Herbert Rowse Armstrong

Victims
1 murder: his wife, Katharine Armstrong, who died February 1921 (jury verdict, Hereford, April 13, 1922).
Years active
February 1921
Location
Cusop, near Hay-on-Wye, Herefordshire, England (killing and residence); Hay-on-Wye, Powys, Wales (arrest); Hereford, Herefordshire, England (trial).
Method
Poisoning (the Crown's case, accepted by the jury; contested by later writers).
Status
Sentenced to death, April 13, 1922; appeal dismissed; the Attorney General refused leave to appeal to the House of Lords. Executed at Gloucester, England, May 31, 1922.

Herbert Rowse Armstrong practiced law in Hay-on-Wye, the market town on the border between England and Wales, and for years he was one of its settled public men: a solicitor with his own firm, a clerk in the local magistrates' court, a churchwarden, a freemason and a former Territorial Army officer known to the town as Major Armstrong. In February 1921 his wife, Katharine Armstrong, died. Her death raised no suspicion at the time. On the last day of that year Armstrong was arrested, and in April 1922 a jury at the Shire Hall in Hereford found him guilty of her murder. He was executed at Gloucester on May 31, 1922, at the age of 53.

No other solicitor in British history has been executed for murder. That distinction alone would have kept the case alive, but there is a second reason it has never settled. The Crown's case was circumstantial from beginning to end, and writers who have gone back through the trial have questioned how it was run: in their reading the judge leaned toward the prosecution, and the man who led that prosecution was also the official who decided that Armstrong could not take his case to the House of Lords. A century on, those writers still divide over whether he did it, and several argue that the Crown never proved that he did.

Armstrong came to the law by an ordinary road. He took a third-class degree at Cambridge and trained as a solicitor with the firm of Alsop, Stevens and Crooks before settling in Hay, where he founded the practice that bore his name. The firm outlived him and still exists.

In a small town a solicitor stood close to the center of things, and Armstrong did. His work as a clerk in the magistrates' court kept him beside the bench that dealt with local cases. He served as churchwarden and belonged to the freemasons. He had been an army officer and a Territorial, and by the time of his arrest he was a retired major. He and his wife had children, and the family lived at Cusop, just outside Hay on the English side of the border.

She was the solicitor's wife and the mother of his children, and when she died in February 1921 the family doctor treated her death as a natural one. For most of that year nothing suggested otherwise.

The case did not begin with her at all. It began with a quarrel between two lawyers. A newcomer had opened a solicitor's practice opposite Armstrong's firm, and by 1921 the two men were acting for opposing sides in a dispute over land: Armstrong for the landowners, his rival for the tenant farmers who stood against them. The two men met over tea, and afterward the rival solicitor fell ill. His family accused Armstrong of trying to kill him, and that accusation is what led investigators back to the death of Armstrong's wife.

On December 31, 1921, Armstrong was arrested at his office in Hay on suspicion of the attempted murder of his rival. The inquiry then turned to his wife's death, and on January 19, 1922, he was charged with her murder. He answered that he was absolutely innocent, and he never moved from that position. The matter of the rival solicitor was not dropped. It went onto the indictment as a second charge, of attempted murder, to stand if the murder charge failed. It was never tried.

The case went first to a committal hearing and then to a full trial, and it drew attention far beyond the border country. The Attorney General led the prosecution himself. Between the committal and the trial the defense lost ground: a woman who had given evidence on Armstrong's side at the committal changed her account before the full trial.

The trial opened at the Shire Hall in Hereford in April 1922, ran for about ten days and drew press interest from around the world. The Crown had no direct evidence that Armstrong had harmed his wife. Its case was circumstantial, resting on expert medical evidence and on what investigators had found in his possession. Armstrong gave evidence in his own defense and denied any part in her death.

On April 13, 1922, after less than half an hour out, the jury found him guilty of murder, and the judge sentenced him to death. Armstrong appealed, and the appeal was dismissed. His lawyers then tried to take the case to the House of Lords, the highest court of the day, and that attempt ended when the Attorney General, the same officer who had led the prosecution at Hereford, refused leave. Herbert Rowse Armstrong was executed at Gloucester on May 31, 1922. He had maintained his innocence throughout.

Armstrong's guilt has been argued over since the year he died. The fullest modern study is by the writer Stephen Bates, whose book on the case appeared in 2022, a century after the trial. Bates calls the trial a seriously flawed process and describes the judge as, in effect, the fourth lawyer on the prosecution side. He also points to the defense witness whose account changed between the committal and the trial. The critic Keith Miller, reviewing the book in April 2022, read Bates as concluding that Armstrong was probably guilty but that the Crown failed to prove its case. Miller himself called the expert testimony speculative and misleading, and concluded that the only fair position is that the jury is still out, or ought to be.

James Morton, a writer and former criminal defense solicitor, has questioned the conduct of the trial on several grounds: the judge's long questioning of the defendant, the run of rulings in the Crown's favor, the treatment of the pathologist's evidence and the thinness of the evidence of motive. He also notes that other explanations for the death were raised and never excluded by direct evidence. Martin Beales, a solicitor who later bought the Armstrongs' former house at Cusop, championed Armstrong's cause. The solicitor David Pickup, reviewing the Bates book in 2022, called the question of a wrongful conviction debatable and suggested that the trial was weighted against Armstrong, perhaps because an earlier trial had gone badly for the prosecution. Miller makes the same link: about a year before, another Welsh solicitor had been tried for the murder of his wife and acquitted.

The alleged attempt on the rival solicitor was never tested before a jury on its own charge, and it remains an accusation, not a finding. Against all of this stands the verdict itself: a jury that heard some ten days of evidence and the defendant's own testimony returned a guilty verdict in under half an hour, and the appeal court let it stand.

Timeline

1921, February: Armstrong's wife dies; her death is treated as natural.

1921: Armstrong and a rival Hay solicitor, on opposite sides of a land dispute, meet over tea; the rival's family later accuses Armstrong of an attempt on his life.

1921, December 31: Armstrong is arrested at Hay-on-Wye on suspicion of the attempted murder of the rival solicitor.

1922, January 19: Armstrong is charged with the murder of his wife.

1922, April: The trial opens at the Shire Hall, Hereford, and runs about ten days.

1922, April 13: The jury finds him guilty of murder after less than half an hour; he is sentenced to death.

1922: His appeal is dismissed; the Attorney General refuses leave to take the case to the House of Lords.

1922, May 31: Armstrong is executed at Gloucester, aged 53.