George Sodini

Victims
3 women killed and 9 wounded in one attack on August 4, 2009; police account, never charged or tried
Years active
August 4, 2009
Location
Collier Township, Pennsylvania (killings and death); Scott Township, Pennsylvania (residence)
Method
Shot with handguns (police account; no court tested it).
Status
Died untried. Suicide before trial: he took his own life in Collier Township, Pennsylvania, on August 4, 2009, before any charge could be brought.

On the evening of Tuesday, August 4, 2009, George Sodini walked into a weekly evening class at a fitness club in Collier Township, a suburb southwest of Pittsburgh, and before the night was over three women were dead, nine more were wounded and he had died by suicide. He was 48, a computer systems analyst who had worked at a downtown Pittsburgh law firm for a decade, owned his own property in neighboring Scott Township, lived alone and had never been arrested. Police found no link between him and any of the women in the room.

Because he died that night, no charge was ever filed, no prosecutor laid out a case and no jury heard one. The three deaths stand on the findings of the Allegheny County medical examiner's office and the investigation led by Allegheny County police, which held him responsible. What courts there were in the case were civil courts: in the months that followed, nearly every woman he wounded, and the families of the three who died, turned to the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas to claim what they could from the estate he left behind.

Sodini graduated from the University of Pittsburgh in 1992 with a degree in computer science. In 1999 he joined a Pittsburgh law firm as a systems analyst, and he was still working there in the summer of 2009. He had never married, and he lived by himself in a two-bedroom brick ranch in Scott Township.

The people who lived around him knew almost nothing about him. Neighbors described a quiet man who kept to himself. One thought he seemed happy enough; another found him so withdrawn that in years of living nearby the neighbors had learned nothing personal about him at all. The co-owner of a tanning salon he visited remembered him as awkward and a little odd, but never as someone who seemed dangerous. He had once belonged to a church congregation in Plum. He had no criminal record of any kind.

After his death an online diary he had kept, and two undated videos he appeared to have recorded himself, surfaced on the internet. The writings recorded years of loneliness and anger toward women. Police concluded from them, and from their own inquiries, that he had planned the attack for months.

The Allegheny County medical examiner's office identified the three women who died. Heidi Overmier lived in Carnegie. Elizabeth Gannon lived in Green Tree. Jody Billingsley lived in Mount Lebanon.

None of the three knew Sodini. Police said he had no personal relationship with anyone in the room. The three women were in that class on a Tuesday night in August for the same reason the others were, and that was the only thing that put them in his path.

Collier Township police took part, but the investigation was led by the homicide unit of the Allegheny County police. He had carried identification, but police held back the name until his identity was formally confirmed; by the following day it was public.

Detectives worked from the club's records and the writings he had left. They concluded that he had planned the attack for months and that he had no relationship with any of his victims. Once those findings were in, there was no criminal case to pursue. The man police held responsible was dead, and the matter passed to the civil courts and the probate records of Allegheny County.

Sodini had made a will, and in mid-August 2009 it was filed with Allegheny County. It named the University of Pittsburgh, his alma mater, as the sole beneficiary of his estate, then estimated at about $225,000. The university turned the gift down within days and said it would help steer any money bequeathed to it toward the victims and their families.

By the spring of 2010 the estate's lawyer put its value at between $100,000 and $300,000, and no final accounting had been filed with the county courts. His property in Scott Township sold in November 2009 for $100,000.

Within weeks of the killings, two of the wounded women filed notices in Allegheny County Court that they intended to sue the estate. In early October 2009 a third wounded woman sued it for $175,000. By March 2010, nearly all of the victims or their families had sued in the Court of Common Pleas, some against the estate, some against the business that ran the club, and some against both; the claims against the business alleged negligence by its staff before the attack. Sodini's estate was to go into a court-ordered fund, divided among the victims according to how their cases came out.

His insurance was the largest addition at stake. His State Farm property policy carried $100,000 in personal liability coverage, and early in 2010 the company asked an Allegheny County judge to rule that it did not cover the claims, on the ground that such coverage is written for accidents and the attack was deliberate. The answer decided whether the fund would hold roughly the value of the estate or something closer to $300,000. As of March 2010 the judge had not ruled.

The cases moved slowly. In August 2012, three years after the killings, one of the wounded women filed papers announcing that she had settled and discontinued her suit against the estate and the business that operated the club. The terms were not disclosed.

Nothing about who carried out the killings has ever been in doubt; the open questions have been about the edges of the case, and none of them reached a court. Early reports on the night of August 4 suggested Sodini had a personal connection to someone in the class. Police investigated and rejected that idea. Most reports put the number of wounded at nine, though a few gave other figures, and accounts differ by a year or two on the age of the youngest woman who died.

His writings are the only account of his reasons. Police accepted that he had planned for months, but no court ever weighed what he wrote, and because there was no trial, no court made findings on his state of mind. No documented history of mental illness had come to light in the days after his death.

Timeline

1992: Sodini graduates from the University of Pittsburgh with a degree in computer science.

1999: He joins a Pittsburgh law firm as a systems analyst.

August 4, 2009: Three women are killed and nine wounded in Collier Township; Sodini dies by suicide the same night.

Mid-August 2009: His will, naming the University of Pittsburgh as sole beneficiary, is filed with Allegheny County; the university declines the bequest; two wounded women file notices of intent to sue the estate.

October 2009: A third wounded woman sues the estate for $175,000.

November 2009: His property in Scott Township sells for $100,000.

March 2010: Nearly all victims or their families have sued in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas; State Farm's request for a ruling on his liability coverage is still pending.

August 2012: One wounded woman settles and discontinues her suit against the estate and the business that operated the club.