Gabriel Cardona

Victims
3 counts of murder in Webb County, Texas, by guilty plea. Also pleaded guilty in federal court to conspiracy to kill and kidnap in a foreign country over two deaths in Nuevo Laredo, Mexico
Years active
January 8, 2006 (Laredo); Nuevo Laredo deaths before the 2008 federal indictment
Location
Laredo, Texas; Nuevo Laredo, Tamaulipas, Mexico
Method
Murder (Texas, three counts); conspiracy to kill and kidnap in a foreign country (federal)
Status
80 years on each of three Texas murder counts; no appeal; state habeas relief denied April 13, 2016. Federal guilty-plea conviction affirmed by the Fifth Circuit, December 23, 2009

Gabriel Cardona answered for his part in a Laredo cell in two court systems, one state and one federal. In the 49th District Court of Webb County, Texas, he pleaded guilty to three counts of murder, among them the death of Noe Flores, who died in Laredo on January 8, 2006, and he received 80 years on each count. By the summer of 2007 he was serving that term. In the federal court in Laredo he pleaded guilty to a rarer charge, conspiracy to kill and kidnap in a foreign country, over two deaths in Nuevo Laredo, the Mexican city across the Rio Grande. He appealed that plea, arguing that he had never understood the charge and that the facts behind it did not make out the crime. The United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit rejected every point and affirmed the conviction on December 23, 2009.

He never appealed the Texas judgments. Eight years after he entered them, he went back to the state's highest criminal court with a different complaint: that his pleas had rested on a promise about federal time that could not be kept. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals sent the question down for a hearing, received the trial court's findings and denied relief in April 2016.

Both prosecutions grew out of the same small group of young men in Laredo. Texas prosecutors described that group as a cell of assassins working for the Gulf Cartel, and Webb County jail records classified Cardona as a registered member of the Zetas, which a Texas appellate court later called a known gang organization in Laredo. He was 20 years old in August 2007.

The fullest official account of the group comes from the trial of one of Cardona's co-defendants. A cooperating witness told a Webb County jury that he had gone to work as a member of a group of assassins operated by the Gulf Cartel. The group answered to a local manager in Laredo, and the manager took his orders from a cartel commander in Nuevo Laredo. Statements from men inside the network tied Cardona to the manager, to the commander and to two younger men from the same cell. One of them, Rosalio Reta, was convicted in Webb County of murder in the Laredo killing and sentenced to 40 years.

The third man the State charged in that killing was released on bail and left for Mexico before he could be tried.

The State's theory of the Laredo killing named three participants, Cardona among them. The case against them was built by the Laredo Police Department. A detective assigned to the inquiry followed the evidence from contact to contact in the days after the death, and the trail led into the network of the cell. Interviews with two men who had worked inside it supplied the structure above the three, from the local manager to the commander across the river. At trial the same detective walked a jury through the investigation step by step, linking the men who carried out the killing to the ring that directed it and to the people who had supplied what they used.

Cardona did not go to trial. The State's cases against him sat in the 49th District Court of Webb County under cause numbers that began in 2006, among them 2006 CRN770-D1 and 2006CRN952-D1. He pleaded guilty under plea agreements, and the court convicted him of three counts of murder and sentenced him to 80 years in each case.

The agreements carried a term that would matter years later. In the words the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals used to describe them, they called for any time to be served concurrently in relation to possible future federal time. When Cardona made those agreements, no federal judgment yet existed; the federal indictment had not been returned.

By July 2007 he was serving the 80-year term. Prosecutors in Laredo were then trying his co-defendant for the Laredo killing. Cardona filed no appeal from any of the three judgments.

The federal case was much larger. A grand jury in the Southern District of Texas returned an indictment in 2008 in the Laredo Division, docketed as No. 5:08-CR-244. It named several dozen defendants, among them cartel commanders, managers and members of the Laredo cells, many of them identified in the caption only by their aliases. Cardona was the eighth defendant, listed under the name Gabriel Cardona-Ramirez.

The count against Cardona charged conspiracy to kill and kidnap in a foreign country, an offense under section 956 of Title 18 of the United States Code. The count concerned two people: Jorge Alfonso Aviles and a second victim, Inez. Both died in Nuevo Laredo.

Cardona pleaded guilty to that count. At his rearraignment the count of the indictment was read to him, and the district court established that he and his lawyer had discussed the charge. The court did not go further. It did not ask whether Cardona understood the charge or had any questions about it.

The facts that supported the plea came from three places: the indictment itself, a written factual basis and an oral factual basis stated at the hearing. Read together, as the court of appeals later summarized them, they showed that Cardona was in Laredo when he learned where the two victims could be found and that he then took part in the killings in Nuevo Laredo.

Cardona appealed his guilty-plea conviction to the Fifth Circuit, where the case was docketed as No. 09-40359 and placed on the court's summary calendar. He raised three points.

The first was that the district court had violated Rule 11 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure by failing to advise him adequately of the nature of the charge. Because Cardona had not objected in the district court, the panel reviewed only for plain error. To win under that standard he had to show an error that was clear or obvious and that affected his substantial rights, and even then the court of appeals would correct it only if it seriously affected the fairness, integrity or public reputation of judicial proceedings. The panel left open whether the district court had erred at all. Even if it had, Cardona had not shown a reasonable probability that he would have refused to plead guilty without the error, which is what Rule 11 claims require. He did not claim that he had failed to understand the charge, and the panel held that his argument that it was reasonable to conclude he would not have pleaded guilty was not enough.

The second point attacked the voluntariness of the plea. Cardona argued, in hypothetical terms, that he could not have understood the nature of the charge because no one had identified its elements for him. The panel found that he had failed to point to any element he did not understand and had never asserted that his plea was in fact involuntary. He had again shown no effect on his substantial rights.

The third point went to the heart of the federal charge. Cardona argued that the factual basis did not show that he had agreed with anyone else to kidnap or kill the victims, or that he or anyone else had been within the jurisdiction of the United States when the agreement was made. He also argued that the indictment conflicted with the oral factual basis given at the hearing and that only the oral version should count. The panel declined to reach that last argument, because he had raised it for the first time in his reply brief. It held that the district court could properly consider the indictment in judging the factual basis, and that the indictment and the written and oral factual bases, read together, supplied every fact the offense required. Cardona's presence in Laredo when he learned where the victims were was a reasonable inference from the sequence of events. A portion of the conspiracy, the overt act, had therefore taken place in the United States.

The claim that there was no agreement to kidnap or kill fared no better. The panel held that it was belied by the sequence of events, by the fact that Cardona had been told where the victims were and by the fact that he had directed what was done with them. He had shown no reversible plain error.

Cardona also sought to raise claims that his lawyer had been ineffective. The panel held that the record on direct appeal was too thin to decide them, which left those claims for any later collateral proceeding. The judgment was affirmed in a per curiam opinion by three circuit judges, filed December 23, 2009, and designated unpublished and not precedent except in the limited circumstances the court's rules allow.

The state judgments returned to court in the summer of 2015. On June 8 of that year the clerk of the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals in Austin received a set of applications for writs of habeas corpus that Cardona had filed under Article 11.07 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure. Two of them, docketed as Nos. WR-83,424-03 and WR-83,424-04, attacked the murder judgments in causes 2006 CRN770-D1 and 2006CRN952-D1. He filed them without a lawyer, and over the following weeks he added letters and motions to the file.

His claims were narrow. He contended that his pleas had been involuntary because the plea agreements, with their promise about future federal time, could not be followed. He also alleged that his lawyer had misadvised him about when he would become eligible for parole.

On September 16, 2015, the court issued a per curiam order. It found that Cardona had alleged facts that, if true, might entitle him to relief, and that more facts were needed before anyone could say. The trial court, the order said, was the right place to find them. It directed the 49th District Court to order Cardona's plea counsel to respond to the claim that the pleas were involuntary, and allowed the judge to use affidavits, interrogatories, a hearing or personal recollection. If the court chose to hold a hearing, it was to decide whether Cardona was indigent and, if he was and wanted a lawyer, to appoint one.

The order then set out exactly what the trial court had to decide. It was to find whether Cardona had pleaded guilty under an agreement that his state sentences would run concurrently with a federal sentence. It was to find whether he had been sentenced in any federal case arising from the same facts, and if so how that time was to be served and credited. If the federal court had ordered cumulative sentences, the trial court was to find how counsel had advised Cardona about that possibility. It was also to find how counsel had advised him about parole eligibility and whether that advice was correct, and to address the State's assertion of laches, its argument that he had waited too long to complain. The applications were held in abeyance, with 90 days allowed to resolve the facts and 120 days to send the results back to Austin.

The trial court's findings and the State's material followed. Objections were filed with the Court of Criminal Appeals on December 4, 2015, and a supplement on January 19, 2016. The trial court signed findings of fact and conclusions of law recommending that relief be denied.

On April 13, 2016, the Court of Criminal Appeals agreed. In a second per curiam order it said that relief should be denied, but it declined to adopt the trial court's ninth finding of fact. Relying on the remaining findings and conclusions and on its own independent review of the record, it denied relief in both applications. Cardona asked the court to reconsider. The motion for reconsideration arrived on June 17, 2016, and the court dismissed it on June 29, 2016. The three 80-year sentences stood.

When his habeas applications reached Austin in June 2015, Cardona was held in the Texas state prison system, the custody in which he was serving the Webb County sentences. The 2016 orders left those judgments in place, and his federal conviction has stood since the Fifth Circuit's affirmance in December 2009.

Cardona's appeal challenged the federal plea on every ground it reached. He argued that he had not been told the nature of the charge, that his plea was not voluntary and that the facts did not show an agreement or any act inside the United States. The Fifth Circuit rejected each argument, though it expressly declined to decide whether the district court's questioning at the rearraignment had been adequate, holding only that any error made no difference. His claims of ineffective assistance were not decided on direct appeal.

In the state courts he disputed the bargain rather than the killings. His claim that the plea agreements' promise of concurrent federal time could not be honored, and his complaint about parole advice, went to a hearing in Webb County and were rejected by the Court of Criminal Appeals in 2016, which declined to adopt one of the trial court's findings but did not say which question it concerned. Prosecutors said that the man who died in Laredo was not the man the cell had been sent to kill.

Timeline

January 8, 2006: Death of a man in Laredo, Texas; the State later charges Cardona and two others with murder.

By July 2007: Cardona has pleaded guilty to three counts of murder in the 49th District Court of Webb County and is serving 80 years on each.

2008: Federal indictment in the Southern District of Texas, Laredo Division, No. 5:08-CR-244, naming Cardona as the eighth defendant.

After the 2008 indictment: Cardona pleads guilty to conspiracy to kill and kidnap in a foreign country over two deaths in Nuevo Laredo, Mexico.

December 23, 2009: The Fifth Circuit affirms Cardona's federal conviction, No. 09-40359.

June 8, 2015: The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals receives Cardona's habeas applications, Nos. WR-83,424-03 and WR-83,424-04.

September 16, 2015: The court remands the applications to the trial court for findings on the plea agreements, any federal sentence, parole advice and laches.

April 13, 2016: The Court of Criminal Appeals denies habeas relief.

June 29, 2016: The court dismisses Cardona's motion for reconsideration.