Thirty-nine people died in the people-smuggling case that ended at Purfleet, Essex, on October 23, 2019. They were Vietnamese nationals, 31 men and 8 women, and they had been promised a way into Britain by a ring that sold that promise for money.
Gheorghe Nica was not with them. He was a Romanian-born mechanic who lived in Basildon, Essex, and the trial judge found that he was a leader, organizer and manager of the ring, responsible for its British end. On December 21, 2020, a jury at the Central Criminal Court in London convicted him of 39 counts of manslaughter and of conspiracy to assist unlawful immigration. A month later he received 27 years' imprisonment, the longest sentence passed on anyone in the case. The Court of Appeal refused to let him challenge the conviction in November 2021.
He never denied that he had smuggled people. His defense was narrower and, in the end, legal: that he had nothing to do with the fatal run, and that even if he had, nothing in the earlier ones had warned him that this one would carry so many people. The jury rejected the first point. Three judges of the Court of Appeal rejected the second.
Nica was born on January 14, 1977, Romanian by birth, and he held British citizenship as well. He spent years working as a truck driver and mechanic in Ireland and England, including a period in Dublin, before moving to England in 2008 and settling in the Basildon area. He was 43 when he was convicted.
There was no dispute at the trial that a conspiracy existed. The Court of Appeal summarized it as a long-running and profitable operation set up to bring people into the United Kingdom in deliberate breach of border control. It had two halves. A haulage operator from County Armagh in Northern Ireland, a friend and former colleague of Nica's, ran the transport side; he had come into the scheme, the trial judge found, at Nica's invitation. Nica's half was the handover in Essex, where he recruited and directed the drivers who took the passengers on toward London and was present to supervise the unloading.
He drew those drivers from people he knew: a friend from Tilbury, an acquaintance from Birmingham, and a Romanian associate who served under him. Before the trial Nica pleaded guilty to a conspiracy count covering two earlier successful runs in October 2019, which did not include the fatal one. That plea mattered to his defense. It let him say that he had seen what the earlier runs looked like and that they had carried about 15 people, not 39.
Nica left Britain after the deaths. In January 2020, German authorities detained him at Frankfurt Airport under a European Arrest Warrant obtained by Essex Police and the Crown Prosecution Service. Returned to England, he was charged in February 2020 with 39 counts of manslaughter and conspiracy to assist unlawful immigration.
Others in the ring admitted their parts. The haulage operator pleaded guilty in August 2020 to 39 counts of manslaughter and to the conspiracy. The driver who collected the passengers in Essex admitted the manslaughter counts, the conspiracy and acquiring criminal property. The friend from Tilbury pleaded guilty to the conspiracy before the jury was sworn. That left Nica and a driver from County Down to face a jury on the manslaughter counts, with the truck driver from County Armagh and the acquaintance from Birmingham tried beside them on the conspiracy charge.
The Crown's case on manslaughter did not depend on anyone having wanted the passengers to die. It argued that carrying people the way this ring did, sealed in and with no means of escape or of calling for help, was plainly dangerous whatever their number.
Nica's first line of defense was that he had played no part in the events of October 22 and 23. He admitted taking part in two earlier runs, on October 11 and 18, and accepted that he had given the driver directions the night before the deaths, but said he believed the load was cigarettes. He denied being a ringleader and put the blame on the operator and on his Romanian associate.
His second line addressed the law. If the jury were sure he was involved, he argued, he could only have expected a load about the size of the earlier runs, and on the evidence of those runs a smaller group faced no real risk of harm. The judge directed the jury that to convict they had to be sure that he took part in an unlawful act, with the state of mind that crime required, which all sober and reasonable people would inevitably have recognized exposed the victims to the risk of some physical harm, and which caused the deaths. The prosecution did not have to prove that he intended harm or foresaw it.
On December 21, 2020, the jury convicted Nica of all 39 counts of manslaughter and of a second conspiracy count covering the fatal run. The driver from County Down was convicted of the 39 manslaughter counts and the conspiracy. The truck driver from County Armagh and the acquaintance from Birmingham were convicted of conspiracy to assist unlawful immigration.
The trial judge passed sentence on January 22, 2021. He sentenced the case as a conspiracy to smuggle people, not "people trafficking", and assessed Nica as a leader, organizer and manager of the ring. Nica received 27 years on each count of manslaughter and eleven and a half years on each of the two conspiracy counts, all concurrent, for a total of 27 years, less six days spent in custody pending extradition. The judge decided that the offenses, grave as they were, did not meet the criteria for life sentences, and he told the defendants convicted of manslaughter that they would serve two-thirds of their terms in custody before release.
The haulage operator received 20 years, reduced from 30 for his early guilty pleas. The driver from County Down received 18 years. The driver who collected the passengers in Essex received 13 years and four months. The truck driver from County Armagh received seven years, the acquaintance from Birmingham four and a half years, and the friend from Tilbury three years.
A single judge refused Nica leave to appeal, and he renewed the application before a three-judge Court of Appeal, which heard it on November 23, 2021. He argued that assisting unlawful immigration is not in itself a dangerous act, so the prosecution should have had to prove that he knew roughly how many people were involved before the test of risk came into play. The court rejected that argument. It held that the test the courts settled in 1966 still governs unlawful act manslaughter, that any change to it was a matter for Parliament, and that whether Nica's acts, carried out with his co-conspirators, created a risk of harm was a question of fact for the jury, on which the trial judge had directed them properly. The conviction was safe, and the application was refused.
Nica was later ordered to pay £65,157.65 in confiscation, all of it directed to the families of the 39 dead, and when he did not pay, a magistrates' court in Kent ordered him to serve an additional 11.5 months in prison on July 11, 2024.
Nica has never accepted the court's view of his place in the ring. He denied being a ringleader, maintained that he had expected goods, not people, on the fatal run, and disputed the trial judge's assessment of him as a leader, organizer and manager. The jury rejected his account, and the Court of Appeal found no arguable ground to disturb the verdicts. The full number of runs the ring made is not known; the trial judge found there had been more than those detected.
May 1, 2018: The start date of the conspiracy charged in the case.
October 11 and 18, 2019: Nica takes part in two earlier runs, later covered by his guilty plea.
October 22 to 23, 2019: Thirty-nine people die; the case ends at Purfleet, Essex.
January 2020: Nica is detained at Frankfurt Airport under a European Arrest Warrant.
February 2020: Charged with 39 counts of manslaughter and conspiracy to assist unlawful immigration.
August 28, 2020: The haulage operator pleads guilty to 39 counts of manslaughter and conspiracy.
December 21, 2020: The jury convicts Nica of 39 counts of manslaughter and conspiracy to assist unlawful immigration.
January 22, 2021: Nica is sentenced to 27 years' imprisonment.
November 23, 2021: The Court of Appeal refuses his renewed application for leave to appeal against conviction.
July 11, 2024: Ordered to serve an additional 11.5 months for failing to pay a confiscation order.