Franz Novak never commanded a camp. His work was paperwork: wagon requisitions, timetables and the orders that turned a deportation plan into a train with a departure hour. As the transport officer of Adolf Eichmann's office in Berlin, and later of Eichmann's special unit in Budapest, he arranged the rail movement of Jews from Austria, the Czech lands, Germany, France and, in the spring and summer of 1944, Hungary. The Hungarian deportations alone carried about 437,000 people in less than eight weeks, and most of them were murdered at Auschwitz on arrival.
After the war he lived quietly in Austria, first under a false name and later under his own, working as a printer. He was arrested in Vienna in January 1961, while Eichmann awaited trial in Israel. His case became one of the longest prosecutions in Austrian postwar justice: four jury trials in eight years, two verdicts overturned by the Supreme Court, and a final sentence of seven years. None of the four juries convicted him of murder. The offense that stood, in the English rendering of the verdict, was "violence under aggravating circumstances," for the deaths of deportees in the freight cars on their way to the camp.
Novak was born in 1913 in Austria, and he was a printer by trade. From 1929 he was active in the Hitler Youth and then in the Nazi Party. After 1934 he left Austria for Germany.
He came back after the German annexation of Austria in March 1938 and joined the office Eichmann was setting up in Vienna to drive Austria's Jews out of the country by forced emigration and expropriation. He began there as Eichmann's assistant. When Eichmann moved on, first to Prague and then to Berlin, Novak went with him. In 1939 he was transferred to Berlin as what was later described as an "expert on technical questions" of Jewish deportation.
In Berlin, Novak worked in Eichmann's office, which organized the deportation of Jews from across occupied Europe to concentration and extermination camps. His title was transport adviser. In practice, he ordered the railway wagons, drew up the timetables with the railway authorities and followed the trains to their departure. Among the destinations of the transports he organized was Maly Trostinec.
He told the Vienna court in 1964 that he had held a subordinate post. His work, he said, had been confined to forwarding documents, and in Berlin he had carried out the evacuation orders of his immediate superior, Rolf Günther. Asked whether it had struck him as strange that every transport went to Auschwitz, he answered that he had thought the deportees were going there to work, and he added that Jews had been regarded at the time as enemies of Germany.
German troops entered Hungary on March 19, 1944. Eichmann came to Budapest with a team of deportation specialists, and Novak was one of them. Working with Hungarian officials and the Hungarian gendarmerie, the team concentrated the Jews of the provinces in ghettos and transit camps placed close to railway lines, then moved them out zone by zone.
The deportations ran from May 15 to July 9, 1944. In that time about 437,000 Jews left Hungary on 147 trains, and about 420,000 of them were sent to Auschwitz-Birkenau. Roughly 100,000 were selected there for forced labor. About 330,000, three in every four, were murdered on arrival. The deportees were men, women and children, forced into freight cars.
On July 7, 1944, the Hungarian regent, Admiral Miklós Horthy, ordered the deportations stopped. Trains from the towns around Budapest continued for two more days. Smaller transports from internment camps to Auschwitz followed in late July and August. One of these was the case that witnesses later pressed hardest in Vienna: a train of Jews held at the Kistarcsa camp, which Horthy had ordered returned. Two witnesses at the 1964 trial told the court that Novak came to the camp and saw to it that the train went on to Auschwitz. Novak told the court he had never been at Kistarcsa.
When the war ended, Novak disappeared. He worked under a false name as a farm laborer and later in a series of printing shops. In later years he used his own name again, living in Langenzersdorf and working at a printing shop in Vienna.
With Eichmann in Israeli custody, West German prosecutors in Frankfurt offered a reward of 10,000 marks for information leading to the arrest of Novak and two other former members of Eichmann's office. In January 1961 an announcement on the radio said that a warrant for him had been issued in Frankfurt. An anonymous caller gave his whereabouts, and he was arrested on Friday, January 20, 1961, at the Vienna printing shop where he worked.
Under questioning he admitted that he had been Eichmann's "right hand." He asked not to be handed over to Israel. The Vienna State Attorney opened an investigation within days. He stayed in Austria, and the case went to the Vienna Regional Court.
The trial opened in Vienna on November 17, 1964, before a jury of eight. Much of the evidence was drawn from material gathered for the Eichmann trial in Jerusalem. The prosecution charged him with "active murder" and accused him of issuing more than 1,000 orders for the transport of Jewish deportees. A second complaint, brought by a Hungarian businessman, held him responsible for sending the man's mother, wife and children to Auschwitz, where they were murdered. Novak pleaded not guilty on the first day and again on the second.
Witnesses came from the United States, West Germany and Hungary. A former member of the Budapest Jewish Council, who had negotiated with Novak in 1944, testified that Novak "certainly knew" the fate of the people he helped send to Auschwitz. A leader of the Zionist underground in Hungary told the court that Eichmann and Novak had consistently opposed proposals to rescue Jews. A non-Jewish officer of the Budapest security police in 1944 said he had discussed with Novak a plan, raised by Swiss consular officials, to send 10 to 15 prominent Hungarian Jews to Switzerland rather than to Auschwitz, and that the conversation showed Novak knew where the others were going. Novak denied it.
The hearing of evidence ended after 17 days. On December 17, 1964, the jury returned its verdict. By five votes to three, the jurors declined to convict him of aiding and plotting mass murder, and all eight acquitted him of the murder charges that concerned Jews from France and Germany deported in 1942. They found him guilty, with extenuating circumstances, of "violence under aggravating circumstances," for endangering the lives of the Jewish men, women and children he had placed on the trains, thousands of whom died in the freight cars on the way. The court sentenced him to eight years in prison. He had already served four years.
Novak appealed. In December 1965 the Austrian Supreme Court found the verdict "incomplete and contradictory" and granted him a new trial; the verdict was annulled, in the later wire account, "for technical reasons." He was to stay in custody until it took place.
The second trial opened in Vienna in September 1966, again on charges of complicity in the murder of about 400,000 Jews. The verdict came on October 6, 1966. The jury, five women and three men, found by seven votes to one that Novak had known the Jews whose transport he arranged were going to Auschwitz to be killed, and that he had thereby endangered their lives. On the next question, whether he had acted under duress, the jurors split four to four. Under Austrian law a tied vote on that question meant acquittal, and Novak was freed.
The prosecution appealed. In February 1968 the Supreme Court accepted the appeal, on the ground that the jurors had been insufficiently instructed on the nature of acting under duress, and quashed the acquittal. In the same ruling the court held it to be well established that Novak had been a voluntary and enthusiastic helper of Eichmann. It ordered a third trial.
The third trial opened in Vienna at the start of December 1969. Novak, by then 55, admitted that he had helped transport hundreds of thousands of Jews to Auschwitz.
On March 22, 1972, at 59, Novak went on trial for the fourth time in eight years. The last of the four trials ended in a conviction and a sentence of seven years in prison. That conviction was not for aiding murder. It rested on his failure to provide food for the deportees during the deportations.
He did not serve the full term. The Federal President granted him a pardon, and he was released early. Novak died in 1983.
The central question in all four trials was what Novak knew. He maintained throughout that Auschwitz had been, for him, only a railway destination, and that he had believed the deportees were sent there to work. Witnesses at the 1964 trial said he knew, and the 1966 jury found by seven votes to one that he had known. No jury convicted him of murder or complicity in murder.
The specific accusations of Kistarcsa and of the obstructed rescue plans rest on the testimony of witnesses at the 1964 trial. Novak denied being at Kistarcsa, and no verdict made a finding on that transport by name.
The outcome of the third trial is not on record. The record also differs on the end of the case: one account dates the seven-year sentence to 1973 and counts three trials rather than four, and the date of the pardon is not on record.
1913: Franz Novak is born in Austria.
1929: He is active in the Hitler Youth and then the Nazi Party.
After 1934: He leaves Austria for Germany.
March 1938: After the annexation of Austria he returns and joins Eichmann's office in Vienna as an assistant.
1939: After following Eichmann to Prague, he is transferred to Berlin as a deportation specialist.
From 1939: As transport adviser in Eichmann's office in Berlin he orders wagons and draws up timetables for deportation trains.
March 19, 1944: German troops enter Hungary; he goes to Budapest with Eichmann's unit.
May 15 to July 9, 1944: About 437,000 Jews are deported from Hungary on 147 trains.
July 7, 1944: Horthy orders the deportations stopped.
1945: He disappears and lives under a false name in Austria.
Later years: He uses his own name again and lives in Langenzersdorf.
January 20, 1961: He is arrested in Vienna.
November 17, 1964: The first trial opens before a Vienna jury.
December 17, 1964: Acquitted of murder; convicted of "violence under aggravating circumstances"; sentenced to eight years.
December 1965: The Supreme Court finds the verdict "incomplete and contradictory" and grants a new trial.
October 6, 1966: The second jury ties four to four on duress; he is acquitted and freed.
February 1968: The Supreme Court quashes the acquittal and orders a retrial.
December 1969: The third trial opens in Vienna.
March 22, 1972: The fourth trial opens; the case ends in a sentence of seven years.
Later: The Federal President pardons him and he is released early.
1983: Franz Novak dies.