Frederick Seddon

Victims
1 murder: convicted of murdering his lodger, Eliza Mary Barrow, at the Old Bailey, March 1912.
Years active
1911
Location
North London, London, England (killing); London, England (trial and death)
Method
Poisoning (the prosecution's case at trial; the jury convicted).
Status
Sentenced to death, March 1912. Appeal heard 16 days after the trial and dismissed. Executed in London, 1912.

Frederick Seddon was an insurance agent and a Freemason who lived with his family in north London. In 1911 a woman who lodged in his household, Eliza Mary Barrow, died. Seddon had come to manage her money, and not long before her death she had made a new will naming him its executor. Within months he and his wife stood together in the dock at the Old Bailey, charged with her murder. In March 1912, after a trial of ten days, the jury acquitted his wife and convicted him. The Court of Criminal Appeal dismissed his appeal, and he was executed in London a few weeks later.

The Attorney General led the prosecution in person. The decisive moment of the trial came not from either side's counsel but from Seddon himself, who insisted on going into the witness box against his lawyer's advice.

Seddon earned his living in insurance, and it was through that work that he came to know Barrow. He invited her to live with his family in north London, and she accepted. The arrangement was more than a room and board. Over time Seddon took over the management of her finances, and the money she had once controlled passed into his hands.

The new will she made named Seddon as her executor. In 1911 she died. Her death drew suspicion onto the household, and the inquiry that followed ended with both Seddon and his wife charged with her murder.

The case came to trial at the Old Bailey, the Central Criminal Court in London, in March 1912. Husband and wife were tried together on the same charge, and the prosecution's case against each rested on the same body of evidence. That evidence was circumstantial, and much of it turned on technical testimony that the defense contested.

The law allowed Seddon to give evidence in his own defense if he applied to do so, and it also left him free to stay silent. His counsel advised silence. Seddon refused the advice, took the stand and faced cross-examination by the Attorney General.

The jury retired for about an hour. They acquitted his wife and found Seddon guilty of murder, and the judge sentenced him to death.

On March 15, 1912, an illustrated paper published a large photograph of the courtroom at the close of the trial, showing the judge in the black cap and the prisoner receiving the sentence of death. No permission had been given for it. The picture was raised in the House of Commons three days later, and on March 21 the Home Secretary told the House that it must have been taken without authority and surreptitiously.

Seddon appealed. The Court of Criminal Appeal heard the case 16 days after the trial ended. The hearing lasted two days, and the appeal was dismissed. Seddon was executed in London 16 days after it failed. His wife, acquitted by the jury, went free.

The case against Seddon and his wife was circumstantial, and the defense disputed the technical evidence on which much of it rested. Both defendants gave evidence in their own defense. The jury accepted the prosecution's case against Seddon and rejected it against his wife, although the evidence against the two was the same. Her acquittal is the only finding the law made about her part in the case.

Timeline

1911: Seddon's lodger dies in north London; Seddon and his wife are later charged with her murder.

March 1912: Joint trial of Seddon and his wife at the Old Bailey lasts ten days; the jury acquits his wife and convicts Seddon of murder after retiring for about an hour; he is sentenced to death.

March 15, 1912: An illustrated paper publishes an unauthorized photograph of the judge passing sentence of death.

March 18 and 21, 1912: The photograph is raised in the House of Commons; the Home Secretary says no permission was given.

1912: The Court of Criminal Appeal hears Seddon's appeal over two days, 16 days after the trial, and dismisses it.

1912: Seddon is executed in London, 16 days after the appeal is dismissed.