Günther Tschanun

Victims
4 murders and 1 attempted murder, Zurich, April 16, 1986; convicted of murder and attempted murder, 1990 (first judgment, 1988: fourfold intentional killing).
Years active
April 16, 1986
Location
Zurich, Switzerland (killings and trials); Burgundy, France (arrest); Vienna, Austria (birth); Losone, Ticino, Switzerland (death).
Method
Shot with a revolver (four killed; a fifth man wounded).
Status
17 years' penitentiary (1988); raised to 20 years' penitentiary, August 31, 1990. Conditionally released January 2000; lived free until his death in Ticino, Switzerland, February 25, 2015.

On the morning of April 16, 1986, Günther Tschanun, the head of the building police of the city of Zurich, killed four men who worked under him and seriously injured a fifth, a department head who survived. Then he left Switzerland. For about three weeks a senior official of the country's largest city was a fugitive, until he was arrested in Burgundy, France, in May 1986.

The legal battle that came next was never about the facts. Tschanun did not deny the killings. The fight was over what to call them, and it ran through two Zurich judgments and a ruling of Switzerland's highest court before it was settled.

Tschanun was born in Vienna on September 13, 1941, and trained as an architect. He was working in Bern, with no experience of leading a large staff, when the member of the Zurich city government responsible for the building department brought him to Zurich, about two years before the killings, and made him chief of the Baupolizei, the city's building police. Despite its name, the post was an administrative one inside the building department, and it called for legal knowledge as well as an architect's training.

The appointment went badly almost from the start. Cases piled up, and instead of drawing on the experienced officials beneath him, he withdrew into his own office. Several of his subordinates set out their objections to his leadership in an internal written complaint, and Tschanun learned of it.

The killings took place at his workplace in Zurich. All four dead men were his subordinates, and all four were among his closest colleagues in the department. They were public servants at work on an ordinary weekday morning, and the complaint they had helped put on paper would sit at the center of every legal argument that followed. The fifth man, the department head, was seriously injured and lived.

The case came before the Obergericht, the cantonal high court of Zurich, about two years later. The prosecution asked for a conviction for murder. On February 29, 1988, a majority of the judges declined to find it. They convicted Tschanun of fourfold intentional killing and sentenced him to 17 years in the penitentiary. Central to the majority's reasoning was the view that the victims bore part of the responsibility for the situation in the department, a line of argument that became known as the bullying theory.

The prosecution appealed to the Federal Court. At the end of January 1990, its cassation division quashed the Zurich judgment, rejected any notion that the dead men had shared responsibility for what was done to them, and held that the crime had to be treated as murder. The case went back to Zurich. On August 31, 1990, the Obergericht convicted Tschanun of murder and attempted murder, the attempted murder covering the department head who survived, and raised his sentence by three years, to 20 years in the penitentiary.

He was conditionally released in January 2000 after 14 years, settled in the canton of Ticino under a new name, and died there in an accident on February 25, 2015, a death that became public only in April 2021.

The central dispute in the case was legal rather than factual. Tschanun did not deny that he had killed his staff. What was contested was his state of mind and the weight to be given to the conflict in his office. The first Zurich court accepted that the victims bore part of the responsibility for the situation that preceded the killings. The Federal Court rejected that finding outright, and the final conviction for murder rests on the Federal Court's view, not on any share of blame placed on the four men.

Timeline

September 13, 1941: Günther Tschanun is born in Vienna, Austria.

About two years before the killings: He is brought from Bern to Zurich and made head of the city building police.

Before April 1986: Members of his staff put an internal complaint about his leadership in writing; he learns of it.

April 16, 1986: He kills four men on his staff in Zurich, seriously injures a fifth, and leaves for France.

May 1986: He is arrested in Burgundy, France, about three weeks later.

February 29, 1988: The Zurich Obergericht convicts him of fourfold intentional killing and sentences him to 17 years in the penitentiary.

Late January 1990: The Federal Court's cassation division quashes the judgment and requires a conviction for murder.

August 31, 1990: The Zurich Obergericht convicts him of murder and attempted murder and raises the sentence to 20 years.

January 2000: He is conditionally released after 14 years.

February 25, 2015: He dies in an accident in Ticino.

April 2021: His death becomes public.