Heinrich Boere

Victims
3 Dutch civilians murdered in the occupied Netherlands, 1944. Convicted of three murders at Aachen, March 23, 2010, final December 2010; sentenced to death in absentia in Amsterdam, 1949
Years active
July 14, 1944 to September 3, 1944
Location
Breda; Voorschoten; Wassenaar; Eschweiler; Aachen
Method
Reprisal murders of three Dutch civilians on superiors' orders in occupied Netherlands; each classed by the court as heimtückischer Mord
Status
Life imprisonment; Bundesgerichtshof rejected the appeal on December 1, 2010; served from December 2011; died in custody December 1, 2013

In the summer of 1944, in the occupied Netherlands, a Dutch-raised member of the SS named Heinrich Boere killed three civilians on the orders of his superiors. The men's names had been passed to him in advance by members of the SS and the SD, the security service. The killings were reprisals. Their purpose, as the German courts later found, was to frighten the Dutch resistance and everyone who sympathized with it by killing people who had no part in the attacks being answered.

A Dutch special court sentenced Boere to death in absentia in 1949, and the sentence was later commuted to life imprisonment. He never served a day of it. He had crossed into Germany two years earlier, and for six decades the border, a disputed question of nationality and a string of court rulings kept him beyond the reach of either country's prisons. When he was finally tried, it was before the Landgericht Aachen, the regional court of the city on whose outskirts he had been born. He was 88 and admitted all three killings.

On March 23, 2010, the court convicted him of murder in three cases and sentenced him to life imprisonment, classing each killing as heimtückischer Mord, murder by treachery. On December 1, 2010, the Bundesgerichtshof, Germany's Federal Court of Justice, rejected his appeal as unfounded, and the verdict became final. Boere began serving the sentence in December 2011, at the age of 90. He died in custody in North Rhine-Westphalia on December 1, 2013.

Eschweiler and Maastricht

Boere was born in 1921 in Eschweiler, a mining town on the edge of Aachen, to a Dutch father and a German mother. While he was still a small child the family moved across the border to Maastricht, and it was there, in the southern tip of the Netherlands, that he grew up. He spoke at his trial of how his family had welcomed the German invasion of May 1940.

After the Germans took Maastricht, Boere, then 18, saw an SS recruiting poster that carried Heinrich Himmler's signature. It promised German citizenship after two years of service and the possibility of a later career in the police. About a hundred Dutchmen applied. Boere was one of fifteen accepted, and he joined the Waffen-SS that year.

He served on the Eastern Front, in the Caucasus. In 1942 he joined the Nationaal-Socialistische Beweging (NSB), the Dutch National Socialist movement, and its auxiliary guard, the Landwacht. By 1944 he held the rank of SS-Hauptscharführer in the Germanic SS in the Netherlands, the branch of the SS made up of Dutch volunteers.

The squad

Back in the Netherlands, Boere was assigned to a special unit of about fifteen Dutch SS men under the Dutch SS leader Johannes Hendrik Feldmeijer. The unit belonged to a program of reprisals that, by the findings of the German courts, ran from October 1943 under the code name "Geheime Reichssache Silbertanne." The Landwacht carried it out in close cooperation with the SD. Each time the resistance struck at the occupiers or their Dutch collaborators, the program answered by killing Dutch civilians who were judged to be hostile to Germany. The targets were chosen in advance. The men who did the killing were given names and sent out to find them.

The courts that tried Boere were clear about what this was: the killing of uninvolved people to spread fear. The Federal Court of Justice set that finding at the head of its summary of the case: Boere had acted on the order of a superior, against three Dutch civilians whose personal details SS and SD staff had given him beforehand.

The first of the three killings took place in Breda on the evening of July 14, 1944. The man who died was Fritz Hubert Ernst Bicknese. Boere acted with a second Dutch SS man. The killing was ordered in reprisal for an attack on a commander of the Landwacht.

Voorschoten, September 1944

On September 3, 1944, in Voorschoten, in the province of South Holland, he and another member of the squad killed Teunis de Groot, known as Teun. Later the same day the two men killed a third civilian, Frans Willem Kusters. The two September killings took place in Voorschoten and in Wassenaar, the town beside it.

None of the three men was found by the squad. Their names came down from the SS and the SD. After the war Boere told the Dutch authorities that he and another SS man had been handed a list of names marked for "retaliatory measures," and that was how all three had been chosen.

The court in Aachen dealt directly with one of the reasons the occupiers had marked the man in Voorschoten for death. He was known as a man who disliked the Germans. The court held that this gave no justification whatever for killing him and rejected the argument that the conditions of war could excuse it.

When the war ended, Boere was in Allied hands. American forces captured him, and by May 1945 he was a prisoner of the Dutch authorities, held in a prisoner-of-war camp in the province of Limburg. In 1947 he escaped and crossed into Germany. He settled in Eschweiler, the town where he had been born, worked through the 1950s and beyond as a coal miner, and lived there under his own name. He made no secret of who he was. When he was asked about the war, he did not deny what he had done.

The Netherlands tried him without him. On October 18, 1949, after a hearing that lasted a single day, the Bijzonder Gerechtshof in Amsterdam, one of the special courts the Dutch government had set up to try wartime crimes and collaboration, sentenced him to death in absentia for the killings. The sentence was later commuted to life imprisonment. Boere, in Germany, served none of his.

Two refusals

Germany refused to send him back. The Netherlands asked for his extradition in the early 1980s; he spent two months in extradition custody before the Oberlandesgericht Köln, the higher regional court in Cologne, declared the extradition inadmissible, on the ground that a decree of May 19, 1943, had made foreigners of German descent who joined the Waffen-SS German citizens, and Germany did not extradite its own nationals.

The same year, 1980, the Central Office for the investigation of Nazi crimes in Dortmund opened its own inquiry. Its head at the time concluded that the reprisal program had been consistent with the international law then in force and that its ordering and execution had been lawful, and the inquiry went no further.

In 2003 the Dutch Ministry of Justice tried another route. It asked Germany to enforce the 1949 sentence, so that Boere would serve the Dutch life term in a German prison. In February 2007 the Landgericht Aachen granted the request. The Oberlandesgericht Köln overturned it. This time the Cologne court held that the 1949 trial had violated basic fair-trial standards: Boere had not been properly defended in Amsterdam, had been unable to appeal, and had lacked any effective legal means of contesting a conviction handed down in his absence. To the Cologne judges, a sentence passed on a man who had not been present to defend himself was not one a German court could carry out. The same court said the crimes should not go unpunished. Its ruling left one path open, a new trial in Germany under German law.

The Dortmund indictment

In August 2007 a new head of the Dortmund Central Office reopened the investigation and began it again from the beginning. Their position was that because the Dutch sentence had never been enforced, the case could be tried again, this time in a German court. In April 2008 his office indicted Boere before the Landgericht Aachen on a charge of gemeinschaftlicher Mord in drei Fällen, joint murder in three cases. The indictment charged that between July and September 1944, as an SS-Hauptscharführer and in the course of unlawful reprisals against the Dutch population, he had killed three Dutch nationals together with other members of the SS, acting treacherously and from base motives. The case was unusual in its materials. Nearly everyone who had witnessed the killings was dead. The prosecution named one living witness, together with twenty-seven records of earlier interviews, nine further documents and five photographs, and the court expected that most of the evidence would be read aloud. The core of the case was Boere's own account. The indictment recorded that he had admitted the charges in full. The same year the Simon Wiesenthal Center added him to its list of the most-wanted Nazi war criminals.

Fit to stand trial

The case nearly ended before it began. On January 7, 2009, the Landgericht Aachen refused to open the main proceedings. A medical expert had found that Boere's mind was sound but that his physical health was poor enough that the strain of a trial might endanger his life, and the court declared him permanently unfit to stand trial. He was 87.

The prosecution appealed. The Oberlandesgericht Köln took fresh evidence about his condition and found that it had improved noticeably. On July 1, 2009, it reversed the Aachen decision and ordered the trial to proceed, holding that the risk of a serious emotional strain during the hearings was rather low and that the remaining danger belonged to the ordinary risks of his life. The presiding judge of the Aachen jury court, the Schwurgericht, set the trial for October 28, 2009, with twelve further hearing days through December 18.

Boere took the question to the Bundesverfassungsgericht, the Federal Constitutional Court, arguing that a trial would violate his right to life and physical integrity under the Basic Law. On October 6, 2009, a three-judge chamber of the court's Second Senate declined to accept the complaint. The chamber held that the state's duty to keep criminal justice working could collide with a defendant's right to life, and that the conflict had to be settled by weighing the two. A trial had to stop only on a sufficiently reliable prediction of serious harm, not on a mere possibility. The Cologne court had weighed the gravity of the charges, the limited scope of the evidence and the likely length of the trial; its finding that his health had improved rested on credible testimony; and the risks could be reduced by medical supervision, breaks and adjustments to the hearings. Fitness to stand trial, the chamber added, was a legal question for the court, not a medical one for the expert. The decision could not be appealed.

Trial at Aachen

The trial opened on October 28, 2009. The indictment was not read on the first day. The defense moved to have the lead prosecutor removed for bias, and the court adjourned for a week to allow a response. In November the hearings were halted again until Boere could follow the proceedings, and on November 23, the fourth day of the trial, the court rejected a defense request to stop the case altogether.

The defense's main legal argument was double jeopardy. Boere had already been convicted of the same killings in Amsterdam, his lawyers said, and he could not be tried for them a second time. They relied on the European ban on being punished twice for the same offense, which the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union had made binding when the Treaty of Lisbon took effect on December 1, 2009. In December the court rejected the motion, relying on the Schengen Implementation Convention.

On December 8, 2009, Boere's lawyer told the court that his client admitted killing all three men. His defense was that he had acted under military orders. The prosecution answered that he had been a willing member of the Waffen-SS who volunteered soon after the occupation began, and it asked for a life sentence on each count.

The verdict

On March 23, 2010, the court convicted Boere of murder in three cases and imposed a life sentence, the most severe penalty German law allows. It classed each of the three killings as heimtückischer Mord. It refused to treat the orders he had been given as a ground for mitigation; the killings were murder, and the court called them that.

The court issued no warrant for his arrest. It found no danger that he would flee or offend again, and he was allowed to remain at liberty in Eschweiler while his appeal ran its course.

The appeal

The defense filed a Revision, an appeal on points of law, to the Bundesgerichtshof, again arguing that the Amsterdam judgment barred a second trial. The Second Criminal Senate of the Federal Court of Justice decided the case on December 1, 2010. It rejected the appeal as unfounded: review of the grounds raised had shown no legal error to the defendant's disadvantage. Boere was ordered to bear the costs of the appeal.

On double jeopardy the senate added a short holding of its own. The Charter's ban applied only to the extent that the Schengen Implementation Convention provided for it, and the Convention barred a second prosecution only where the earlier penalty had been enforced, was being enforced, or could no longer be enforced under the law of the convicting state. The Amsterdam sentence met none of those conditions. It had never been carried out, it was not being carried out, and it could still be carried out. The senate followed a decision of the court's First Criminal Senate of October 25, 2010, including that senate's conclusion that there was no need to refer the question to the European Court of Justice. On December 20, 2010, the Landgericht Aachen announced that its judgment was final.

Custody and death

A year later Boere was still living in Eschweiler. In October 2011 the Aachen prosecutor's office said he would be given one of the next places that came free. A court-appointed expert had found him "prinzipiell haftfähig," fit in principle for detention, despite his age. In mid-December 2011, at 90, he was taken from Eschweiler into the custody of the North Rhine-Westphalia prison system to begin his life sentence.

He died in custody on December 1, 2013, still serving the life sentence. The state's Justice Ministry announced his death the next day. He was, at his death, the oldest prisoner in North Rhine-Westphalia.

Context: the special court of 1949

The Bijzonder Gerechtshof that sentenced Boere in 1949 belonged to the system of special justice that the Dutch government in exile created by decrees in 1943 and 1944, to try war crimes and collaboration once the country was free. Its chambers were all at work by early 1946. The Amsterdam court heard Boere's case without him because he had already escaped to Germany, and that absence decided the fate of every later Dutch attempt to have its sentence carried out.

The German proceedings of 2009 and 2010 were not a review of the Amsterdam judgment. The Landgericht Aachen tried the case afresh under German criminal law, as murder rather than as a war crime, on evidence that rested largely on Boere's own statements and on records read into the trial. The Dutch judgment entered the German case only as the basis of the defense's double-jeopardy argument, which the trial court and the Federal Court of Justice both rejected.

Disputed and unproven points

Boere admitted the three killings but maintained throughout that he had acted under orders he could not refuse. The prosecution held that he was a volunteer and a willing member of the SS. The question of duress was argued at trial and decided against him; the court gave the orders no weight in mitigation.

His nationality remained unsettled for decades. The refusal to extradite him in the early 1980s rested on a wartime decree conferring German citizenship on foreign volunteers of German descent in the Waffen-SS, and German authorities at the time could not determine whether he was German or stateless.

German prosecutors themselves took opposite views of the reprisals. In 1980 the Dortmund Central Office found them lawful under the international law of the time; from 2007 the same office treated them as murder, and the courts agreed.

The standing of the 1949 judgment was contested as well. The Oberlandesgericht Köln held in 2007 that the Amsterdam trial had fallen short of basic fair-trial standards and would not let its sentence be served in Germany. The Federal Court of Justice in 2010 treated the same judgment as a sentence still enforceable in the Netherlands, and for that reason found it no bar to the German conviction.

Timeline

1921: Heinrich Boere is born in Eschweiler, near Aachen; the family later moves to Maastricht.

May 1940: Germany invades and occupies the Netherlands.

1940: Boere joins the Waffen-SS; he later serves on the Eastern Front.

1942: He joins the NSB and the Landwacht.

October 1943: The reprisal program begins under its code name, by the findings of the German courts.

July 14, 1944: The first of the three killings, in Breda.

September 3, 1944: The second and third killings, in Voorschoten and Wassenaar.

May 1945: Boere is a prisoner of the Dutch authorities.

1947: Boere escapes from a prisoner-of-war camp in Limburg and crosses into Germany.

October 18, 1949: The Bijzonder Gerechtshof in Amsterdam sentences him to death in absentia; the sentence is later commuted to life imprisonment.

1980: The Dortmund Central Office opens an inquiry and closes it, finding the reprisals lawful under the international law of the time.

Early 1980s: The Oberlandesgericht Köln declares his extradition to the Netherlands inadmissible.

2003: The Dutch Ministry of Justice asks Germany to enforce the 1949 sentence.

February 2007: The Landgericht Aachen grants the request; the Oberlandesgericht Köln later overturns it.

August 2007: The Dortmund Central Office reopens the investigation.

April 2008: Boere is indicted for joint murder in three cases.

January 7, 2009: The Landgericht Aachen finds him unfit to stand trial.

July 1, 2009: The Oberlandesgericht Köln reverses that decision and orders the trial to proceed.

October 6, 2009: The Federal Constitutional Court declines to accept his constitutional complaint.

October 28, 2009: The trial opens at the Landgericht Aachen.

November 23, 2009: The court rejects a defense request to stop the trial.

December 8, 2009: Through his lawyer, Boere admits the three killings.

March 23, 2010: The court convicts him of murder in three cases and sentences him to life imprisonment.

December 1, 2010: The Federal Court of Justice rejects his appeal.

December 20, 2010: The Landgericht Aachen announces that the verdict is final.

December 2011: Boere, 90, begins serving his life sentence.

December 1, 2013: He dies in custody in North Rhine-Westphalia.