Hugo Pinell spent about fifty years in California's prisons, and nearly everything that made his name happened inside them. He entered the state system in 1965 with a life sentence for rape. On March 3, 1971, at the Correctional Training Facility in Soledad, he killed Correctional Officer R. J. McCarthey, and on May 22, 1972, he was sentenced to a second term of life with the possibility of parole for that death. It is the only killing for which a court ever sentenced him.
Between those two dates came the day that fixed him in public memory. On August 21, 1971, an escape attempt at San Quentin left six men dead: three officers, two inmates and George Jackson, the prisoner and author who led it. Pinell was one of six inmates tried together for those deaths. After a trial in San Rafael that ran for about sixteen months and cost more than $2 million, both California records at the time, a Marin County jury returned no conviction against him on the murder and conspiracy charges. It convicted him instead of two counts of felony assault by a prisoner serving a life sentence, for attacks on two officers who lived, and on September 1, 1976, he received a third life term.
He was never again a free man. He spent about 45 years in segregation units, was denied parole for the ninth time in 2009, and was moved into a general population yard only days before his death in custody in 2015.
Pinell was born in Nicaragua, and he was 19 when he was convicted of rape. On February 17, 1965, he was committed to state prison from San Francisco County to serve life with the possibility of parole for rape with force.
In early 1971 Pinell was held at the Correctional Training Facility, the state prison at Soledad. He was six years into his first life term when the officer died there on March 3, 1971. On May 22, 1972, he was sentenced to life with the possibility of parole for the officer's death, and that sentence, his second, stood for the rest of his life. By the summer of 1971, while the Soledad case was still pending, he was held at San Quentin, in Marin County.
On August 21, 1971, an escape attempt at San Quentin failed the same day it began. Six men died. Three were officers. Two were inmate workers. The sixth was the escape's leader.
Three other officers were badly injured and survived to give evidence. One of them later testified that Pinell had attacked him. The jury that heard the case did not convict him of any of the six deaths.
The state charged six inmates in connection with the day's events, Pinell among them. The charges, brought in Marin County, included murder, conspiracy and assault.
The six men were tried jointly in San Rafael before a Marin County jury. The trial ran for about sixteen months, and by its end it was the longest criminal trial California had yet seen and the most expensive, at more than $2 million. Pinell went to trial on every count, and the case on the assault charges against him turned on the evidence of the officers who survived.
The jury returned its verdicts in August 1976, and most of the charges ended in acquittal. One co-defendant was convicted of two counts of murder and of conspiracy to escape, the only one of the six found guilty of murder. A second co-defendant was convicted of assault. Three were acquitted on every count.
Pinell was convicted of two counts of felony assault by a prisoner serving a life sentence, for the attacks on two officers who survived. On the remaining charges against him, murder and conspiracy among them, the jury found the evidence insufficient. On September 1, 1976, he was sentenced to life with the possibility of parole, his third such term.
From the early 1970s onward Pinell was held apart from the general prison population, a placement the state tied to his repeated assaults on guards. He was kept in Security Housing Units at two of California's highest-security prisons, and he was held in segregation longer than any other inmate in the state system. By August 2015 the total came to about 45 years.
The policy changed late in his life. After the state moved away from holding inmates in isolation indefinitely, Pinell was transferred in 2014 to California State Prison, Sacramento, a maximum-security institution beside Folsom State Prison. In August 2015, with no recent gang-related or criminal behavior on his file, he was released into its general population.
Each of Pinell's three sentences carried the possibility of parole, and the Board of Parole Hearings took up his case repeatedly over the decades. It never found him suitable for release. At his last hearing, in 2009, the board denied parole for the ninth time.
Earlier denials had set his next hearing between one and five years away. After the 2009 denial, the board set his next hearing for 2024.
On August 12, 2015, Pinell was killed by fellow inmates at California State Prison, Sacramento, near Folsom.
The joint trial that produced Pinell's assault convictions also reached the United States Supreme Court, in a case brought by the co-defendant convicted of murder. On December 12, 1983, in Rushen v. Spain, the Court vacated a federal grant of habeas relief to that co-defendant, holding that a trial judge's unrecorded private exchanges with a juror are subject to harmless-error review. The opinion also recorded the outcome for the others: the jury had convicted two co-defendants of assault and found insufficient evidence on the remaining charges against them. Pinell was one of those two.
Pinell was charged with murder and conspiracy in the San Quentin deaths of August 21, 1971, and he was not convicted of either. The jury found the evidence insufficient on those counts. His convictions from that day are for assaults on two officers who survived, and one of those officers testified against him at trial.
The Soledad death is the only killing for which he was sentenced. The deaths of the three officers, the two inmates and the escape's leader at San Quentin remain outside any verdict against him.
February 17, 1965: committed to state prison from San Francisco County to serve life with the possibility of parole for rape with force.
March 3, 1971: a correctional officer dies at the Correctional Training Facility, Soledad.
August 21, 1971: escape attempt at San Quentin; three officers, two inmates and the escape's leader die.
May 22, 1972: sentenced to life with the possibility of parole for the Soledad killing.
August 1976: after a joint trial of about sixteen months in San Rafael, convicted of two counts of felony assault by a prisoner serving a life sentence; no conviction on the murder and conspiracy charges.
September 1, 1976: sentenced to a third term of life with the possibility of parole.
December 12, 1983: the United States Supreme Court decides Rushen v. Spain, arising from the same trial.
2009: parole denied for the ninth time; next hearing set for 2024.
2014: transferred to California State Prison, Sacramento, near Folsom.
August 2015: released into the general population.
August 12, 2015: killed by fellow inmates at California State Prison, Sacramento.