Haradin Bala

Victims
9 murders of Lapušnik camp detainees, July 1998. Also torture and cruel treatment, all as violations of the laws or customs of war (ICTY, 2005).
Years active
July 25 or 26, 1998
Location
Berishe/Beriša Mountains, Kosovo (killings); Lapušnik/Llapushnik, Kosovo (prison camp); Gornja Koretica, Kosovo (birth); The Hague, Netherlands (trial); France (prison)
Method
Shot (court finding for six of the nine; the cause of death of the other three was not identified)
Status
13 years' imprisonment (ICTY, November 30, 2005); appeal dismissed September 27, 2007; served in France from May 2008. Released early, December 31, 2012.

In the last days of July 1998, as Serbian forces advanced on the village of Lapušnik in central Kosovo, the Kosovo Liberation Army abandoned the prison camp it had been running there since the spring. The detainees still held in it, more than twenty of them, were marched under armed escort into the nearby Berishe Mountains. About half were set free and told to go. Nine of those who remained were murdered. Seven years later, judges of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia found that one of the guards who led that column, a KLA soldier the prisoners knew as Shala, had personally taken part in their murder.

That guard was Haradin Bala. On November 30, 2005, a Trial Chamber at The Hague convicted him of torture, cruel treatment and murder, all as violations of the laws or customs of war, and sentenced him to 13 years' imprisonment. In the same judgment it acquitted the two KLA commanders tried beside him. The ruling was the first the tribunal delivered on crimes in Kosovo, and it left Bala, a subordinate the court found had acted under orders from a superior it could never identify, as the only man held criminally responsible for what happened at Lapušnik. The Appeals Chamber rejected every ground of his appeal in September 2007. He served most of his sentence in France, was granted early release at the end of 2012 and died in January 2018.

A guard called Shala

Bala was born on June 10, 1957, in Gornja Koretica, a village known in Albanian as Koroticë e Epërme, in the municipality of Glogovac in central Kosovo. By the summer of 1998 he was a member of the Kosovo Liberation Army and, the tribunal later found, a guard at its prison camp in Lapušnik, roughly 25 kilometers west of Priština. Among the prisoners he was known as Shala.

His health would become a running thread in the case. Defense witnesses told the trial court that he had been in poor health for years before the war, and his defense leaned on that evidence heavily. Both courts rejected it, finding that his medical condition had not stopped him from performing physical duties for the KLA.

The camp at Lapušnik

The Trial Chamber found that the KLA held a prison camp in a farm compound in Lapušnik, and that in June and July 1998 mainly civilian prisoners, both Kosovo Albanian and Serbian, were held there. The identities of 27 detainees were firmly established at trial. Almost all were confined in one of two rooms, a small basement storage room and a room normally used as a cowshed. The judges found the conditions in those rooms appalling: food and water came irregularly and in inadequate amounts, there were no sanitary facilities, and no medical care was provided even though a doctor and a clinic used by KLA personnel were in a nearby village. The Chamber held that detaining a prisoner in such conditions was itself the crime of cruel treatment.

The camp also saw repeated individual violence. The Chamber identified twelve specific incidents in which named prisoners were taken from the detention rooms by KLA soldiers and severely mistreated, and it found that four of them amounted to torture. It also found that three prisoners had been murdered at the camp itself.

Bala's place in all of this was narrower than the prosecution had alleged. The judges stressed that he had no authority over the camp and that the prosecution never established who ran it. He was a guard. Shala, witnesses said, had relatively frequent contact with the prisoners; he generally held the keys and often brought the food and water. The Chamber found that he personally mistreated three prisoners and aided in another episode of mistreatment of one of them, that he aided in the torture of one prisoner, and that his day-to-day running of the prison played a personal role in maintaining and enforcing the inhumane conditions of detention. It also found a culture of violence in the camp, of which Bala was fully aware and which his own conduct helped to create and reinforce.

The prosecution failed, however, to prove that he was responsible for any of the three murders committed at the camp, and that count failed against him.

The last day of the camp

By late July 1998 Serbian forces were closing on Lapušnik, which they captured on July 26. The KLA abandoned the camp on July 25 or 26. The remaining detainees were escorted out on that last day by Bala and at least one other guard; the Chamber allowed that there may have been a third. In the Berishe Mountains, some of the prisoners were released and allowed to leave. The rest stayed under KLA guard.

The Chamber found that nine of them were murdered there by Bala and the other guard or guards, acting together. At least one of the prisoners who remained was not killed, but most were. The nine dead, as the tribunal named them, were Emin Emini, Ibush Hamza, Hyzri Harjizi, Shaban Hoti, Hasan Hoxha, Safet Hysenaj, Bashkim Rashiti, Lutfi Xhemshiti and Shyqyri Zymer. Each, the judges found, had been held as a prisoner of the KLA at Lapušnik, and each was among the group still under guard in the mountains after the others had been set free.

The Chamber held the killings to be the gravest part of Bala's criminal conduct. It also found that he had not acted on his own initiative. In marching the prisoners into the mountains, releasing some and killing nine, he had been acting under orders from a higher authority whose identity the evidence did not establish.

Indictment and arrest

In early 2003 the tribunal moved for the first time against members of the KLA. A sealed indictment, confirmed on January 27, named four former KLA members in connection with the Lapušnik camp: Bala; Fatmir Limaj, a former KLA commander, and Isak Musliu, alleged to have been a second commander, both of whom would be acquitted; and Agim Murtezi, against whom the charges were later withdrawn. They were the first Kosovo Albanians publicly indicted by the tribunal.

On February 17, 2003, troops of the NATO-led Kosovo Force arrested Bala and two of the other accused in Kosovo. They were transferred to the tribunal's detention unit in The Hague the next day, when the indictment was made public. The former commander, who had left Kosovo, was arrested by Slovenian authorities on February 18 and brought to The Hague in March. Bala appeared before the court for the first time on February 20, 2003, and pleaded not guilty to all charges.

The first indictment described Bala as a commander and guard at the camp and alleged that eleven detainees had been killed in the mountains. The prosecution twice amended it, and the final version charged the three remaining accused with taking part in a joint criminal enterprise aimed at civilians who resisted or refused to cooperate with the KLA. Against Bala it charged individual responsibility alone, not the command responsibility alleged against the other two: imprisonment, torture, inhumane acts and murder as crimes against humanity, and cruel treatment, torture and murder as violations of the laws or customs of war. The murders in the mountains were Count 10. Bala again pleaded not guilty to every count.

The trial

The trial opened on November 15, 2004, and closed in September 2005. Bala did not give sworn evidence. His defense rested on two propositions. The first was that the witnesses had the wrong man. The second was a partial alibi: that he had been somewhere else for much of the relevant period and that his health would not have allowed him to do what was alleged. A defense witness testified that he had seen Bala on July 26, 1998, in the village of Banjica, where, the witness said, Bala had been staying for several months.

The prosecution answered with former detainees who knew Shala from the camp and identified Bala as that guard. The Chamber treated the identification evidence with care, saying it was not satisfied of the honesty of every witness and examining the reliability of each identification. It found the evidence against Bala more extensive and more varied than the evidence against his co-accused, and it found one witness's identification particularly convincing.

Verdict

The Trial Chamber delivered its judgment on November 30, 2005. On the threshold questions it rejected much of the prosecution's case. It was satisfied that a state of armed conflict existed in Kosovo between Serbian forces and the KLA before the end of May 1998, the finding on which any war-crimes conviction depended. It found that KLA soldiers had abducted, detained and mistreated both Serbian and Kosovo Albanian civilians between May and July 1998, but that those acts had not been shown to be on the scale or of the nature needed to amount to a widespread or systematic attack on a civilian population. All five counts charged as crimes against humanity were therefore dismissed against all three accused. It dismissed Count 2, cruel treatment based on seizure, detention and interrogation, finding that those acts in themselves did not amount to a serious attack on human dignity. It found no proof of a joint criminal enterprise involving any of the accused.

The case against the two commanders failed on identification. The Chamber found it had not been proved beyond reasonable doubt that the former commander had any role in the camp or in the killings in the mountains, and that there was little evidence to tie the second man to the camp at all. Both were acquitted on every count and ordered released.

The case against Bala succeeded. The Chamber found beyond reasonable doubt that he was the guard known as Shala who took part in running the camp and who escorted the remaining prisoners into the mountains on July 25 or 26, 1998. It found him guilty on three counts:

Count 4, torture, a violation of the laws or customs of war under Article 3 of the Statute, for having aided the torture of a prisoner;

Count 6, cruel treatment, a violation of the laws or customs of war under Article 3, for having personally mistreated three prisoners and aided another episode of mistreatment of one of them, and for his personal role in maintaining and enforcing inhumane conditions of detention in the Lapušnik camp;

Count 10, murder, a violation of the laws or customs of war under Article 3, for having personally participated in the murder of nine detainees in the Berishe Mountains on July 25 or 26, 1998.

He was found not guilty on all other counts. Seven of the ten counts against him were dismissed.

Sentence

The Chamber imposed a single sentence of 13 years' imprisonment, with full credit for the time he had spent in custody since February 17, 2003. In setting it, the judges weighed his subordinate role. He had held no command or authority in the camp, and the evidence did not show that he had any authority over the KLA members around him or that he actively encouraged the mistreatment of detainees. Often, the judges found, he appeared to act on instructions from others. In the mountains he had been a soldier under orders. That did not excuse his conduct, the Chamber said, but it bore on how serious it was. The Chamber also heard that Bala had treated some detainees well, and it gave that evidence little weight, holding that any kindness he showed did not lessen the gravity of the crimes. It took into account the sentencing practice of the courts of the former Yugoslavia and the sentences the tribunal had imposed for similar crimes.

Appeals

Both sides appealed, and the prosecution also challenged the two acquittals. While the appeals were pending, the Appeals Chamber twice allowed Bala to return to Kosovo for short periods on compassionate grounds, in 2006.

Bala renewed his defense on appeal. He argued that the Trial Chamber had wrongly found him to be Shala, giving no weight to the failure of three eyewitnesses to pick him out of a photo spread and relying on identifications made in the courtroom. The Appeals Chamber agreed that the trial judges had erred in law by giving even slight weight to the in-court identifications, but it held that the error changed nothing, because the conviction rested on other evidence, above all the identification the trial court had found particularly convincing. He argued that he was physically incapable of walking the prisoners into the mountains; the appeals judges held that the trial court had reasonably found him capable, and they upheld the finding that he was present and directly involved in the killings, since no evidence suggested he had left before they took place. They found that the trial judges had correctly required the prosecution to eliminate any reasonable possibility that his alibi was true and had not held his silence against him. Two prosecution witnesses whose testimony differed from statements they had once given to Serbian authorities could still be believed, the Appeals Chamber held, because other witnesses corroborated much of what they said.

The prosecution's appeal against Bala failed as well. It had argued that he should have been held responsible as a member of a systemic joint criminal enterprise for the whole system of ill-treatment at the camp. The Appeals Chamber upheld the trial finding that the evidence did not identify a group of people sharing a common plan, and agreed that it could not be ruled out that rogue KLA soldiers or outsiders had mistreated or killed detainees for personal reasons such as revenge. It also rejected the argument that his 13-year sentence was manifestly inadequate. It found one error: the trial judges had counted his subordinate role twice in his favor. But that error was so slight as to be harmless, and the same sentence would have been imposed without it.

On September 27, 2007, the Appeals Chamber dismissed his appeal in its entirety, dismissed the prosecution's appeal, affirmed the acquittals of his co-accused, and affirmed his sentence of 13 years' imprisonment, subject to credit for the time he had already spent in detention.

Prison in France

On May 14, 2008, Bala was transferred to France to serve his sentence. Under the agreement between the United Nations and France on the enforcement of the tribunal's sentences, the conditions of his imprisonment were governed by French law, subject to the tribunal's supervision.

In 2009 the French authorities told the tribunal that Bala was eligible under French law for sentence reductions, which, if applied, would have brought his release date forward from February 17, 2016, to September 15, 2014. French reports described his conduct in detention as good: he had faced no disciplinary proceedings, his work in the prison workshops was satisfactory, and he had taken French lessons. A psychological report, however, found that he denied any involvement in the crimes of which he had been convicted and accepted the sentence as something imposed for political reasons. On October 15, 2010, the tribunal's President declined the reduction, citing his very limited demonstration of rehabilitation and the high gravity of his crimes.

Early release and death

In November 2011, having served more than two thirds of his sentence, Bala applied for early release. The President's decision, dated June 28, 2012, held that the crimes were of high gravity and that this weighed against release. It rejected Bala's argument that his crimes should be measured against those of other convicted men, noting that none of the nine prisoners he had cited had been convicted of murder. It treated his rehabilitation as neutral and his cooperation with the prosecution as irrelevant. What weighed for him was the time he had served: under the tribunal's consistent practice, completing two thirds of a sentence counted heavily toward release. The President granted early release but postponed it to December 31, 2012, on condition that Bala keep up good conduct in the meantime. Bala was released on December 31, 2012, having served almost ten years of his 13-year sentence.

He died in January 2018.

Disputed and unproven points

Bala never accepted the verdict. He contested his identification as Shala at trial and on appeal, offered a partial alibi and argued that his health made the alleged acts impossible. Both courts rejected those arguments. A psychological assessment supplied by the French authorities found that in prison he still denied any involvement.

The number of dead changed as the case moved from accusation to judgment. The first indictment alleged that eleven detainees were killed in the mountains; the trial court found nine murders proved. The prosecution also alleged that fourteen identified prisoners were murdered at the camp; the Chamber found three such murders proved and held Bala responsible for none of them.

The indictment called him a commander and guard. The court found he was a guard only, with no command or authority, and that he acted under orders from a superior whose identity was never established. The prosecution's theory that the camp was run as a joint criminal enterprise was rejected at trial and on appeal, and both courts allowed that rogue soldiers or outsiders may have committed some of the crimes at the camp for personal reasons.

Timeline

June 10, 1957: Haradin Bala is born in Gornja Koretica, Glogovac municipality, Kosovo.

May to July 1998: The KLA holds mainly civilian prisoners at a camp in Lapušnik.

July 25 or 26, 1998: The camp is abandoned; nine detainees are murdered in the Berishe Mountains.

July 26, 1998: Serbian forces capture Lapušnik.

January 27, 2003: The tribunal confirms a sealed indictment against Bala and three others.

February 17, 2003: KFOR troops arrest Bala in Kosovo.

February 18, 2003: He is transferred to The Hague; the indictment is made public.

February 20, 2003: He pleads not guilty to all charges.

November 15, 2004: The trial opens.

November 30, 2005: He is convicted of torture, cruel treatment and murder and sentenced to 13 years; his two co-accused are acquitted.

September 27, 2007: The Appeals Chamber dismisses his appeal and the prosecution's, and affirms the sentence.

May 14, 2008: Bala is transferred to France to serve his sentence.

October 15, 2010: The tribunal's President declines a French sentence reduction.

June 28, 2012: The President grants early release, effective December 31, 2012.

December 31, 2012: Bala is released.

January 2018: Bala dies.