On the morning of November 7, 1938, French police arrested a 17-year-old at the German embassy in Paris. His name was Herschel Grynszpan. The man he was accused of attacking, the German diplomat Ernst vom Rath, died of his injuries two days later, and within hours the Nazi leadership used that death as the pretext for the November pogrom, the violence against Jews across Germany and Austria that the regime called Kristallnacht.
Grynszpan never stood trial. France charged him, and then Germany charged him, and neither state ever brought the case before a court. His name appears in German records for the last time in September 1942. What happened to him after that has never been settled, and in 1960 the district court in Hanover, the city where he was born, declared him dead.
He was born there on March 28, 1921, and was known as Hermann. Through his parents he was a Polish citizen from birth, though he had never lived in Poland and grew up speaking German and Yiddish. He left school in 1935 without a diploma, spent a few months at a rabbinical college in Frankfurt am Main, and came back to a city where the regime's racial laws kept him from finding work. His request for a certificate to emigrate to Palestine was refused because of his age.
In July 1936 he left Germany on a Belgian visa, and that August or September he crossed from Belgium into France without permission and went to Paris. The crossing shaped everything that followed. With no French entry stamp in his passport, his 1937 application for permanent residence failed, leaving him only a provisional permit. His German return visa lapsed on April 1, 1937, and his requests to go back to Hanover were refused. On June 8, 1938, the French Interior Ministry denied him a residence permit and ordered him out of France by August 15. He stayed in Paris, out of sight, and in October French police looked for him without success.
That same month Poland closed the last door. A decree of October 15, 1938, effective October 29, stripped citizenship from Poles who had lived abroad for five years or more, and Grynszpan became stateless. From October 27 to 29, Germany expelled more than 17,000 Jews with Polish citizenship across the Polish border; his parents and siblings were among them, and French police records state that word of the expulsion, which reached him in Paris on November 3, prompted his decision to go to the embassy.
He went there on the morning of Monday, November 7, and was arrested on the spot. Questioned twice that day without a lawyer present, he admitted the act, though the police records show him giving varying accounts of his background and his reasons. The next day he was brought before a French examining judge. No court ever tested the case against him; it remained a charge, never a verdict.
From November 1938 he was held in the youth prison at Fresnes, outside Paris. France refused Germany's request for his extradition, and French Jewish organizations retained counsel for his defense. On June 8, 1939, the investigating judge formally charged him. The proceedings were postponed several times, and after war broke out in September 1939 the trial could not take place while the civil complainant was a German national. In June 1940 the French prosecution charged him with murder.
By then German armies were in France. On June 12, 1940, Grynszpan and 96 other prisoners were moved south from Fresnes under French guard. Turned away at Bourges and again at Châteauroux, he reached Toulouse on July 10 and fell into German hands there the next day. The Vichy government raised no objection, and on July 14 he was handed to the Gestapo and taken to Berlin. He had spent about 20 months in French custody, charged and never tried.
In Berlin he was held at the Gestapo prison in Moabit, and from January 18, 1941, in the isolation block of the Sachsenhausen concentration camp north of the city, moved between the two while the Gestapo questioned him at length. The regime wanted him alive for a public trial in Berlin, planned by three ministries with its outcome settled in advance, at which he was to be presented as the tool of a Jewish conspiracy. On October 16, 1941, the German Reich charged him with murder and high treason. He was not allowed a defense lawyer, and the trial date was set and postponed more than once.
In his last interrogation, that October, he gave the Gestapo a new account of his motive, claiming that the act had grown out of a private relationship with the diplomat, a claim no evidence has ever supported. In May 1942 Hitler ordered the trial suspended. The order was framed as a postponement rather than a cancellation, and Grynszpan was kept in custody so that he could be tried after the war. His name appears in German records for the last time in September 1942.
After that the trail goes cold. No death certificate, camp record of death or eyewitness account of his end has ever come to light. Whether he died in German custody before the war ended or survived it has never been established. In 1960 the Amtsgericht Hannover, the district court of his native city, declared him dead.
His fate is the central open question. The last German record of him dates from September 1942, and no record has settled whether he died in custody before the end of the war or survived it.
The handover to German custody is told two ways: some accounts give a handover by the Vichy government in July 1940, while others describe him falling into German hands in Toulouse on July 11 and being delivered to the Gestapo on July 14.
His accounts of his motive changed. On the day of his arrest he gave varying versions, and the private relationship he described to the Gestapo in October 1941 is regarded by his biographer, on the basis of later records, as invented; no evidence has been found to support it.
March 28, 1921: Born in Hanover, Germany.
1935: Leaves school in Hanover; briefly attends a rabbinical college in Frankfurt am Main.
July 1936: Leaves Germany for Brussels on a Belgian visa.
August or September 1936: Crosses into France without permission and settles in Paris.
April 1, 1937: His German return visa expires.
April 1937: Applies for permanent residence in France; receives only a provisional permit.
June 8, 1938: The French Interior Ministry orders him to leave France by August 15; he stays in Paris.
October 15, 1938: A Polish decree strips citizenship from long-term Poles abroad, effective October 29.
October 27 to 29, 1938: Germany expels more than 17,000 Jews with Polish citizenship across the Polish border.
November 7, 1938: Arrested at the German embassy in Paris.
November 8, 1938: Brought before a French examining judge.
November 9, 1938: The diplomat dies; the regime uses his death as the pretext for the November pogrom.
June 8, 1939: Formally charged by the French investigating judge.
June 1940: Charged with murder by the French prosecution.
June 12, 1940: Moved south from Fresnes with 96 other prisoners.
July 14, 1940: Handed over to the Gestapo and taken to Berlin.
January 18, 1941: Moved to Sachsenhausen concentration camp.
October 16, 1941: Charged by the German Reich with murder and high treason.
May 1942: Hitler orders the planned trial suspended.
September 1942: Last mention in German records.
1960: Declared dead by the Hanover district court.