In the late winter of 1901, in the far north of the Transvaal, a small detachment of a British irregular regiment killed men who had already surrendered to it. Two of its lieutenants, Harry Harbord Morant and Peter Joseph Handcock, both volunteers from the Australian colonies, were tried for those deaths by British courts martial in January and February 1902. The courts found them guilty of the murder and manslaughter of 12 Boer prisoners. On a separate charge, the murder of a missionary of the Berlin Missionary Society, both were found "Not Guilty." The death sentences were confirmed, the courts' recommendation of mercy was not applied to either man, and they were executed at Pretoria on February 27, 1902.
Neither man denied the killings of the prisoners. Their defense was that they had acted on verbal orders from above that no prisoners were to be taken. The courts rejected that defense, and no written order was ever produced. Whether any such order existed is still argued in Australia, but no government in London or Canberra has granted or sought a pardon, and the convictions stand.
Morant's own accounts of his origins do not hold together. He claimed to be the son of an English admiral; historians believe he was born Edwin Henry Murrant, probably on December 9, 1864, at Bridgwater in Somerset. He reached Townsville, Queensland, in early April 1883, and he made his name in the outback as a horseman, working as a groom and then droving cattle out of Winton in western Queensland.
By 1899 his debts were mounting, and the war in South Africa had just begun. He was in Adelaide that year and enlisted in the 2nd Contingent of the South Australian Mounted Rifles as a lance corporal, leaving with the unit in January 1900. He served first as a dispatch rider. When his enlistment ran out, about the middle of 1900, he was offered a commission but went to England instead.
Peter Joseph Handcock was born on February 17, 1868, at Winburndale, near Peel in New South Wales. At 12 he was apprenticed to a blacksmith in Bathurst, and he later worked as a laborer in the Dubbo district. In December 1899 he was a blacksmith with the Railway Department at Manildra.
He enlisted in Sydney in the 1st New South Wales Mounted Rifles, marched out of Victoria Barracks with the contingent on January 17, 1900, and sailed for Cape Town. He rose to farrier sergeant and was in action at Driefontein in March 1900 and at Diamond Hill in June.
The Bushveldt Carbineers was raised in South Africa early in 1901. It was a locally raised irregular regiment under British command, not an Australian unit, although many of its men were Australians. Its work was to garrison the northern Transvaal, round up the small bands of armed Boers still in the field, and bring in Boer families willing to take the oath of allegiance to the Crown. The regiment mustered at Pretoria in March 1901, and after Pietersburg fell in mid-April it made the town its headquarters.
Handcock was commissioned as the regiment's veterinary lieutenant on February 21, 1901. Morant came back to South Africa in March 1901 in company with Captain Percy Hunt and was commissioned a lieutenant in the Carbineers on April 1.
In June 1901 Handcock went north with a detachment to the Spelonken district, where the Carbineers held a post called Fort Edward. In mid-July the detachment was placed under Hunt. Even before the killings that came to trial, the unit had a name for taking no prisoners, for looting and for insubordination. An intelligence officer attached to the district from the staff in Pretoria worked closely with the detachment, and his part in what followed became one of the points the defense later pressed.
Early in August 1901 Hunt was killed in a night attack on a Boer-held farmstead, on August 5 or August 6. Morant, his close friend, took command at Fort Edward. In the weeks that followed, Boers taken by the detachment were killed instead of held.
The first death that came before the courts was that of Floris Visser, a young Boer who had been wounded and taken prisoner by a patrol under Morant's command. He was killed on about August 10, 1901, and the court treated his death as the killing of a prisoner of war.
On August 23, 1901, eight Boer men who had given themselves up near the mission at Elim in the Soutpansberg were killed as prisoners. Morant, Handcock and a fellow Australian lieutenant, George Witton, were all implicated in their deaths, the largest single group in the courts' findings.
The same day, a missionary who had spoken with those prisoners was killed. Carl August Daniel Heese was born at Amalienstein mission station in the Cape Colony, trained in Berlin, and was ordained a missionary of the Berlin Missionary Society, serving at Makapanspoort, near Pietersburg. He had come to Elim to help a friend who was ill, and there he had talked with the Boer prisoners, who feared what was coming. He left a young family. Morant and Handcock were later tried for his murder and found not guilty.
In early September 1901 a patrol that included Morant and Handcock took a Boer man and his two sons, who had come in to surrender, and all three were killed. The date most often given is September 7. With the wounded prisoner of August and the eight men of August 23, these three made up the 12 prisoners on whom the courts later convicted.
The men who ended the killings were the Carbineers' own rank and file. In early October 1901 fifteen troopers of the regiment set out their complaints in a letter to the commander at Pietersburg, and several of the unit's officers were arrested as a result. Morant and Handcock were taken into custody at Pietersburg on October 22, 1901, and held apart from one another in solitary confinement. A court of inquiry then brought murder charges against them, against Witton and against a British lieutenant of the regiment.
The first court martial opened on January 16, 1902, and the proceedings concluded on February 19. Both Morant and Handcock admitted the deaths of the prisoners; the question was whether they had acted under orders. No written order was produced, no witness established that the commander-in-chief or his staff had given one, and the courts rejected the defense. Morant and Handcock were found guilty of the murder and manslaughter of the 12 Boer prisoners. On the charge of murdering the missionary, they were found "Not Guilty," and in law that acquittal stands.
Morant, Handcock and Witton were sentenced to death with a recommendation of mercy. On February 25, 1902, the sentences were confirmed. Witton's was commuted to life, and he was released in 1904; the recommendations of mercy for Morant and Handcock were not applied, and no appeal was open to them. They were told on February 26 and executed at Pretoria on February 27, 1902.
Later efforts to clear them have failed. The British Ministry of Defense rejected a petition for review in November 2010, the Australian Attorney-General declined to seek a pardon in May 2012, and a motion in the Australian House of Representatives in February 2018 acknowledged the convictions while regretting that the men had been denied procedural fairness.
The existence of an order to take no prisoners is the central dispute. Morant described it as a verbal instruction from the commander-in-chief passed to Hunt through the military secretary. Both the secretary and the regiment's commanding officer denied that it was given, no written order was ever produced, and the courts rejected the defense. Some historians point to the diary of the army's provost marshal as evidence that such orders existed; others regard the claimed orders as an invention of men on trial for their lives. A letter from a senior British Army legal officer, found in the British archives in 2010, has been read as referring to a "no prisoners" order and as placing chief responsibility on the intelligence officer attached to the district. None of this has changed the verdicts.
The fairness of the trials is also disputed. The case for the men stresses the months of solitary confinement, the single day their counsel had to prepare, the removal of defense witnesses before the trials, the absence of any appeal and the speed of the executions. Historians on the other side find no reason to challenge the courts' decision on the facts, and note that the men's own comrades brought the killings to light.
The full transcript of the trials has not been found. The review file of the Judge Advocate General survives, and it was closed to the public for 75 years.
December 9, 1864: Harry Harbord Morant (born Edwin Henry Murrant, it is believed) is born at Bridgwater, Somerset, England.
February 17, 1868: Peter Joseph Handcock is born at Winburndale, near Peel, New South Wales.
April 1883: Morant reaches Townsville, Queensland.
January 1900: Morant leaves Adelaide with the 2nd South Australian Mounted Rifles; on January 17 Handcock's contingent of the 1st New South Wales Mounted Rifles marches out of Victoria Barracks, Sydney.
February 21, 1901: Handcock is commissioned veterinary lieutenant in the Bushveldt Carbineers.
April 1, 1901: Morant is commissioned a lieutenant in the Carbineers.
June 1901: Handcock goes north with the detachment to Fort Edward in the Spelonken.
August 5 or 6, 1901: Captain Percy Hunt is killed; Morant takes command.
About August 10, 1901: A wounded Boer prisoner is killed.
August 23, 1901: Eight surrendered Boer men are killed; the missionary is killed the same day.
September 7, 1901: A Boer man and his two sons are killed after surrendering.
Early October 1901: Fifteen troopers send a letter of complaint to the commander at Pietersburg.
October 22, 1901: Morant and Handcock are arrested at Pietersburg.
January 16, 1902: The first court martial opens.
February 19, 1902: The proceedings conclude; Morant and Handcock are found guilty on the 12 prisoners and "Not Guilty" of the missionary's murder.
February 25, 1902: The sentences are confirmed; Witton's is commuted to life.
February 27, 1902: Morant and Handcock are executed at Pretoria.
1904: Witton is released.