Hakimullah Mehsud

Victims
7 American citizens killed near Khost, Afghanistan, 2009. Charged in a United States complaint (conspiracy), never tried; other attacks attributed to his group.
Years active
December 30, 2009 (the attack charged in the U.S. complaint)
Location
Khost, Afghanistan (killings); Kotkai, South Waziristan, Pakistan (residence); North Waziristan, Pakistan (death)
Method
Bombing by another man, Humam Khalil Abu Mulal al-Balawi; the U.S. complaint alleged Mehsud's part in a conspiracy (never tried)
Status
Never tried; designated a Specially Designated Global Terrorist, 2010; $5 million U.S. reward. Killed in North Waziristan, Pakistan, November 1, 2013; died untried.

Hakimullah Mehsud led Tehrik-e Taliban Pakistan, the armed alliance the United States designated a foreign terrorist organization in 2010, from August 2009 until he was killed on November 1, 2013. He was never arrested and never stood trial anywhere. The only killings for which any court process named him took place on December 30, 2009, at a U.S. military base near the town of Khost, in eastern Afghanistan, where seven American citizens died and six more were injured. A criminal complaint filed in Washington in August 2010 charged him with conspiracy to murder U.S. citizens abroad and conspiracy to use a weapon of mass destruction (explosives) against U.S. citizens abroad, alleging his involvement in those seven deaths. A complaint is a formal accusation and nothing more, and this one never came before a jury.

Around him stood a much larger record of violence that belongs to his group rather than to any verdict. Under his command the organization claimed, or was blamed by Pakistani and American officials for, attacks across Pakistan that left hundreds dead. He was declared dead several times before it was true, and he twice reappeared on tape after governments had written him off. He was killed in North Waziristan three weeks after telling an interviewer that his movement was ready for serious talks with the government of Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif. The charges against him died with him.

Kotkai and the road to Baitullah

He was born in South Waziristan, by one account near Jandola, and in August 2009 he was believed to be about 28 years old. He grew up in the Kotkai area of South Waziristan and belonged to the Ishangi branch of the Mehsud tribe, a smaller and less influential branch than that of the man he would succeed. He studied to the eighth class at a government middle school for boys in Kotkai, kept a small shop there for a time, and attended a madrassa in the village of Shahu, in Hangu district, which he left before finishing.

The name the world came to know was not the one he started with. By most accounts he was known first as Jamshed. As the spokesman for Baitullah Mehsud, the founder of Tehrik-e Taliban Pakistan, he used the name Zulfiqar, and he took the name Hakimullah as he rose to lead the movement. The U.S. sanctions listing carried both forms, recording him as Hakimullah Mehsud, also known as Hakeemullah Mehsud, also known as Zulfiqar.

He joined the Taliban in Afghanistan in the late 1990s and trained with them in the last years of their government there, then returned to Waziristan after the Taliban fell in 2001. Around 2004, when Baitullah Mehsud emerged as a leader of the militants in South Waziristan, the younger man went to work as his driver. He became a confidant. In October 2007 Baitullah named him chief spokesman, and it was under the name Zulfiqar Mehsud that his voice first reached newspapers.

That same year he made his reputation in the field. Accounts of the period tied the capture of about 300 Pakistani soldiers in 2007, the biggest success the Pakistani Taliban had achieved to that point, to his command, and his standing among the militants rose with it.

Commander in Orakzai, Kurram and Khyber

Early in 2008 Baitullah gave him three tribal agencies along the Afghan border to run: Khyber, Kurram and Orakzai. He replaced the group's earlier commander in Orakzai, who broke away and formed a rival militia, and by the end of 2008 he held a commanding position across the three agencies, in part through his hold on the smuggling and supply routes that ran through them.

Those routes carried the cargo that fed the U.S. and NATO war in Afghanistan, and the trucks became his signature target. Reports tied him to a long series of attacks on supply convoys moving through Peshawar and the Khyber Agency, and the U.S. affidavit filed against him in 2010 listed numerous attacks on NATO supply lines across the tribal areas among the acts in which the group had alleged roles or claimed responsibility. In November 2008 he received Western journalists in Orakzai, claimed that his men had destroyed more than 600 trucks and shipping containers bound for NATO forces, and showed them an armored U.S. Humvee taken from a military convoy. In December 2008 he imposed his own rule in Orakzai, including a levy on the agency's Sikh and Hindu residents.

By 2009 his name was attached to attacks well beyond the border agencies. He claimed responsibility for the attack on the Pearl Continental hotel in Peshawar on June 9, 2009, in which at least 15 people were killed, and reports linked him to the attack on the visiting Sri Lankan cricket team in Lahore earlier that year. The government of Pakistan offered a reward of 10 million rupees for him.

Succession in August 2009

Baitullah Mehsud was killed in a U.S. strike in South Waziristan in early August 2009. For weeks the movement denied that its founder was dead, and the denial left room for rumor about who would follow him. Pakistani officials announced on August 10 that Hakimullah himself had died; hours later a journalist spoke with him.

On August 25, 2009, two Pakistani Taliban commanders admitted that Baitullah was dead and announced that Hakimullah had been chosen to lead. Another commander said a council of 42 members had selected him unanimously at a meeting in South Waziristan. The selection followed about three weeks of internal struggle.

Reports of his own death did not stop. In early September Pakistani forces said they had detained a man who claimed to have killed him, and at the start of October a Pakistani newspaper wrote that he had probably died. He answered by meeting reporters in person.

The autumn of 2009

The weeks after his succession brought a wave of violence inside Pakistan that officials laid at the door of his movement. The U.S. affidavit later listed the September 2009 attack on the police station in Bannu among the acts in which the group had an alleged role or claimed responsibility. In October came an attack on a United Nations office in Islamabad on October 5, an assault on the army's General Headquarters in Rawalpindi on October 10, coordinated attacks in Lahore on October 15 that killed more than 30 people and were claimed by the group, the assassination of an army brigadier in Islamabad on October 22, and, on October 28, an attack in Peshawar that killed more than 100 people and for which the movement was blamed. That last attack came hours after U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton arrived in Islamabad.

The Pakistani army answered with a ground offensive in South Waziristan that autumn. It killed hundreds of Taliban fighters but neither caught nor killed the man who led them.

Khost, December 30, 2009

The attack that brought an American charge against him took place at a U.S. military base near Khost, a short distance from the Pakistani border, on December 30, 2009. The man who carried it out was Humam Khalil Abu Mulal al-Balawi, a Jordanian physician also known as Abu Dujanah al-Khorasani. Jordanian intelligence had cultivated him, and the Americans had come to treat him as a source. Seven U.S. citizens were killed and six more injured; al-Balawi died with them.

The seven Americans worked for the Central Intelligence Agency, and the chief of the base was among them. Two were contract employees. The agency, as a rule, does not name its dead, but within a week the names of four of them had become public: Harold E. Brown Jr., of Massachusetts; Scott Michael Roberson, of Ohio, who was new to the agency; Jeremy Wise, of Arkansas; and Elizabeth Hanson, who was from Illinois. The dead also included an officer of Jordan's intelligence service, Ali bin Zaid. For the agency it was the second deadliest attack in its history.

Within days both al-Qaeda and the Taliban had claimed the attack.

The video

On Saturday, January 9, 2010, a privately owned Pakistani television channel broadcast a video about a minute and a half long, and other networks carried it within hours. It showed al-Balawi in Afghan dress, seated beside Hakimullah Mehsud. The recording did not say where it was filmed.

The U.S. affidavit filed the following summer made the video the center of its case. It alleged that the media arm of Tehrik-e Taliban Pakistan released the recording soon after the attack; that in it Hakimullah Mehsud introduced al-Balawi and stated the Jordanian's reasons for the attack; and that the two men claimed responsibility together for an attack still to come. The affidavit added that the group itself had claimed the Khost attack.

Dead, then alive

The response came quickly. On January 14, 2010, a U.S. strike in Pakistan's tribal areas killed 18 people, and Hakimullah Mehsud was said to be among them. An audio message released by the Taliban said he was unhurt. On January 31 Pakistani television said he had died on January 17. The group rejected the account. In February, U.S. officials speaking without their names said he had died of wounds from the January strike, and Pakistani officials said the same. By late April, Pakistani intelligence officials had concluded that he had only been injured.

On May 3, 2010, a nine-minute video surfaced that showed him alive. Monitoring groups dated it to April 4; an audio message dated April 19 appeared with it. A U.S. defense spokesman said it was unclear whether he was alive or dead.

The video arrived in the same week as another claim. On May 1, 2010, an attempted attack in Times Square, New York, had failed, and a separate Pakistani Taliban recording claimed responsibility. The man arrested for it, Faisal Shahzad, later pleaded guilty and said he had received training and $12,000 from Tehrik-e Taliban Pakistan. No one was killed or injured in Times Square, and no American charge against Mehsud rested on it.

The group's violence inside Pakistan continued through that spring. In May 2010 attacks in Lahore killed nearly 100 members of the Ahmadi community, and those killings too were attributed to the Pakistani Taliban.

The case in Washington

On August 20, 2010, federal prosecutors filed a criminal complaint against him in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. It was kept sealed until September 1, 2010, when the Justice Department announced it. The complaint charged Hakimullah Mehsud, also known as Hakimullah Mahsud, with conspiracy to murder U.S. citizens abroad and conspiracy to use a weapon of mass destruction (explosives) against U.S. citizens abroad, both arising from his alleged involvement in the murder of the seven Americans near Khost.

The affidavit filed in support of the complaint described him as a resident of the Federally Administered Tribal Areas of Pakistan and the leader of Tehrik-e Taliban Pakistan, a post he had inherited after Baitullah Mehsud was killed in August 2009. It set out the group's alleged roles in, or claims of responsibility for, a series of acts of violence: the assassination of former Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto in December 2007, the September 2009 attack on the Bannu police station, and the attacks on NATO supply lines. It said the group had claimed both the Khost attack and the failed attempt in Times Square. The Justice Department described him as a fugitive believed to be living in the tribal areas.

The same day, the Federal Register published the State Department's designations, and the Treasury Department added him to its sanctions list, entering his year of birth as 1979. Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton had signed the documents on August 12, 2010. Tehrik-e Taliban Pakistan was designated a foreign terrorist organization and a Specially Designated Global Terrorist. Hakimullah Mehsud was designated a Specially Designated Global Terrorist in Public Notice 7143, which found that he "committed, or poses a significant risk of committing, acts of terrorism that threaten the security of U.S. nationals or the national security, foreign policy, or economy of the United States." His deputy, Wali ur Rehman, was designated in the same terms. The State Department's Rewards for Justice program offered up to $5 million each for information leading to the location of the two men, and in 2013 the offer still stood.

No arrest followed, and the complaint never reached a courtroom. His death in 2013 ended any prospect that it would.

The last years

For three more years he led a movement that, by the time of his death, was blamed for the deaths of thousands of civilians and members of the security forces in Pakistan. Under his leadership, profiles published at his death reported, the group drew closer to al-Qaeda and to other armed organizations, and paid for its operations in part through extortion, kidnapping and bank robbery.

The pressure on his command grew in 2013. In May a drone strike killed Wali ur Rehman, his second in command. The movement responded by rejecting talks with the government and accusing it of cooperating with the United States. In October 2013 U.S. forces in Afghanistan took custody of Latif Mehsud, a senior lieutenant.

The new government in Islamabad, elected that May, wanted negotiations. On October 9, 2013, Mehsud gave an interview in which he said his movement believed in serious talks but that the government had taken no real step toward them. He said a credible ceasefire depended on an end to U.S. drone strikes on Pakistani territory, offered security to any negotiating council the government sent, and denied that his men were behind recent attacks on crowded public places. On October 31 Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif said a process to begin talks had started. A delegation was due to travel to North Waziristan on Saturday, November 2.

November 1, 2013

On Friday, November 1, 2013, Hakimullah Mehsud was killed in North Waziristan. Pakistani intelligence officials and militant sources confirmed his death that day, and a senior U.S. intelligence official said the United States had received positive confirmation of it. The next day the movement's spokesman in South Waziristan gave the group's first formal confirmation. The delegation's trip was canceled.

A council of the movement named Sheharyar Mehsud as caretaker chief. On November 7, 2013, it chose Mullah Fazlullah, the leader of the Taliban in the Swat valley, as Hakimullah's successor, and the group's spokesman announced that there would be no more talks.

Hakimullah Mehsud was never arrested, never extradited and never tried. He died untried, and the charge that he took part in the murder of seven Americans near Khost stands as an allegation that no court examined.

Disputed and unproven points

No court ever found Hakimullah Mehsud responsible for any death. The Khost charge rests on the affidavit and on the video in which he appears beside the Jordanian attacker, a recording that never said where it was made.

The attacks in Pakistan laid at his movement's door rest on its own claims or on statements by Pakistani and American officials, not on any verdict against him. He himself denied, in October 2013, that his men were behind recent attacks on public places.

His names do not line up neatly. One account gives his birth name as Zulfiqar and treats Hakimullah as a name adopted later; others give his first name as Jamshed and Zulfiqar as the name he used as spokesman. His year of birth appears as 1979 in the U.S. sanctions listing and as about 1980 elsewhere.

The count of the dead at Khost also varies with the account. The U.S. complaint concerns seven American citizens. Most accounts add a Jordanian intelligence officer; the earliest reports added an Afghan man instead.

Timeline

About 1979 or 1980: Born in South Waziristan, Pakistan.

Late 1990s: Joins the Taliban in Afghanistan.

About 2004: Becomes Baitullah Mehsud's driver.

October 2007: Named chief spokesman of the Pakistani Taliban, using the name Zulfiqar.

Early 2008: Given command of the Khyber, Kurram and Orakzai agencies.

November 2008: Meets Western journalists in Orakzai and claims attacks on NATO supply convoys.

June 9, 2009: Claims the attack on the Pearl Continental hotel in Peshawar; at least 15 dead.

August 2009: Baitullah Mehsud killed in a U.S. strike; Pakistani officials wrongly announce Hakimullah's death on August 10.

August 25, 2009: Named leader of Tehrik-e Taliban Pakistan.

October 2009: Attacks in Islamabad, Rawalpindi, Lahore and Peshawar attributed to the group; more than 100 dead in Peshawar on October 28.

December 30, 2009: Seven U.S. citizens killed and six injured at a U.S. base near Khost, Afghanistan; a Jordanian intelligence officer also dies.

January 9, 2010: Video showing him seated beside the Khost attacker is broadcast.

January 14, 2010: U.S. strike in the tribal areas; he is reported dead.

May 1, 2010: Failed attempt in Times Square, New York, claimed by the group.

May 3, 2010: New video shows him alive.

August 12, 2010: Secretary of State signs the designations of the group and of Mehsud.

August 20, 2010: Criminal complaint filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.

September 1, 2010: Complaint unsealed; designations published; reward of up to $5 million announced.

May 2013: Deputy Wali ur Rehman killed in a drone strike.

October 9, 2013: Says in an interview that the group is ready for serious talks.

November 1, 2013: Killed in North Waziristan; never tried.

November 7, 2013: Mullah Fazlullah chosen to succeed him.