On the morning of Wednesday, March 13, 2019, eight people were killed within minutes of one another in Suzano, a city on the eastern edge of Greater São Paulo, about 55 kilometers from the center of the capital. The first was Jorge Antônio de Moraes, killed elsewhere in the city shortly before the violence reached a state school. At the school five pupils died, and with them two women who worked at the school, Marilena Ferreira Vieira Umezo and Eliana Regina de Oliveira Xavier; one of them knew both attackers as former pupils. Eleven more people were wounded, by the final count of the state's Public Security Secretariat. By the time it was over, ten people were dead.
São Paulo state authorities and the Civil Police attributed all eight deaths to two former pupils of the school, Guilherme Taucci Monteiro, 17, and Luiz Henrique de Castro, 25. The first victim, they said, was Monteiro's own uncle, and when the police reached the school Monteiro killed de Castro and then himself, a sequence the official report on the two deaths later confirmed.
Monteiro was born on July 13, 2001. Because he and de Castro died that morning, no court ever weighed the evidence against either of them. Monteiro was never charged, never tried and never convicted, and nothing said about what he did that day was ever tested by a defense.
The proceedings that followed concerned other people. On March 14 the Civil Police named a third suspect, a 17-year-old former classmate of Monteiro who had not gone to the school that day, and accused him of helping to plan the attack and of encouraging and supporting it. Questioned by a prosecutor in Suzano the next day, he denied any involvement and was released. On March 19, on a judge's order, he was taken into provisional juvenile detention for 45 days at a unit of Fundação Casa, the São Paulo state agency that holds juveniles. His defense denied that he had any part in the attack. Because he was a minor, the evidence in his case was placed under judicial secrecy.
Four men were accused over supplying a weapon; in February 2020 the 2nd Criminal Court of Suzano ruled that none of them would answer for homicide, convicting two of an offense under the arms law, releasing a third pending appeal and acquitting the fourth.
No court ever ruled on what Guilherme Taucci Monteiro did. The attribution of the eight deaths to him and de Castro, and the account that he killed de Castro before his own death, rest on the investigation alone, and none of it was answered by a defense. No tribunal ever settled a motive.
The part of the third suspect also remains contested. The police alleged that he helped to plan and encouraged the attack; he denied it to the prosecutor, and his defense denied any involvement.
July 13, 2001: Guilherme Taucci Monteiro is born.
March 13, 2019: Monteiro's uncle is killed in Suzano, and seven more people are killed at a state school in the city, where eleven others are wounded. Monteiro and Luiz Henrique de Castro die the same morning.
March 14, 2019: The Civil Police name a 17-year-old former classmate of Monteiro as a third suspect.
March 15, 2019: Questioned by a prosecutor, the third suspect denies involvement and is released.
March 19, 2019: On a judge's order he is taken into 45 days of provisional juvenile detention.
February 28, 2020: The 2nd Criminal Court of Suzano rules that four men accused over supplying a weapon will not answer for homicide; two are convicted of an arms-law offense.