Herbert Kappler ran the German Security Police and Security Service in Rome during the nine months of German occupation, and on March 24, 1944, he organized the killing of 335 men and boys in reprisal for a partisan attack the day before. The Rome courts found that he had asked to be given the task. In September 1943 he had also forced the Jewish community of Rome to hand over fifty kilograms of gold under threat of deportation.
An Italian military tribunal judged him on July 20, 1948. It sentenced him to life imprisonment for continuing homicide and to fifteen years for the extortion, and acquitted the five subordinates tried with him on the ground that they had obeyed orders. The courts that reviewed the verdict confirmed his responsibility only for fifteen of the dead, the killings the tribunal attributed to his own initiative. He served his sentence in a military prison at Gaeta and later in a military hospital in Rome, 29 years and one month in detention in all.
Kappler was born in Stuttgart on September 23, 1907. He studied mathematics at the Technical University of Stuttgart and worked as an electrical engineer. He joined the Nazi Party on August 1, 1931, and the SS on December 1, 1932, and from 1934 he led a branch office of the SD, the SS intelligence service, in Tübingen. In 1937 he completed the training course of the Security Police. He was commissioned an SS-Untersturmführer on November 9, 1938, and finished the war as an SS-Obersturmbannführer, the equivalent of a lieutenant colonel.
In March 1939 he was posted to Rome as police attaché at the German embassy, and he would spend the rest of the war there.
Italy's armistice with the Allies was announced on September 8, 1943, and German forces took control of Rome. That same month Kappler set up and took command of the Außenkommando, the field detachment of the Security Police and SD in the city, which was operating by early October.
On September 26, 1943, he summoned the presidents of the Union of Italian Jewish Communities and of the Jewish Community of Rome and demanded fifty kilograms of gold, threatening that two hundred Jews would otherwise be seized and deported to Germany. That demand became the second charge against him. The Rome tribunal convicted him of extortion against the Jewish community and imposed fifteen years.
On March 23, 1944, seventeen members of the Patriotic Action Groups, communist partisan units, attacked a column of the 11th Company of the Bozen Police Regiment in central Rome. Thirty-three of the policemen were dead by the next day.
The response was settled that evening. Kappler and the German military commander of Rome recommended that ten Italians be killed for every policeman who had died, and the army commander and Field Marshal Albert Kesselring approved the measure as proposed. The Rome courts later found that Kappler was told on March 24 that the order came from Hitler, and that he had asked to be put in charge of everything connected with the attack and had been told yes.
On March 24, 1944, 335 men and boys were killed in Rome. None of them had taken part in the attack. Among them were 75 Jews, prisoners of the German Security Police, political prisoners brought from Italian prisons and men arrested in the streets.
The ratio called for 330 victims, and the five killed beyond that number became the most contested point of the later trials. The 1948 tribunal accepted that they had been included by mistake, through the "straordinaria negligenza," the extraordinary negligence, of two captains under Kappler's command, and that Kappler learned of the error only on March 25. Fifty years later the Rome military appeal court rejected that account. It found that the officer who kept the lists told Kappler that five men too many were present, and that Kappler ordered that they be killed as well.
The Allies entered Rome in June 1944. That summer Kappler was transferred north to Maderno on Lake Garda as liaison officer to the police of Mussolini's Italian Social Republic. British forces captured him at Bolzano on May 9, 1945. By December 1946 the British command in the Mediterranean counted him among the prisoners it was holding for the Italians, ready to hand him over as soon as Italy applied with the evidence needed to bring him to trial. The transfer came in July 1947, and the five men later tried beside him came with him.
The case was heard by the Tribunale Militare Territoriale di Roma, the territorial military tribunal of Rome. Kappler stood trial with five men from his command: a major, a captain, two senior warrant officers and a sergeant major. He was charged under article 185 of the wartime military penal code for the reprisal and with extortion against the Jewish community for the gold. At trial he said that he regarded the order he had received as entirely lawful, and that on more than one occasion, when he had judged an order illegal, he had not carried it out.
The tribunal rejected every legal shelter the defense offered for the killings themselves. It held that they could not stand as a lawful reprisal, because nothing in them answered to any proportion between the offense and the response. Nor could they pass as collective repression under article 50 of the regulations annexed to the 1907 Hague Convention: the search for the men behind the attack had been marginal and had come after the reprisal was already in preparation, and the occupying power had never issued any rule setting out when a population could be held collectively responsible. The killing of the hostages therefore fell under article 185, which punished violence or homicide committed without necessity or justified cause against enemy civilians taking no part in military operations. On superior orders the tribunal held, under German penal law and article 40 of the Italian peacetime military penal code, that a superior's command did not excuse a crime unless the man who carried it out believed he was obeying a lawful order.
The tribunal gave judgment on July 20, 1948. Its operative ruling declared Kappler responsible for the offense charged, "omicidio continuato," continuing homicide. Its reasoning was narrower. As to the 320 men killed under the ratio that his superiors had ordered, it held that "non può affermarsi con sicurezza che il Kappler abbia avuto coscienza e volontà di obbedire ad un ordine illegittimo," that it could not be affirmed with certainty that Kappler was aware of, and willed, obedience to an unlawful order. His liability rested on fifteen deaths: the ten he ordered on his own initiative, without any order from above, after a thirty-third policeman died, all of them Jews; and the five beyond the 330, whose deaths the tribunal traced to his own failure to give adequate instructions. It refused him the general mitigating circumstances and found aggravating circumstances in his conduct. The tribunal also found that the cruelty of the killings was objective evidence of awareness of their illegality.
It sentenced him to life imprisonment, "ergastolo," for the homicide and to fifteen years for the extortion. It acquitted the five subordinates, holding that despite the criminal character of the order they could not be shown to have known that they were carrying out an unlawful one. They belonged, it reasoned, to an organization of the strictest discipline that bred a habit of prompt obedience, and they had not known all that their commander knew of the situation.
Kappler appealed to the Tribunale Supremo Militare, the supreme military tribunal. On October 25, 1952, it rejected the appeal. It noted the contradiction between the 1948 operative ruling, which convicted him of continuing homicide, and the reasoning, which doubted his awareness of the illegality of the order, but held that the ruling was supported by adequate reasoning and declined to annul it. It confirmed "la penale responsabilità del Kappler limitatamente all'uccisione di quindici delle vittime," his criminal responsibility limited to the killing of fifteen of the victims. It went further than the first court on the reprisal itself, holding it unlawful as to every one of the victims and not only as to the fifteen. It excluded premeditation in his case and upheld the aggravating circumstance of cruelty for the killings as a whole.
The case went on to the Court of Cassation, which rejected the appeal on December 19, 1953. Kappler had withdrawn it shortly before. The life sentence was final.
Kappler served his sentence in the military prison at Gaeta. By 1953 he and one other German officer were the only men convicted of war crimes by Italian military courts who were still serving life; the few others had soon benefited from remissions that brought early release. From the early 1950s his pardon was pressed through diplomatic channels and came up again and again in talks between the foreign ministers of the countries concerned. Italy's Foreign Ministry argued for clemency, but each request stopped at the contrary opinion of the Minister of Defense, both in 1955 and under a later minister. In February 1960 a Rome court dismissed his petition for amnesty. It found that his crimes were not political offenses of the kind for which amnesties had been granted, but "common crimes committed against Italian citizens."
He later applied for conditional release, a decision that the law at the time gave to the Minister of Defense. On July 24, 1974, the military supervisory judge at the Supreme Military Tribunal, finding that the papers did not plainly lack the conditions for release, referred that rule to the Constitutional Court in his case and in that of the other officer serving life at Gaeta. On July 14, 1976, the Constitutional Court ruled that the decision must belong "ad un organo giurisdizionale di adeguato livello," to a court of appropriate rank, and not to a minister.
He was seriously ill by the mid-1970s. As his twenty-eighth year in prison came to an end, the military prosecutor general at the Supreme Military Tribunal completed a favorable inquiry toward a pardon that would commute his sentence and free him. No pardon came. Instead, on March 13, 1976, the execution of his sentence was suspended, and that year he was moved from Gaeta to the Celio military hospital in Rome. On November 13, 1976, the Rome military tribunal ordered his release under five years of supervised liberty, finding that he had served more than the twenty-eight years required before conditional release could be considered, that his conduct in prison had been good and that he was seriously ill. The military prosecutor appealed. On December 9, 1976, the Supreme Military Tribunal set the release order aside, and he was held at the Celio once more.
On August 15, 1977, he escaped from the Celio to West Germany. He died at Soltau, West Germany, on February 9, 1978.
The reach of his conviction is the main point of dispute. The 1948 operative ruling declared him responsible for continuing homicide in a reprisal that killed 335 people, while its reasoning attached his guilt only to fifteen of them; the 1952 supreme military tribunal confirmed the conviction on that limited basis. The 1998 appeal court, in a judgment on other defendants, called the 1948 reasoning on his awareness fallacious and held that the doubts were unfounded, but it did not reopen his conviction, which had been final since 1953. In law, he stands convicted for fifteen of the deaths.
The five killed beyond the ratio are explained differently by the two sets of courts. The 1948 tribunal accepted that they were included by mistake and that Kappler learned of them the next day; the 1998 appeal court found that he was told of them before they died and ordered that they be killed.
September 23, 1907: Born in Stuttgart.
August 1, 1931: Joins the Nazi Party; joins the SS on December 1, 1932.
March 1939: Posted to Rome as police attaché at the German embassy.
September 1943: Takes command of the Security Police and SD detachment in occupied Rome.
September 26, 1943: Demands fifty kilograms of gold from the Jewish community of Rome under threat of deportation.
March 23, 1944: Partisan attack on a German police column in Rome; 33 policemen dead by the next day.
March 24, 1944: 335 men and boys are killed in Rome in the reprisal he organizes.
May 9, 1945: Captured by British forces at Bolzano.
July 1947: Handed by the British to the Italian government.
July 20, 1948: The Rome territorial military tribunal sentences him to life imprisonment and fifteen years; his five subordinates are acquitted.
October 25, 1952: The supreme military tribunal rejects his appeal, confirming responsibility for fifteen of the deaths.
December 19, 1953: The Court of Cassation rejects the appeal, which he had withdrawn; the sentence is final.
February 1960: A Rome court dismisses his amnesty petition.
July 24, 1974: The military supervisory judge refers the rule on conditional release to the Constitutional Court.
March 13, 1976: The execution of his sentence is suspended.
July 14, 1976: The Constitutional Court rules that conditional release for military convicts must be decided by a court.
November 13, 1976: The Rome military tribunal orders his release under supervised liberty.
December 9, 1976: The Supreme Military Tribunal sets the release order aside on the prosecutor's appeal.
August 15, 1977: Escapes from the Celio military hospital in Rome to West Germany.
February 9, 1978: Dies at Soltau, West Germany.