Georges Ruggiu was the only person the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda ever tried who was not a Rwandan. Born in Belgium to an Italian father and a Belgian mother, he had worked for his country's social security administration, joined a small circle of Belgians and Rwandans close to President Juvenal Habyarimana's government, and moved to Kigali at the end of 1993. From January 6 to July 14, 1994, the months that took in the genocide against the Tutsi, he was a presenter on Radio Television Libre des Mille Collines, the private station known as RTLM. On May 15, 2000, at the tribunal in Arusha, Tanzania, he pleaded guilty to direct and public incitement to commit genocide and to persecution as a crime against humanity. Trial Chamber I sentenced him on June 1, 2000, to 12 years' imprisonment on each count, to run concurrently.
The judgment found that RTLM had been a key instrument of propaganda during the genocide and that his broadcasts had incited massacres of the Tutsi. It also found that from mid-April 1994 he knew the station's broadcasts were contributing to those massacres and chose to stay on the air. He admitted at his plea hearing that people had been killed in Rwanda in 1994, that he was responsible, and that his broadcasts were directly linked to their deaths. The Chamber found, too, that he never killed anyone with his own hands, and it named no individual victim. Neither side appealed. He served most of the sentence in the tribunal's detention facility in Arusha, was flown to Italy in February 2008 to serve the rest, and was released early by the Italian authorities on April 21, 2009, without the decision of the tribunal's President that the tribunal's statute required.
Georges Henry Joseph Ruggiu was born on October 12, 1957, in Verviers, in the Belgian province of Liege. He held both Belgian and Italian nationality. He worked as a social worker for the Belgian Social Security Administration and volunteered with a neighborhood branch of the Red Cross, and the judges accepted that he had spent much of his free time helping people in need.
His interest in Rwanda began in 1990, when he came to know Rwandan students who lived near him in Belgium. He became a founding member of the Groupe de reflexion rwando-belge, a Rwandan-Belgian discussion group that published articles on the Arusha Accords, the 1993 peace agreement between the Rwandan government and the rebel Rwandan Patriotic Front (RPF), and on Rwandan politics generally. The group stood close to the government of President Habyarimana and to its ruling party, the MRND.
He traveled to Rwanda for the first time in August 1992, for a friend's wedding. By early 1993, the judgment records, he had turned firmly against the RPF, and in May 1993 he met President Habyarimana on several occasions. In late 1993 he left Belgium to settle in Rwanda, intending to start a family there and to work for the MRND. Influence from the President's circle helped him find a place at RTLM, the new private radio station that had begun broadcasting in Kigali that year. He later testified that he was hired on December 31, 1993.
His employment at RTLM ran from January 6 to July 14, 1994. In January 1994 he was one of eight employees at the station, working as a presenter and program adviser. He broadcast in French.
On April 6, 1994, the plane carrying President Habyarimana was downed and the President was killed, and the massacres of Tutsi civilians and of Hutu political opponents began.
The plea agreement he signed in May 2000 set out what he accepted about his own broadcasts. He admitted that his work at RTLM had been directed at mobilizing the population against the RPF and those considered its allies, that his broadcasts had incited violence against Tutsi and moderate Hutu, and that they had also targeted Belgians and the United Nations peacekeeping mission in Rwanda, UNAMIR. He accepted that RTLM's staff and broadcasters bore responsibility for the massacres of 1994.
The agreement also recorded one broadcast by date and place. Between April 8 and 13, 1994, he made a broadcast about Gikondo, a district of Kigali. The station's editor-in-chief, who lived in Gikondo, later told him that many people there, women and children among them, had been killed as a result. The number was never established.
The turning point in the judgment's account came shortly after April 12, 1994. In the middle of that month he was taken on a tour of Kigali, and on that tour he saw the scale of what was being done and understood that it was a campaign to destroy the Tutsi as a group. The Chamber found that from then on he knew RTLM's broadcasts were contributing to the massacres, that he could have left, and that he chose instead to stay in Rwanda and keep broadcasting.
The tribunal accepted two further facts that sit beside those findings. He held no official position in Rwanda and no senior post at RTLM, had no say over the content of its programs, and was at one point openly reprimanded by the station's management for failing to reflect its line fully. And during the same months, by accounts the prosecution did not challenge, he took Tutsi children to a mission where they could be protected and fed farmers and refugees, Tutsi among them. He stayed at RTLM until July 14, 1994, when the interim government and its radio station collapsed.
After the collapse he left Rwanda for Tanzania and later moved on to Kenya. In 1995 he published a book in French, Dans la tourmente rwandaise, in which he defended RTLM; he would later tell the tribunal under oath that he had knowingly written falsehoods in it to protect the station and its backers. He was also known as Georges Omar Ruggiu.
At the request of the tribunal's prosecutor, Kenyan police arrested him in Mombasa on July 23, 1997, and he was handed over to the tribunal in Arusha the same day. The indictment, confirmed that October, charged him with two counts: direct and public incitement to commit genocide, and persecution as a crime against humanity. It alleged that his broadcasts had incited the killing of Tutsi and amounted to persecution of Tutsi, of certain Hutu and of Belgians. He pleaded not guilty to both.
The prosecution intended to try him alongside three Rwandans accused over the media of 1994: Ferdinand Nahimana, Jean-Bosco Barayagwiza and Hassan Ngeze. Detention brought him into daily contact with men accused of planning the genocide, and that contact changed his position. Until then, by his own account, he had believed that the massacres which began on April 6, 1994, were not planned. After he heard of a statement by Ngeze describing the genocide as planned, he questioned other detainees about it. Their hostile response, and his conversations with them, convinced him that he had been misled and had taken part in a planned genocide.
His relations with the other detainees broke down, and in July 1999, after concerns for his safety, he was moved to a separate facility in Arusha. That same month he began to cooperate with the prosecution and to negotiate a plea agreement. He was removed from the joint case, which went ahead against the three Rwandans without him.
On May 15, 2000, he changed his plea and pleaded guilty to both counts, under an agreement both sides said had been reached without any promise. The judges questioned him to confirm that the plea was voluntary, informed and unequivocal, and he answered yes to each question. He told the court that it had indeed been a genocide and that he had taken part in it, that he understood certain people had been killed in Rwanda in 1994 and that he was responsible, and that he had decided to assume that responsibility.
At the end of the hearing he addressed the victims of the genocide and their families, Rwandans and Belgians, and the members of UNAMIR. He said he deeply regretted what had happened in Rwanda in 1994, offered his apologies, and asked the victims for their forgiveness. The most he could now do, he said, was testify and make the truth known.
The prosecution asked for 20 years' imprisonment on each count, to run concurrently. The defense proposed no figure, and two character witnesses spoke for him.
Trial Chamber I delivered its Judgement and Sentence on June 1, 2000. On the first count, it held that the crime of direct and public incitement to commit genocide had been made out: he had the specific intent the offense requires, and his words were public because they went out over a mass medium to the population at large. On the second count, it held that his broadcasts amounted to persecution on political and racial grounds, because they singled out and attacked the Tutsi, Hutu political opponents and Belgians as part of a widespread and systematic attack on civilians. He was found guilty on both counts.
In weighing the sentence, the Chamber treated the gravity of the offenses as aggravating in itself, since genocide and crimes against humanity fall in the most serious category of crimes under the tribunal's statute. It found that he had played a crucial role in inciting ethnic hatred and violence through RTLM, a station with a wide audience across Rwanda, and it held against him the decision to keep broadcasting after the tour of Kigali in April 1994.
It then set out the mitigating circumstances. His guilty plea had saved the tribunal time and resources and showed, the Chamber found, genuine awareness of his guilt. His cooperation with the prosecution was substantial. He had no previous convictions, held no authority in Rwanda or at RTLM, and had not personally taken part in the killings. The Chamber accepted his remorse as sincere and took account of the help he had given Tutsi children and refugees in 1994. These circumstances warranted some clemency, it said, although they did nothing to reduce the gravity of the crimes.
The sentence was 12 years' imprisonment on the first count and 12 years on the second, to be served concurrently, with the time he had spent in custody since July 23, 1997, counted toward it. He was the eighth person convicted by the tribunal and the third to plead guilty, after the former interim prime minister Jean Kambanda and Omar Serushago, a militia leader who had received 15 years; the Chamber noted that, unlike Serushago, he had killed no one himself. Neither side appealed, and the judgment became final.
The plea agreement left him open to be called against the men with whom he had once been charged. In February and March 2002 he testified for the prosecution in the media trial of Nahimana, Barayagwiza and Ngeze. He testified that Nahimana had signed his letter of engagement as director of the station, that Nahimana remained a driving force at RTLM after a director-general took over day-to-day management in January 1994, and that Barayagwiza sat with Nahimana on the station's three-member management committee.
Cross-examination turned on his own record. Besides the falsehoods in his book, he admitted that he had lied about several events in interviews with prosecution investigators before he changed his plea, and he accepted that parts of his testimony contradicted a 1999 statement he had given them. He said he was now telling the truth. In its judgment of December 3, 2003, which convicted all three accused, the Chamber did not find his testimony credible and did not rely on it.
He was called once more, in June 2003, in the Military I trial of four senior officers of the former Rwandan army. He described how RTLM operated in 1994, but he had difficulty recalling dates and did not connect the events he described to any of the accused.
Until 2008 he was held in Arusha. Under a 2004 agreement between Italy and the United Nations, and on the order of the tribunal's President, he was flown from Arusha to Italy on February 28, 2008, to serve the remainder of his sentence under Italian law and subject to the tribunal's supervision. About 17 months remained, and his release was due on July 20, 2009.
He was released on April 21, 2009, and the tribunal learned of it informally from Italian judicial sources. Under Article 27 of its statute, a prisoner serving a tribunal sentence abroad could be released early only if the tribunal's President, after consulting the judges, decided that this served the interests of justice. The tribunal had twice asked the Italian Minister of Justice in writing to be told of any early release for which he became eligible, and had received no reply. Its position was that the release violated Article 27.
Nothing later about his life or whereabouts is on record.
The judgment records findings about RTLM's broadcasts as a whole and his admissions about his own, but it attaches no number of deaths and no named victim to any broadcast of his. The only dated consequence in its text is the Gikondo broadcast of April 1994, and the deaths that followed it rest on what the station's editor-in-chief later told him. The tribunal's own published case profile goes further. It states that the Chamber found that on June 18, 1994, he made a broadcast concerning Gitwe and that more than seventy families, mainly Tutsi, were killed after it. That finding does not appear in the text of the judgment, which contains no mention of Gitwe, of June 18 or of seventy families.
When he understood what RTLM was doing is a matter on which his own accounts changed. His 1995 book defended the station, and he later told the tribunal that he had written it knowing it was false. At his plea and in his testimony he said he came to see the genocide as planned only in detention. The Chamber found that he knew from mid-April 1994 that the broadcasts were contributing to massacres.
His value as a witness was also contested. He admitted lying to investigators before his plea and contradicting his own earlier statement, and the Chamber in the media trial declined to rely on his evidence.
The tribunal held that the April 2009 release breached Article 27 of its statute because its President never decided on it. No ruling by the President on the release is on record.
October 12, 1957: Born in Verviers, Belgium.
1990: Becomes interested in Rwanda through Rwandan students living near him in Belgium.
August 1992: First visit to Rwanda.
May 1993: Meets President Habyarimana several times.
Late 1993: Moves to Rwanda.
January 6, 1994: Begins work at RTLM in Kigali.
April 6, 1994: President Habyarimana is killed; the genocide begins.
April 8 to 13, 1994: Makes the broadcast about Gikondo described in his plea agreement.
Mid-April 1994: Tour of Kigali after which, the tribunal found, he knew the broadcasts were contributing to massacres.
July 14, 1994: Leaves RTLM; goes into exile in Tanzania, later Kenya.
1995: Publishes Dans la tourmente rwandaise.
July 23, 1997: Arrested in Mombasa, Kenya; transferred to the tribunal in Arusha.
October 1997: Indictment confirmed on two counts; pleads not guilty.
July 1999: Begins cooperating with the prosecution; moved to a separate facility.
May 15, 2000: Pleads guilty to both counts.
June 1, 2000: Sentenced to 12 years' imprisonment on each count, concurrent.
February to March 2002: Testifies for the prosecution in the media trial.
June 2003: Testifies for the prosecution in the Military I trial.
December 3, 2003: Media trial judgment; his testimony found not credible.
February 28, 2008: Transferred to Italy.
April 21, 2009: Released early by the Italian authorities.