorder and full criminal responsibility. The trial court and the appeal court both accepted the second conclusion, and the conviction is final, but the defense maintained to the end that the question had not been properly resolved.

The defense also argued on appeal that the Article 167 count, the damage to the school building, had not been proved as an intentional act. The appeal court rejected that argument with the rest of the appeal.

The brain disease diagnosed in 2020 was never named in public.

Timeline

September 11, 2001: Ilnaz Galyaviev is born in Kazan.

January 2021: He stops attending classes at his institute in Kazan.

April 26, 2021: He is expelled for poor academic performance.

May 11, 2021: Nine people are killed and 24 injured at his former school in Kazan; he is detained the same day, and the Investigative Committee opens a case under Article 105, Part 2.

May 12, 2021: The Sovetsky District Court of Kazan orders him held in custody for two months.

July 21, 2021: The finding of the Serbsky examination, that he was insane at the time, becomes public; the Investigative Committee says the examination is not complete.

November 16, 2021: A repeat examination in St. Petersburg is disclosed to have found him sane.

December 10, 2021: The Investigative Committee brings final charges; more than 600 people are recognized as victims.

October 14, 2022: The Prosecutor General's Office approves the indictment and sends the case to the Supreme Court of Tatarstan.

November 9, 2022: The trial opens.

November 15, 2022: He pleads guilty in full.

March 29, 2023: The prosecution asks for life imprisonment.

April 13, 2023: The Supreme Court of Tatarstan convicts him and sentences him to life imprisonment in a special-regime colony and a fine of 200,000 rubles.

August 7, 2023: The Fourth Court of Appeal of General Jurisdiction upholds the sentence.

August 2023: He is sent to a colony for prisoners serving life terms.