Frederick Bywaters was a merchant seaman of 20 when, on October 3, 1922, he killed Percy Thompson in Ilford. He never denied that he was the one who did it. The dead man's wife, Edith Thompson, eight years older than Bywaters and his lover, was with her husband that night, and it was never suggested that she played any physical part in his death. Even so, the two of them were tried together at the Old Bailey that December for the same murder. On December 11, 1922, the jury found both of them guilty, and both were sentenced to death.
Bywaters's guilt was never really the question at the trial. Hers was. The Crown relied on letters she had written to him, and those letters carried the case against her. A petition for his reprieve gathered more than a million signatures, and it changed nothing. Her appeal was rejected, and on January 9, 1923, Bywaters and Edith Thompson were executed in London on the same day. He insisted to the end that she had known nothing of what he meant to do.
Bywaters went to sea young, joining the Merchant Navy at 15, and by 1922 his work kept him away from England for long stretches. For a time he lodged with Edith Thompson and her husband, and it was as their former lodger that he became her lover.
While he was at sea the two of them kept up a steady correspondence. In the summer of 1922 alone she sent two dozen letters to his ship. She destroyed nearly all of what he wrote to her. He kept what she sent him.
On the night of Tuesday, October 3, 1922, Bywaters killed her husband in Ilford while Edith Thompson was beside him.
Within days both of them were under arrest, and the arrests were in the London newspapers on October 6. About a week after the killing, the police recovered the letters she had written to Bywaters, and from then on the correspondence stood at the center of the case against her. Bywaters and Edith Thompson were both charged with murder, and after a hearing before a magistrate they were committed for trial at the Central Criminal Court.
The trial opened at the Old Bailey in December 1922, before a judge and jury. The two defendants were tried together on the same charge of murder.
Against Bywaters there was little to argue, since he had admitted the killing from the start. He gave evidence in his own defense, and from the first he held to one position above all others: that Edith Thompson had known nothing of it.
Against her, the case was the letters. She had struck no one, and there was no evidence that she knew what he would do that night. The Crown asked the jury to treat what she had written to him as evidence of her intent, and the letters were used against her throughout the trial.
On December 11, 1922, the jury returned its verdicts. Both defendants were found guilty of murder, and the judge sentenced both to death. The newspapers carried the sentences the next morning. Against Edith Thompson the conviction rested on foreknowledge and incitement: the Crown's case was that she had known of the killing in advance and urged on the man who carried it out.
Within days of the verdict a petition for Bywaters's reprieve was circulating, and by December 15 there was a rush to sign it; it gathered more than a million signatures.
Edith Thompson took her case to the Court of Criminal Appeal, and her appeal was rejected. No reprieve was granted to either prisoner.
Frederick Bywaters and Edith Thompson were executed in London on January 9, 1923, in separate prisons on the same day.
That Bywaters killed her husband has never been in doubt. He admitted it from the start and never withdrew the admission.
What Edith Thompson knew is another matter, and it has been argued over ever since the verdict. Bywaters said repeatedly, through the trial and up to his execution, that she had known nothing about the crime. Her conviction rested on the jury's reading of her letters, and the passages the Crown relied on most heavily dated from months before the killing.
Before 1922: Bywaters, a merchant seaman, lodges for a time with Edith Thompson and her husband; the affair begins.
Summer 1922: Edith Thompson sends two dozen letters to Bywaters's ship.
October 3, 1922: Bywaters kills her husband in Ilford.
October 6, 1922: The arrests of Bywaters and Edith Thompson are in the newspapers; both are charged with murder.
Mid-October 1922: Police recover her letters to Bywaters, about a week after the killing.
December 1922: Joint trial at the Old Bailey.
December 11, 1922: Both found guilty of murder and sentenced to death.
December 14 to 15, 1922: A petition for Bywaters's reprieve circulates; it gathers more than a million signatures.
Late December 1922: The Court of Criminal Appeal rejects Edith Thompson's appeal.
January 9, 1923: Bywaters and Edith Thompson are executed in London.