Ghulam Azam

Victims
4 murders found as crimes against humanity, Brahmanbaria, 1971; also convicted of conspiracy, planning, incitement and complicity in crimes against humanity and genocide
Years active
March to December 1971; the four murders on November 21, 1971
Location
Brahmanbaria, Bangladesh, then East Pakistan (killings); Dhaka, Bangladesh (trial and death in custody)
Method
Cause of death not made public; one victim also tortured (court finding)
Status
Sentenced July 15, 2013 to 90 years; the court said he deserved death but cited age and illness. Appeals abated February 2015. Died in custody in Dhaka, Bangladesh, October 23, 2014.

Ghulam Azam was the wartime leader of Jamaat-e-Islami in East Pakistan, the province that became Bangladesh after nine months of war in 1971. On July 15, 2013, International Crimes Tribunal-1 in Dhaka found him guilty on all five charges brought against him: conspiracy, planning, incitement and complicity in crimes against humanity and genocide, and murder as a crime against humanity. The murder charge concerned four civilians held in the jail at Brahmanbaria and killed on the night of Eid-ul-Fitr, November 21, 1971. The court held that he had never been present at any of the crimes but that, as a civilian superior, he had built and directed the forces that carried them out and had incited them by word and by example.

The judges said he deserved the highest punishment the law allowed, which was death. They gave him 90 years instead, citing his age and long illness, and ordered the terms to run consecutively or until his death. He had been in custody since January 2012, most of it in a guarded ward of a Dhaka hospital. In August 2013 both he and the government appealed, he to overturn the conviction and the government to have him sentenced to death. On October 23, 2014, the day after the Appellate Division set a hearing date, he died in custody in Dhaka. In February 2015 the Appellate Division dismissed both appeals as abated. No appeal court ever reviewed the conviction, and the trial judgment stands as the last word of any court on what he did in 1971.

The case was the second judgment of Tribunal-1, and he was the most prominent of the men brought before the war crimes tribunals Bangladesh set up in 2010.

Teacher, party organizer, ameer

He was born on November 7, 1922. He studied first at a madrasa and then at the University of Dhaka, where he took a master's degree in political science in 1950. From 1950 to 1955 he taught at Carmichael College in Rangpur, in the north of what was then East Bengal.

He joined Jamaat-e-Islami in 1954. He served as its provincial secretary from 1957 to 1960 and in 1969 became ameer, or leader, of Jamaat-e-Islami in East Pakistan. He held that post through 1971.

In late March 1971 the Pakistani army sent troops to arrest the leaders of the Awami League, the party of Bengali autonomy, and to put down protests across East Pakistan, and the army and the groups allied with it turned on the civilian population. Bengali fighters, the freedom fighters, took up the war that followed, and in its last weeks the Indian army intervened. The Pakistani forces surrendered on December 16, 1971, and Bangladesh emerged as an independent state.

The tribunal's account of 1971

What Ghulam Azam did during those nine months is set out in the tribunal's judgment. Many of its findings drew on documents from 1971, among them newspaper reports of his speeches, statements and meetings, which the court treated as circumstantial evidence.

The judgment found that he knew of the army's atrocities by March 26, 1971. On April 4 he and other political leaders met the military governor of East Pakistan and, the court found, assured him of their full cooperation. They presented a plan for a citizens' committee to support the army. Two days later, on April 6, he met the governor alone. The court held that these two meetings demonstrated his complicity in all the atrocities that followed.

From those meetings came the Central Peace Committee, a body of 140 members formed to support military rule. Ghulam Azam sat on it, on its 21-member executive committee and on a six-member sub-committee. The court found that peace committees across the province became the civilian arm of the occupation, and that the paramilitary forces raised in 1971 were mostly formed by his subordinates. These were the Razakars, an auxiliary force under the army, and Al-Badr and Al-Shams, two further auxiliary forces manned largely by the student wing of his party. As head of Jamaat-e-Islami, the court held, he "substantially contributed much in forming" these forces and had effective control over them.

On June 19, 1971, after meeting Pakistan's president, he gave a press conference in Lahore. He won a seat in the Pakistan National Assembly in a by-election for Tangail. Through the summer and autumn, newspapers in Dhaka printed his praise for the army and its auxiliaries, and the court found that he did so on purpose, to encourage their work.

The incitement charge rested on his own published words, and the judges went through them one occasion at a time. They found that in one speech he expressed hatred toward the Hindu community of East Pakistan with intent to destroy or deport it, and that a speech he gave at Curzon Hall in Dhaka on August 16, 1971, amounted to "clear incitement to commit crimes against humanity and genocide." They also weighed his remarks to the press in Lahore on November 23 about the needs of the Peace Committee members and Razakars, and a meeting with the president on December 2 at which he pressed for more Razakars to be raised. Each of these, the judges held, was incitement under international law.

He left East Pakistan for West Pakistan on November 22, 1971. In the last days of the war, Al-Badr forces killed many of the province's intellectuals, and the tribunal counted those killings among the crimes of the forces it found he had helped to create.

Brahmanbaria, November 1971

Only one charge accused him of murder. It concerned a group of people arrested on October 27, 1971, and held in the jail at Brahmanbaria, in the east of the province. On the night of Eid-ul-Fitr, which witnesses placed on November 21, 1971, forty prisoners were taken out of the jail, and one survived. The tribunal found that thirty-eight people were killed that night; the murder charge, and the conviction, concerned four of them.

The charge named the four: Siru Miah, Anwar Kamal, Nazrul Islam and Abul Kashem. The court found that one of them had also been tortured.

The case on this charge did not claim that Ghulam Azam gave the order in person. It turned on a letter of his, admitted as an exhibit, and on the statement of the man who delivered it, which the tribunal treated as corroboration rather than as proof on its own. Its conclusion was that he could have saved the lives of the four civilians by directing his subordinate, the local Peace Committee leader in Brahmanbaria, to release them. Instead, the court found, he "intentionally facilitated and substantially contributed" to the killings by giving that subordinate a negative signal, and it held him guilty of murder as a crime against humanity.

Exile and return

In Pakistan after the war he formed a committee whose aim was the restoration of East Pakistan, and campaigned against the new state until 1973. He spent most of the next seven years in London, where he published a weekly paper. On April 18, 1973, the government of Bangladesh revoked his citizenship. In March 1975 he traveled to Saudi Arabia and met King Faisal.

In August 1978, under the military government of Ziaur Rahman, he came back to Bangladesh on a Pakistani passport and a short visa. He never left again. He remained a Pakistani citizen until 1994, and for much of that time he led Jamaat-e-Islami without holding the title. The party declared him its ameer in 1991.

In 1992 he went to the High Court to have his citizenship recognized, and the government had him arrested and held in jail. The same year a citizens' movement staged a symbolic People's Court in Dhaka, which tried him in absentia for his role in 1971 and recommended capital punishment. In 1994 a court order restored his Bangladeshi citizenship, and he was released.

He stepped down as ameer in late 2000 but remained the party's spiritual leader.

Charges and custody

Special tribunals set up in 1972 to try collaborators had held no trials. In 2009 Parliament amended the International Crimes (Tribunals) Act of 1973, and in 2010 the government set up the first tribunal under it.

The prosecution brought its formal charge against Ghulam Azam before Tribunal-1 in December 2011. On January 11, 2012, the tribunal refused him bail, holding that age alone could not decide the question in a case of that seriousness, and ordered him held at Dhaka Central Jail. Within hours he was taken to Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujib Medical University for examination, and he spent most of the rest of his life under guard in the ward the hospital kept for prisoners.

On May 13, 2012, Tribunal-1 framed five charges against him under the 1973 Act. They covered conspiracy, planning, incitement and complicity in crimes against humanity and genocide, and murder and torture as crimes against humanity, and they rested on 61 separate incidents or counts. He pleaded not guilty.

The trial

The first prosecution witness testified on July 1, 2012. The prosecution called sixteen witnesses: seven who proved the seizure of documents, eight who spoke to the events of 1971, and the investigating officer. The defense had listed 2,939 witnesses. The tribunal allowed it twelve, and it produced one.

In December 2012 the tribunal chairman's Skype conversations and emails were hacked and published abroad. He resigned, and a new chairman took over the bench. The tribunal refused a defense request for a retrial, and on February 14, 2013, it closed the defense case, citing the defense's repeated failure to bring its other witnesses. It reserved its verdict on April 17, 2013.

The verdict

The three judges found him guilty on every charge. On conspiracy and planning they relied on his repeated meetings with the military leadership and his part in forming the peace committees and the auxiliary forces. They held that conspiracy to commit crimes against humanity and genocide is an inchoate offense, so that the prosecution did not have to prove that genocide had taken place; the circumstantial evidence, they said, led them to hold him guilty of conspiracy and planning. On incitement they relied on the speeches. On complicity they found him guilty of crimes against humanity and genocide "by aiding, abetting and incitement," and held that he had known of the atrocities from the start. On the fifth charge they found him guilty of the four murders at Brahmanbaria.

The court held that he was a civilian superior and that a de facto command over the perpetrators was enough to make him responsible. He had failed to prevent his subordinates' crimes or to punish them, the judges said, and had in fact encouraged them. They found that he committed the crimes through Jamaat-e-Islami and its wings, and that the party had "intentionally functioned as a 'Criminal Organisation'" during the war. The tribunal also held that four decades of delay did not bar the prosecution, and it rejected the argument that the 1974 Tripartite Agreement barred the trial of civilians.

The judges said he deserved capital punishment. They wrote that old age did not reduce guilt, but they treated his age and long illness as extenuating circumstances. They sentenced him to ten years each on the conspiracy and planning charges, twenty years each for incitement and complicity, and thirty years for the murders, ninety years in all, and ordered that "the period of aforesaid sentences awarded to the accused shall run consecutively or till his death." He was committed to Dhaka Central Jail on a conviction warrant. He had denied the charges throughout.

Disputed and unproven points

The judgment is the only court ruling on what he did in 1971. His appeal abated on his death, so no appeal court tested the conviction.

In November 2012 the United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention found his detention before trial arbitrary, because the tribunal had put the burden of justifying release on the accused. In August 2013 Human Rights Watch said the conviction rested on flawed proceedings, citing the judges' own inquiries outside the defense's knowledge, the hacked communications, the change of chairman and the intimidation of defense witnesses, while taking no position on his guilt; Tribunal-1 rejected that criticism in a contempt ruling on September 4, 2014, and warned the organization without imposing a penalty.

The defense maintained that he had held no command over the Pakistani army or the auxiliary forces, and that the case rested on press reports of his speeches rather than on any witness who tied him to a crime. The tribunal found otherwise, holding that a de facto command was enough.

The death toll of the 1971 war is itself contested. The Bangladeshi government's figure, which the tribunal adopted, is about three million dead. Independent researchers have put the true numbers lower, and estimates of the dead range from three hundred thousand to three million.

Timeline

November 7, 1922: Ghulam Azam is born.

1950: He takes a master's degree in political science at the University of Dhaka and begins teaching at Carmichael College, Rangpur (to 1955).

1954: He joins Jamaat-e-Islami; he is its provincial secretary from 1957 to 1960.

1969: He becomes ameer of Jamaat-e-Islami in East Pakistan.

March 1971: The Pakistani army moves against the Awami League and the civilian population of East Pakistan.

April 4 and 6, 1971: He meets the military governor of East Pakistan, first with other leaders and then alone.

June 19, 1971: He gives a press conference in Lahore after meeting Pakistan's president.

August 16, 1971: He speaks at Curzon Hall, Dhaka; the tribunal later finds the speech was incitement.

October 27, 1971: A group of people is arrested and held in the jail at Brahmanbaria.

November 21, 1971: Four civilians named in the murder charge are killed with others taken from the jail at Brahmanbaria.

November 22, 1971: He leaves for West Pakistan.

December 16, 1971: The Pakistani forces surrender; Bangladesh is independent.

April 18, 1973: The government of Bangladesh revokes his citizenship.

August 1978: He returns to Bangladesh on a Pakistani passport.

1991: Jamaat-e-Islami declares him its ameer.

1992: He seeks recognition of his citizenship and is arrested and held.

1994: A court order restores his citizenship, and he is released.

2000: He steps down as ameer.

2010: The government sets up the first International Crimes Tribunal.

December 2011: The prosecution brings its formal charge.

January 11, 2012: Bail is refused and he is taken into custody.

May 13, 2012: He is indicted on five charges covering 61 counts and pleads not guilty.

July 1, 2012: The first prosecution witness testifies.

November 2012: The UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention finds his detention arbitrary.

December 2012: The tribunal's chairman resigns after his communications are hacked and published.

February 14, 2013: The tribunal closes the defense case.

April 17, 2013: The tribunal reserves its verdict.

July 15, 2013: He is convicted on all five charges and sentenced to 90 years.

August 2013: He and the government appeal, and Human Rights Watch calls the proceedings flawed.

September 4, 2014: Tribunal-1 warns Human Rights Watch in a contempt ruling.

October 22, 2014: The Appellate Division sets a date to hear the appeals.

October 23, 2014: He dies in custody in Dhaka.

February 2015: The Appellate Division dismisses both appeals as abated.