Heinrich Tillessen was one of the two men who murdered Matthias Erzberger, the Center Party politician who had signed the armistice that ended the First World War and had then served as the Reich's finance minister. The murder took place near Bad Griesbach, a spa town in the Black Forest of Baden, on August 26, 1921. Tillessen and his partner, Heinrich Schulz, were former members of the naval brigade that had carried the Kapp Putsch of 1920, and they acted on an order passed to them inside the Organisation Consul, the secret right-wing network that grew out of that brigade. They escaped abroad before Baden's investigators could reach them, returned in 1933 after the new National Socialist government declared them exempt from punishment, and lived openly in Germany for more than a decade.
Tillessen's case did not end with the war. After American forces took him into custody in 1945 he declared himself to be one of the killers. A court of the Offenburg district, sitting in Freiburg in November 1946, heard his case and acquitted him on the strength of the 1933 amnesty. The French military government, which governed Baden, refused to let that verdict stand: it set the decision aside, had Tillessen arrested again and sent the case to the Landgericht Konstanz. On February 28, 1947, that court convicted him of murder and sentenced him to 15 years' Zuchthaus, the German penalty of penal servitude. Schulz was tried separately in Offenburg in 1950 and received 12 years. Both men served only a few years in prison, and Tillessen lived on as a free man until his death in 1984.
The minister's career began in Württemberg. A founder of the state's Center Party drew him onto the editorial staff of the Deutsches Volksblatt, and alongside his journalism he ran a Catholic workers' secretariat there and backed the Christian trade unions founded in 1899.
In 1903 he was elected to the Reichstag for the Center Party as its youngest member. Deputies drew no salary at the time, and he kept himself by writing on Berlin politics for Catholic newspapers in southern Germany through a press agency he set up for the purpose. On the budget committee he became known as an expert on the military budget and as a critic of abuses in the colonial administration, and he pushed for a parliament with real power over the chancellor: his initiative in 1912 gave the Reichstag a formal vote of disapproval against the chancellor, first used in 1913.
When the war began he went into government service and organized German propaganda in neutral countries, at first in support of sweeping war aims. He changed course during the war and became one of the strongest voices for a negotiated peace without annexations. The Reichstag peace resolution of July 1917, which he helped to launch, was the first joint act of the Center, Social Democrats and liberals who later carried the Weimar Republic. In November 1918, as head of the German armistice commission, he signed the armistice in the forest of Compiègne with the approval of the army's supreme command. He then argued that Germany had to accept the Treaty of Versailles, because refusal would bring Allied troops into the country and endanger its unity.
Those two acts made him the most hated man in the nationalist camp. From June 1919 he was Reich finance minister in the cabinet of the Social Democratic chancellor Gustav Bauer, and in nine months he pushed through a reform of 16 laws that moved the tax administration from the states to the Reich, created a single national tax code, raised taxes on wealth, introduced a new inheritance tax and redistributed revenue among the Reich, the states and the towns. He also brought the state railways together into one national system.
The attacks on him did not stop. A campaign against his integrity, led by a former state secretary of the treasury, ended in a libel trial whose judgment cast doubt on his honesty, and he resigned as finance minister on March 12, 1920, the day of the verdict, intending to clear his name. In June 1921 he announced that he would return to active politics in the autumn.
Heinrich Tillessen was born in 1894 and served as an officer in the German navy. After the revolution of November 1918 he joined the Freikorps, the volunteer units that fought the uprisings on the left in the first years of the republic, and served in the Marine Brigade Ehrhardt, the naval unit that carried the Kapp Putsch in March 1920. There he served alongside Heinrich Schulz, another former officer, and the two men stayed together after the putsch failed and the government dissolved the brigade.
The two men spent some months in Regensburg, where they read pamphlets of the völkisch movement and went to its meetings, and Tillessen's letters from those years show how completely he took up that movement's antisemitism and its hostility to the republic. In 1946 he told the examining magistrate that he had soaked all of it up because he felt uprooted, and that he now regarded it as poison.
By the spring of 1921 the two men had moved to Munich, where the brigade lived on in secret. Its successor, the Organisation Consul, took its name from the cover name of the brigade's commander, Hermann Ehrhardt, who was wanted for high treason. Tillessen and Schulz were employed at the organization's cover business, a sham timber firm. Its statutes, seized by the Baden police in 1921, describe an anti-republican secret society with a military structure that kept the brigade's men together for a possible return to arms.
How the order reached Tillessen and Schulz was settled only after 1945, from their own statements. Schulz said the two of them had sworn oaths to the Organisation Consul and to the Germanenorden, a secret völkisch order, to carry out any order given to them, and that once the order came they agreed they could not get out of it. At the Konstanz trial Tillessen said that about three weeks before the murder a former cavalry captain told the two of them that lots had been drawn at the order's headquarters in Jena and had fallen on them. Schulz, questioned in 1950, could not say who had handed them the order, but placed the handover in the office of their direct superior at the timber firm, a former naval lieutenant, and in his presence.
The former minister was murdered near Bad Griesbach on August 26, 1921. A fellow Reichstag deputy of the Center Party who was with him survived, and the prosecution later included his attempted murder in its case.
Baden's police soon identified Tillessen and Schulz. The public prosecutor's office in Offenburg, which had charge of the case, followed their trail to Munich and there came upon the timber firm, and it established that the two men had met their superior again after the murder. They were gone before they could be arrested. The Bavarian police, instead of detaining them, had summoned them in writing for questioning, a warning reached their superior, and the Munich police president personally supplied the passports for their flight abroad.
Baden issued a wanted notice for both men. Without them, the case against their helpers could not be made. Their superior was charged with aiding the crime, and a jury court in Offenburg acquitted him in 1922. A second proceeding, for membership in a secret society, uncovered the Organisation Consul for the first time.
Tillessen and Schulz spent the following years outside Germany, chiefly in Hungary, and the organization's commander supported them abroad for years. Tillessen stayed away until the National Socialists came to power.
The end of the republic brought them back. In March 1933, after the National Socialists took power, a decree of exemption from punishment covered offenses committed in the struggle for the "national uprising" of the German people, and Tillessen and Schulz were declared exempt from punishment that month. Tillessen returned to Germany and was no longer pursued. At the urging of the National Socialist party he was made an honorary Sturmbannführer in 1933, against his own wishes. He lived a withdrawn life through the Third Reich and returned to his Catholic faith. The murder weighed on him, and at times he suffered from depression.
In 1945, after American forces had taken him into custody in a routine arrest, Tillessen identified himself on his own initiative as one of the murderers, saying that he wanted at last to be free of the burden. His first statement on the matter is dated August 15, 1945. The American authorities asked that the case be tried, and Tillessen was handed to the justice system of Baden, then part of the French occupation zone. He was questioned at length by an examining magistrate in the summer of 1946. In those interviews he described his politics and the organization, but he denied that anyone had incited him or that the Organisation Consul had supported the crime. He admitted the full background only at his second trial, in Konstanz.
The case was heard in November 1946 by a criminal chamber of the Offenburg court sitting in Freiburg. Tillessen admitted his guilt. The question before the court was legal: whether the 1933 decree still protected him after the fall of the regime that had issued it. The prosecution pressed for a conviction. The court held that the amnesty, so far as it remained in force, exempted Tillessen from punishment, and it acquitted him.
The verdict caused a scandal in Baden, and the French military government answered with force. It set the decision aside, and French authorities arrested Tillessen again.
The case went to the second criminal chamber of the Landgericht Konstanz, which heard it at the end of February 1947. This time the 1933 decree was no bar. At this trial Tillessen told the court what he had held back before: the meeting three weeks before the crime, the drawing of lots at the Germanenorden's headquarters in Jena and the order that followed. On February 28, 1947, the court convicted him of murder and sentenced him to 15 years' Zuchthaus.
Schulz came back into the hands of the German authorities after the war. Questioned by an examining magistrate in 1950, he confirmed the account Tillessen had given in Konstanz, except that he could not say who had passed them the order. The Offenburg court tried him in 1950 and sentenced him to 12 years' Zuchthaus.
The identity of the person who handed Tillessen and Schulz the order was never settled. Tillessen told the Konstanz court that a former cavalry captain informed them of the decision; Schulz placed the handover in their superior's office and in his presence but could not say whether the captain or the superior passed it on. Their superior had been acquitted in 1922 and died in 1944 without being tried again, so no court ever ruled on his part.
The sources describe the Offenburg outcome of 1946 in two ways: one account says the court rejected the indictment and stopped the proceedings on the amnesty, while others call it an acquittal.
1894: Heinrich Tillessen is born.
1920, March: The Kapp Putsch fails; the Marine Brigade Ehrhardt is dissolved.
1921, August 26: The former Reich finance minister is murdered near Bad Griesbach, Baden.
1921, September: Tillessen and Schulz escape abroad.
1922: Their superior in the organization is tried by a jury court in Offenburg and acquitted.
1933, March: Tillessen and Schulz are declared exempt from punishment; Tillessen returns to Germany.
1945: In American custody, Tillessen identifies himself as one of the killers; statement dated August 15.
1946, November: The Offenburg court, sitting in Freiburg, acquits Tillessen on the 1933 amnesty; the French military government sets the decision aside.
1947, February 28: The Landgericht Konstanz convicts Tillessen of murder and sentences him to 15 years' Zuchthaus.
1950: Schulz is tried in Offenburg and sentenced to 12 years' Zuchthaus.
1984: Tillessen dies.