INFAMOUS AND TERRIFYING HOUSES OF MURDER

Most murders leave no trace on a building. A room is cleaned, a tenant moves on, a family sells up, and within a generation nobody on the street remembers. A handful of houses never get that mercy. Their names travel further than the names of the people who died in them. Tourists come to stare, neighbors put up fences, councils send in bulldozers, and occasionally an owner opens the front door and sells tickets.

These ten homes became known for very different reasons. In some, a killer went undetected for years behind an ordinary front door. In others, a single night of violence fixed a farmhouse or a family home in the public mind for good. Three of the cases are not serial at all, and one of those ended in an acquittal. What they share is that the crime and the building became inseparable, and that somebody, years later, had to decide what to do with the house.

Gloucester: Fred and Rosemary West

Fred West was born on September 29, 1941, at Much Marcle in Herefordshire, and he grew up to work as a builder. In 1969, at a bus stop in Cheltenham, he met Rosemary Letts. He was 27 and she was 15. Her parents objected; she moved in with him anyway, and their first child, Heather, was born soon afterward.

West already had two young daughters. In 1971, while he was serving a prison sentence for stealing car tires and a vehicle tax disc, Rosemary looked after the children. The elder girl, Charmaine, who was about eight, was taken out of her school that year. Her parents said she had gone to London to live with her mother, and the school accepted it, as schools then routinely did, the education journalist Josephine Gardiner reported in 1995. Nobody reported Charmaine missing. Her mother, Catherine Costello, known as Rena, went missing in August 1971 while she was looking for her daughter. Nobody reported her missing either.

The couple married in Gloucester in 1972 and that year moved into a house in Gloucester that would be the family home for the next 22 years. They had more children; in all, ten grew up in the household. The house also took in lodgers, and some of the young women who lived there or called in were teenagers who had been in council care or had run away from home. Between 1973 and 1987, nine young women and girls who passed through the house disappeared: Lynda Gough, Carol Ann Cooper, Lucy Partington, Therese Siegenthaler, Shirley Hubbard, Juanita Mott, Shirley Robinson, Alison Chambers and, last of all, the Wests' own eldest daughter, Heather.

Heather West was 16 and had just sat her GCSE examinations when she was last seen on June 19, 1987. Her parents said she had gone to work at a holiday camp in Devon. Their accounts of her afterward kept changing, and no one reported her missing.

The case came apart through the children. In August 1992 the five youngest West children were taken into local authority care over allegations of abuse, and Fred and Rosemary West were charged with abusing one of their daughters. The prosecution collapsed when the main witness withdrew her evidence, and in 1993 Fred West was found not guilty. But the children in care kept repeating a family joke: anyone who misbehaved would end up like Heather. Social workers passed their concern to the police in the summer of 1993, and Detective Constable Hazel Savage of Gloucestershire police would not let it go.

Detectives moved on the house in late February 1994. On February 25 Fred West admitted killing Heather, and he and Rosemary were arrested there on suspicion of her murder. Over the following months the inquiry widened to the family’s earlier home in Gloucester and to the countryside around Much Marcle, and it came to account for 12 deaths, among them Charmaine, Rena Costello and Anne McFall, a young woman from West’s Scottish years who had been last seen in 1967. It was the largest inquiry Gloucestershire police had ever mounted, with Detective Superintendent John Bennett speaking for it at news conferences. Detectives traced 110 missing people in the course of it, checking for other possible victims, and found every one of them alive.

Fred West was charged with 12 murders. He was questioned in long, rambling interviews, admitting, denying and insisting that his wife knew nothing. He never stood trial. On January 1, 1995, he was found hanged in his remand cell at Winson Green prison in Birmingham. He was 53. His death ended the case against him, and no court has ever found that he killed anyone.

Rosemary West was tried alone at Winchester Crown Court in the autumn of 1995, before Mr. Justice Mantell, on ten counts of murder: Charmaine, Heather and the eight other young women and girls who had lived at or visited the house. The jurors were taken to see the building on October 19, with police guarding the front door. She denied everything. On November 22, 1995, the jury convicted her on all ten counts, and she was sentenced to life imprisonment; the judge said he hoped she would never be released. The Court of Appeal refused her leave to appeal in 1996, rejecting the argument that press coverage and newspaper payments to witnesses had made a fair trial impossible, and a later application to Strasbourg failed on a time limit. She is serving a whole life term. In June 2019 she was moved to HMP New Hall, near Wakefield in West Yorkshire, the Yorkshire Evening Post reported. She has always maintained her innocence.

An inquiry commissioned by Gloucestershire County Council concluded in 1995 that no child protection service could have predicted that the family was at the center of multiple killings, while urging teachers, doctors, social workers and police not to dismiss what children said, however odd it sounded. The ten West children had passed through 12 schools in 26 years.

The house did not survive the case. It was demolished in 1996, after the investigation. The council laid a footpath and a small garden over the site, and photographs in the Gloucestershire Police Archives record both the demolition and the walkway that replaced it.

Sacramento: Dorothea Puente

The house that Dorothea Puente made known is still standing: a two-story Victorian in downtown Sacramento. She rented its upstairs flat and ran it as a boarding house.

Puente had a long record before the deaths. In the 1970s she ran another boarding house for the elderly and needy in Sacramento, and in 1978 she was arrested for forging tenants' signatures on their benefit checks and placed on five years' probation, on condition that she stop running a boarding house. Between 1978 and 1980 she moved to the Victorian, a house owned by friends. In 1982 she was convicted of robbery and of administering stupefying drugs to commit robbery, and sent to prison for five years. She served three.

The first death later charged against her came that same spring. Ruth Munroe, 61, moved in with her in April 1982 and was dead within weeks of an overdose. The death was ruled a suicide. Her family suspected Puente.

While she was in prison, Puente struck up a correspondence with Everson Gillmouth, a 77-year-old retiree from Oregon. When she was paroled in September 1985 the two became a couple and opened a joint bank account. Her parole barred her from running a boarding house, from caring for the elderly and from handling anyone else’s government checks. She went back to the Victorian and began taking in tenants again. Gillmouth was dead by January 1986, though his death was not linked to her until 1989.

Her tenants were the people social services found hardest to place: the elderly, the mentally ill, men and women who drank. She became the signatory on their checks, handed them a small allowance and kept the rest. Seven of them dropped out of sight: Betty Palmer, Leona Carpenter, James Gallop, Vera Faye Martin, Dorothy Miller, Benjamin Fink and Alvaro Gonzales Montoya, known as Bert.

The warnings were there. In the middle of 1988 an acquaintance, Brenda Trujillo, complained to police about her. Later that year a social worker, Judy Moise, filed a missing-person report for Bert Montoya, and that report set the investigation moving. On Friday, November 11, 1988, Veterans Day, Detective John Cabrera and other officers came to the house. Within days the deaths of seven tenants, Montoya among them, were part of a homicide investigation, and the story had gone national.

Puente was questioned and allowed to leave, and she disappeared. She made her way to Los Angeles and was arrested there four days later, after a man she had met in a bar recognized her from television and turned her in. She had about 3,000 dollars in cash.

She was charged with nine murders: the seven tenants, Ruth Munroe and Everson Gillmouth. A Sacramento judge ruled that local coverage had made a fair trial there impossible, and the case went to Monterey County. Jury selection began on November 2, 1992, and took three months; the trial itself ran about five more, with some 3,100 exhibits. The prosecution’s case was circumstantial. The tenants had lived in her house, she had given false accounts of their disappearances, and she had kept cashing their checks. The defense said they had died of age, illness and drink, and that she had buried them because she was afraid of going back to prison for running a boarding house.

After 24 days of deliberation, the jury of eight men and four women convicted her in the summer of 1993 of three murders, those of Dorothy Miller, Benjamin Fink and Leona Carpenter. It could not agree on the other six, and those deaths were never resolved by any verdict. In the penalty phase the jurors deadlocked again, split seven to five in favor of prison over death, and Superior Court Judge Michael Virga declared a mistrial. Prosecutors declined to try the penalty again, so Puente, then 64, would spend the rest of her life in prison without parole. Afterward the judge invited the jurors into his chambers for lemonade and cookies.

She died at the Central California Women’s Facility in Chowchilla on March 27, 2011, aged 82.

The house outlived her and changed hands. In 2015 its owners, Barbara Holmes and Tom Williams, who had bought and renovated it about five years earlier, opened it to the public for a day. An estimated 600 people walked through, and the proceeds went to the Francis House Center, which serves homeless people in Sacramento. A mannequin of Puente in a red overcoat stood in the yard. Steve Martarano, who had covered the case as a young crime reporter for The Sacramento Union, wrote that he remembered watching police walk a well-dressed older woman in a red coat out of the same house in 1988. A 13-minute film about the owners and Detective Cabrera, The House Is Innocent, by the Los Angeles filmmaker Nicholas Coles, won the top documentary award at the Sacramento Music and Film Festival that September.

Notting Hill: John Reginald Christie

John Reginald Christie was born in Halifax, in the West Riding of Yorkshire, in 1899. He was hurt in a gas attack in the First World War and spent the years between the wars drifting in and out of trouble, mostly for theft. By 1939 he had five criminal convictions. When the war came again, the Metropolitan Police expanded quickly by enrolling men in its War Reserve, and Christie was taken on as War Reserve Constable X 112 without anyone discovering his record. In July 1953 the Home Secretary told the House of Commons that he regretted the oversight, which he put down to the conditions of rapid wartime expansion.

He and his wife, Ethel, had moved in 1937 into the ground-floor flat of a small house in a run-down corner of Notting Hill, in west London, an area Air Mail has described as a postwar slum. Other tenants lived upstairs.

The first woman Christie later admitted killing was Ruth Fuerst. She had been born in Austria in 1922 and reached Britain in 1939 as a refugee, helped by Quakers; she was interned on the Isle of Man and later worked at a hotel in Mayfair, the London Review of Books records. She disappeared in 1943. Muriel Eady had grown up in a children’s home after her mother died in the influenza epidemic of 1918. In 1944 she met Christie at a radio factory in Acton where both of them worked, and she disappeared on October 7 of that year. Christie later admitted killing both women at the house. Nobody connected their disappearances with him for nine years.

By 1949 the top-floor flat belonged to a young couple, Timothy and Beryl Evans, and their baby daughter, Geraldine. Timothy Evans could not read or write; that much, a member of Parliament told the Commons in 1953, was admitted on all sides. In November 1949 Beryl and Geraldine were killed. Evans left London, and his first confession was made to police in Wales. He gave four differing accounts in all. His first statement to the police accused Christie. His later confessions blamed himself.

Evans went on trial at the Central Criminal Court in January 1950, charged with murdering his daughter. Christie, the former war reserve policeman from downstairs, was the principal witness for the Crown, and he denied every accusation Evans made against him. The jury did not know that two women’s bodies already lay hidden at the house. On January 13, 1950, Evans was convicted of Geraldine’s murder, and on March 9, 1950, he was hanged. His last words, as the London Review of Books records them, were "Christie done it."

Christie and his wife stayed on downstairs. Ethel Christie was killed in December 1952, and in the first weeks of 1953 three more women died in the flat: Kathleen Maloney, Rita Nelson and Hectorina Maclennan, all in their twenties. Christie moved out in March 1953. On March 24 the deaths came to light, and within days the police knew that six women, Ethel Christie, Ruth Fuerst and Muriel Eady among them, had died at the house, the same house in which Beryl and Geraldine Evans had died four years earlier.

Scotland Yard announced that it wanted to question the former tenant of the ground-floor flat. On March 31, 1953, a police officer near the Thames at Putney noticed a man in a brown trilby and asked him to come to the station. It was Christie. He was charged with his wife’s murder. In custody he admitted killing all six women found at the house, and he confessed to killing Beryl Evans. He denied, then and afterward, that he had killed the child.

He was tried at the Central Criminal Court in June 1953 for one murder only, that of his wife. He pleaded insanity. The jury found him guilty, and on June 25, 1953, he was sentenced to death. None of the other deaths at the house ever came before a jury.

The government now had two men from the same small house convicted of strangling women, the first hanged on the evidence of the second. The Home Secretary, Sir David Maxwell Fyfe, asked a barrister, Scott Henderson QC, to inquire in private, and within about a week he reported that Evans had murdered both his wife and his child. On the eve of the execution, members asked in the Commons how the report could be debated once its most important witness was dead. The Home Secretary did not postpone the hanging, and Christie was hanged at Pentonville on the morning of July 15, 1953.

The Evans case would not lie down. The broadcaster Ludovic Kennedy challenged the verdict in a 1961 book, and in 1965 a High Court judge, Sir Daniel Brabin, opened a new inquiry. Brabin concluded that it was no longer possible to establish the truth beyond doubt, but that on the balance of probabilities Evans had not killed his daughter, the crime for which he was hanged, though he had probably killed his wife. On October 18, 1966, the Home Secretary, Roy Jenkins, told the Commons that the Queen had granted Evans a free pardon. "This case has no precedent," Jenkins said, "and will, I hope and believe, have no successor." In the Lords the same day, the government minister Lord Stonham said the pardon amounted to an admission by the State that Evans had been wrongly put to death. The jury’s verdict was never quashed; it was the pardon that removed its force.

By the time a feature film of the case went into production in 1970, with Richard Attenborough as Christie and John Hurt as Evans, the street had been renamed. Filming could not take place inside the house itself, so most scenes were shot at the house next door, the American Film Institute’s catalog records. The film opened in London on January 28, 1971. The street did not last much longer. It was demolished in 1970 and rebuilt under a new name, and nothing of the house remains.

Indianapolis: Gertrude Baniszewski and Sylvia Likens

The death of Sylvia Likens was not the work of a serial killer. It was a single killing, carried out over weeks, in one house on the east side of Indianapolis, and it shocked the city precisely because so many people had a hand in it or knew of it and did nothing.

Sylvia was 16. Her parents, Lester and Betty Likens, worked the fair and carnival circuit, and in July 1965 they left her and her 15-year-old sister, Jenny, as boarders with Gertrude Baniszewski, a 37-year-old divorced mother of seven, for 20 dollars a week. When one of the payments arrived late, Baniszewski beat the girls. Over the following weeks the abuse grew, and it fell mostly on Sylvia. Children from the household and the neighborhood joined in. An older Likens sister alerted social services, and a caseworker came to the house, but Jenny said Sylvia had run away, and nothing more was done. Her father last visited on October 5, 1965.

On October 26, 1965, police were called to the house, where Sylvia had died. A neighborhood boy, Richard Hobbs, had made the call. Jenny told the officers she would tell them everything if they took her out of the house.

Police took the Baniszewski family and eight neighborhood children into custody. In December 1965 a grand jury indicted Gertrude Baniszewski, three of her children and two neighborhood boys, Richard Hobbs and Coy Hubbard, on charges of first-degree murder. The trial in April 1966 drew national attention. Gertrude Baniszewski pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity; the jury found her guilty of first-degree murder, and she was sentenced to life in prison. Her daughter Paula was found guilty of second-degree murder and also sentenced to life. Hobbs, Hubbard and John Baniszewski Jr. were convicted of manslaughter and sentenced to two to 21 years; the Encyclopedia of Indianapolis records that they served about 18 months. A 15-year-old daughter who testified for the state was tried separately and found not guilty.

In 1970 the Indiana Supreme Court reversed Gertrude Baniszewski’s conviction and ordered a new trial with a change of venue. At the retrial in 1971 she was convicted of first-degree murder again. Paula, also granted a new trial, pleaded guilty to manslaughter and was paroled in 1972. Gertrude Baniszewski was paroled in 1985, over a public petition carrying more than 40,000 signatures. She moved to Iowa under another name and died of lung cancer on June 16, 1990, at 60.

The case followed its survivors for decades. Richard Hobbs died of cancer in 1972, at 21. Jenny Likens died in 2004, at 54. In 2012 Paula Baniszewski was found working for a school system in Iowa under another name, and she was dismissed for giving false information on her job application, Indianapolis Monthly reported. A feature film based on the case, An American Crime, had its premiere at the Sundance Film Festival in 2007. In 2015, half a century after Sylvia’s death, Indianapolis Monthly marked the anniversary with a long feature tracing what had become of everyone involved.

Plainfield: Ed Gein

Edward Theodore Gein was born on August 27, 1906, in La Crosse, Wisconsin. His family moved to a farm outside Plainfield, in central Wisconsin, when Ed was a boy, and he spent the rest of his free life there. His father died in 1940, his older brother, Henry, in 1944, and his mother in December 1945. After that Ed lived alone in the farmhouse, a quiet bachelor who did odd jobs and farm work and whom the village regarded as peculiar but harmless.

Mary Hogan vanished in December 1954 while tending bar at a rural tavern. The case went cold. On November 16, 1957, the opening Saturday of deer season, Bernice Worden, 58, disappeared from Plainfield, where she ran the hardware store. Ed Gein was arrested that day. He admitted shooting both women.

He was charged with first-degree murder in Bernice Worden’s death. He was never charged over Mary Hogan. In January 1958 he was found unfit to stand trial and committed to Central State Hospital at Waupun.

The farm and its contents were set for auction in March 1958, on Palm Sunday, and talk spread that a buyer wanted to turn the house into a museum. Plainfield did not want one. Several days before the sale, the house burned to the ground; by the time the volunteer fire department arrived, after what Isthmus described as an extended detour, there was nothing left to save. The cause was never established. Gein’s car was sold at the auction and toured county fairs as a sideshow attraction until the authorities shut the exhibit down.

After doctors found that he could at last take part in his own defense, in November 1968 Circuit Judge Robert Gollmar heard the case without a jury, found that Gein had committed the first-degree murder of Bernice Worden, and then, in a separate hearing as Wisconsin law required, found that he had been insane at the time. He was sent back to the hospital. He worked there for years as a carpenter, a mason and a groundskeeper. In 1978 he was moved to the Mendota Mental Health Institute in Madison, and he died in its geriatric ward on July 26, 1984, at 77.

What remained of the farm passed through other hands. In April 2006 the last 40 acres were listed on eBay for 250,000 dollars; bidding was light, and the listing was pulled after five days under eBay’s rule against murder memorabilia. A cattle farmer told Isthmus in 2007 that the land was mostly a pine plantation, with nothing else left. A Plainfield woman said she and her neighbors were tired of the case being dredged up. "Some things are best not talked about," the farmer said.

The novelist Robert Bloch drew on the case for Psycho, published in 1959, and Alfred Hitchcock filmed the book in 1960. The house itself is gone; its story has outlived it in fiction.

North Philadelphia: Gary Heidnik

Gary Heidnik did not fit the usual picture of a man on the margins. He had trained as an Army medic in the 1960s and been posted to Germany before a medical discharge, after which, by the account of the prosecutor who later tried him, he obtained 100 percent disability. A forensic psychologist told his trial that he had been hospitalized about 22 times and had a history of schizophrenia. He was also clever with money. He founded his own church, the United Church of the Ministers of God, which a friend believed began as a tax dodge, and invested its funds so shrewdly that 1,500 dollars grew into a stock portfolio worth more than half a million. Philadelphia Magazine put his IQ at 148.

In late 1986 Heidnik, then 43, began abducting women and holding them captive in his house in North Philadelphia. One was taken on November 25, 1986. Sandra Lindsay disappeared the day after Thanksgiving. Over the following months six women were held in the house. Two of them, Sandra Lindsay and Deborah Dudley, died there. When Lindsay’s family pressed the police, a detective treated her case as a voluntary disappearance and closed it, and an officer who came to the house after neighbors complained left once Heidnik had given him an explanation.

On March 24, 1987, one of the women escaped and went to the police, and Heidnik was arrested. The other women held in the house were freed.

Heidnik was tried before Judge Lynne Abraham, who later became Philadelphia’s district attorney. His lawyer, Chuck Peruto, argued that he was insane. Abraham concluded quickly that he was faking, and the prosecution called his stockbroker to show the jury how carefully he had managed his money. The jury convicted him of two counts of first-degree murder and voted for death. He then asked not to appeal. In March 1991 the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, reviewing the case as the law required, upheld both death sentences, finding them "neither excessive nor disproportionate," and directed the governor to proceed with a death warrant.

Heidnik was executed in 1999. He was the last person put to death in Pennsylvania. "He wanted to die," a neighbor told Philadelphia Magazine. She remembered news crews filling the block for about two weeks after the rescue. Peruto said years later that he had always regretted not winning the insanity defense.

Holcomb: the Clutter family

The killings at the Clutter farmhouse were the work of one night and two men, and they reached readers around the world because a novelist from New York came to town.

Herbert Clutter farmed near Holcomb, in Finney County, western Kansas. He lived with his wife, Bonnie Mae, and the two youngest of their children, Nancy, 16, and Kenyon, 15. On November 15, 1959, all four were killed in their farmhouse, about seven miles from Garden City.

The men responsible were Richard Hickock and Perry Smith, two ex-convicts. According to the Mob Museum in Las Vegas, Hickock had heard from a former cellmate, Floyd Wells, that the farmer kept 10,000 dollars in a safe. There was no safe full of money. The two men left with about 40 dollars, a pair of binoculars and a transistor radio.

For days the Kansas Bureau of Investigation had nothing to go on. Then Wells, still in prison, heard about the killings on the radio and came forward, with an eye, the museum says, on a 1,000-dollar reward. Shortly after 5 p.m. on December 30, 1959, two Las Vegas police officers spotted a Chevrolet bearing a Kansas plate that had been reported stolen and arrested Hickock and Smith for parole violations.

They were charged jointly in Finney County with four counts of first-degree murder. At their arraignment on February 9, 1960, they stood mute, and the court entered pleas of not guilty for them. The trial opened on March 22, 1960, in the Finney County District Court in Garden City. The jury found both men guilty on every count and fixed the punishment at death. The Kansas Supreme Court affirmed. In federal court the men argued that their lawyers had been inadequate, that local publicity had made a fair trial impossible, and that their confessions had been coerced. In July 1964 the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit rejected every claim, finding that their lawyers had made a reasoned choice to try to save them from death rather than chase an acquittal, and that the jurors had credibly testified they could judge the case fairly.

Hickock and Smith were executed at the Kansas State Penitentiary in Lansing on April 14, 1965. The next year Truman Capote published In Cold Blood, the book he called a nonfiction novel, and the case has belonged to literature ever since.

The farmhouse is still standing in Finney County. In 2019, sixty years after the killings, it was put up for auction, Topeka’s WIBW reported.

Bath Township and Milwaukee: Jeffrey Dahmer

Two houses are tied to Jeffrey Dahmer, and they met opposite fates.

The first is the family home in Bath Township, a semi-rural community near Akron, Ohio, a ranch-style house built in 1952 on about an acre and a half of woods with a pond, where he spent his teenage years. In the summer of 1978, just after he finished high school, he was living there alone. On June 18 he picked up a hitchhiker, Steven Hicks, 18, who had just finished high school and was trying to get to a rock concert. Dahmer took him back to the house and killed him. It was his first killing, and for 13 years nobody knew.

The second is apartment 213 of a building on Milwaukee’s near west side, a few blocks from the Marquette University campus, where Dahmer moved in May 1990. In the next 14 months, 12 men and boys died there. He found them in gay bars, at shopping malls, at bus stops and on the street, offered them money to pose for photographs or a drink and a place to go, and drugged them. Most of them were Black. Several of their families later said that police had not taken their missing-person reports seriously.

On July 22, 1991, a man who had been held in the apartment went to the police, and Dahmer was arrested there that night. Over the following weeks he gave detectives an account of 17 killings going back to 1978.

He was charged in Milwaukee with 15 counts of first-degree intentional homicide and pleaded guilty but insane, so the trial that opened in January 1992 was only about his sanity. On February 15, 1992, the jury found him sane on every count. Two days later, after relatives of the dead had addressed him, he told the court, "I take all the blame for what I did," and Judge Laurence Gram sentenced him to 15 consecutive life terms. Wisconsin had no death penalty. On May 1, 1992, in Akron, he pleaded guilty to the aggravated murder of Steven Hicks and received a 16th life sentence. On November 28, 1994, another inmate beat him to death at the Columbia Correctional Institution in Portage, Wisconsin. He was 34.

The Milwaukee building did not survive him. It was torn down, and the city later sold the lot to a developer for 500 dollars on condition that it be kept as green space; it remains an empty, grassy lot. Victims' families who had won judgments against his estate went to court in 1996 to auction his belongings, and a Milwaukee real estate developer, Joseph Zilber, raised 407,225 dollars through a civic group to buy the items instead. They were destroyed that June, so that, in Zilber’s words, "these tools of death be permanently destroyed."

The Ohio house stayed in private hands. When it was listed in August 2012 for 329,000 dollars, the agent told prospective buyers that families had lived there since the killing and that it was "not a museum," but someone’s home. In April 2014, with the house back on the market, the animal rights group PETA floated a plan to turn it into a vegan restaurant called "Eat For Life: Home Cooking." Within a week a PETA spokeswoman told the Akron Beacon Journal that the group "won’t be able to move forward," the Associated Press reported. The listing agent said he doubted the offer had ever been serious.

Port Coquitlam: Robert Pickton

Robert William Pickton was born in 1949 and grew up on his family’s pig farm in Port Coquitlam, a suburb east of Vancouver, British Columbia. The family once held 22 hectares there. In the 1990s much of the land was sold for development, and homes, condominiums, a park and an elementary school went up on what had been farmland; the siblings kept about six and a half hectares, much of it buried under piles of fill. Pickton raised pigs, and he and his brother ran salvage and demolition businesses from the property.

Through the 1990s women were disappearing from Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside, many of them Indigenous and many of them working in the sex trade. Their families marched and pleaded for attention. Police had information pointing toward Pickton by 1998 and 1999. He had been charged with attempted murder in 1997, and the charge had been dropped.

Police searched the farm from February 2002, and on February 22, 2002, Pickton was charged with the first-degree murders of Sereena Abotsway and Mona Wilson. In custody, he told an undercover officer placed in his cell that he had killed 49 women. No court ever tested the number.

The investigation of the farm became the largest crime scene investigation in Canadian history, The Canadian Encyclopedia records, and it lasted until November 2003. By the end of that year it had cost 70 million dollars, Maclean’s reported.

Pickton was charged with the first-degree murders of 26 women and tried in New Westminster on six of the counts. On December 9, 2007, the jury acquitted him of first-degree murder and found him guilty of second-degree murder on all six: Sereena Abotsway, Mona Wilson, Andrea Joesbury, Brenda Ann Wolfe, Georgina Faith Papin and Marnie Frey. Two days later Justice Williams sentenced him to life in prison with no chance of parole for 25 years, the maximum. "Mr. Pickton’s conduct was murderous and repeatedly so," the judge said. The British Columbia Court of Appeal upheld the convictions in 2009, and the Supreme Court of Canada did the same on July 30, 2010. Five days later the Crown stayed the 20 remaining murder charges, saying that further convictions could not add to his sentence. Those women’s families were left without a trial.

A provincial inquiry led by the former judge Wally Oppal reported in 2012 that the police investigations had been "a blatant failure" and that the women had been "forsaken by society at large and then again by the police." Vancouver police and the RCMP apologized for not catching him sooner.

On May 19, 2024, another inmate attacked Pickton at the Port-Cartier Institution, a maximum-security prison in Quebec. He died in hospital on May 31, 2024, aged 74, Correctional Service Canada announced. The inmate, Martin Charest, pleaded guilty to first-degree murder in September 2025 and was sentenced to life with no parole for 25 years.

In March 2014 the federal government, British Columbia and the City of Vancouver announced a joint compensation framework under which each of the 98 living children of the missing and murdered women identified in the inquiry’s report was entitled to 50,000 dollars.

Fall River: the Borden house

On the morning of August 4, 1892, Andrew Borden, 69, and his wife, Abby, 64, were killed in their home in Fall River, Massachusetts. Abby was Andrew’s second wife. His two daughters, Lizzie, 32, and Emma, 41, both unmarried, still lived in the family home. Emma was away on vacation that day.

The police first looked outside the family. Within hours of the killings they arrested an innocent Portuguese American man. Then suspicion turned to Lizzie, who said she had been in the barn at the time. A grand jury indicted her for both killings. The prosecution’s case was circumstantial: an alleged attempt to buy poison the day before, and a dress she burned the following Sunday. Fingerprint evidence was not then trusted by most American investigators, and the police did not test the suspected weapon for prints. In 1893 a jury acquitted her.

She never shook the suspicion. She and Emma bought a Victorian mansion in Fall River known as Maplecroft in 1893, and Lizzie lived there until she died of pneumonia on June 1, 1927, at 66.

The house where her father and stepmother died had a stranger afterlife. By 2021 it had operated for more than 15 years as a bed and breakfast and museum, with original doors and hardware, period decor, case-related artifacts on display and rooms for overnight guests. In February 2018 Donald Woods, who owned the Borden bed and breakfast, also bought Maplecroft, for 600,000 dollars, with plans to run it as a second bed and breakfast, the Providence station WJAR reported. In 2021 the original house was listed for 2 million dollars, and that year Lance Zaal, founder of a company called U.S. Ghost Adventures, bought it for between 1.8 and 1.9 million dollars. It offers daily tours and reenactments of the morning of the killings, and it sells itself as the most haunted house in the United States. "Did she do it or didn’t she do it?" one visitor asked a reporter in 2022. The question has filled the rooms for more than a century.

The houses that remain

Of the ten, the buildings in Gloucester, Notting Hill and Milwaukee were pulled down, and the Gein farmhouse burned before anyone could buy it. The houses in Sacramento, Holcomb and Bath Township still stand and have changed hands more than once. In Gloucester a footpath runs where the West house stood, and in Milwaukee the city kept the lot empty on purpose. In Sacramento and Fall River the owners took the opposite course and opened the doors.

Timeline

• August 4, 1892: Andrew and Abby Borden are killed in their home in Fall River, Massachusetts.

• 1893: Lizzie Borden is acquitted; she and her sister buy Maplecroft.

• 1937: John and Ethel Christie move into the ground-floor flat of a house in Notting Hill, London.

• 1943 and 1944: Ruth Fuerst and Muriel Eady disappear in London.

• November 1949: Beryl and Geraldine Evans are killed in the same house.

• January 13, 1950: Timothy Evans is convicted of murdering his daughter; he is hanged on March 9.

• March 24, 1953: The deaths at the Christie house come to light; Christie is arrested on March 31.

• June 25, 1953: Christie is convicted of murdering his wife; he is hanged on July 15.

• December 1954: Mary Hogan disappears in Wisconsin.

• November 16, 1957: Bernice Worden disappears in Plainfield, Wisconsin; Ed Gein is arrested.

• March 1958: The Gein farmhouse burns days before its auction.

• November 15, 1959: The Clutter family is killed near Holcomb, Kansas.

• December 30, 1959: Richard Hickock and Perry Smith are arrested in Las Vegas.

• March 1960: Hickock and Smith are convicted in Garden City and sentenced to death.

• April 14, 1965: Hickock and Smith are executed at Lansing.

• October 26, 1965: Sylvia Likens dies in Indianapolis.

• 1966: Gertrude Baniszewski is convicted of first-degree murder.

• October 18, 1966: Timothy Evans receives a posthumous free pardon.

• November 1968: Ed Gein is found to have committed the murder of Bernice Worden and found insane at the time.

• 1970: The renamed Notting Hill street where Christie lived is demolished.

• 1971: Gertrude Baniszewski is convicted again at a retrial.

• 1972: Fred and Rosemary West marry and move into their house in Gloucester.

• June 18, 1978: Jeffrey Dahmer kills Steven Hicks at his family home in Bath Township, Ohio.

• 1985: Gertrude Baniszewski is paroled; Dorothea Puente is paroled in September.

• November 1986 to March 1987: Gary Heidnik holds six women in his house in North Philadelphia; one escapes on March 24, 1987.

• June 19, 1987: Heather West is last seen.

• November 11, 1988: Police open the investigation at Dorothea Puente’s boarding house in Sacramento.

• May 1990 to July 1991: Twelve men and boys die in Dahmer’s Milwaukee apartment.

• June 16, 1990: Gertrude Baniszewski dies in Iowa.

• March 1991: The Pennsylvania Supreme Court upholds Heidnik’s death sentences.

• July 22, 1991: Dahmer is arrested in Milwaukee.

• February 15, 1992: A Milwaukee jury finds Dahmer sane; he is sentenced to life terms two days later.

• Summer 1993: Puente is convicted of three murders in Monterey County.

• February 25, 1994: Fred West and Rosemary West are arrested in Gloucester.

• November 28, 1994: Dahmer is killed in prison.

• January 1, 1995: Fred West dies in custody before trial.

• November 22, 1995: Rosemary West is convicted of ten murders.

• 1996: The West house is demolished.

• 1999: Heidnik is executed.

• February 22, 2002: Robert Pickton is charged with two murders.

• December 9, 2007: Pickton is found guilty of six counts of second-degree murder.

• March 27, 2011: Puente dies in prison.

• August 2012: The Dahmer family home in Bath Township is listed for sale.

• April 2014: PETA proposes, then drops, a plan to buy the Bath Township house.

• September 2015: About 600 people tour Puente’s former boarding house for charity.

• 2021: Lance Zaal buys the Borden house.

• May 31, 2024: Pickton dies after an assault in prison.

• September 2025: Martin Charest pleads guilty to Pickton’s murder.