On the evening of September 11, 2003, in the Cheshire town of Warrington, Iftikhar and Farzana Ahmed killed their eldest daughter. She was a minor, and for most of the year before her death she had been trying to get away from them. For close to nine years the couple insisted that she had simply left one night and never come back. They said so to detectives, to their other children's teachers and, under oath, to a coroner. The account held until 2010, when a younger sister who had been in the room that night told police what she had seen.
On August 3, 2012, a jury at Chester Crown Court found both parents guilty of murder. The verdict was unanimous, and it came at the end of a trial that had begun in May. The trial judge sentenced each of them the same day to life imprisonment, with a minimum term of 25 years before either could be considered for release. In his sentencing remarks he found that the couple had killed their daughter because her wish to live an ordinary life in the town where she had grown up was, in their eyes, bringing "shame" on them in their community.
Iftikhar Ahmed was born in Pakistan and came to the United Kingdom at the age of 10. In 1985 he went back to Pakistan, and while he was there he married Farzana. In 1986 the couple traveled to England to settle, and Farzana Ahmed was already pregnant with their first child.
They made their life in Warrington, a large town between Liverpool and Manchester, and lived in the Great Sankey district. Iftikhar Ahmed worked as a taxi driver. Four more children followed their first daughter: three more daughters and a son. By the time of the trial the couple had lived in England for about 25 years. They had no previous convictions.
Their eldest daughter went to local schools in Warrington. The court found that she was a determined, able and ambitious girl who wanted the life that was normal for a teenager in the town where her parents had chosen to raise her, and that her parents objected to her friendships, her clothes and any contact with boys.
The court found that the conflict sharpened in the last year of her life, and that her parents tried to force their values on her through intimidation, bullying and physical violence. Her school saw some of it. In October 2002, staff alerted social services, and that same month she told a social worker that she was due to be married in Pakistan in February 2003. Her social services file was closed before the year was out. Between November 2002 and January 2003 she told friends and teachers that the violence at home was getting worse.
She tried to leave. In January 2003 she ran away, saying her parents would not leave her alone, and later went back. In February she left again and asked the local council for emergency accommodation. In her written application she said she had suffered regular domestic violence for years, that she had been prevented from going to college, and that her parents were trying to force her into an arranged marriage.
She knew, the judge found, what lay ahead of her at her parents' hands: being taken to Pakistan to be "sorted out" and then married off. On February 10, 2003, her parents brought her back against her will. About a week later they took her to Pakistan. The court had no doubt that they meant her to stay there and be married.
The plan failed. When she understood what her immediate future was to be, the judge found, she acted to frustrate it, and she was left so weakened that she was no longer wanted as a bride. She was brought back to England in May 2003. Even then she still wanted her freedom and the life she had chosen for herself, and the quarrels over her clothes went on.
On the evening of September 11, 2003, her parents berated her for her behavior. In temper and frustration, the court found, the two of them killed her in Warrington, in front of their four other children. The judge accepted that there had been no plan to kill her that night. But he found that it was Farzana Ahmed who told her husband to "finish it here," and that this, together with other evidence in the case, showed that the couple had already talked between themselves about how they might finally resolve what they saw as the problem their daughter presented. The parents then told their children what to say to anyone who asked what had become of her.
Her parents did not go to the police. Cheshire Police came into the case about a week after that night, and detectives did not take the parents' account at face value. In December 2003 detectives arrested Iftikhar and Farzana Ahmed on suspicion of kidnapping their daughter. Both were released, and in June 2004 the Crown Prosecution Service decided that there was not enough evidence to charge them. Both parents denied any part in what had happened to her.
In February 2004 police confirmed that she was dead, and the inquiry became a murder investigation. An inquest was opened that year and adjourned to allow the police to continue. Four years passed with no one charged, and the parents went on insisting that their daughter had run away.
The inquest resumed in Kendal, Cumbria, in January 2008. Her teachers and friends gave evidence and remembered a hardworking, diligent girl, a loyal friend with a lively sense of humor, who had hoped to go to university and become a lawyer. On January 11, 2008, the coroner recorded a verdict that she had been unlawfully killed. No one had been charged at that point.
Years later, the trial judge found that both of them had lied on oath before the coroner and had made their surviving children give an account designed to hide what had happened.
The case turned in August 2010, when a younger sister gave the police her account of September 11, 2003. She said she had seen her parents kill her eldest sister. That year Iftikhar and Farzana Ahmed were arrested again, this time on suspicion of murder, and released on bail while the evidence was assessed.
On September 7, 2011, the Crown Prosecution Service authorized Cheshire Police to charge both parents with murder. They appeared before magistrates and were remanded in custody. They had always said they had nothing to do with their daughter's death, and they pleaded not guilty.
The trial opened at Chester Crown Court in May 2012 and ran for about ten weeks. The prosecution's case rested above all on the younger sister, who told the jury that she had watched both parents act together to kill her sister. Another sister, called by the prosecution, said that writings of hers produced at the trial, which appeared to support that account, were fiction.
Iftikhar Ahmed told the jury that his daughter had run away in the middle of the night and that he never saw her again. He denied ever hurting her and denied any role in her death. Farzana Ahmed had made the same denial, but partway through the trial she changed her account. She now told the jury that she had seen her husband use violence against their daughter that night and that she believed he had killed her, and she said she had lied to the police because she was afraid of him. She denied saying the words the younger sister attributed to her.
On August 3, 2012, the jury returned unanimous verdicts of guilty against both parents.
Sentence followed the same day. Life imprisonment was the only sentence open to the judge, and his task was to set the minimum term each must serve before the Parole Board could consider release.
He found the couple's culpability exceptionally high and took the higher starting point under the law in force at the time of the killing. He found only two features in mitigation: there had been no plan to kill their daughter that night, and the couple had no previous convictions.
The aggravating features were many. The parents were the people to whom their daughter should have been able to look for protection, and their treatment of her was a fundamental breach of trust. They acted together as a team. In the year before her death they had subjected her to repeated violence, brought her back against her will, taken her to Pakistan and tried to arrange a marriage she did not want. She was vulnerable and weakened when they killed her. They killed her in front of their other children. The killing, he found, was motivated by their fear of shame in their community. Afterward they hid what they had done, lied to the coroner on oath and made their other children repeat a false account.
The judge saw no reason to treat the parents differently. He set a minimum term of 25 years for each, less the 66 days each had already spent in custody. An order under section 39 restricts the reporting of details about the couple's youngest child.
A month after the verdicts, in September 2012, the Crown Prosecution Service confirmed that the Court of Appeal had received an application from Farzana Ahmed for permission to appeal against her murder conviction. The prosecution said it had not been told the grounds.
The parents' versions of the night of September 11, 2003, conflicted with each other and with the jury's verdicts. Iftikhar Ahmed said his daughter ran away. Farzana Ahmed first said the same, then told the jury she had seen her husband use violence and believed he alone was responsible. The jury rejected both accounts and convicted them jointly, and the judge found that they acted together as a team.
The judge expressly declined to reach any conclusion on whether the couple's son played a part in the killing. He was never charged with any offense in connection with his sister's death.
The second sister's position at trial, that the writings produced in court were fiction, conflicted with the younger sister's account. The jury's verdicts show that it accepted the younger sister's evidence.
1985: Iftikhar Ahmed marries Farzana in Pakistan.
1986: The couple settle in England and later make their life in Warrington, Cheshire.
October 2002: Their eldest daughter's school alerts social services after she arrives with facial injuries.
January 2003: She runs away for the first time and later returns.
February 2003: She leaves again and applies to the council for emergency accommodation; on February 10 her parents take her back against her will, and about a week later she is taken to Pakistan.
May 2003: She is brought back to England.
September 11, 2003: Iftikhar and Farzana Ahmed kill her in Warrington.
December 2003: Both parents are arrested on suspicion of kidnapping and released.
February 2004: Police confirm her death and open a murder investigation.
June 2004: The Crown Prosecution Service decides there is insufficient evidence to charge the parents.
January 11, 2008: An inquest in Kendal records a verdict of unlawful killing.
August 2010: A younger sister tells police she saw her parents kill her eldest sister; both parents are later arrested on suspicion of murder and bailed.
September 7, 2011: The Crown Prosecution Service authorizes murder charges against both parents.
May 2012: The trial opens at Chester Crown Court.
August 3, 2012: The jury returns unanimous guilty verdicts; each parent is sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 25 years.
September 2012: The Court of Appeal receives Farzana Ahmed's application for permission to appeal against her conviction.