On September 21, 2015, a federal jury in Denver found Harold Henthorn guilty of the first-degree murder of his second wife, Toni Henthorn, who had died three years earlier in Rocky Mountain National Park. The couple had gone into the park to mark their twelfth wedding anniversary. He was the only other person present when she died, and from the first evening he described her death as an accident. The government's case was that he had planned it, and the jury agreed.
Because the park lies within the exclusive jurisdiction of the United States, the case was never a state prosecution. National Park Service special agents led the inquiry, the FBI joined it, a federal grand jury returned the indictment, and the trial took place in the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado. The sentence the law required on that verdict was life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. Henthorn has challenged the conviction on direct appeal, in the Supreme Court of the United States and in a motion to vacate, and he has lost at every stage.
At the time of his arrest Henthorn was 58 and lived in Highlands Ranch, a suburb south of Denver in Douglas County. To friends and acquaintances he presented himself as a busy fundraiser for charities, churches and nonprofit groups. The financial record told a different story. At his detention hearing in November 2014, an auditor from the U.S. Attorney's Office testified that his tax and Social Security records showed no steady work and no real income for years, with only minimal earnings in 1993, 1999 and 2000. Investigators later established that he had not held a job since 1992.
His second marriage had lasted twelve years when the couple went to the park in September 2012, and the court record treats the outing as part of their anniversary celebration.
The couple drove into Rocky Mountain National Park, near Estes Park. She died there that day. Henthorn called for help, and the rangers who reached her that evening found that she had died.
Henthorn gave rangers his account in the hours that followed. He said the couple had changed their plans at the last moment and that the walk that ended in her death had been a spontaneous decision. He spoke with emergency dispatchers several times that evening.
The Larimer County coroner did not rule the death an accident. The manner of death was recorded as undetermined, with homicide not excluded.
The National Park Service's Investigative Services Branch opened what became a three-year investigation, led by one of its special agents and assisted by park rangers and agents of the FBI's Denver Division. The Douglas County Sheriff's Office later gave substantial support.
The questions began with Henthorn's own account. When rangers asked about the outing, he told them he had made only one earlier visit to the park to look around. Investigators established that he had been in the park at least eight or nine times in the six weeks before his wife died, and that he knew the area far better than he had admitted.
On motive, the Tenth Circuit recorded that at the time of her death Henthorn held three $1.5 million life insurance policies on his wife and a $205,000 annuity, and stood to receive more than $4.7 million.
Investigators also set his statements to dispatchers and rangers that evening beside the medical findings and the recordings of his calls, and found that the two did not agree. That comparison, presented through the county coroner and the dispatcher who took his calls, became part of the government's case at trial.
As the inquiry went on, prosecutors learned of earlier events in Henthorn's life that they would later ask the trial court to put before the jury. The investigation ran for more than two years before any charge was filed.
On November 5, 2014, a federal grand jury in Denver returned a one-count indictment charging Henthorn with first-degree murder. It alleged that on or about September 29, 2012, in Rocky Mountain National Park, he "willfully, deliberately, maliciously, and with premeditation and malice aforethought" did unlawfully kill his wife. The next morning, November 6, special agents of the National Park Service and the FBI arrested him in Highlands Ranch without incident, with the Douglas County Sheriff's Office assisting. The indictment carried a mandatory sentence of life in federal prison without parole and a fine of up to $250,000. That afternoon he appeared before a U.S. magistrate judge in Denver to be advised of the charge and its penalty, and he said he understood both.
On November 12, 2014, he was arraigned and pleaded not guilty. The detention hearing that followed lasted several hours. The government argued that he was a flight risk and a danger to the community, and its auditor described the income record and the roughly $1.5 million in cash and assets he could reach. The magistrate judge found him a substantial flight risk and ordered him held without bond. His lead defense lawyer said he would not appeal the ruling. Henthorn remained in custody from then on.
Henthorn retained a defense team of three lawyers. The case was assigned to a senior U.S. district judge in Denver, who presided over every later stage in the district court.
The winter and spring of 2015 belonged to preparation. The court set a ten-day jury trial for September, ordered the government to disclose the earlier-incident evidence it meant to use, and set aside two days in May to hear the fight over that evidence.
The decisive pretrial battle concerned what else the jury would hear. The government filed notice under Federal Rule of Evidence 404(b) that it intended to offer evidence of three earlier incidents. The defense moved to exclude all of it, chiefly on the ground that it was improper character evidence and far more prejudicial than probative.
The district court held a two-day hearing at which ten witnesses testified, seven of them for the defense, and more than thirty exhibits were received. It then issued an eighteen-page order applying the four-part test the Supreme Court set out in Huddleston v. United States. The court admitted evidence of two incidents, one of them the 1995 death of Henthorn's first wife, which was never charged and which came before the jury only for limited purposes, and it excluded the third as not relevant to the crime charged. The admitted evidence could be used only to rebut the defense that the 2012 death was an accident and to show planning and intent. The judge told jurors so when the evidence was introduced, repeated the instruction when a juror asked to hear it again, and set it out once more in the written instructions, which told jurors that if they decided an earlier incident was an accident they were not to consider it for any purpose. Those instructions closely tracked language the defense itself had proposed.
A jury was seated in the first days of September 2015, and testimony began on Tuesday, September 8. The prosecution listed a long roster of witnesses and more than 300 exhibits, among them financial and bank records, summaries of his travel, photographs and recordings of his calls to dispatchers. Rangers, investigators, the coroner, the dispatcher, records witnesses and members of the victim's family testified.
The court agreed to a written jury questionnaire, and the lead defense lawyer questioned the prospective jurors himself, gave the opening statement, conducted many of the cross-examinations and delivered the closing argument. Twice during testimony he asked the judge to repeat the limiting instruction on the earlier-incident evidence, and the judge did. The defense cross-examined the government's witnesses and called none of its own. Henthorn did not testify. His lawyers' position was that the government had not proved that the death was a murder rather than an accident.
Closing arguments came on Friday, September 18. The case went to the jury that afternoon. After about a day of deliberation, on Monday afternoon, September 21, 2015, the jury returned its verdict: guilty of first-degree murder. The trial had run ten days.
The penalty the government announced at indictment was a mandatory term of life in federal prison without parole. On December 8, 2015, the district judge imposed that sentence. Henthorn was 59.
He spoke at the hearing and told the judge that he had not killed his wife or anyone else. The judgment of life imprisonment without the possibility of parole was entered, and Henthorn was committed to the custody of the Bureau of Prisons.
Henthorn appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, represented by the Office of the Federal Public Defender for the Districts of Colorado and Wyoming. He raised one issue: that the district court had abused its discretion by admitting the evidence of the earlier incidents.
A three-judge panel decided the case in a published opinion filed July 26, 2017, United States v. Henthorn, 864 F.3d 1241. The question was whether the trial court had abused its discretion in admitting evidence of prior, similar incidents. The panel answered it at the outset: "We affirm. The district court did not abuse its discretion in admitting prior similar conduct."
The opinion was written by the circuit's chief judge. The standard of review was deferential: admissibility of this kind of evidence, the panel wrote, "involves a case-specific inquiry that is within the district court's broad discretion," and the ruling could be overturned only if it fell outside the bounds of permissible choice.
The panel took the four Huddleston factors in turn. On purpose, it held that rebutting accident and proving plan and intent are purposes Rule 404(b) expressly allows, and noted that the government had to prove a specific-intent crime: a "willful, deliberate, malicious, and premeditated killing." On relevance, it agreed with the trial judge that the incidents were "extraordinarily similar" to the charged offense and that the reasoning rested on "a logic of improbability" rather than on the forbidden inference that a person of bad character acts in character. The court discussed, without adopting by name, the so-called doctrine of chances, and pointed to a 1941 Supreme Court decision, Lisenba v. California, as recognizing the same common-sense principle. It called similarity "the lynchpin" of the relevance inquiry, and it held that the seventeen years separating the first incident from the death in the park did not disqualify it, given how closely the circumstances matched. It distinguished an earlier Tenth Circuit reversal in which prior acts had shown nothing more than a tendency to violence: here the defendant's answer to each incident was the same claim of accident, and the earlier incidents bore directly on intent. It noted that Henthorn had not challenged the trial judge's preliminary findings under Rule 104(b) that a jury could reasonably find each earlier incident was not an accident.
On prejudice, the panel held that the evidence, though prejudicial in the broad sense, was "highly probative of lack of accident" and of specific intent, and that the trial judge made no "obvious" or "substantial" error in the Rule 403 balance. It repeated that exclusion under Rule 403 "is an extraordinary remedy and should be used sparingly." On the limiting instructions, it observed that the final wording differed from the defense's own proposal only in minor ways, and it held that they "adequately advised the jury of its obligations under Rule 404(b)." It added in a footnote that even if one of the two incidents had been wrongly admitted, any error would have been harmless in light of the other evidence. The disposition read: "we hold the district court did not abuse its discretion in admitting the challenged evidence and thus AFFIRM Henthorn's conviction."
Henthorn sought review in the Supreme Court of the United States. On October 12, 2017, a justice extended the time to file his petition, and on December 1, 2017, he filed a petition for a writ of certiorari with a motion to proceed in forma pauperis, docketed as Henthorn v. United States, No. 17-7008. Represented by the Office of the Federal Public Defender, he asked the Court to decide a single question: whether the doctrine of chances, which is said to differ from character evidence because it rests on the objective improbability that similar incidents repeat by coincidence, can logically support the inference that all of the incidents were the product of design. The United States waived its right to respond. The petition was distributed for the conference of January 5, 2018, and on January 8, 2018, the Court denied it. One justice took no part in the consideration or decision of the petition. The denial made the conviction final.
On January 8, 2019, the last day before the one-year limit under 28 U.S.C. § 2255 ran out, Henthorn filed a motion to vacate his conviction, written without a lawyer. He claimed that his lead trial lawyer had given ineffective assistance: that the lawyer had promised a strong defense with expert witnesses, had twice asked him for substantial sums to retain experts in the month before trial, and had then presented no defense case at all. He alleged that only after the prosecution rested did the lawyer tell him he wanted to present no defense case, on the view that the government had not proved a murder. He also complained that he had been kept from taking part in his own defense during the trial.
The district judge found most of the allegations conclusory but held that some warranted a hearing, and on the government's request appointed counsel for Henthorn. On November 11, 2020, appointed counsel filed a supplemental motion of more than fifty pages, setting out twelve categories of alleged deficiencies in the trial lawyer's performance, from failures to object to the handling of jury instructions and closing argument. Because it was filed after the one-year limit, the government moved to strike eleven of the twelve categories as untimely, conceding only that one related back to the original motion.
The court held a three-day evidentiary hearing beginning May 23, 2022. A defense expert testified about the trial lawyer's performance. The trial lawyer testified for the government and explained his decisions. He described many meetings with Henthorn before and after the indictment, the investigators he had hired to interview likely witnesses, the discussions in which the defense team and Henthorn weighed whether to present evidence and whether Henthorn should testify, and the reasoning behind presenting no expert.
On June 23, 2022, the court issued its order. It held that eight categories and parts of two others did not relate back to the original motion and dismissed them for lack of jurisdiction. The claims it could reach concerned the cross-examination of a detective, the jury questionnaire, the decision not to call one potential witness, and two passages of the defense opening statement. On those, it found the trial lawyer's account of extensive preparation credible and the claim that the lawyer had never prepared a defense without merit. It found that the lawyer had agreed to the jury questionnaire but chose, as a matter of strategy, to keep case-specific questions off it; that his opening statement rested on reports from the investigators he had hired to interview the witnesses, which a reasonable lawyer was entitled to rely on; and that the arrangements for communicating with Henthorn during trial did not fall below the standard of care, since Henthorn could still speak with the other members of the defense team and with his lead lawyer during breaks. It found the remaining complaints to reflect strategic choices rather than a failure to prepare, and held that Henthorn had shown neither deficient performance nor prejudice under Strickland v. Washington. The judge, who had presided at the trial, reviewed the transcript again and found that, given the strength of the evidence of guilt, there was not a reasonable probability that the outcome would have been different. On the certificate, he acknowledged that reasonable minds could differ about the jurisdictional rulings but held that Henthorn had made no substantial showing that he was denied his Sixth Amendment right to effective counsel. The motion to vacate was denied, and the court declined to issue a certificate of appealability.
Henthorn asked the Tenth Circuit for a certificate of appealability. He did not address the rulings on the merits, which the panel treated as waived; he argued only that the district court had read his original motion too narrowly and wrongly found that the new categories did not relate back.
On September 5, 2023, a three-judge panel issued a unanimous order, written by one of its circuit judges, denying a certificate of appealability. Because the district court had disposed of the new categories on a procedural ground, Henthorn had to show, under Slack v. McDaniel, that reasonable jurists would find that procedural ruling debatable. The panel first noted that, although appointed counsel had called the 2020 filing a supplemental motion, it was in substance an amended one, because it concerned events before the original motion was filed. Applying Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 15(c) and the Supreme Court's decision in Mayle v. Felix, it held that the original motion focused on the failure to prepare and present a defense case-in-chief, while the new categories concerned other parts of the trial and were "supported by facts that differ in both time and type." Each, it held, amounted "to a new claim of ineffectiveness or, at the very least, a new theory of ineffectiveness." The Supreme Court in Mayle, it added, had already rejected the idea that the trial itself is the transaction or occurrence that counts for relation back. It rejected his argument that two references in his motion to his lawyer's conduct "during my trial" covered the whole trial. It rejected, too, his argument that the government's motion to strike had given fair notice of the new claims, because the notice that counts must come from the original motion itself. And it saw nothing unreasonable in applying the relation-back rule to filings by appointed counsel. The order concluded: "we deny Henthorn's application for a COA and dismiss this matter."
Henthorn is serving his life sentence in federal custody.
Rocky Mountain National Park is one of the places over which the United States holds sole and exclusive jurisdiction. In February 1929 the Colorado legislature ceded that jurisdiction over the park, and by an act of March 2, 1929, Congress accepted it, now codified at 16 U.S.C. § 198. The statute provides that all the laws applicable to places under the sole and exclusive jurisdiction of the United States "shall have force and effect in said park." That is why the death was investigated by National Park Service special agents, charged by a federal grand jury and tried in the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado rather than in a Colorado state court.
The charge itself came from 18 U.S.C. § 1111, the federal murder statute for the special maritime and territorial jurisdiction of the United States. It defines first-degree murder to include any "willful, deliberate, malicious, and premeditated killing," the specific-intent element the Tenth Circuit said the government had to prove and that the earlier-incident evidence was admitted to help establish. The statute punishes first-degree murder "by death or by imprisonment for life."
Henthorn has always denied killing his wife. His defense at trial was that her death was an accident, and he repeated his denial at sentencing.
The claims in his motion to vacate that his trial lawyer took money for experts and never prepared a defense were heard in full and rejected; the district court denied relief, and the appeals court declined to take the matter further.
September 29, 2012: his wife dies in Rocky Mountain National Park, near Estes Park, Colorado.
2012 to 2014: National Park Service Investigative Services Branch investigation, with the FBI and later the Douglas County Sheriff's Office.
November 5, 2014: a federal grand jury in Denver indicts Henthorn on one count of first-degree murder.
November 6, 2014: arrested in Highlands Ranch; initial appearance before a U.S. magistrate judge.
November 12, 2014: pleads not guilty; ordered held without bond as a flight risk.
Before trial: the district court admits evidence of two earlier incidents under Rule 404(b) and excludes a third.
September 8, 2015: testimony begins in the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado.
September 18, 2015: closing arguments; the case goes to the jury.
September 21, 2015: jury finds him guilty of first-degree murder.
December 8, 2015: sentenced to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole.
July 26, 2017: the Tenth Circuit affirms, 864 F.3d 1241.
January 8, 2018: the Supreme Court denies certiorari, No. 17-7008.
January 8, 2019: files a motion to vacate under 28 U.S.C. § 2255.
November 11, 2020: appointed counsel files a supplemental motion.
May 23, 2022: three-day evidentiary hearing begins.
June 23, 2022: motion to vacate denied; certificate of appealability refused.
September 5, 2023: the Tenth Circuit denies a certificate of appealability and dismisses the matter.