On April 17, 1972, a corrections officer named Brent Miller died inside the state penitentiary at Angola, Louisiana. Within months two inmates were charged with his murder: Herman Wallace and Albert Woodfox, both from New Orleans and both serving long sentences for armed robbery. Woodfox was convicted in 1973 and Wallace in 1974. Each received a life sentence, and each said, from the day he was accused until the day he died, that he had not done it.
The story that followed belongs more to the courts than to the day itself. Juries convicted Woodfox twice. Judges set his convictions aside three times, and higher courts restored or reversed those rulings in turn. Wallace's conviction stood for almost four decades before a federal judge in Baton Rouge vacated it on October 1, 2013; he was released that night and died three days later, by then indicted again. Woodfox was released on February 19, 2016, his sixty-ninth birthday, after pleading no contest to manslaughter and aggravated burglary, a plea that stands as a conviction but is not an admission of guilt. No physical evidence ever tied either man to the death. The case against them rested on what other inmates said they had seen, and the credibility of those inmates became the central question of every proceeding that came after.
Herman Wallace was born in New Orleans on October 13, 1941, and came to Angola serving a fifty-year term for armed robbery. Albert Woodfox first entered prison in 1965 for armed robbery, and by the spring of 1972 he too was serving a fifty-year sentence at Angola. After the officer's death the authorities quickly settled on a group of inmates, and on May 5, 1972, a West Feliciana Parish grand jury indicted four of them for murder. Two others were charged alongside Wallace and Woodfox: one pleaded guilty to manslaughter, and the other was tried and acquitted. From that spring onward Wallace and Woodfox were held in solitary confinement, with almost no break, for more than forty years.
Woodfox went to trial first, in 1973, and was convicted of murder on March 7; the Louisiana Supreme Court affirmed the verdict. Wallace was tried separately and convicted of murder in 1974. Both were sentenced to life.
Wallace's road to that verdict was longer. A state judge quashed his first indictment on May 7, 1973, and that September a new West Feliciana Parish grand jury indicted him again. A change of venue sent the case to the 19th Judicial District Court in East Baton Rouge Parish, where it was joined with the case of one of the co-defendants. Wallace moved to quash the second indictment as well, on the ground that women had been systematically kept off the grand jury. At the hearing in January 1974 the parish clerk of court, who sat on the jury commission, testified that the names had come from the list of male registered voters and that no woman had ever served on a jury in the parish, and the registrar of voters testified that about half the parish's registered voters were women. The trial court found no evidence of discrimination and denied the motion, and the trial got under way the next day. After it began, the co-defendant who had shared Wallace's lawyer announced that he would testify for the prosecution, and he later pleaded guilty to manslaughter. The jury returned its verdict on January 10, 1974, and Wallace was sentenced to life at hard labor without benefit of probation, parole or suspension of sentence.
The state's case at both trials came from inmates. Its principal eyewitness was a fellow prisoner who testified that he had seen the killing and named Woodfox among those responsible. A second inmate witness, who had serious problems with his eyesight, and a third inmate also placed Woodfox there.
What the jurors did not hear was that the principal eyewitness had been promised help. The warden of the time later testified that promises had been made to that witness, who went on to receive a pardon from the governor of Louisiana. The promise had not been disclosed to the defense in 1973. The witness died before Woodfox's second trial, and whether his testimony could ever be tested in front of a jury became the core of years of argument.
Woodfox's 1973 conviction stood for almost twenty years. In 1992 the 18th Judicial District Court of Louisiana vacated it, finding that he had been denied the effective assistance of counsel: his lawyer had failed to move to quash an indictment returned by an unconstitutionally impaneled grand jury. The order, dated May 27, 1992, found that Woodfox had filed a motion to quash on his own, that his hired lawyer had never pursued it, and that the same grand jury's indictments of his co-defendants had been quashed. The conviction, the court held, "was obtained on the basis of an unconstitutional indictment." In March 1993 a grand jury in West Feliciana Parish indicted him again for the murder, and five years passed before the case came to trial.
By 1998 most of the state's key witnesses were dead, among them the principal eyewitness and the inmate with poor sight, and their 1973 testimony was read aloud to the new jury. A former prosecutor testified about the principal eyewitness's demeanor a quarter century earlier, and the former warden testified about the promises made to him. Another inmate who had been in the unit at the time denied that he had ever identified Woodfox, and three inmates testified for the defense that Woodfox had been elsewhere.
The jury again found him guilty in December 1998, this time of second-degree murder, and in 1999 he was sentenced to life in prison without the benefit of parole, probation or suspension of sentence. The Louisiana First Circuit Court of Appeal affirmed in 2000. His claim that the parish had chosen grand jury forepersons by race was denied by the trial court, and in 2001 both the Louisiana Supreme Court and the United States Supreme Court declined to review the case. State post-conviction review ended in refusals by 2006.
Woodfox then turned to the United States District Court for the Middle District of Louisiana, which granted him a writ of habeas corpus on September 25, 2008. It found that his lawyers at the 1998 trial had failed him in several ways: they did not object, on Confrontation Clause grounds, to the reading of the principal eyewitness's 1973 testimony or to the former prosecutor's testimony vouching for that witness; they did not pursue the physical evidence; they did not present proof of the second witness's blindness; and they did not object to hearsay in a prior statement by the inmate who had pleaded guilty.
On June 21, 2010, a divided panel of the Fifth Circuit reversed. The majority held that federal habeas law required deference to the state courts and that none of the ineffective-assistance findings could stand. It found the confrontation claim unexhausted and procedurally barred, and held in the alternative that the state court's rejection of it was reasonable. It sent back only one question, the selection of the grand jury foreperson. One judge dissented and would have upheld relief on the confrontation ground.
Under the procedure applied in Woodfox's case, the judge chose the grand jury foreperson personally before the other members were drawn by lot, and the foreperson then voted like any other grand juror. On remand, on February 26, 2013, the district court granted habeas relief again on that issue. In West Feliciana Parish between 1980 and March 1993, African Americans made up about 44 percent of the population outside the prison and about 41 percent of the grand jurors who were not forepersons, yet only five of the twenty-seven forepersons. The court found the selection procedure Louisiana used before 1999 open to abuse through subjective criteria that could include race. The state answered that in a small rural parish the judges knew their neighbors well enough to choose qualified forepersons of any race; the court held that this amounted to "an affirmation of good faith," which the law treats as insufficient. It found that the state had failed to rebut the prima facie case of discrimination and that it had "altered the numbers to reduce the baseline of eligible African-Americans."
On November 20, 2014, the Fifth Circuit affirmed. It held that the state courts' ruling was not entitled to deference, that the disparities established a prima facie case of discrimination, and that the state had not overcome it. For the judge who made nineteen of the selections in the period studied, choosing an African American only once, the court found "almost no evidence" of race-neutral criteria. The United States Supreme Court declined to hear the state's appeal on October 5, 2015.
The state moved to try Woodfox a third time. A grand jury indicted him again on February 12, 2015, one day after the Fifth Circuit issued its mandate, and he was transferred from Angola to the parish jail in St. Francisville to await trial. On June 8, 2015, the district court issued an unconditional writ of habeas corpus, ordering him released and barring any retrial. It accepted that the grand jury violation could, in principle, be cured by a new indictment, but it held that exceptional circumstances would make a third trial unjust: his age and health, the deaths of key prosecution witnesses whose credibility had come into question after 1973, its lack of confidence in the state's ability to give him a fair third trial, more than forty years in solitary confinement, and the prospect of trying him a third time for a death more than four decades old. This was not, the court added, a case in which the evidence of guilt was "overwhelming." The third indictment itself, it stressed, was not before it. The Fifth Circuit stayed that order four days later, holding that barring retrial was a remedy reserved for "the most extraordinary of circumstances," and on November 9, 2015, a divided panel reversed it: the grand jury violation, the majority held, could be cured by a new indictment and trial. It took the district court's reasons one by one. Age and health, it held, were irrelevant to a habeas remedy. The effect of the lost witnesses and the strength of the evidence, including any claim of actual innocence, were for the state courts to weigh first, at a retrial. The state's conduct did not resemble the defiance of court mandates that had justified such writs in other cases, and the conditions of his confinement belonged in a civil rights action, not a habeas case. Absent a constitutional violation that no new trial could cure, the majority concluded, a state may try a defendant again. The dissenting judge would have left the writ in place.
Woodfox never faced that third jury. On February 19, 2016, in St. Francisville, he pleaded no contest to manslaughter and to aggravated burglary, the second count an unrelated charge. He was sentenced to forty-two years with credit for time served; he had already served longer than that, and he walked out of the parish jail the same day. Under the terms, according to the state attorney general's office, he waived his right to appeal the sentence. In a statement he said he had hoped to prove his innocence at a new trial, but that "concerns about my health and my age have caused me to resolve this case now." The plea stands as a conviction and was never set aside. Albert Woodfox died on August 4, 2022, at seventy-five, and no jury ever heard the case a third time.
Wallace's conviction stood far longer. He did not appeal at first; the state courts granted him an out-of-time appeal in 1991, the Louisiana First Circuit Court of Appeal affirmed the conviction in 1992, and the Louisiana Supreme Court denied review in April 1993. In later post-conviction proceedings he argued that the state had hidden its promise of help toward a pardon for the principal eyewitness. The appellate court sent that claim back for a hearing, but the trial court denied relief in 2007, and the Louisiana Supreme Court refused review in October 2009.
He then brought his own habeas petition in the Middle District of Louisiana, on the ground that the grand jury that indicted him had systematically excluded women. In September 2013 a magistrate judge recommended that the petition be denied, reasoning that when the conviction became final the United States Supreme Court had not explicitly declared the exemption of women from grand jury pools unconstitutional. On October 1, 2013, the chief judge of the district court granted it, holding that the exclusion of women from the grand jury that returned his indictment violated the Fourteenth Amendment. Supreme Court precedent existing when the conviction became final, the court held, "undoubtedly compelled the conclusion" that Louisiana's exemption of women from grand jury service violated equal protection; his evidence had "clearly and convincingly established" the underrepresentation of women, and the state had neither rebutted it nor tried to defend the exemption. The court quashed the September 1973 indictment, vacated the verdict, the sentence and the judgment of January 10, 1974, and ordered the state to release him from custody immediately, and he left the prison that evening at seventy-one.
The state answered at once. On October 3, 2013, a grand jury in West Feliciana Parish indicted him again for the murder. Herman Wallace died in New Orleans on October 4, 2013, and the new indictment died with him. The state had appealed the federal ruling. On May 22, 2014, in line with the Fifth Circuit's mandate and its rule for a habeas petitioner who dies while the state's appeal is pending, the district court vacated its judgment and dismissed the case as moot.
Neither man ever admitted any part in the death. Woodfox's 2016 plea was a plea of no contest, entered, he said, because of his health and his age; it carries the weight of a conviction for manslaughter but not an admission. Wallace died before the state could try him on the 2013 indictment, and in 2014 the federal judgment that had vacated his conviction was itself vacated when his case was dismissed as moot.
The evidence that convicted them has been contested for decades. No physical evidence linked either man to the death. The state's principal eyewitness was a fellow inmate who had been promised help toward a pardon, a promise not disclosed to the defense when he testified, and who was later pardoned. A second inmate witness was nearly blind. In 2015 the district court found that not one piece of physical evidence had incriminated Woodfox; the Fifth Circuit majority answered that he had been convicted twice and that both convictions had been upheld on appeal. Federal judges split over what those facts meant: the district court found in 2008 that Woodfox's lawyers had failed him at the 1998 trial in several ways, while a Fifth Circuit majority held that the state courts' contrary view deserved deference. The courts that vacated the convictions did so on the composition of the grand juries, not on any finding about who caused the death.
Both men maintained throughout that they had been singled out for their political activity inside the prison, not because of any evidence.
1965: Albert Woodfox enters prison for armed robbery.
April 17, 1972: A corrections officer dies on duty at Angola; Wallace and Woodfox are accused.
May 5, 1972: A West Feliciana Parish grand jury indicts Wallace, Woodfox and two other inmates for murder.
March 7, 1973: Woodfox is convicted of murder and sentenced to life.
May 7, 1973: Wallace's first indictment is quashed; he is indicted again that September.
January 10, 1974: Wallace is convicted of murder in East Baton Rouge Parish and sentenced to life.
May 27, 1992: The 18th Judicial District Court vacates Woodfox's 1973 conviction for ineffective assistance of counsel.
March 1993: A West Feliciana Parish grand jury indicts Woodfox again.
1991 to 1993: Wallace is granted an out-of-time appeal; his conviction is affirmed, and the Louisiana Supreme Court denies review.
December 1998: Woodfox is convicted of second-degree murder; sentenced to life in 1999.
2000 to 2001: The Louisiana First Circuit affirms; the Louisiana Supreme Court and the United States Supreme Court decline review.
September 25, 2008: The federal district court grants Woodfox habeas relief on ineffective-assistance grounds.
June 21, 2010: The Fifth Circuit reverses and remands the grand jury foreperson claim.
October 2009: The Louisiana Supreme Court refuses review of Wallace's post-conviction claim about the eyewitness's pardon.
February 26, 2013: The district court grants Woodfox relief on grand jury foreperson discrimination.
October 1, 2013: A federal judge vacates Wallace's conviction; he is released that evening.
October 3, 2013: A West Feliciana Parish grand jury indicts Wallace again.
October 4, 2013: Herman Wallace dies in New Orleans.
May 22, 2014: The district court vacates its judgment for Wallace and dismisses his case as moot.
November 20, 2014: The Fifth Circuit affirms relief for Woodfox.
February 12, 2015: Woodfox is indicted a third time and moved to the parish jail.
June 8, 2015: The district court issues an unconditional writ barring retrial; the Fifth Circuit stays it on June 12.
October 5, 2015: The United States Supreme Court declines the state's appeal of the 2014 ruling.
November 9, 2015: The Fifth Circuit reverses the unconditional writ.
February 19, 2016: Woodfox pleads no contest to manslaughter and aggravated burglary and is released.
August 4, 2022: Albert Woodfox dies at seventy-five.