Hubert Zafke

Victims
3,681 deaths charged as accessory to murder; never tried, case discontinued 2017
Years active
August 15 to September 14, 1944 (period charged)
Location
Oświęcim (Auschwitz-Birkenau), Poland (killings); Kraków, Poland (trial); Neubrandenburg, Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, Germany (arrest); Neubrandenburg, Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, Germany (trial)
Method
Gassing (indictment: deportees killed in the camp's gas chambers on arrival); charged as an accessory, with no direct act alleged.
Status
Kraków court, 1948: four years for SS membership; released 1951. 2015 case discontinued September 12, 2017 (unfit, dementia); no verdict. Died untried, July 2018.

Hubert Zafke spent one month of 1944 as an SS medical orderly at Auschwitz-Birkenau, from August 15 to September 14. Seventy years later, prosecutors in the German city of Schwerin charged him as an accessory to the murder of at least 3,681 people, the Jewish deportees who were killed on arrival from fourteen trains that reached the camp in those weeks. One of the trains had left the Westerbork transit camp in the Netherlands on September 3, 1944, carrying the eight people who had hidden in the Secret Annex in Amsterdam, among them Anne Frank and the rest of the Frank family.

The case never reached a verdict. Zafke was 94 when he was indicted in February 2015, and the regional court in Neubrandenburg spent the next two and a half years deciding whether he could be tried at all. In September 2017 the court discontinued the proceedings because the accused, by then 96, had dementia too far advanced for him to follow a trial. He denied any part in the killings, and he died in July 2018, in his ninety-eighth year, without having been tried for any of them.

Zafke was the son of a farmer. He joined the Waffen-SS at 19 and served first on the eastern front. He later held the rank of sergeant and worked as a medic. His service at Auschwitz came in two periods: on the camp staff from October 1943 to January 1944, and as a medical orderly at Auschwitz-Birkenau, attached to the SS military hospital, from mid-August to mid-September 1944.

The second period became the indictment. According to the prosecution, the medical unit in which he served treated SS personnel, tested samples taken from women prisoners in the camp infirmary, stood auxiliary guard duty, and had a part in the killings when transports arrived. Prosecutors never alleged that Zafke personally took part in the selections. Their case was that by fitting himself into the camp's organization he kept it running and so furthered the murder of the deportees, and that he knew what the camp was for.

The count of 3,681 rested on the deportees from the fourteen trains that arrived in those weeks and were killed on arrival. The Westerbork train of September 3, 1944, carried 1,019 Jews from the Netherlands. It reached Auschwitz-Birkenau two and a half days later, in the night, and 371 of the people aboard were murdered on arrival. The eight people from the Secret Annex were selected for forced labor; of them, only Otto Frank survived the war.

The end of the war brought Zafke before a court once already. In 1948 a court in Kraków, in postwar Poland, sentenced him to four years in prison for his membership in the SS. He served the sentence and was released in 1951. That case concerned his membership of the organization, not any killing.

After his release he settled near Neubrandenburg, in the part of Germany that became the German Democratic Republic, and he stayed there for the rest of his life. He lived in a village of about 300 people between Altentreptow and Demmin, in Western Pomerania, and worked at a local mill as a pest controller until he retired. He never changed his name.

The case against him began with the Central Office of the State Justice Administrations for the Investigation of National Socialist Crimes in Ludwigsburg. In 2013 the Central Office recommended the prosecution of about thirty former camp guards, and Zafke was on the list. The file went to the prosecutor's office in Schwerin.

On March 18, 2014, he was arrested near Neubrandenburg. At that stage the allegation covered a shorter stretch of his service: eight prisoner transports and 1,721 deportees who had been classed as unfit for work and killed on arrival. He was 93. The arrest warrant was soon suspended and he was released on conditions. When German investigators first questioned him, in 2014, he denied ever having served at Auschwitz. He later admitted that he had been there but said he had not known about the killings until after the war, and that he had given first aid and treated prisoners and nothing more.

The prosecutors then separated out the part of the case that concerned August 15 to September 14, 1944. On February 23, 2015, they filed an indictment with the Landgericht Neubrandenburg, the regional court, charging him as an accessory to murder in at least 3,681 cases. Inquiries into other periods and places of his SS service continued separately.

In June 2015 the Neubrandenburg court declined to open the trial, finding that he suffered from dementia that was getting worse with no prospect of improvement. In December 2015 the Higher Regional Court in Rostock overruled it on the prosecutors' appeal and ordered a fresh medical report, which found that he could stand trial on a limited basis, in short sessions under close medical supervision. Two attempts at a trial followed, in February and September 2016, and both collapsed, first over his health and then over bias applications that the prosecutors and the Holocaust survivors and relatives of the dead who had joined the case as co-plaintiffs brought against the judges; in 2017 the applications were granted and three new judges took over the case.

Medical examinations in March and July 2017 found Zafke unfit. Two court-appointed psychiatrists, working independently, diagnosed a progressive dementia syndrome of moderate severity and concluded that he could not follow a discussion or retain information for more than a few minutes. His dementia, they found, had progressed since October 2015 to the point where he could no longer represent his own interests, take in what was said in court or make statements of his own.

On September 12, 2017, at the prosecutors' request, the newly composed chamber of the Landgericht Neubrandenburg discontinued the proceedings, for a single reason: because of his dementia, Zafke was no longer capable of following a trial. The ruling ended the case without any finding on the facts. The indictment was never tested in court, and Zafke was never convicted of any of the 3,681 deaths with which he was charged.

Hubert Zafke died in July 2018, in his ninety-eighth year. He died an accused man who had never been tried.

Zafke's own account changed. When he was first questioned in 2014 he denied having served at Auschwitz at all. Later he accepted that he had been there but said that he had given first aid, treated prisoners and neither saw nor took part in any of the killings, which he said he learned about only after the war. The prosecutors' case was that he knew the camp's purpose and willingly supported it. No court ever decided between the two accounts.

The scale of the allegation also changed. In 2014 the investigation concerned eight transports and 1,721 deaths; the 2015 indictment covered fourteen transports and at least 3,681 deaths over a slightly different stretch of time. The prosecutors never alleged that he took part in the selections, and the 1948 conviction in Kraków was for membership of the SS, not for any killing.

Timeline

1944, August 15 to September 14: Zafke serves as an SS medical orderly at Auschwitz-Birkenau; fourteen deportation trains arrive in the period later charged.

1944, September 3: A transport of 1,019 Jews leaves Westerbork for Auschwitz-Birkenau.

1948: A court in Kraków sentences him to four years for SS membership.

1951: He is released and settles near Neubrandenburg.

2013: The Central Office in Ludwigsburg recommends his prosecution.

2014, March 18: He is arrested near Neubrandenburg; the warrant is later suspended and he is released on conditions.

2015, February 23: The Schwerin prosecutors indict him at the Landgericht Neubrandenburg as an accessory to murder in at least 3,681 cases.

2015, June: The Neubrandenburg court declines to open the trial, citing dementia.

2015, December: The Higher Regional Court in Rostock overrules it.

2016, February and September: Two attempts to open the trial fail.

2017, March and July: Medical examinations find him unfit to stand trial.

2017, September 12: The Landgericht Neubrandenburg discontinues the proceedings.

2018, July: Zafke dies, aged 97, never tried.