Georges Rutaganda was a businessman in Kigali and the second vice-president of the national committee of the Interahamwe, the youth wing of Rwanda's ruling MRND party, when the killing of Tutsi civilians began in April 1994. On December 6, 1999, Trial Chamber I of the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, sitting in Arusha, Tanzania, found him guilty of genocide, of extermination as a crime against humanity and of murder as a crime against humanity, and imposed a single sentence of life imprisonment. The judges found that he had taken part in the attack on thousands of refugees at a technical school in Kicukiro on April 11, 1994, that he had directed the killings at Nyanza that followed the same evening, and that he had ordered the deaths of ten detainees near his business premises later that month.
The case did not end there. On May 26, 2003, the tribunal's Appeals Chamber set aside the conviction for murder as a crime against humanity, which rested on a single death, and found him not guilty on that count. On the Prosecution's appeal it reversed two of his acquittals and found him guilty of murder as a violation of Article 3 common to the Geneva Conventions, for the killings at the school and at Nyanza. They were the first war-crimes convictions the tribunal had ever entered. The life sentence stood. Rutaganda was moved to Benin to serve it in June 2009 and died there on October 11, 2010.
Rutaganda was born on November 28, 1958. He told the court that he took a degree in agricultural engineering at the National University of Rwanda in 1985 and worked in that field before going into trade. From June 1991 he was the general manager and owner of an import company in Kigali that carried his name, Rutaganda SARL. His business premises stood beside the Amgar garage in the capital, a place that would figure in the case against him.
By his own account he had little interest in politics before 1991. He joined the MRND, then Rwanda's ruling and largest party, in about September or October of that year, mainly, he said, for the protection it offered his business. The tribunal's sentencing judgment described him as a member of the party at the national and prefectural levels.
He testified that he was named second vice-president of the national committee of the Interahamwe za MRND, the party's youth movement, and he described the post as a formality with no budget, no command and no real authority. The indictment described him as holding that office on April 6, 1994, the night the aircraft carrying the presidents of Rwanda and Burundi was brought down over Kigali.
The tribunal found that the attack on the Tutsi civilian population of Rwanda in 1994 was widespread and systematic and reached many parts of the country. It found that the Tutsi formed a stable and permanent group, generally accepted as distinct, and so a group protected by the Genocide Convention. It also found that an internal armed conflict was under way during the same months between the government forces and the Rwandese Patriotic Front.
In the days after April 6, Interahamwe militiamen set up roadblocks across the capital. The judges found that Rutaganda was present on at least three occasions in April 1994 when the Interahamwe in Nyarugenge commune, including the Cyahafi sector, were equipped for the killings, and that he took part in that distribution.
The École Technique Officielle, known as ETO, was a technical school in Kicukiro, in the southeast of Kigali, where a contingent of UN peacekeepers from UNAMIR, the United Nations Assistance Mission for Rwanda, was stationed. From April 7, several thousand people, most of them Tutsi, gathered there in the hope of UN protection.
The peacekeepers left the compound on April 11, 1994. The Trial Chamber found that Interahamwe and members of the Presidential Guard then attacked the refugees and killed a large number of them, and that Rutaganda was present and took part. The survivors, about 4,000 people, were taken from the school to Nyanza, in the same commune, and the judges found that Rutaganda took part in diverting them there.
That evening the refugees at Nyanza were attacked again. The Trial Chamber found that Rutaganda directed and took part in the killings. Of the roughly 4,000 people brought to Nyanza, about 200 survived. The court found the dead to be Tutsi refugees, civilians who had sought the protection of the United Nations.
The second group of findings concerned Rutaganda's own premises. The Trial Chamber found that from mid-April 1994 the Interahamwe ran a roadblock near the Amgar garage and held people identified as Tutsi or taken for Tutsi. Those people were brought to Rutaganda, and he ordered them detained on the premises. Defense witnesses did not dislodge the finding that he was in his office there in the second half of April.
Around April 21, the court found, Rutaganda ordered his men to take fourteen of the detainees, at least four of them Tutsi, from the garage. On his orders and in his presence, ten of them were killed. The account came from a single prosecution witness known as Q, whom the Trial Chamber believed. Other allegations about the roadblock failed: the Chamber was not satisfied that Rutaganda had posted the Interahamwe there, and it disregarded the only witness to a separate set of killings at the roadblock because of inconsistencies it could not resolve.
The indictment also charged Rutaganda with the death of Emmanuel Kayitare, a Tutsi man, on or about April 28, 1994, near the garage. At trial two witnesses, AA and U, described the death, and the Trial Chamber found them credible and mutually corroborative. On that basis it found Rutaganda guilty of murder as a crime against humanity under Count 7. The Appeals Chamber later concluded that the two accounts did not support each other in that way, and on that death Rutaganda was finally acquitted.
Rutaganda testified that he left Rwanda around June 10, 1994. He was arrested in Zambia on October 10, 1995, and on February 16, 1996, a judge of the tribunal confirmed an indictment against him and issued a warrant for his arrest. On May 26, 1996, he was transferred to the tribunal's detention facility in Arusha.
The indictment charged eight counts: genocide; extermination as a crime against humanity; and, for each of the ETO school, Nyanza and the April 28 death, one count of murder as a crime against humanity and one of murder as a violation of Article 3 common to the Geneva Conventions. At his initial appearance on May 30, 1996, Rutaganda pleaded not guilty to every count. The trial began on March 18, 1997.
Rutaganda testified in his own defense. He maintained that the Interahamwe had no real hierarchy or command, that his title carried no responsibility for what militiamen did, and that the roadblocks in the capital had at first been civilian and mixed. His lawyers challenged the credibility of several prosecution witnesses. Defense witnesses told the court that he had fed and sheltered people, Tutsi refugees among them, and had tried to arrange evacuations.
He also offered an alibi for the period from April 6 to about late June 1994, and said that on April 11, the day of the ETO school and Nyanza, he was on the road to Masango. The Chamber rejected the alibi. It noted that it had surfaced late in the trial, had not been put to the prosecution witnesses and rested on a witness with a personal interest in the outcome, and it found it an afterthought.
The Trial Chamber delivered its judgment on December 6, 1999. It inferred Rutaganda's intent to destroy the Tutsi group, in whole or in part, from his position of authority, his own participation in the events, the systematic selection of Tutsi victims and the scale of the killing across the country. The same set of facts supported the conviction for extermination, as part of a widespread and systematic attack on the Tutsi population of which he knew and to which his conduct belonged.
The judges set out his responsibility event by event. In Cyahafi, he had aided and abetted the preparation and carrying out of killings of members of the Tutsi group. At the Amgar garage, he had ordered, committed and aided and abetted killings. At the ETO school, he had committed and aided and abetted killings, and at Nyanza, on the genocide count, his presence alone had abetted the crimes. For each of these events the Chamber also found that he had caused serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group. The extermination count gathered the same conduct into one finding: the equipping of the militia in Cyahafi, the order that ten people be killed, the attack at the school, and the attack at Nyanza that he directed and joined.
It found him Guilty of Genocide on Count 1, Guilty of Crime Against Humanity (Extermination) on Count 2 and Guilty of Crime Against Humanity (Murder) on Count 7, and Not Guilty on the other five counts. Counts 3 and 5 failed because they rested on the same facts as the extermination count, and the Chamber held that murder was subsumed in extermination as a collective killing. The three war-crimes counts failed for a different reason. The judges accepted that an internal armed conflict existed and that the victims were protected persons, but they held that the Prosecutor had not proved beyond reasonable doubt a link, or nexus, between Rutaganda's own acts and that conflict.
The Chamber found that his position as a national officer of the Interahamwe and his leading role in the events were aggravating factors, and that they outweighed what it accepted in his favor: the help he had given the families of two defense witnesses and the food and shelter he had provided to some refugees. Its sentence was "a single sentence of life imprisonment for all the counts on which he has been found guilty."
Rutaganda appealed his convictions and asked for an acquittal or a retrial. The Prosecution appealed the acquittals on the war-crimes counts. The Appeals Chamber admitted some additional evidence on whether he had been at Kicukiro on April 11, 1994, but gave it limited weight, holding that it could not cast doubt on the four eyewitnesses who placed him at the school and at Nyanza. The five judges gave their judgment in Arusha on May 26, 2003.
They rejected the challenges to the fairness of the trial and to the alibi ruling, finding that eyewitness evidence placed Rutaganda at the scene on April 11 in any event. They upheld the findings on the Amgar garage, holding that the discrepancies in witness Q's evidence were minor. On the Interahamwe, they held that whether the movement survived after April 6, 1994, or whether he still held an office in it, made no difference: he had been convicted for his own personal and direct participation, not for his rank or for what other members did. On genocide, they held that the Trial Chamber had applied the right test and had not convicted him by association, because his intent was established by his own conduct.
The ground on the April 28 death succeeded. The Appeals Chamber found significant inconsistencies between the accounts of witnesses AA and U, held that the Trial Chamber had given no reasons for treating them as corroborative, and concluded that no reasonable tribunal could have found them so. It entered a verdict of not guilty on Count 7. The genocide conviction was unaffected.
The Prosecution's appeal succeeded in part. The Appeals Chamber held that the armed conflict did not have to cause the crime, but it had to play a substantial part in the perpetrator's ability, decision, manner or purpose in committing it. At the ETO school, Rutaganda took part in an attack carried out by the Interahamwe alongside soldiers of the Presidential Guard on refugees who were protected persons, and the attack at Nyanza, which he directed, formed one connected sequence with it. No reasonable trier of fact, the Appeals Chamber held, could have failed to find the nexus. It reversed the acquittals on Counts 4 and 6 and found him guilty of murder as a violation of Article 3 common to the Geneva Conventions. The appeal on Count 8, which concerned the April 28 death, failed.
One of the five judges dissented on Counts 4 and 6; the rest of the disposition was unanimous. The dissenting judge agreed that the Trial Chamber had been wrong about the nexus. His objection was to the remedy. A conviction entered for the first time on appeal could not itself be appealed, he reasoned, and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights guarantees everyone convicted of a crime the right to have the conviction reviewed by a higher tribunal. Because the conduct at the school and at Nyanza already underlay the affirmed convictions for genocide and extermination, sending the two counts back to a Trial Chamber would only prolong the case, and he would have left the acquittals undisturbed.
Two judges of the majority wrote separately on the same concern. They joined the new convictions because the conduct behind them was already covered by the trial convictions and carried no heavier penalty, but they urged the Appeals Chamber to settle in a future case whether it could fairly enter convictions from which no appeal lay. Another judge, who agreed with the judgment, wrote separately to examine whether the Appeals Chamber had the power to substitute convictions for acquittals at all, a question neither side had raised.
The Appeals Chamber affirmed the convictions for genocide and for extermination as a crime against humanity and affirmed the single sentence of life imprisonment, holding that the facts on which it rested were unchanged, among them the finding that only about 200 of the 4,000 people taken to Nyanza survived.
In 2006 Rutaganda asked the Appeals Chamber to reconsider its judgment, to review it on the strength of new facts, to assign him counsel at the tribunal's expense and to order further disclosure. His main new material was the judgment of a Rwandan court in the case of another man, which in his account told a different story of the events in Cyahafi and cast doubt on three of the witnesses against him. On December 8, 2006, the Appeals Chamber denied every request.
It held that its power to reconsider its own decisions did not extend to a final judgment. It accepted that statements the three witnesses had apparently given to Rwandan authorities were new facts, but it found that he had not shown due diligence: the Rwandan judgment had been delivered in February 1999, while his own trial was still under way, and his claim that security concerns had kept his lawyers out of Rwanda was unsupported. Nor did it find that ignoring the material would cause a miscarriage of justice. The Trial Chamber had not relied on those witnesses for every Cyahafi finding, and his convictions and life sentence rested equally and independently on the school and Nyanza, findings that owed nothing to their evidence.
The rest of the request fared no better. Affidavits from two UNAMIR officers about his help in the evacuation of refugees from a Kigali hotel, and a radio appeal for calm he had signed in April 1994, were not new facts, because his assistance to Tutsi had been argued at trial and on appeal. The Appeals Chamber did find that the Prosecution had breached its duty to disclose the transcript of that radio statement, and it warned the Prosecution that a future breach could bring sanctions, but it held that the failure had not prejudiced him. A complaint about his detention in Zambia before his transfer to Arusha had appeared in his notice of appeal and then been abandoned, so it was waived. Review being an exceptional remedy, and his written submissions already extensive, the Chamber declined to assign him counsel at the tribunal's expense.
Rutaganda remained in the tribunal's custody in Arusha while a state was chosen to hold him. Benin had signed an agreement with the United Nations in Cotonou on August 26, 1999, to receive people convicted by the tribunal; under the tribunal's Statute, imprisonment there follows Benin's law, under the tribunal's supervision. On June 27, 2009, he was among nine convicted prisoners moved from the UN detention facility in Arusha to Benin to serve the rest of their sentences. He died in Benin on October 11, 2010, while serving his life sentence.
Several allegations in the indictment were never proved. The Trial Chamber found no proof that Rutaganda had posted the Interahamwe at the Amgar roadblock, and it disregarded the only witness to a separate set of killings there. In Masango commune, in Gitarama prefecture, it was not satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that he had ordered the killings alleged, because the only witness on that point was uncorroborated. For June 1994, it rejected the allegation that he acted to hide his crimes from the international community. His conviction for the April 28 death was quashed on appeal, and the parallel war-crimes count was dismissed. Rutaganda denied every charge from his first appearance to the end of his appeal.
November 28, 1958: Georges Rutaganda is born in Rwanda.
June 1991: He becomes general manager and owner of the import firm Rutaganda SARL in Kigali.
About September or October 1991: He joins the MRND.
April 6, 1994: The aircraft carrying the presidents of Rwanda and Burundi is brought down over Kigali; he is second vice-president of the Interahamwe national committee.
April 11, 1994: UN peacekeepers leave the ETO school in Kicukiro; the attack on the refugees and the killings at Nyanza follow, and the tribunal later finds that he took part in both and directed the second.
About April 21, 1994: Ten detainees taken from the Amgar garage are killed on his orders and in his presence.
Around June 10, 1994: By his own account, he leaves Rwanda.
October 10, 1995: He is arrested in Zambia.
February 16, 1996: The indictment is confirmed and a warrant issued.
May 26, 1996: He is transferred to the tribunal's detention facility in Arusha.
May 30, 1996: He pleads not guilty to all eight counts.
March 18, 1997: The trial opens.
December 6, 1999: Found guilty on Counts 1, 2 and 7 and sentenced to a single term of life imprisonment.
May 26, 2003: The Appeals Chamber quashes Count 7, enters convictions on Counts 4 and 6, the tribunal's first war-crimes convictions, and affirms the life sentence.
December 8, 2006: The Appeals Chamber denies his requests for reconsideration and review.
June 27, 2009: He is transferred from Arusha to Benin to serve his sentence.
October 11, 2010: He dies in Benin while serving his life sentence.