In May 1863 the miners of Bannack, a gold camp on Grasshopper Creek in what was then Idaho Territory, elected a man from Maine as their sheriff. Henry Plummer was a Democrat who said in public that he opposed vigilante rule. Behind him lay a murder conviction in California and a governor's pardon. Eight months after the election, on January 10, 1864, the same camp's vigilantes seized him and executed him without a trial.
Plummer's legal record is narrower than his legend. One court convicted him of one crime: a death at Nevada City, California, in September 1857, for which a jury found him "guilty of murder in the second degree" and a judge sentenced him to ten years. None of the later deaths ever produced a conviction, and for the last of them, at Bannack in January 1863, a miners' jury "honorably acquitted" him. The charge that brought the vigilantes to his door, that the sheriff secretly led the road agents preying on the trails of the new gold country, was never put to any court.
Plummer was born in 1832 in Addison, in Washington County on the coast of Maine. He signed his name Plumer, with one m, in surviving documents; the two-m spelling came later and stuck.
He left Maine for the California gold fields early in the 1850s. After about a year in San Francisco he moved inland to Nevada City, a mining town in the Sierra Nevada foothills, where he bought a mine and a ranch. In May 1856 he was elected town marshal of Nevada City by a narrow margin. He won a second term easily in 1857 and was rising in local Democratic politics; that year he also ran for the state assembly and lost.
John Vedder died in Nevada City in September 1857, and Plummer, still the town marshal, was the man responsible. The death grew out of a domestic dispute in which the marshal had become involved. Plummer said he acted in self-defense. It took two trials to settle the case. At the end of the second, in 1859, the jury rejected his account and found him "guilty of murder in the second degree," and the judge sentenced him to ten years in the state prison of California.
Plummer did not serve long. The governor of California pardoned him soon after and did not rest the pardon on any doubt about the verdict. The ground he gave was "imminent dangers of death from Consumption." The pardon released Plummer from prison but left the conviction standing. It is the only verdict of guilty any court ever returned against him.
He went back to Nevada City, and there he was involved in another death. According to published histories of the case, William Riley, a man who had broken out of custody, died in a confrontation that began when Plummer tried to take him in. Plummer gave himself up and was held in the town jail. The accounts differ on what followed: one has the town's police accepting that he had acted in self-defense and letting him leave the jail, the other has him breaking out. On either version he never stood trial for the death, and late in 1861 he left California for good.
He went north to Washington Territory, which then took in the country that later became Idaho and Montana. At the mining camp of Oro Fino, the same magazine accounts say, Patrick Ford died after a quarrel with Plummer's party. Plummer said he acted in self-defense. No court heard the matter. The dead man's friends gathered to punish Plummer themselves, and he left the region ahead of them.
In 1862 he was at Fort Benton on the upper Missouri. He thought of going back to Maine but joined instead a party guarding a government post at Sun River.
Gold was found on Grasshopper Creek on July 28, 1862. It was the first major strike in what became Montana, and by 1863 the camp of Bannack held more than 3,000 people. Plummer arrived in the winter of 1862.
On January 14, 1863, Jack Cleveland, a man who had known Plummer in California and had followed him north, died at Bannack in a confrontation with him. By the account that prevailed, the dead man had sought the fight. The miners convened a jury of their own, and it "honorably acquitted" Plummer. It was the only one of the deaths after California that any tribunal examined, and it ended in his favor.
On May 24, 1863, the miners of Bannack and the surrounding diggings elected Plummer sheriff. As sheriff he appointed deputies across the camps, and he is credited with building the first jail in what became Montana. He also applied to become a deputy territorial marshal; news of the appointment arrived after his death.
The summer and fall of 1863 brought a run of robberies and killings on the trails between Bannack and the newer camp at Alder Gulch, where Virginia City had grown up, most often between October and December. Leading men of Bannack came to suspect that their sheriff was connected to them, and some decided that he led the road agents himself. No charge to that effect was ever laid before a court.
On December 23, 1863, citizens of Virginia City and Bannack organized a Vigilance Committee and swore in its members. In place of arrests, trials and sentences, the committee acted on its own authority, and in the winter of 1863 to 1864 its members put to death more than twenty men in and around Bannack and Virginia City. The committee said its case against Plummer rested on his California past, the company he kept and statements by men who claimed to have been his partners. None of it was tested before a judge or jury, and Plummer was given no chance to answer it.
On January 10, 1864, a party of vigilantes seized Plummer at Bannack and executed him that same day, together with two of his deputies. There was no trial.
Whether Plummer led the road agents has never been settled: a Virginia City newspaper series of 1865, the first published history of the vigilantes, made him the master of a criminal band and traditionalist historians still defend that view, while historians writing since 1987, including academic work at the University of Montana, have found no evidence that such a band existed, and a mock trial staged at Virginia City in 1993 as a school history exercise ended with its jurors split six to six.
The Nevada City conviction is disputed as well. Plummer maintained that he had acted in self-defense while protecting the victim's wife, and the jury rejected that account.
The deaths that followed rest on Plummer's word and on the recollections of others. In each of them he said he had acted in self-defense. Only one, at Bannack, came before a tribunal of any kind, and that tribunal acquitted him; the other two never came before any court.
1832: Born in Addison, Washington County, Maine.
Early 1850s: Leaves Maine for California; settles at Nevada City.
May 1856: Elected town marshal of Nevada City.
1857: Re-elected marshal; loses a race for the state assembly.
September 1857: A man dies at Nevada City at the marshal's hands.
1859: After a second trial, a jury finds him "guilty of murder in the second degree"; sentenced to ten years.
Soon after: Pardoned by the governor of California on the ground of "imminent dangers of death from Consumption."
Before late 1861: A second death at Nevada City; he is held in the town jail but never tried.
Late 1861: Leaves California for Washington Territory.
1861 or 1862: A death at Oro Fino; he leaves the region ahead of the dead man's friends.
July 28, 1862: Gold discovered on Grasshopper Creek; Bannack founded.
Winter 1862: Arrives at Bannack.
January 14, 1863: A death at Bannack; a miners' jury "honorably acquitted" him.
May 24, 1863: Elected sheriff of Bannack and the surrounding mines.
December 23, 1863: Vigilance Committee organized by citizens of Virginia City and Bannack.
January 10, 1864: Seized at Bannack and executed by vigilantes without trial, together with two of his deputies.