Frank Roque

Victims
1 man murdered in Mesa, Arizona, September 15, 2001. Convicted of murder, attempted murder, reckless endangerment and three drive-by shooting counts; natural life, 2006
Years active
September 15, 2001
Location
Mesa, Arizona (killing and related offenses); Arizona (trial and custody)
Method
Shot (court record)
Status
Guilty on all counts, September 2003; death verdict, October 2003; Arizona Supreme Court reduced it to natural life without release, 2006. Imprisoned in Arizona as of September 2019.

Frank Silva Roque was convicted of first-degree murder for the death of Balbir Singh Sodhi in Mesa, Arizona, on September 15, 2001, four days after the attacks on New York and Washington. The man he killed had been born in India and was a Sikh, who wore a turban and an uncut beard as his faith required. The state's case was that Roque singled him out because he believed him to be Arab. The jury also convicted him of the attempted murder of a second man at a separate location that afternoon and of related offenses; no one else was hurt. It rejected his plea that he was legally insane, found him guilty on every count in September 2003 and returned a verdict of death the following month.

The case did not end there. Arizona law sent the death sentence straight to the state supreme court, and in August 2006 that court affirmed every conviction but found that the evidence of his impaired mental condition, set against a single aggravating circumstance, left real doubt about whether death was the right sentence. It resolved that doubt in his favor.

Roque was 42 in September 2001 and worked as an aircraft mechanic at the Boeing plant in Mesa. In 1983, in California, he had been convicted of attempted robbery, a conviction that would later be put before his Arizona jury. His intelligence tested below average, with a full-scale IQ of 80, though not low enough to meet Arizona's legal definition of mental retardation. His mental health was the center of the case from the start.

He was at work when news of the September 11 attacks came, and for the rest of that day he cried uncontrollably and talked incoherently. The next day he stayed away from work, which was out of character for him. On the afternoon of Saturday, September 15, in Mesa, he killed the man whose death made this case. Another man was with the victim when he died, and the danger to him would become both a separate count of reckless endangerment and the one aggravating circumstance that made the murder eligible for death. Police arrested Roque in Mesa that evening.

Two days later he was charged with murder and attempted murder. Six counts went to trial: the first-degree murder; the attempted first-degree murder of the second man; reckless endangerment of the man who had been with the victim; and three counts of drive-by shooting, one for each of the three places involved that afternoon.

The trial was held in Arizona superior court in 2003. Roque did not dispute that he had committed the acts charged. His defense was insanity: a mental illness, his lawyers argued, had been set off into an episode of insanity by the September 11 attacks, and under Arizona's verdict of guilty except insane, success would have sent him to a state mental hospital rather than a penitentiary. Defense experts testified that he was legally insane and the state's experts that he was not, and Arizona law required him to prove insanity by clear and convincing evidence.

In September 2003 the jury rejected the insanity defense and found him guilty on all six counts. The trial court refused to let the state treat the California conviction as a prior serious offense, but the jury found that he had knowingly created a grave risk of death to the man who had been with the victim. In October 2003 it returned a verdict of death. On the other counts the court imposed terms of 12 years for the attempted murder and for each of the three drive-by shooting counts, and one and a quarter years for reckless endangerment.

The Arizona Supreme Court decided the appeal on August 14, 2006, and upheld the convictions. It found that the state had broken Arizona's disclosure rule by failing to reveal in advance the substance of one expert's conclusions, and that three instances of the state's conduct at trial were improper, but it held that none of it required a new trial, in part because the defense had turned down the trial judge's offer of a short continuance. It agreed that the California conviction could not count as an aggravating circumstance, upheld the grave-risk finding, and rejected the argument that the state had sought death because of the victim's race, ethnicity or religion.

Because the crimes predated August 1, 2002, the court then had to weigh the sentence itself. The single aggravating circumstance, the grave risk to the man who had been with the victim, was proved beyond a reasonable doubt. Against it stood Roque's mental condition. All four experts whose opinions the court weighed agreed that it had impaired his capacity to conform his conduct to the law, differing only on degree, and the court gave that evidence substantial weight. It counted his IQ of 80 as further mitigation. The balance raised a substantial question whether death was appropriate, and under the court's precedent that doubt had to be resolved in favor of life. Its disposition read: "Defendant's convictions and non-capital sentences are affirmed. His sentence of death is reduced to natural life imprisonment without possibility of release."

Successive petitions for post-conviction relief in the Arizona courts failed, and the Supreme Court of the United States denied certiorari in Roque v. Arizona on May 31, 2016. As of September 2019, he was serving the life sentence in Arizona custody.

His state of mind was the issue argued from first to last. The defense experts found him legally insane; the state's did not, and one of them saw signs of malingering, an assessment the supreme court gave little weight. The jury's verdicts settled the legal question of insanity, while the supreme court's independent review accepted that his capacity to obey the law was genuinely impaired.

His motive was contested in the same terms, the state's theory of anger and racial hatred against the defense's account of a psychotic episode set off by September 11. The convictions rest on the jury's rejection of the insanity defense, not on any separate finding about hatred.

Timeline

1983: Roque is convicted of attempted robbery in California.

September 15, 2001: In Mesa he kills a Sikh man and commits the related offenses that afternoon, injuring no one else; he is arrested that evening.

September 17, 2001: He is charged with murder and attempted murder.

September 2003: A jury rejects his insanity defense and convicts him on all six counts.

October 2003: The same jury returns a verdict of death.

August 14, 2006: The Arizona Supreme Court affirms the convictions and reduces the death sentence to natural life imprisonment without possibility of release.

May 31, 2016: The Supreme Court of the United States denies certiorari.

September 2019: He is serving the life sentence in Arizona custody.