Huu Can Tran

Victims
11 people killed in Monterey Park, California, January 2023; attributed to him by the sheriff's department; never charged or tried.
Years active
January 21, 2023
Location
Monterey Park, California (killings); Alhambra, California (disarmed); Torrance, California (death); Hemet, California (residence)
Method
Shot (sheriff's department account); never tested in court.
Status
Never charged or tried; as of January 19, 2024, police had not stated a motive. Suicide before any charge or trial, in Torrance, California, January 22, 2023.

Late on the evening of Saturday, January 21, 2023, the first night of the Lunar New Year, 11 people were killed in Monterey Park, California, a small city on the eastern edge of Los Angeles. Ten died that night. The eleventh, a woman, died of her injuries afterward, and nine others were hurt. Within a day the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department named the man it said was responsible: Huu Can Tran, 72, a former trucker who had spent much of his adult life in the San Gabriel Valley and who, in his last years, lived in a senior community in Hemet, in Riverside County.

Tran never stood trial. About 20 minutes after the killings he tried to enter a second business in neighboring Alhambra, where a young man who worked there disarmed him, and no one there was hurt. The next morning, January 22, he died by suicide in Torrance. No charge was ever filed. Investigators did not find a connection between Tran and any of the people who died, and as of January 19, 2024, police had not stated a motive. What remains is the record the investigators assembled in the first days, the facts of his own life, and the eleven people whose lives ended that night.

The accounts of his origin differ: the sheriff's department said he was originally from Vietnam, while his marriage license described him as an immigrant from China.

He lived in Houston before moving to California in the late 1980s. Over the following decades he lived in a string of San Gabriel Valley cities: Alhambra, Monterey Park, San Gabriel and Arcadia. He owned property in San Gabriel from 1989 until he sold it in 2013. For at least 20 years he drove trucks for a living. In 2002 he formed a company of his own, Tran's Trucking Inc., in San Gabriel, and served as its chief executive. It was dissolved in 2004, with no assets or liabilities. A former friend later said that he had also run a small business cleaning carpets in restaurants.

His one known brush with the law came in 1990, when he was arrested on a possession charge under California's arms law. It was an arrest, not a conviction.

For much of his life in California, Tran's social world centered on the ballroom dance halls of the San Gabriel Valley. A former friend said that he went to two of them, in Monterey Park and Alhambra, on a daily basis, and that dancing was the only thing that held his interest. A neighbor in Hemet recalled that he had once taught ballroom dance.

People who knew him in those years gave a consistent picture of a solitary man. A former tenant and longtime acquaintance described him as a loner who had few friends at the dance halls and spent most nights alone, someone who distrusted everyone and found it hard to get along with people, though he was not aggressive. A former friend said that Tran was always suspicious that others were speaking ill of him behind his back, and that he complained often about people at the halls. Acquaintances said he offered free lessons to women who were new to the halls, so that he would have a partner, and that this caused friction with the paid instructors, who kept their distance from him.

In his last years Tran lived in Hemet, a city in Riverside County roughly 75 miles east of Los Angeles, in a gated manufactured-housing community for residents aged 55 and older. He had moved there from the San Gabriel Valley. A neighbor there described him as a quiet, pleasant man who was often seen walking his dog. The Hemet Police Department later said that it had no record of any incident involving him and no calls for service to the address where he lived.

Two weeks before the killings, Tran went twice to the Hemet police station, on January 7 and January 9, 2023. According to the department, he made allegations of past fraud, theft and an attempt to harm him, all of it, he said, 10 to 20 years earlier. He was told to return with documents supporting his claims. He said that he would. He never came back.

Saturday, January 21, 2023, was the opening night of the Year of the Rabbit. Tens of thousands of people had attended Monterey Park's festivities earlier that evening, and the celebrations had ended for the night when the killings began.

Ten people were dead that night. Ten more were hurt; one of them, a woman, died later, bringing the toll to 11, and nine survived.

The Los Angeles County Department of Medical Examiner-Coroner identified all of the dead by January 24, 2023: six women and five men.

My My Nhan, known as Mymy, had been a regular among Monterey Park's dancers for more than a decade and went dancing on weekends for many years. She was devoted to her nieces and nephews and treated them as her own children, and she had been looking forward to celebrating the new year with her family the following day. She was remembered as warm and kind, the one who encouraged everyone around her.

Lilan Li had gone out that night with friends to mark the new year, a woman remembered for her strength and her optimism.

Xiujuan Yu was a married mother of three, including twins, who worked hard to support her family. She had gone out with friends that evening and did not return.

Muoi Dai Ung was outgoing and loved to dance.

Hongying Jian, known as Nancy, had been a regular among the city's dancers for years. She enjoyed singing, playing the piano and dancing, and was known as kind and sociable.

Diana Man Ling Tom was a mother, wife and grandmother who loved to dance and to sing karaoke and was known for her generosity. She was the woman who died of her injuries after that night.

Yu Lun Kao, whom friends called Andy, was a longtime figure in the city's dance community. He took group classes and practiced on his own, often for hours.

Chia Ling Yau loved music, dance and travel. He was remembered as a caring and fun-loving father, uncle, brother and friend, generous with his time.

Valentino Marcos Alvero was a ballroom dancer and a devoted family man, a father, grandfather and uncle, and a devout Catholic.

Wen Tau Yu was among the dancers of the San Gabriel Valley.

Ming Wei Ma was a skilled dancer, cheerful and welcoming, who spoke little English but made people feel at ease through his warmth. Friends remembered him as a patient and much-loved figure in the community.

Most of them were dancers from the same world of ballroom halls that Tran had once frequented.

About 20 minutes after the killings, Tran arrived at a second business in Alhambra, a few miles away. A young man who worked there disarmed him, ordered him to leave, and called the police. Tran left without hurting anyone. Investigators believed he had come intending a second attack. Evidence from Alhambra helped investigators identify Tran as the suspect, and detectives later said they had found evidence linking him to both cities.

On the morning of Sunday, January 22, police and sheriff's deputies found him in Torrance, where he died by suicide. That afternoon the sheriff's department announced his name, and said that no other suspect was being sought.

The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department led the inquiry, and the FBI worked with it on the question of motive.

At a news conference on Wednesday, January 25, the sheriff set out what the investigation had and had not found. Detectives had not been able to establish a connection between Tran and any of the victims. Reports that Tran was still a regular at the place in Monterey Park where the killings happened, and that he saw himself as an instructor there, did not fit what investigators had learned: according to the sheriff, he had not been there in at least five years. He did not appear to have chosen the victims as individuals.

In the first days, the sheriff said investigators did not know that the killings were a hate crime as the law defines one. As of January 19, 2024, a year after the killings, police still had not stated a motive.

Because Tran died the day after the killings, before any arrest, no prosecutor filed a charge, no grand jury heard evidence, and no court made any finding about what happened in Monterey Park. His responsibility rests on the investigation of the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department, on the evidence detectives said linked him to Monterey Park and Alhambra, and on the circumstances of his death in Torrance. Under the law he died an untried man. The deaths of the eleven were never the subject of a verdict.

Tran's motive was never established. As of January 19, 2024, police had not stated one, and no court ever weighed it.

His recent ties to the place in Monterey Park where the killings happened are contested. Early accounts, including those of acquaintances, described him as a fixture of the halls; the sheriff said that he had not been there in at least five years.

Who disarmed him in Alhambra was stated differently at first. The sheriff spoke of two people; the young man said he acted alone, and security video showed only him and Tran.

Timeline

1989: Tran buys property in San Gabriel, California, where he holds it until 2013.

1990: He is arrested on a possession charge under California's arms law; no conviction follows.

2002: He forms Tran's Trucking Inc. in San Gabriel; it is dissolved in 2004.

2013: He sells the San Gabriel property; he later moves to a senior community in Hemet.

January 7 and 9, 2023: He visits the Hemet police station to allege past fraud, theft and an attempt to harm him.

January 21, 2023: Ten people are killed in Monterey Park on the first night of the Lunar New Year; an eleventh dies later. About 20 minutes afterward he is disarmed in Alhambra.

January 22, 2023: He dies by suicide in Torrance; the sheriff's department names him that afternoon.

January 24, 2023: The county medical examiner-coroner releases the names of all eleven dead.

January 25, 2023: The sheriff says no connection between Tran and any victim has been found.

January 19, 2024: A year on, police still have not stated a motive.