Hermann Pfannmüller

Victims
Eglfing-Haar patients, 1940-1945; convicted of manslaughter. Munich jury court, 1951: manslaughter and aiding and abetting manslaughter, five years; the court ruled it was not murder
Years active
September 1939 to April 1945
Location
Haar and Munich, Bavaria, Germany
Method
Manslaughter and aiding and abetting manslaughter of asylum patients, including children, in the Nazi "euthanasia" program
Status
Five years (verdict of March 15, 1951, final). Died in Munich on April 10, 1961

Hermann Pfannmüller ran the Heil- und Pflegeanstalt Eglfing-Haar, the state asylum at Haar, just outside Munich, from 1938 until the end of the Second World War. In those seven years the institution became one of the working centers of the Nazi campaign against the mentally ill and the disabled. Its patients were sent away by the thousand to the killing centers at Grafeneck and Hartheim, its wards held children chosen for death by a committee in Berlin, and its director, at the same time, sat at his desk in Haar as one of the assessors whose marks on a printed form decided who would live. The hospital that stands on the site today counts roughly 4,000 people who were killed at Eglfing-Haar or taken from it to be killed between 1939 and 1945.

He was a psychiatrist and neurologist, born in Munich and trained in the Bavarian asylum service, and a member of the Nazi Party since 1922. After the war it took the Bavarian courts six years to bring his case to a final judgment. A jury court in Munich convicted him in 1949 and sentenced him to six years. The Bavarian Supreme Court heard his appeal in March 1950, and on March 15, 1951, the jury court at the Landgericht München I convicted him again, of Totschlag and Beihilfe zum Totschlag, manslaughter and aiding and abetting manslaughter, and sentenced him to five years. The court held that the killing of the children in his asylum had not been murder. He died in Munich in April 1961.

A Munich doctor in the asylum service

Pfannmüller was born in Munich on June 8, 1886. He studied medicine, qualified as a physician and went into psychiatry, and his first posts were as an asylum doctor at Weilmünster, at Ansbach and at Kaufbeuren. During the First World War he served as a doctor in a military hospital. As a student he was already an ardent advocate of eugenics and of "euthanasia," the idea that the lives of the incurably ill could be ended by the state.

He gave his own account of those years under oath in 1947, and it is the account of a career built slowly inside the Bavarian institutions. He had gone to school in Munich and studied medicine at the University of Munich, passing his state examinations in 1911. In 1913, at his teacher's urging, he went to the asylum at Weilmünster to help bring its diagnosis and treatment up to date. From 1916 to 1919 he was a medical officer at the Bavarian state institution at Homburg, where he also ran a Red Cross observation hospital. In 1919 he moved to Ansbach, rose to senior physician and took charge of a department for the most seriously ill patients, and in 1930 he went to Kaufbeuren as second deputy to the director, with the organization of welfare for mental patients across Swabia added to his duties.

He joined the Nazi Party in 1922, in the movement's Munich years, more than a decade before it came to power. He joined the party again in 1933 and entered the SA, the party's brownshirt organization, the same year. In 1936 he took charge of the department of hereditary and racial care at the public health office in Augsburg, where he shared responsibility for forced sterilization, which the hereditary health courts ordered on the strength of medical reports.

Director of Eglfing-Haar

In 1938 Pfannmüller became director of Eglfing-Haar. The institution had about 3,000 beds and a medical staff of 15. Under his predecessor it had already set out to become a "model institution" of hereditary and racial psychiatry: from 1934 onward at least 1,703 of its patients were sterilized. Under Pfannmüller the hospital's own history describes a further step. He carried the ideas of hereditary and racial hygiene to their end, it says, and regarded people who could not work as "ballast existences" whose removal would relieve the community. Under his direction Eglfing-Haar became a place where patients were killed.

He told the tribunal at Nuremberg that he had not applied for the post. Eglfing, about 15 kilometers from Munich, was by his description the largest asylum in Bavaria, with some 2,500 beds when he arrived and about 3,000 later, and an average of 2,700 to 2,800 patients of every age. A children's house already stood on the grounds, inherited from his predecessor.

He was close to retirement age by then. He also showed the asylum to outside visitors, leading groups through the wards in an effort to convince them that the patients were of lesser worth. No other center of the program offered tours of this kind.

The assessor

From November 1939 Pfannmüller was one of the outside assessors of the program later known as Aktion T4, judging the registration forms that the asylums of the Reich sent to Berlin. The work was done on top of his post as director. In the last weeks of 1940 he went through more than 2,000 forms filled in by colleagues in a period of four weeks, and his verdict on each decided the fate of the patient named on it. The hospital's history credits him with a part in the deaths of more than 4,000 patients through this work alone.

The forms left a paper trail. From November 19, 1940, letters went out of Eglfing-Haar over his name to the program's central office in Berlin, each returning a batch of assessed forms, and the series ran to the 158th shipment. The forms reached him at Haar, often as photostatic copies, and for each one he had to choose between the categories printed on it or mark the case as doubtful. He took finished forms to Berlin himself twice; the rest went back by registered mail. Under oath in 1947 he described working through a few hundred of them in a single morning and coming back to them later, and he insisted that he had never given an opinion on a form about a patient of his own asylum.

The transports

On January 18, 1940, a bus carrying 25 men left Eglfing-Haar for Grafeneck in Württemberg, where a killing center had just been set up. The men were killed there the same day. It was the first such transport anywhere in the German Reich. The name at the head of the list was that of Ludwig Alexander, a German Jewish patient. A copy of a list from that first transport later entered the record of the Nuremberg Medical Trial.

Nineteen more transports followed by June 20, 1941. From May 1940, beginning with the fourth transport, patients were also sent to Hartheim near Linz, in Upper Austria, most of them by rail, since the asylum had its own railway siding. From early 1940 to the end of June 1941 at least 2,018 patients were sent from Eglfing-Haar to the two centers and killed. The transports of 1940 took mainly Eglfing-Haar's own patients. From the autumn of 1940 they also took residents of the Upper Bavarian care institutions, most of them run by the churches, who had first been moved to Haar. The asylum became the hub for the deportation of mentally ill and disabled people from all of Upper Bavaria.

Eglfing-Haar was also made the collection point for Jewish patients from the Bavarian asylums, who were brought there from at least 20 institutions. On September 20, 1940, 191 Jewish children, adolescents, women and men were deported from Haar to Hartheim and killed. It was the first systematic mass murder of Jews before the deportations to the ghettos and the death camps began. On the same day Pfannmüller sent a letter to the health department of the Bavarian Ministry of the Interior under the subject line "Transfer of mentally diseased Jews." The letter became an exhibit at the Nuremberg Medical Trial.

The children's ward

The Reich Committee, set up in Berlin in 1939, chose the children who were sent to its "special wards." The ward at Eglfing-Haar opened in October 1940. It was the first in Bavaria and one of the first anywhere. It was attached to the asylum's children's house, which had been founded in 1913 for the observation and treatment of children with mental illness, and in 1943 it moved into House I, across the way. Pfannmüller had medical charge of it from the beginning. The ward physician who carried out the examinations and assessments of the committee children alongside him died by suicide in 1945, while American investigators were looking into his conduct.

On January 17, 1941, Pfannmüller wrote to the Reich Committee in Berlin about the compulsory registration of the newborn and disabled children in the asylum's children's house. In May 1941 the committee asked him for a medical report on a child who had been moved from Haar to another institution, and the reply from Eglfing-Haar set out the child's history. Both letters, with the asylum's annotated lists of the children reported to Berlin, later went before the American tribunal at Nuremberg.

The criminal proceedings in Munich concerned the killing of at least 120 of the committee children at Eglfing-Haar between 1940 and 1945. The hospital's own history, drawing on the director appointed after the war, gives a total of 337 children and adolescents who fell victim to the program in the ward by April 1945. In the last months of the war alone 131 children died there.

Patients outside the children's ward died as well. Between 1941 and 1945 the death rate among the patients rose from 5.8 percent to 19.3 percent. The hospital's research on the Munich patients alone identified 850 victims of killing on site, and it puts the likely toll across all of Eglfing-Haar at about 1,660. The proceedings that ended in his conviction concerned his assessments, the transfers to the killing centers and the deaths of the committee children.

After the surrender

The children's ward closed in May 1945. The psychiatrist whom the American authorities installed as the first postwar director of Eglfing-Haar set about uncovering what had happened in the asylum and wrote it down; his book on the institution, Selektion in der Heilanstalt, appeared in 1965. By the autumn of 1945 the Allies had handed the "euthanasia" cases to the German courts, which were then working short-handed after the temporary dismissal of thousands of officials who had served the regime.

The Bavarian authorities moved slowly. In 1947 the legal adviser to the American military tribunal found it necessary to remind the Bavarian Ministry of the Interior in Munich that the killings at Eglfing-Haar had still gone unpunished. Pfannmüller himself appeared as a witness at the Nuremberg Medical Trial, the American tribunal's case against the doctors and officials of the program, where his September 1940 letter on the transfer of the Jewish patients was entered as an exhibit.

Before the tribunal at Nuremberg

The Eglfing-Haar papers reached the courtroom first. On January 13, 1947, the prosecution read a long run of them into the record: orders from the Bavarian Ministry of the Interior addressed to the director to send away patients in groups of 120 and 140, the transport lists that followed through 1940 and the first half of 1941, his September 1940 letter on the transfer of the Jewish patients, his January 1941 letter to the Reich Committee on the registration of children, the replies the asylum sent to authorities who asked where a patient had gone, and the letters with which he returned the assessed forms to Berlin. The replies said the patient had been moved on ministry orders and that the receiving institution was unknown to Eglfing-Haar. Even an inquiry from a public prosecutor's office in Nuremberg about a former patient received an answer of that kind in January 1941.

Pfannmüller himself took the stand on May 9, 1947. He was called by the defense of Viktor Brack, one of the defendants, and he was sworn before the tribunal. On direct examination he described his career, the asylum and its children's house, and his work as an assessor. He said that the Reich Committee ward had been set up in the children's house after discussions with officials of the Bavarian ministry, that he had not been told of the directives behind it at the time, and that he did not know who made the final decisions on the children whose cases were assessed. He also said that, as he had understood it, Jewish patients and foreigners fell outside the program.

The prosecution cross-examined him on May 9 and again on May 12. It took him through the transfers of patients from his asylum, the Jewish patients among them, his role as an assessor and how he knew what his marks would be used for, and the handling of the children's cases at Haar, including the way each was authorized and reviewed from Berlin. He told the court that he had been under oath when the American prosecution staff interviewed him, but not when a German prosecutor questioned him. On redirect, Brack's defense returned to the transport lists, the list of the Jewish patients and the forms judged incomplete. The tribunal then excused him. He had come to Nuremberg as a witness, not as a defendant, and his own case remained with the German courts.

The first case to reach judgment in Munich concerned the children's ward. Three members of the ward's nursing staff, who had been paid extra for their part in the killings, were tried by the Landgericht München I in 1948. The proceedings concerned the killing of at least 120 committee children at Eglfing-Haar between 1940 and 1945, and each of the three was sentenced to two and a half years. The Oberlandesgericht München ruled on the case later the same year.

The first trial, 1949

Pfannmüller's own trial came before the jury court, the Schwurgericht, at the Landgericht München I in the autumn of 1949. The case against him covered his work as an assessor, the filling in of the registration forms, the transfer of patients to the killing centers at Hartheim near Linz and at Grafeneck, and the killing of the committee children in his asylum. The jury court was hearing witnesses by late October 1949.

The court convicted him in 1949 and sentenced him to six years. He appealed.

The appeal went to the Bayerisches Oberstes Landesgericht, the Bavarian Supreme Court, which decided it on March 15, 1950. The case went back to the jury court in Munich for a new hearing.

The verdict of March 15, 1951

The second trial ended on March 15, 1951. The jury court at the Landgericht München I convicted Pfannmüller of Totschlag and Beihilfe zum Totschlag, manslaughter and aiding and abetting manslaughter, and sentenced him to five years.

The court held, in substance, that the killing of the children had not been murder. The question on which the case turned was Heimtücke, treachery. American military courts had treated the killings in the asylums as treacherous. The Munich court did not. It reasoned that the children in the institutions had been no more defenseless than they already were, and so found no treachery in their killing. It also treated the ideological grounding of the program as a mitigating factor, on the ground that the idea of "euthanasia" had been put forward in earlier years by scientists who were taken seriously, still had prominent advocates at the time of the trial, and so could not be charged to the defendant alone.

The judgment dealt with his conduct at the Heil- und Pflegeanstalt Eglfing-Haar from September 1940 to April 1945: his assessments for the program, the transfer of patients to the killing centers near Linz and at Grafeneck, and the deaths of the committee children in his asylum.

The five-year term was the final sentence in the case. Pfannmüller lost neither his doctorate nor his license to practice medicine. He died in Munich on April 10, 1961.

Context: the T4 program and the Reich Committee

The two programs in which Pfannmüller worked were run from Berlin. The adult program took its later name, Aktion T4, from the address Tiergartenstraße 4, where its cover organizations had their offices from the spring of 1940, and its basis was a letter of authorization signed by Hitler and backdated to September 1, 1939. Every asylum had to fill in a registration form for patients with certain illnesses, and the most important entry on the form was the kind of work the patient could do. The forms went to outside assessors, who marked each one in a box at the lower left, a plus for death and a minus for life. It was this marking that Pfannmüller did from November 1939, and it formed part of the case against him in Munich.

The children's program ran through the "Reich Committee for the Scientific Registration of Serious Hereditary and Congenital Illnesses," founded in 1939. Midwives and doctors had to report newborns and young children with disabilities to the public health office, which passed the reports to the committee. When a child was classed as a committee case, the health office pressed the parents to place the child in a "special ward," telling them that the child would receive advanced treatment there. Thirty such wards were opened across the Reich, and the one at Eglfing-Haar, opened in October 1940, was the first in Bavaria.

Disputed and unproven points

The total number of children who died in the ward at Eglfing-Haar is larger than the figure on which the courts proceeded. The court cases concerned at least 120 committee children; the hospital's own history, based on its postwar director's work and later research, puts the number of children and adolescents who fell victim to the program there at 337. The court figure was a minimum fixed for a criminal proceeding, not a count of all the dead.

The number of adults who were killed inside the asylum, as distinct from those deported to the killing centers, is still being established. The hospital's research identified 850 victims among the Munich patients and estimates about 1,660 for the institution as a whole, while noting the difficulty of telling a deliberate killing from a natural death. It treats its own total of about 4,000 victims at Eglfing-Haar from 1939 to 1945 as provisional until research on the Upper Bavarian patients is complete.

The judgment of 1951 rested on the finding that the killings were not murder. That legal finding, and not any later historical judgment, fixed the offenses of which he was convicted.

Timeline

June 8, 1886: Born in Munich.

1911: Passes his state medical examinations at the University of Munich.

1919: Moves to the asylum at Ansbach as senior physician.

1922: Joins the Nazi Party.

1930: Becomes second deputy director at Kaufbeuren.

1933: Joins the party again and enters the SA.

1936: Heads the department of hereditary and racial care at the Augsburg public health office.

1938: Becomes director of the Heil- und Pflegeanstalt Eglfing-Haar.

November 1939: Begins work as an assessor in the T4 program.

January 18, 1940: The first transport of 25 men leaves Eglfing-Haar for Grafeneck.

September 20, 1940: 191 Jewish patients are deported from Haar to Hartheim; he writes to the Bavarian Ministry of the Interior on their transfer.

October 1940: The Reich Committee ward opens at Eglfing-Haar.

November 19, 1940: The first of his letters returning batches of assessed forms to the program's Berlin office.

January 17, 1941: Writes to the Reich Committee on the registration of children in the asylum's children's house.

June 20, 1941: The last of 20 transports to the killing centers leaves the asylum.

May 1945: The children's ward at Eglfing-Haar closes.

Autumn 1945: The Allies pass the "euthanasia" cases to the German courts.

January 13, 1947: The prosecution reads the Eglfing-Haar documents into the record of the Nuremberg Medical Trial.

May 9 and 12, 1947: Testifies at Nuremberg as a defense witness.

1948: Three nurses of the children's ward are each sentenced to two and a half years in Munich.

1949: The Munich jury court convicts him and sentences him to six years.

March 15, 1950: The Bavarian Supreme Court rules on his appeal.

March 15, 1951: The jury court at the Landgericht München I convicts him of manslaughter and aiding and abetting manslaughter and sentences him to five years.

April 10, 1961: Dies in Munich.