On May 21, 1971, two New York City police officers, Waverly Jones and Joseph Piagentini, were killed in Harlem. Herman Bell, a former member of the Black Panther Party who had joined the underground Black Liberation Army, was one of three men a New York jury convicted of those murders four years later. He was sentenced to 25 years to life on each count and spent close to 45 years in custody. In March 2018, at his eighth appearance before the New York State Board of Parole, a panel voted two to one to release him, and on April 27, 2018, after a court challenge to the grant had failed, he left a state prison at the age of 70.
The officers died together. Their deaths opened a prosecution that took four years to reach a verdict and a parole fight that ran on for decades after it.
The killings were the work of three men. Bell and his two co-defendants belonged to the Black Liberation Army, a militant offshoot of the Black Panther Party. The jury that heard the case would find all three guilty of both deaths.
Bell was not taken into custody in New York in the months after the killings. More than two years passed. He was arrested in New Orleans in September 1973 and brought back to New York to face trial.
The three men were tried together in New York State Supreme Court, and in 1975 a jury convicted them. Bell was found guilty of two counts of murder in the first degree, one for each officer.
On May 12, 1975, the trial judge sentenced him to 25 years to life for each conviction. The two terms were to run concurrently with each other but consecutively to any sentence imposed by another court. Each co-defendant was given the same term of 25 years to life.
The consecutive order had a practical meaning. Bell had also been convicted in California on federal bank robbery charges and given a 25-year federal sentence, and after his New York trial he served about five years in federal custody. Only in 1979 did he pass into the New York state system to begin serving the murder sentences. The sentencing minutes that set out that order would be read again, more than 40 years later, when the state decided whether to let him go.
Bell spent the next four decades in New York's state prisons. He earned a bachelor's degree and a master's degree while serving his sentence, and he counseled and mentored younger men serving time alongside him. He took part in educational programs and helped organize a community gardening project and outreach to homeless young people from inside.
His minimum term ran out in the early 2000s, and he first became eligible for parole in 2004. From 2008 he appeared before the board roughly every two years. Each time, until 2018, the board refused him. In February 2014, more than 40 years after the deaths in Harlem, it turned him down once more. By the time of his eighth hearing he had been denied seven times.
A second case reached him while he was serving that sentence. In 2007 California charged him, with other former Black Panthers, in the August 1971 death of a San Francisco police sergeant, and he was brought from New York to San Francisco to answer the charge. In 2009, in San Francisco, he pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter in the death of Sergeant John Young and received a sentence of probation, and he then returned to New York to go on serving the murder sentences.
Bell appeared before a three-member panel of the New York State Board of Parole in early March 2018. On March 13, 2018, by a vote of two to one, the board decided "to conditionally release Herman Bell to parole supervision," setting an earliest release date of April 17, 2018. The decision became public the next day. In granting release the panel found a "reasonable probability that if released, you will remain at liberty without violating the law," the first part of the test that New York law sets for parole.
The board met again on March 21, 2018. It considered the 1975 sentencing minutes, with their order that the New York terms run consecutively to the California sentence, kept its earlier decision, and reaffirmed the grant by the same two-to-one vote.
A petition was then filed in State Supreme Court in Albany County, an Article 78 proceeding asking the court to annul the board's decision. A temporary restraining order kept Bell in custody past his April 17 release date while the court considered the case.
On April 20, 2018, the court dismissed the petition. It held that the petitioner lacked standing, because an emotional stake in the outcome was not an "injury in fact" recognized in law, and it found in the alternative that the board's decision had not been irrational or bordering on impropriety. It did not decide whether Bell himself was a necessary party. The court lifted the restraining order and stayed its own ruling until April 27, 2018, to leave time for an appeal.
An appeal followed at once. In the week of the new release date a single justice of the Appellate Division denied a request for a further restraining order, and state corrections officials said they would abide by that ruling. On Friday, April 27, 2018, Bell was released from a New York state prison, nearly 45 years after his arrest in New Orleans and almost 47 years after the deaths in Harlem. He was placed under the supervision of the state's Department of Corrections and Community Supervision for the rest of his life.
The appeal from the dismissal went on after his release. On August 22, 2019, the Appellate Division, Third Department, affirmed, holding that "crime victims do not have standing to challenge parole determinations." The panel's opinion drew one concurrence and one dissent.
One co-defendant died in a New York prison in 2000, still serving his sentence. The other, who in 2009 entered a plea of no contest to voluntary manslaughter in the same San Francisco case, was released on parole in October 2020.
Herman Bell has lived in the New York City region since his release in April 2018 and remains under lifetime parole supervision.
The New York convictions stand. What remained in dispute after the verdict was whether, and when, Bell should be released. The 2018 grant was decided by a split vote, with one commissioner voting against release at both the March 13 and the March 21 meetings, and the board's power to grant it was challenged in court. The Third Department's 2019 ruling on standing was itself divided, with a concurrence and a dissent. The San Francisco case was resolved by plea rather than trial, so the facts of the 1971 death there were never tested before a jury.
May 21, 1971: Two New York City police officers are killed in Harlem.
August 1971: A San Francisco police sergeant is killed in San Francisco.
September 1973: Bell is arrested in New Orleans.
1975: A jury convicts Bell and two co-defendants; Bell is found guilty of two counts of murder in the first degree.
May 12, 1975: Bell is sentenced to 25 years to life on each count.
1979: Bell passes from federal custody into the New York system.
2000: One co-defendant dies in a New York prison.
2004: Bell becomes eligible for parole.
2007: California charges Bell in the 1971 San Francisco case.
2009: Bell pleads guilty in San Francisco to voluntary manslaughter and receives probation.
February 2014: The parole board again denies release.
March 13, 2018: At his eighth hearing the board votes two to one to grant parole.
March 21, 2018: The board reaffirms its decision.
April 20, 2018: State Supreme Court in Albany County dismisses a challenge to the grant.
April 27, 2018: Bell is released on parole at 70.
August 22, 2019: The Appellate Division, Third Department, affirms the dismissal.
October 2020: The other co-defendant is released on parole.