On July 4, 2002, two people were killed at the ticket counter of El Al, the Israeli airline, at Los Angeles International Airport, and Hesham Mohamed Hadayet was killed there by a member of the airline's security staff. The FBI attributed both deaths to him. He was never charged and never tried, because he did not survive the day.
What the killings meant took far longer to settle than what had happened. On April 12, 2003, nine months later, the U.S. Department of Justice publicly declared them an act of terrorism. The FBI concluded that Hadayet had acted alone, unconnected to any terrorist organization, and recorded the case as the only incident of international terrorism in the United States in the years 2002 through 2005.
Hadayet was born in Egypt on July 4, 1961, the date given in the immigration chronology later compiled by the staff of the 9/11 Commission. On July 13, 1992, the United States consulate in Cairo issued him a multiple-entry tourist visa, and on July 31 he arrived at Los Angeles and was admitted as a visitor with permission to stay until January 25, 1993.
He did not leave. In December 1992 he applied for political asylum and for permission to work. He told immigration officers that he would be persecuted for his religious beliefs if he were sent back to Egypt, that the Egyptian security police had arrested him many times and tortured him, and that they had made him sign papers admitting membership in Gama'a al-Islamiyya, an accusation he called false. None of these claims was ever proven, and the Immigration and Naturalization Service found his asylum claim not entirely credible.
On the strength of the pending application, the INS granted him a work permit in March 1993. His wife and son arrived in the country that same month, with no immigration record of their entry, and at his asylum interview on March 30 he concealed their presence, a material omission that by itself was grounds for denying his petition. By then he was working as a chauffeur, mainly at the Los Angeles airport.
The INS denied the claim in 1995 and charged him as deportable for overstaying his visa, but the papers sent to him by certified mail came back undeliverable. Because the notice had never reached him, he was never entered in the system that tracked deportable aliens, and in March 1996 the deportation proceedings were terminated because he could not be located. That June the INS renewed his work permit once more.
The next change in his status came by chance. His wife won one of the visas issued each year through the State Department's diversity lottery and became a lawful permanent resident. In January 1997 Hadayet applied to adjust his own status as her spouse; his fingerprints went to the FBI, and name checks ran through the FBI and the CIA. Neither turned up anything against him, and on August 29, 1997, the INS approved his application. From that day he was a lawful permanent resident of the United States.
He held two California driver's licenses, one in the name Hesham Mohamed Ali and a second, issued in May 2000, in the name Hesham Mohamed Hadayet. He lived in Irvine, in Orange County, and ran a small livery business, Five Star Limo, out of his home there. He had no criminal record and appeared on no FBI or Federal Aviation Administration watch list.
The two people who died on July 4 were strangers to him. Victoria Hen had been born in Israel and had come to the United States in 1990. Yaakov Aminov, a bystander with no connection to the airline, had emigrated from Israel about fourteen years earlier and lived in the San Fernando Valley, where he had helped found a small Orthodox congregation. The security officer who stopped Hadayet was injured, and others in the line were hurt.
Investigators identified the dead man later that day. The FBI's Los Angeles office went on to open the case as a terrorism investigation, which the bureau confirmed in August 2002.
His immigration history drew its own scrutiny. On October 9, 2002, a deputy executive associate commissioner of the INS testified about the case before the House Subcommittee on Immigration, Border Security, and Claims. The agency had reviewed everything it held on him, and its finding was that nothing in any of it showed that he had ever been associated with a terrorist organization or had engaged in criminal activity before July 4, 2002. The only suggestion that he could pose a danger had come from his own statement that he had been falsely accused. The INS concluded that its decisions on both the asylum application and the adjustment of status had been proper under the rules in force at the time. Gama'a al-Islamiyya was not designated a foreign terrorist organization by the State Department until October 8, 1997.
The investigation ran for nine months and, in the FBI's own description, worldwide. Its conclusion was that no one else had taken part and that no network stood behind him.
The FBI set out its reasoning in Terrorism 2002-2005, its published survey of terrorist incidents in the United States for those years. It found that his religious and political beliefs, not personal revenge, were the primary motivation, and that he had meant to influence the Israeli-Palestinian conflict through the killing of civilians at an airline owned by the Israeli government. On that basis the case was officially designated an act of international terrorism. The report also listed it as the only terrorist act in the country in 2002 that took a life.
Hadayet was never charged, and no court ever examined the evidence. His responsibility for the two deaths rests on the FBI's findings and has never been tested at trial; the same is true of the motive the bureau named.
The claims he made about his life in Egypt, including repeated arrests, torture and a false accusation of membership in Gama'a al-Islamiyya, were his own statements in support of an asylum application that the INS denied. No evidence ever showed that he belonged to that group or to any other terrorist organization.
The two official accounts of his immigration history differ on how he gained permanent residence: the 9/11 Commission staff report says he was approved as an asylee, the INS that he qualified as the spouse of a diversity visa winner.
Even his date of birth is uncertain. His two California licenses gave April 7 and July 4, 1961; July 4 is the date in the 9/11 Commission staff's chronology.
July 13, 1992: The U.S. consulate in Cairo issues him a multiple-entry tourist visa.
July 31, 1992: He is admitted at Los Angeles as a visitor, with permission to stay until January 25, 1993.
December 1992: He applies for political asylum and permission to work.
March 1993: The INS grants him a work permit.
March 30, 1993: At his asylum interview he conceals that his wife and son are in the United States.
1995: The INS denies the asylum claim and charges him as deportable; the papers come back undeliverable.
March 1996: Deportation proceedings end because he cannot be located.
January 1997: He applies for permanent residence as the spouse of a diversity visa winner.
August 29, 1997: The INS approves his adjustment of status.
July 4, 2002: Two people are killed in Los Angeles; Hadayet is killed the same day.
August 2002: The FBI confirms that its Los Angeles office has opened a terrorism investigation.
October 9, 2002: The INS testifies about his immigration history before a House subcommittee.
April 12, 2003: The U.S. Department of Justice publicly declares the killings an act of terrorism.