Graham Frederick Young: The Teacup Poisoner

Victims
2 co-workers died in Hertfordshire, 1971; convicted of murder. In 1962 convicted of poisoning his sister, father and a schoolfellow, who recovered. Stepmother's death never charged
Years active
1961 to 1962 (family and schoolfellow); 1971 (Bovingdon)
Location
London (Central Criminal Court, 1962); Broadmoor Hospital; Slough and Bovingdon, near Hemel Hempstead, Hertfordshire (1971); Sheerness, Kent (arrest); St Albans (trial).
Method
Poisoning. Thallium is the poison linked with his name in the historical literature and was found on him at his arrest
Status
1962: Broadmoor hospital order, no release for 15 years without the Home Secretary's consent; conditionally discharged 1971. 1972: life imprisonment. Died at Parkhurst, August 1, 1990

Graham Young was convicted twice of poisoning people close to him. The first time he was 14. In July 1962 the Central Criminal Court in London found him guilty of poisoning his sister, his father and a schoolfellow, all of whom recovered, and found him to be suffering from psychopathic disorder. He was sent to Broadmoor, a special hospital, under an order that he could not be released for 15 years without the Home Secretary's consent.

In February 1971, aged 23, he was conditionally discharged on the advice of the doctor responsible for him, who had reported the previous summer that he had changed profoundly and was no longer a danger to others. Within months men at the firm where he found work near Hemel Hempstead, in Hertfordshire, began to fall ill. Two of them died. On June 29, 1972, a jury at St Albans Crown Court convicted him of murder and other offenses and he was sentenced to life imprisonment.

That day the Home Secretary, Reginald Maudling, went to the House of Commons to explain how a man found to be dangerous as a boy had come to be living and working freely in the community. He announced two inquiries. The first, a review of how restricted patients were discharged and supervised, reported in January 1973 and led to a new independent board to advise on difficult cases. The second, a committee under Lord Butler of Saffron Walden, examined how the criminal law dealt with mentally disordered offenders and reported in 1975. Young spent the rest of his life in custody and died in his cell at Parkhurst prison on the Isle of Wight on August 1, 1990.

Early years

An undated HertsLive feature on the case gives his year of birth as 1947 and says he was a gifted science pupil whose classmates called him the "Mad Professor." He lived with his father, his stepmother and his sister.

What the official record establishes is narrower. By the spring of 1962, when he was 14, he had given poison to three people: his sister, his father and a boy at his school. That is the case on which he was later convicted. The Home Secretary told Parliament in 1972 that all three recovered.

His stepmother

His stepmother died before his arrest in 1962, in the order of events given by the HertsLive feature. Her death was not one of the counts against him. The three counts on which he was convicted that summer, as the Home Secretary later set them out, concerned only his sister, his father and the schoolfellow.

The HertsLive feature says her death was put down at the time to injuries from a bus accident the year before, and that the true cause was never established. No court ever examined whether Young was responsible, and he was never charged with any offense connected with her death.

In May 1962 a science teacher at his school found poisons and notes about well-known poisoners in his desk, according to the HertsLive feature, and Young confessed to giving poison to his sister, his father and a friend. He was charged on three counts.

The Central Criminal Court, July 1962

The case was heard at the Central Criminal Court, the Old Bailey, in July 1962. Young was convicted on three counts of causing grievous bodily harm by administering poison. The court found that he was suffering from psychopathic disorder. It made two orders under the Mental Health Act, 1959: one for his detention in Broadmoor, and a restriction order providing that he could not be discharged without the Home Secretary's consent for 15 years.

Under the restriction order, the hospital could not release him on its own authority; the Home Secretary had to consent. In 1972 Maudling told the Commons that, had Young been dealt with as a sane offender, his offenses would have carried a prison sentence of about seven or eight years. The restriction order ran to 1977.

He was 14, and in 1972 one member of the House of Lords, Baroness Bacon, asked why there had been nowhere other than Broadmoor to send a boy of that age, and called for separate arrangements for young offenders.

Broadmoor

Maudling told the Commons in 1972 that progress in Young's treatment was slow at first. Six consultant psychiatrists worked there, with about 50 years' experience between them, according to Christopher Mayhew, who spoke in the same debate; Lady Ruthven of Freeland told the Lords that the hospital was also short of nurses.

In June 1970 the responsible medical officer, the consultant in charge of Young's care, reported that there had been profound changes in him and that he was no longer a danger to others. The HertsLive feature quotes doctors at that time as saying he was "no longer obsessed with poisons, violence and mischief." That report was the basis for his conditional discharge.

Conditional discharge, February 1971

Young left Broadmoor in February 1971, aged 23. A conditional discharge was not a full release. He had to live at an address approved for him, report to a probation officer who supervised him, and attend a psychiatric outpatient clinic as directed. He remained liable to be recalled to hospital at any time until the restriction order expired in 1977. Mayhew told the Commons that he also kept in contact with the Broadmoor consultant who had treated him.

He first went to the Government Training Centre at Slough. From there he moved to a job with a firm near Hemel Hempstead, at Bovingdon, in Hertfordshire. The government's statement in 1972 said he had complied with the conditions of his discharge and had given his supervisors no grounds for suspicion. It also said that his interest in poisons had resumed almost immediately after he left the hospital.

Maudling was asked by David Steel whether Young had been placed as a storekeeper at a chemical factory. He answered that Young had not obtained poisons through his employment. Whether employers should be told about such histories became one of the questions raised after the trial. In the House of Lords, Lord Byers argued that employers often had no access to the medical histories of the people they hired and called for an inquiry into whether medical confidentiality was serving the public.

Bovingdon, 1971

In 1971 men who worked with Young at the Bovingdon firm began to fall ill. The illness was blamed at first on a virus that people in the area called the "Bovingdon Bug," according to the HertsLive feature. Young made tea and coffee for colleagues, the HertsLive feature says.

Two men died that year. One was Fred Biggs, who fell ill a second time, the HertsLive feature reports, and was moved to a specialist neurological hospital in London, where he died.

Other workers became ill and recovered. When the trial opened, the Watford Observer reported that Young was accused of poisoning eight people, seven of whom worked with him, in a June 1972 report reproduced by the Hertfordshire Police Historical Society.

The government said in 1972 that his employers had no reason at first to connect the illnesses at the firm with him.

Arrest at Sheerness

After his flat was searched, he was arrested on November 21, 1971, at Sheerness, in Kent, where police found thallium on him, according to the HertsLive feature. The same feature says diaries he kept were part of the evidence against him.

Thallium is the substance with which his name has been most closely linked ever since. John Emsley opens his chapter on Young, in his history of poison The Elements of Murder, with the observation that Young is the one multiple murderer whose name will always be tied to it.

St Albans Crown Court, June 1972

The trial opened at St Albans Crown Court in June 1972. Young pleaded not guilty to two counts of murder, two of attempted murder and two of administering poison, according to the HertsLive feature. A June 23, 1972, Watford Observer report, reproduced by the Hertfordshire Police Historical Society, described him as a 24-year-old foreman and said the prosecution told the jury the victims appeared to have been used as "human guinea pigs."

The HertsLive feature says the evidence of a toxicology expert, John Cavanagh, was central to the prosecution case. It also records Young's answer when he was asked whether he felt remorse: "What I feel is the emptiness of my soul."

On June 29, 1972, the jury convicted him. The Lord Chancellor, Quintin Hogg, told the House of Lords that Young had been convicted at St Albans Crown Court that day of murder and other grave offenses. He was sentenced to life imprisonment.

Statements to Parliament, June 29, 1972

Maudling's statement to the Commons set out the history of the case in plain terms: the 1962 convictions, the order and restriction, the June 1970 report, the February 1971 discharge, the conditions, the jobs at Slough and near Hemel Hempstead. "The safety of the public must be the paramount consideration," he said, "and no patient is discharged unless it is considered safe to do so."

He gave figures. More than 300 patients had been released from Broadmoor in the previous 12 years, he said, and Young was the only one known to have committed a further homicide while under supervision. In the Lords, the Lord Chancellor put the number of patients discharged to the community on the Home Secretary's authority since 1960 at 331, and said that apart from Young two had later killed, both long after their supervision had ended.

Maudling announced changes that had already been made. No restricted patient would be discharged from a special hospital until the responsible medical officer had a concurring recommendation from a second experienced consultant psychiatrist. Supervision, including psychiatric supervision, had been strengthened, and supervising officers were to keep in touch with employers, who were to be told enough to report anything that caused concern.

"Poisoning is a unique crime," he told the House. He accepted that the only way to guarantee absolute safety would have been to keep a young man in Broadmoor for the rest of his life. "We have nothing to conceal," he said, when members pressed for a public inquiry with power to summon witnesses. Shirley Williams, Enoch Powell, David Steel and Harold Wilson were among those who questioned him.

In the Lords, the Lord Chancellor defended those who had supervised Young. He said Young had been adequately supervised and had hidden his renewed interest in poisons with considerable ingenuity. Henry Brooke, a former Home Secretary, spoke of how hard such release decisions were. Baroness Wootton of Abinger asked for public figures on serious offenses by people released from Broadmoor.

The Aarvold review

The first inquiry was a review of the procedures for discharging and supervising patients under special restrictions. Its members were Sir Carl Aarvold, the Recorder of London; Professor Sir Denis Hill of the Institute of Psychiatry; and G. P. Newton, director of social services for Wiltshire. Maudling said they would have full access to the file on Young and would advise whether the procedures as improved were adequate, or whether more should be done within the existing law.

In October 1972 Shirley Williams asked when the committee would report. The Home Secretary, now Robert Carr, said he expected to receive the report within weeks. It was published as a Command paper on January 23, 1973. Carr told the Commons that the government accepted its recommendations in principle and would put them into effect as quickly as it could. Among them was an independent board to advise the Home Secretary on discharging or transferring patients from special hospitals in cases that needed special care. A working party was to define which cases those were, and the new procedures were expected to be fully working by that summer.

H. R. Rollin, of Horton Hospital in Epsom, writing in the Journal of Medical Ethics in 1976, noted that the Aarvold committee had reported swiftly and had been concerned with tightening the existing provisions.

The second and wider inquiry was a committee chaired by Lord Butler of Saffron Walden. It was asked to look at how the criminal law treated people who were mentally disordered or abnormal, at trial, on conviction and in sentencing, and at the treatment and aftercare available to them. Rollin recorded that it made its final report in 1975. Writing to a Commons committee in 2000, Peter Snowden, then acting medical director of a Salford mental health trust, described the Young case as the one that led to that joint Home Office and health department report.

The Young case had effects beyond the two reports. In an article in the Psychiatric Bulletin, G. Robertson traced how the use of restriction orders changed in the following years. The number of restricted patients admitted to ordinary local psychiatric hospitals had been fairly steady for 12 years before 1973, he wrote, but then fell quickly, to fewer than 30 orders by 1977. Robertson thought this might be linked to the publicity around the case of the former Broadmoor patient, though he wrote that a direct link could not be established, and suggested it may have been the last straw for long-standing unease about restricted patients in local hospitals.

Young served his life sentence in prison. He died in his cell at Parkhurst prison, on the Isle of Wight, on August 1, 1990. The HertsLive feature gives that date and records the cause as a myocardial infarction, a heart attack. The HertsLive feature says that suggestions he was poisoned, by other prisoners or by his own hand, have never been resolved.

Disputed and unproven points

His stepmother. Young was never charged with any offense connected with his stepmother's death, and no court considered it. Claims that he caused it rest on later accounts, not on any finding.

Broadmoor. The HertsLive feature says Young was suspected of poisoning patients and staff at Broadmoor and that a patient who died there of cyanide poisoning was classed as a suicide. No charge was brought and no official finding links Young to that death.

The number of people harmed. The HertsLive feature says his diaries recorded about 70 people affected. No official source gives that figure; the 1972 trial concerned eight people, according to the Watford Observer report.

His death. The recorded cause was a heart attack. Suggestions that he was poisoned are speculation and have no official support.

Timeline

1947: Graham Frederick Young is born.

1962: His stepmother dies, before his arrest. He is never charged in connection with her death.

May 1962: Arrested, aged 14, after poisons are found at his school.

July 1962: Convicted at the Central Criminal Court on three counts of causing grievous bodily harm by administering poison (his sister, his father and a schoolfellow); found to have psychopathic disorder; ordered detained in Broadmoor with a 15-year restriction on discharge.

June 1970: The responsible medical officer reports that he is no longer a danger to others.

February 1971: Conditionally discharged, aged 23, to live at an approved address under the supervision of a probation officer, with psychiatric outpatient care. Goes to the Government Training Centre at Slough, then to a firm at Bovingdon, near Hemel Hempstead.

1971: Workers at the Bovingdon firm fall ill; two men die, one of them Fred Biggs.

November 21, 1971: Arrested at Sheerness, Kent.

June 1972: Trial opens at St Albans Crown Court.

June 29, 1972: Convicted of murder and other offenses; sentenced to life imprisonment. The Home Secretary announces the Aarvold review and the Butler Committee.

October 24, 1972: The government tells the Commons the Aarvold report is expected within weeks.

January 23, 1973: The Aarvold report is published; the government accepts its recommendations in principle, including an independent advisory board on discharges.

1975: The Butler Committee makes its final report.

1977: The 1962 restriction order would have expired.

August 1, 1990: Young dies in his cell at Parkhurst prison, Isle of Wight; the recorded cause is a heart attack.